Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1204.4191 · Physical Review E

Universality of modulation length and time exponents

Saurish Chakrabarty, V. Dobrosavljević, Alexander Seidel, Zohar Nussinov

Published Oct 18, 2012• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study systems with a crossover parameter λ, such as the temperature T, which has a threshold value λ(*) across which the correlation function changes from exhibiting fixed wavelength (or time period) modulations to continuously varying modulation lengths (or times). We introduce a hitherto unknown exponent ν(L) characterizing the universal nature of this crossover and compute its value in general instances. This exponent, similar to standard correlation length exponents, is obtained from motion of the poles of the momentum (or frequency) space correlation functions in the complex k-plane (or ω-plane) as the parameter λ is varied. Near the crossover (i.e., for λ→λ(*)), the characteristic modulation wave vector K(R) in the variable modulation length "phase" is related to that in the fixed modulation length "phase" q via |K(R)-q|[proportionality]|T-T(*)|(νL). We find, in general, that ν(L)=1/2. In some special instances, ν(L) may attain other rational values. We extend this result to general problems in which the eigenvalue of an operator or a pole characterizing general response functions may attain a constant real (or imaginary) part beyond a particular threshold value λ(*). We discuss extensions of this result to multiple other arenas. These include the axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model. By extending our considerations, we comment on relations pertaining not only to the modulation lengths (or times), but also to the standard correlation lengths (or times). We introduce the notion of a Josephson time scale. We comment on the presence of aperiodic "chaotic" modulations in "soft-spin" and other systems. These relate to glass-type features. We discuss applications to Fermi systems, with particular application to metal to band insulator transitions, change of Fermi surface topology, divergent effective masses, Dirac systems, and topological insulators. Both regular periodic and glassy (and spatially chaotic behavior) may be found in strongly correlated electronic systems.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.86.041132

Related papers

Mapping between finite temperature classical and zero temperature quantum systems: Quantum critical jamming and quantum dynamical heterogeneities

Zohar Nussinov, Patrick Johnson, Matthias J. Graf +1 more

Many electronic systems (e.g., the cuprate superconductors and heavy fermions) exhibit striking features in their dynamical response over a prominent range of experimental parameters. While there are some empirical suggestions of particular increasing length scales that accompany such transitions in some cases, this identification is not universal and in numerous instances no large correlation length is evident. To better understand, as a matter of principle, such behavior in quantum systems, we extend a known mapping (earlier studied in stochastic or supersymmetric quantum mechanics) between finite temperature classical Fokker-Planck systems and related quantum systems at zero temperature to include general nonequilibrium dynamics. Unlike Feynman mappings or stochastic quantization methods in field theories (as well as more recent holographic type dualities), the classical systems that we consider and their quantum duals reside in the same number of space-time dimensions. The upshot of our very broad and rigorous result is that a Wick rotation exactly relates (i) the dynamics in general finite temperature classical dissipative systems to (ii) zero temperature dynamics in the corresponding dual many-body quantum systems. Using this correspondence, we illustrate that, even in the absence of imposed disorder, many continuum quantum fluid systems (and possible lattice counterparts) may exhibit a zero-point ``quantum dynamical heterogeneity'' wherein the dynamics, at a given instant, is spatially nonuniform. While the static length scales accompanying this phenomenon do not seem to exhibit a clear divergence in standard correlation functions, the length scale of the dynamical heterogeneities can increase dramatically. We further study ``quantum jamming'' and illustrate how a hard-core bosonic system can undergo a zero temperature quantum critical metal-to-insulator-type transition with an extremely large effective dynamical exponent $z>4$ that is consistent with length scales that increase far more slowly than the relaxation time as a putative critical transition is approached. Similar results may hold for spin-liquid-type as well as interacting electronic systems. We suggest ways to analyze experimental data in order to adduce such phenomena. Our approach may be used to analyze other quenched quantum systems.

arXiv:1209.3823•Physical Review B•May 15, 2013•20 citations

Modulation and correlations lengths in systems with competing interactions: new exponents and other universal features

Saurish Chakrabarty, Zohar Nussinov

We examine correlation functions in the presence of competing long and short ranged interactions to find multiple correlation and modulation lengths. We calculate the ground state stripe width of an Ising ferromagnet, frustrated by an arbitrary long range interaction. In large $n$ systems, we demonstrate that for a short range system frustrated by a general competing long range interaction, the crossover temperature $T^*$ veers towards the critical temperature of the unfrustrated short range system (i.e., that in which the frustrating long range interaction is removed). We also show that apart from certain special crossover points, the total number of correlation and modulation lengths remains conserved. We derive an expression for the change in modulation length with temperature for a general system near the ground state with a ferromagnetic interaction and an opposing long range interaction. We illustrate that the correlation functions associated with the exact dipolar interactions differ substantially from those in which a scalar product form between the dipoles is assumed.

•Jun 30, 2009•0 citations

Correlation length, universality classes, and scaling laws associated with topological phase transitions

Wei Chen, Markus Legner, Andreas Rüegg +1 more

The correlation functions related to topological phase transitions in inversion-symmetric lattice models described by $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ Dirac Hamiltonians are discussed. In one dimension, the correlation function measures the charge-polarization correlation between Wannier states at different positions, while in two dimensions it measures the itinerant-circulation correlation between Wannier states. The correlation function is nonzero in both the topologically trivial and nontrivial states, and allows us to extract a correlation length that diverges at topological phase transitions. The correlation length and the curvature function that defines the topological invariants are shown to have universal critical exponents, allowing the notion of universality classes to be introduced. Particularly in two dimensions, the universality class is determined by the orbital symmetry of the Dirac model. The scaling laws that constrain the critical exponents are revealed, and are predicted to be satisfied even in interacting systems, as demonstrated in an interacting topological Kondo insulator.

arXiv:1611.06093•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 7, 2017•78 citations

Multicritical behavior in topological phase transitions

S. Rufo, Nei Lopes, M. A. Contínentino +1 more

Topological phase transitions can be described by the theory of critical phenomena and identified by critical exponents that define their universality classes. This is a consequence of the existence of a diverging length at the transition that has been identified as the penetration depth of the surface modes in the nontrivial topological phase. In this paper we characterize different universality classes of topological transitions by determining their correlation length exponents directly from numerical calculations of the penetration length of the edge modes as a function of the distance to the topological transition. We consider generalizations of the topological nontrivial Su-Schriefer-Heeger (SSH) model, for the case of next next nearest neighbors hopping terms and in the presence of a synthetic potential. The latter allows the system to transit between two universality classes with different correlation length and dynamic critical exponents. It presents a line of multicritical point in its phase diagram since the behavior of the Berry connection depends on the path it is approached. We compare our results with those obtained from a scaling approach to the Berry connection.

arXiv:1907.12701•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 25, 2019•43 citations

Arithmetic tuning of dynamical critical exponents in quasiperiodic localization transitions

Anonymous, Yi-Fan Liu, Enguo Guan +1 more

The critical exponents and universality classes of localization transitions in quasiperiodic systems are of fundamental importance for understanding critical phenomena in aperiodic systems. Here we show that the dynamical critical behavior can be tuned without adding new terms or changing the form of the Hamiltonian, but solely by varying the incommensurate frequency of the quasiperiodic onsite potential. We construct a family of incommensurate frequencies from the limiting ratios of generalized Fibonacci sequences controlled by the parameters $(m,n)$, and use them to define the quasiperiodic onsite potential. By combining generalized fidelity susceptibility, localization-length scaling, and finite-size gap analysis, we find that the correlation-length exponent is insensitive to the choice of the incommensurate frequency and remains consistent with the correlation-length critical exponent, $ν\simeq 1$, in the localization transition of the standard Aubry--Andr'e--Harper model. In contrast, the dynamical exponent extracted from the low-energy gap scaling varies systematically with the incommensurate frequency. Our results show that changing the incommensurate frequency provides a simple way to tune dynamical critical scaling in deterministic aperiodic systems. Our results suggest instead that the arithmetic structure of an irrational number can serve as a control parameter for nonequilibrium quantum dynamics, enabling the tuning of dynamical critical behavior without changing the microscopic Hamiltonian or the physical spatial dimension.

arXiv:2608.23990•Physical Review A•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

Universality classes of dynamical behavior (abstract)

Jian-Min Liu, Gerhard H. Muller

In studies of dynamic correlation functions the focus is, in general, on their long-time asymptotic behavior and the singularity structure of the associated spectral densities. It turns out that the analysis of the same dynamic correlation functions from a quite different perspective is equally useful and revealing. The focus of our study is on the properties of spectral densities at high frequencies, specifically their decay law, expressible asΦ0■ω■ ∼exp■ − ω2■λ■, in terms of a characteristic exponent λ. That decay law governs the growth rate of the sequence of recurrents which determine the relaxation function in the continued-fraction representation. The value of λ contains valuable information on the underlying dynamical processes taking place in the system, which, in some sense, is complementary to that inferred from the singularity structure of spectral densities. A detailed study of the dynamics of various quantum and classical spin models has prompted us to introduce the concept of ‘‘universality class’’ for a classification of dynamical behavior on the basis of the characteristic exponent λ. For the equivalent-neighbor XYZ model1 we are able to demonstrate four different prototype universality classes: λ=0 (compact support), λ=1 (Gaussian decay), λ=2 (exponential decay), λ=3 (stretched exponential decay), which can be interpreted in terms of basic notions of classical dynamics. Finally, we present the exact T=∞ dynamic correlation functions for a two-sublattice Heisenberg antiferromagnet with uniform intersublattice interaction and zero intrasublattice interaction.

Journal of Applied Physics•Nov 15, 1991•0 citations
We study systems with a crossover parameter λ, such as the temperature T, which has a threshold value λ() across which the correlation function changes from exhibiting fixed wavelength (or time period) modulations to continuously varying modulation lengths (or times). We introduce a hitherto unknown exponent ν(L) characterizing the universal nature of this crossover and compute its value in general instances. This exponent, similar to standard correlation length exponents, is obtained from motion of the poles of the momentum (or frequency) space correlation functions in the complex k-plane (or ω-plane) as the parameter λ is varied. Near the crossover (i.e., for λ→λ()), the characteristic modulation wave vector K(R) in the variable modulation length "phase" is related to that in the fixed modulation length "phase" q via |K(R)-q|[proportionality]|T-T()|(νL). We find, in general, that ν(L)=1/2. In some special instances, ν(L) may attain other rational values. We extend this result to general problems in which the eigenvalue of an operator or a pole characterizing general response functions may attain a constant real (or imaginary) part beyond a particular threshold value λ(). We discuss extensions of this result to multiple other arenas. These include the axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model. By extending our considerations, we comment on relations pertaining not only to the modulation lengths (or times), but also to the standard correlation lengths (or times). We introduce the notion of a Josephson time scale. We comment on the presence of aperiodic "chaotic" modulations in "soft-spin" and other systems. These relate to glass-type features. We discuss applications to Fermi systems, with particular application to metal to band insulator transitions, change of Fermi surface topology, divergent effective masses, Dirac systems, and topological insulators. Both regular periodic and glassy (and spatially chaotic behavior) may be found in strongly correlated electronic systems.
Many electronic systems (e.g., the cuprate superconductors and heavy fermions) exhibit striking features in their dynamical response over a prominent range of experimental parameters. While there are some empirical suggestions of particular increasing length scales that accompany such transitions in some cases, this identification is not universal and in numerous instances no large correlation length is evident. To better understand, as a matter of principle, such behavior in quantum systems, we extend a known mapping (earlier studied in stochastic or supersymmetric quantum mechanics) between finite temperature classical Fokker-Planck systems and related quantum systems at zero temperature to include general nonequilibrium dynamics. Unlike Feynman mappings or stochastic quantization methods in field theories (as well as more recent holographic type dualities), the classical systems that we consider and their quantum duals reside in the same number of space-time dimensions. The upshot of our very broad and rigorous result is that a Wick rotation exactly relates (i) the dynamics in general finite temperature classical dissipative systems to (ii) zero temperature dynamics in the corresponding dual many-body quantum systems. Using this correspondence, we illustrate that, even in the absence of imposed disorder, many continuum quantum fluid systems (and possible lattice counterparts) may exhibit a zero-point ``quantum dynamical heterogeneity'' wherein the dynamics, at a given instant, is spatially nonuniform. While the static length scales accompanying this phenomenon do not seem to exhibit a clear divergence in standard correlation functions, the length scale of the dynamical heterogeneities can increase dramatically. We further study ``quantum jamming'' and illustrate how a hard-core bosonic system can undergo a zero temperature quantum critical metal-to-insulator-type transition with an extremely large effective dynamical exponent z>4z>4z>4 that is consistent with length scales that increase far more slowly than the relaxation time as a putative critical transition is approached. Similar results may hold for spin-liquid-type as well as interacting electronic systems. We suggest ways to analyze experimental data in order to adduce such phenomena. Our approach may be used to analyze other quenched quantum systems.
We examine correlation functions in the presence of competing long and short ranged interactions to find multiple correlation and modulation lengths. We calculate the ground state stripe width of an Ising ferromagnet, frustrated by an arbitrary long range interaction. In large nnn systems, we demonstrate that for a short range system frustrated by a general competing long range interaction, the crossover temperature T∗T^*T∗ veers towards the critical temperature of the unfrustrated short range system (i.e., that in which the frustrating long range interaction is removed). We also show that apart from certain special crossover points, the total number of correlation and modulation lengths remains conserved. We derive an expression for the change in modulation length with temperature for a general system near the ground state with a ferromagnetic interaction and an opposing long range interaction. We illustrate that the correlation functions associated with the exact dipolar interactions differ substantially from those in which a scalar product form between the dipoles is assumed.
The correlation functions related to topological phase transitions in inversion-symmetric lattice models described by $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ Dirac Hamiltonians are discussed. In one dimension, the correlation function measures the charge-polarization correlation between Wannier states at different positions, while in two dimensions it measures the itinerant-circulation correlation between Wannier states. The correlation function is nonzero in both the topologically trivial and nontrivial states, and allows us to extract a correlation length that diverges at topological phase transitions. The correlation length and the curvature function that defines the topological invariants are shown to have universal critical exponents, allowing the notion of universality classes to be introduced. Particularly in two dimensions, the universality class is determined by the orbital symmetry of the Dirac model. The scaling laws that constrain the critical exponents are revealed, and are predicted to be satisfied even in interacting systems, as demonstrated in an interacting topological Kondo insulator.
Topological phase transitions can be described by the theory of critical phenomena and identified by critical exponents that define their universality classes. This is a consequence of the existence of a diverging length at the transition that has been identified as the penetration depth of the surface modes in the nontrivial topological phase. In this paper we characterize different universality classes of topological transitions by determining their correlation length exponents directly from numerical calculations of the penetration length of the edge modes as a function of the distance to the topological transition. We consider generalizations of the topological nontrivial Su-Schriefer-Heeger (SSH) model, for the case of next next nearest neighbors hopping terms and in the presence of a synthetic potential. The latter allows the system to transit between two universality classes with different correlation length and dynamic critical exponents. It presents a line of multicritical point in its phase diagram since the behavior of the Berry connection depends on the path it is approached. We compare our results with those obtained from a scaling approach to the Berry connection.
The critical exponents and universality classes of localization transitions in quasiperiodic systems are of fundamental importance for understanding critical phenomena in aperiodic systems. Here we show that the dynamical critical behavior can be tuned without adding new terms or changing the form of the Hamiltonian, but solely by varying the incommensurate frequency of the quasiperiodic onsite potential. We construct a family of incommensurate frequencies from the limiting ratios of generalized Fibonacci sequences controlled by the parameters (m,n)(m,n)(m,n), and use them to define the quasiperiodic onsite potential. By combining generalized fidelity susceptibility, localization-length scaling, and finite-size gap analysis, we find that the correlation-length exponent is insensitive to the choice of the incommensurate frequency and remains consistent with the correlation-length critical exponent, ν≃1ν\simeq 1ν≃1, in the localization transition of the standard Aubry--Andr'e--Harper model. In contrast, the dynamical exponent extracted from the low-energy gap scaling varies systematically with the incommensurate frequency. Our results show that changing the incommensurate frequency provides a simple way to tune dynamical critical scaling in deterministic aperiodic systems. Our results suggest instead that the arithmetic structure of an irrational number can serve as a control parameter for nonequilibrium quantum dynamics, enabling the tuning of dynamical critical behavior without changing the microscopic Hamiltonian or the physical spatial dimension.
In studies of dynamic correlation functions the focus is, in general, on their long-time asymptotic behavior and the singularity structure of the associated spectral densities. It turns out that the analysis of the same dynamic correlation functions from a quite different perspective is equally useful and revealing. The focus of our study is on the properties of spectral densities at high frequencies, specifically their decay law, expressible asΦ0■ω■ ∼exp■ − ω2■λ■, in terms of a characteristic exponent λ. That decay law governs the growth rate of the sequence of recurrents which determine the relaxation function in the continued-fraction representation. The value of λ contains valuable information on the underlying dynamical processes taking place in the system, which, in some sense, is complementary to that inferred from the singularity structure of spectral densities. A detailed study of the dynamics of various quantum and classical spin models has prompted us to introduce the concept of ‘‘universality class’’ for a classification of dynamical behavior on the basis of the characteristic exponent λ. For the equivalent-neighbor XYZ model1 we are able to demonstrate four different prototype universality classes: λ=0 (compact support), λ=1 (Gaussian decay), λ=2 (exponential decay), λ=3 (stretched exponential decay), which can be interpreted in terms of basic notions of classical dynamics. Finally, we present the exact T=∞ dynamic correlation functions for a two-sublattice Heisenberg antiferromagnet with uniform intersublattice interaction and zero intrasublattice interaction.