In this thesis we shall demonstrate that a measurement of position alone in non-commutative space cannot yield complete information about the quantum state of a particle. Indeed, the formalism used entails a description that is non-local in that it requires all orders of positional derivatives through the star product that is used ubiquitously to map operator multiplication onto function multiplication in non-commutative systems. It will be shown that there exist several equivalent local descriptions, which are arrived at via the introduction of additional degrees of freedom. Consequently non-commutative quantum mechanical position measurements necessarily confront us with some additional structure which is necessary to specify quantum states completely. The remainder of the thesis, will involve investigations into the physical interpretation of these additional degrees of freedom. For one particular local formulation, the corresponding classical theory will be used to demonstrate that the concept of extended, structured objects emerges quite naturally and unavoidably there. This description will be shown to be equivalent to one describing a two-charge harmonically interacting composite in a strong magnetic field found by Susskind. It will be argued that these notions also extend naturally to the quantum level, and constraints will be shown to arise there. A further local formulation will be introduced, with an interpretation in terms of objects located at a point with a certain angular momentum about that point. This again enforces the idea of particles that are not point-like. Both local descriptions make explicit the additional structure which is encoded more subtly in the non-local description. Additional degrees of freedom introduced by local descriptions may also be thought of as gauge degrees of freedom in a gauge-invariant formulation of the theory.
In this thesis we shall demonstrate that a measurement of position alone in non-commutative space cannot yield complete information about the quantum state of a particle. Indeed, the formalism used entails a description that is non-local in that it requires all orders of positional derivatives through the star product that is used ubiquitously to map operator multiplication onto function multiplication in non-commutative systems. It will be shown that there exist several equivalent local descriptions, which are arrived at via the introduction of additional degrees of freedom. Consequently non-commutative quantum mechanical position measurements necessarily confront us with some additional structure which is necessary to specify quantum states completely. The remainder of the thesis, will involve investigations into the physical interpretation of these additional degrees of freedom. For one particular local formulation, the corresponding classical theory will be used to demonstrate that the concept of extended, structured objects emerges quite naturally and unavoidably there. This description will be shown to be equivalent to one describing a two-charge harmonically interacting composite in a strong magnetic field found by Susskind. It will be argued that these notions also extend naturally to the quantum level, and constraints will be shown to arise there. A further local formulation will be introduced, with an interpretation in terms of objects located at a point with a certain angular momentum about that point. This again enforces the idea of particles that are not point-like. Both local descriptions make explicit the additional structure which is encoded more subtly in the non-local description. Additional degrees of freedom introduced by local descriptions may also be thought of as gauge degrees of freedom in a gauge-invariant formulation of the theory.
We explore the notion of spatial extent and structure, already alluded to in earlier literature, within the formulation of quantum mechanics on the noncommutative plane. Introducing the notion of position and its measurement in the sense of a weak measurement (positive operator-valued measure), we find two equivalent pictures in a position representation: a constrained local description in position containing additional degrees of freedom and an unconstrained nonlocal description in terms of the position without any other degrees of freedom. Both these descriptions have a corresponding classical theory which shows that the concept of extended, structured objects emerges quite naturally and unavoidably there. It is explicitly demonstrated that the conserved energy and angular momentum contain corrections to those of a point particle. We argue that these notions also extend naturally to the quantum level. The local description is found to be the most convenient as it manifestly displays additional information about the structure of quantum states that is more subtly encoded in the nonlocal, unconstrained description. Subsequently, we use this picture to discuss the free particle and harmonic oscillator as examples.
This thesis aims to establish the study of a somewhat novel form of entanglement in field-theoretical quantum systems: that between degrees of freedom in momentum space. Although scattered results can be found in the literature, with some even going back decades, this work, based on the papers published during the PhD, provides a systematic investigation of the matter and arrive at non-perturbative results, shedding light on unexplored structures present in Quantum Field Theories (QFTs) and their ground states. This line of research is motivated by the inherent connection between the notion of momentum modes of fields and the Wilsonian formulation of the Renormalization Group (RG), a cornerstone of the modern understanding of field theories and phases of matter which is naturally defined by the partition of the degrees of freedom into “fast' and “slow' modes, according to their momenta. Furthermore, by glancing at the achievements of techniques such as the Density Matrix Renormalization Group and Tensor Networks, which are based on ideas from renormalization in real space, there is reason to believe that similarly efficient methods may be derived by connecting the fundaments of the RG with quantum information in momentum-space. With this in mind, the thesis begins by introducing the main notions of information theory and renormalization used throughout, with the inclusion of a brief discussion on the use of von Neumann algebras in quantum physics, a formalism which is not directly applied here, but nevertheless provides a solid basis for many intuitions on the nature of entanglement. Afterwards, the idea of degrees of freedom in momentum-space is defined and its different subtleties clarified. A key insight, that any field theory possesses multiple definitions of partitioning its Hilbert space into momentum modes, based on a choice of a complete set of local and commuting observables or field variables in a path integral, is then obtained. Given this solid grasp on the fundaments of quantum information in momentum-space, two directions of further investigation are pursued. First, a path-integral method is developed for the calculation of the associated entanglement entropies in ground states and applied perturbatively to several models, which also allows for the quantitative confirmation of certain predictions. Secondly, the Wilsonian renormalization procedure is translated to this formalism and is shown to be equivalent to a so-called quantum channel which acts on momentum-space. While an interesting result on its own right, this also leads directly to a powerful constraint on the structure of ground states of renormalization group fixed points: they must be separable, and thus uncorrelated, when the degrees of freedom are partitioned based on their momentum scale. This opens the way for further analytical and numerical studies of these special QFTs beyond the scope of this thesis. Finally, the concept of fidelity of quantum states is invoked in order to better understand the information aspects of the renormalization group flow for theories in the critical manifold of a given fixed point. It is used to quantify the idea that such QFTs are indistinguishable from the fixed point itself when long-distance observables are measured and new “critical exponents' are introduced in this context, providing tight bounds on the differences of expectation values of operators in the critical and fixed-point theories. The results obtained in this work mark only the beginning of the in-depth research on different structures present in the momentum-space of Quantum Field Theories and may, hopefully, serve as a basis for further developments.:Contents Acknowledgements iii 1 Introduction 1 1.1 Notions of quantum information 5 1.2 Comments on von Neumann algebras 10 1.3 Basics of Wilsonian renormalization 14 2 Defining momentum-space entanglement 18 2.1 Momentum modes from the path integral 19 2.2 Non-uniqueness of partitions 24 3 The replica method for non-local actions 33 3.1 Construction of the replica trick 34 3.2 Entanglement between momentum scales in perturbation theory 38 3.2.1 Perturbation theory and the replica trick 39 3.2.2 Coupled Oscillators 40 3.2.3 Perturbative interacting QFT 42 3.2.4 Sine-Gordon and Thirring models 48 4 Wilsonian RG as a quantum channel 53 4.1 Quantum operations from the RG steps 54 4.2 Separability of ground states at fixed points 59 4.3 Further implications 63 4.3.1 The RG is a quantum dynamical semigroup 64 4.3.2 First-order phase transitions 67 5 Critical theories and operator estimations 74 5.1 Quantum state distinguishability 75 5.2 Fidelity in translation-invariant systems 77 5.3 Hyperscaling in the critical manifold 80 6 Conclusions and further directions 86 Bibliography 88
Quantum mechanical descriptions in terms of momentum and position are identified as alternatives under the condition of equal complex-vaulted Lebesgue square integrability. While this does not change any of the formal results obtained in quantum mechanics, it does shed a different interpretive light on the steps that lead up to these results. Instead of being independent, even in concept, momentum and position are identified as being the same thing, merely seen from different views. Neither is required to complement the descriptive capability of the other, since each forms a complete alternative in its own right. Apparent complementarity, as well as mutual indeterminacy of codescription, comes about whenever an attempt is made to overlap these two descriptions to form a third codescription which tries to maintain both the terminology and the net integration values of the separate alternatives. Noncommutation of associated operators is a direct consequence of the alternative nature of momentum and position, and the local to global character of the particular map between these alternatives leads to an apparent point-wave duality in their descriptions. It is suggested that challenges to the contemporary interpretation of quantum theory should begin with the assumptions that lead to its formulation involving alternative representations.
Recent works in foundations of quantum (field) theory and relativistic quantum information try to better grasp the interplay between the structure of quantum correlations and the constraints imposed by causality on physical operations. Chapter 1 is dedicated to the study of the conceptual implications of quantum nonlocality, a concept that subsumes that of entanglement in a certain way. We detail the recent information-theoretic approaches to understanding the structure of nonlocal correlations, and the issues the latter raise concerning the ability of local observers to isolate a system from its environment. Chapter 2 reviews in what sense imposing Poincare invariance affects entanglement detection and quantification procedures. This invariance ultimately forces a description of all quantum systems within the framework of quantum field theory, which leads to the impossibility of localized finite-energy states and to the divergence of all entanglement measures for local observers. We provide a solution to these two problems by showing that there exists a generic equivalence between a finite spatial resolution of the measurement apparatus and the exclusion of high-energy degrees of freedom from the definition of the observed system. This equivalence allows for an epistemic interpretation of the standard quantum formalism describing nonrelativistic localized systems and their correlations, hence a clarification of the origin of the finite measures of entanglement between such systems. Chapter 3 presents a recent theoretical framework that predicts the existence of correlations with indefinite causal order. In analogy to the information-theoretic approaches to nonlocal correlations, we introduce some principles that constrain the structure of such correlations, which is a first step toward a clear understanding of their physical origin.
This dissertation addresses the problem of constructing true degrees of freedom in quantum mechanical systems with constraints. The method developed relies on assuming the behavior of the system of interest is ``nearly classical', or semiclassical, in a precise quantitative sense. The approximation is formulated as a perturbative hierarchy of the expectation values of quantum observables and their non-linear combinations, such as spreads and correlations. We formulate the constraint conditions and additional quantum gauge transformations that arise directly on the aforementioned quantities. We specialize this framework to several situations of particular interest. The first situation considered is the case of a constraint that commutes with all quantum observables, which is appropriate for quantization of a Lie algebra with a single Casimir polynomial. Through explicit order-by order counting argue that the true degrees of freedom are captured correctly at each order of the approximation. The rest of the models considered are motivated by the canonical approach to quantizing general relativity. The homogeneous sector of general relativity splits into classes of models, according to topology, which are described by a finite number of degrees of freedom and can therefore be quantized as quantum mechanical systems, making our construction directly applicable. In the Hamiltonian formulation the dynamics of these systems is governed by the Hamiltonian constraint, which, in the quantum theory, gives rise to several conceptual and technical issues collectively known as the Problem of Time. One of the aspects of this problem that does not possess a general solution is the dynamical interpretation of the theory. We use our construction, truncated at the leading order in quantum corrections, together with the intuition gained from dealing with constrained systems in classical mechanics, to define local notion of dynamics relative to a chosen configuration clock variable. We consider a class of models, where the chosen clock in not globally valid, eventually leading to singular dynamics. Within these models we construct an explicit transformation between dynamical evolution relative to two distinct clocks, thus providing a consistent local dynamical interpretation of the true degrees of freedom of the quantum theory.
The thesis is about the peculiar probabilistic structure of quantum mechanics. Typically, a random phenomenon is described using the measure-theoretic formulation of probability theory. Such a description can also be done using algebraic methods, which are capable to deal with non-commutative random variables. A central feature of quantum mechanics is the non-commutativity of operators used to describe physical observables. A method to construct a non-commutative probability theory starting from an ordinary measure-theoretic description of probability is proposed and applied to a series of model to reobtain the quantum behaviour od a particle. In particular, using ordinary probability theory, the kinematics of a point-like particle jumping at random over a discrete random space is studied. After the removal of the random space from the model, the position and velocity of the particle do not commute, when represented as operators on the same Hilbert space. Using a suitable random process for the space one is able to recover non-relativistic quantum mechanics in a suitable limit.