Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1203.3711 · Physical Review A

Four-qubit entangled symmetric states with positive partial transpositions

Jordi Tura, Remigiusz Augusiak, P. Hyllus, Marek Kuś, Jan Samsonowicz, Maciej Lewenstein

Published Jun 22, 2012• 52 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We solve the open question of the existence of four-qubit entangled symmetric states with positive partial transpositions (PPT states). We reach this goal with two different approaches. First, we propose a half-analytical--half-numerical method that allows us to construct multipartite PPT entangled symmetric states (PPTESSs) from the qubit-qudit PPT entangled states. Second, we adapt the algorithm allowing us to search for extremal elements in the convex set of bipartite PPT states [Phys. Rev. A 76, 034304 (2007)] to the multipartite scenario. With its aid we search for extremal four-qubit PPTESSs and show that generically they have ranks $(5,7,8)$. Finally, we provide an exhaustive characterization of these states with respect to their separability properties.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.85.060302

Related papers

Entangled symmetric states of N qubits with all positive partial transpositions

Remigiusz Augusiak, Jordi Tura, Jan Samsonowicz +1 more

From both theoretical and experimental points of view symmetric states constitute an important class of multipartite states. Still, entanglement properties of these states, in particular those with positive partial transposition (PPT), lack a systematic study. Aiming at filling in this gap, we have recently affirmatively answered the open question of existence of four-qubit entangled symmetric states with PPT and thoroughly characterized entanglement properties of such states [J. Tura et al., Phys. Rev. A 85, 060302(R) (2012)]. With the present contribution we continue on characterizing PPT entangled symmetric states. On the one hand, we present all the results of our previous work in a detailed way. On the other hand, we generalize them to systems consisting of an arbitrary number of qubits. In particular, we provide criteria for separability of such states formulated in terms of their ranks. Interestingly, for most of the cases, the symmetric states are either separable or typically separable. Then, edge states in these systems are studied, showing in particular that to characterize generic PPT entangled states with four and five qubits, it is enough to study only those that assume few (respectively, two and three) specific configurations of ranks. Finally, we numerically search for extremal PPT entangled states in such systems consisting of up to 23 qubits. One can clearly notice regularity behind the ranks of such extremal states, and, in particular, for systems composed of odd numbers of qubits we find a single configuration of ranks for which there are extremal states.

arXiv:1206.3088•Physical Review A•Oct 15, 2012•47 citations

Low Rank States with Bound Entanglement in a System of three qubits

Børge Irgens

We have studied mixed quantum states in the system of three qubits with the property that all their partial transposes are positive; these are called PPT states. We classify a PPT state by the ranks of the state itself and its three single partial transposes. We have studied especially the rank 4444 and rank 5555 entangled PPT states.We find two distinct classes of rank four states, identified by a real valued quadratic expression invariant under local $\\sln$ transformations, mathematically equivalent to continuous Lorentz transformations. This quadratic Lorentz invariant is non-zero for one class of states (type 1) and zero for the other class (type 2). We present analytical constructions of states of both types, general enough to reproduce all the rank four PPT states we have found numerically.There are six product vectors in a generic five dimensional subspace. The product vectors are used to define SL invariants of the state and its partial transposes. We find four distinct classes of states based which invariants are conserved or not under partial transposition.We find that a state is in the equivalence class of a symmetric state when its invariants are conserved under a partial transposition, and we have shown how to transform the state into its symmetric form through Lorentz transformations.The dimensions and geometry of extremal rank 5555 PPT states has also been examined. We find that states of different types lie on surfaces of rank 5555 different dimensions. And the surfaces touch the simplex of separable states in different ways

81•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Nonequivalence between absolute separability and positive partial transposition in the symmetric subspace

Jonathan Louvet, Eduardo Serrano-Ensástiga, Thierry Bastin +1 more

The equivalence between absolutely separable states and absolutely positive partial transposed (PPT) states in general remains an open problem in quantum entanglement theory. In this work, we study an analogous question for symmetric multiqubit states. We show that symmetric absolutely PPT (SAPPT) states (symmetric states that remain PPT after any symmetry-preserving unitary evolution) are not always symmetric absolutely separable by providing explicit counterexamples. More precisely, we construct a family of entangled five-qubit SAPPT states. Similar counterexamples for larger odd numbers of qubits are identified.

arXiv:2411.16461•Physical Review A•Apr 11, 2025•5 citations

Positive Partial Transpose States in Multipartite Quantum Systems

Øyvind Steensgaard Garberg

In this master thesis I study the extremal positive partial transpose (PPT) states of the three qubit $(2times2times2)$ system using numerical methods. Using two algorithms which locate PPT states of a specified rank and extremal PPT states respectively, I have located numerical examples of extremal PPT states with a variety of ranks. These numerical results confirm the analytical result that all PPT states of rank less than four are separable. I also derive an upper limit on the ranks of extremal PPT states. The extremal PPT states of lowest rank, the rank four states, were studied in more detail. These states were confirmed to be biseparable in accordance with both previous analytical and numerical results. The range and kernel of these states were examined for product vectors, but none were found. In an attempt to parametrize the SL$otimes$SL equivalence classes of these extremal rank four states I have studied an analytical method to construct such states based on unextendible product bases (UPBs). This method can be used to create PPT states from a single equivalence class where, by design, the kernel of all states contain a UPB and the range contains no product vectors. All states where the range is not spanned by a basis of product vectors are necessarily entangled. I also present a numerical method for creating extremal rank four states that are symmetric under various combinations of partial transposes. Numerical examination of these states reveal no product vectors in neither range nor kernel. The existence of rank four states with and without product vectors in their kernel implies the existence of at least two equivalence classes. To get a better impression of these equivalence classes I construct quantities that are invariant under SL$otimes$SL transformations and must therefore have the same value for all states in the same equivalence class. Calculating the values of these invariants for all the rank four extremal states I have generated gives a seemingly continuous range of values. This indicates that there is an infinite number of equivalence classes likely described by one or more continuous variables. The invariants also revealed an interesting set of states that may belong to a single equivalence class, where one invariant is zero and the others have identical values. This was the only equivalence class where more than one of my states were included. There is obviously something special about this class, but I do not know what it is.

66•Jan 1, 2012•1 citation

Extremal states of positive partial transpose in a system of three qubits

Øyvind Steensgaard Garberg, Børge Irgens, Jan Myrheim

We have studied mixed states in the system of three qubits with the property that all their partial transposes are positive; these are called PPT states. We classify a PPT state by the ranks of the state itself and its three single partial transposes. In random numerical searches, we find entangled PPT states with a large variety of rank combinations. For ranks equal to five or higher, we find both extremal and nonextremal PPT states of nearly every rank combination, with the restriction that the square sum of the four ranks of an extremal PPT state can be at most 193. We have studied especially the rank-four entangled PPT states, which are found to have rank four for every partial transpose. These states are all extremal because of the previously known result that every PPT state of rank three or less is separable. We find two distinct classes of rank-4444 entangled PPT states, identified by a real valued quadratic expression invariant under local $\text{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})$ transformations, mathematically equivalent to Lorentz transformations. This quadratic Lorentz invariant is nonzero for one class of states (type I in our terminology) and zero for the other class (type II). The previously known states based on unextendible product bases are a nongeneric subclass of the type-I states. We present analytical constructions of states of both types, general enough to reproduce all the rank-4444 PPT states we have found numerically. We can not exclude the possibility that there exist nongeneric rank-four PPT states that we do not find in our random numerical searches.

arXiv:1212.5036•Physical Review A•Mar 4, 2013•7 citations

Geometry for separable states and construction of entangled states with positive partial transposes

Kil-Chan Ha, Seung-Hyeok Kye

We construct faces of the convex set of all $2\ensuremath{\bigotimes}4$ bipartite separable states, which are affinely isomorphic to the simplex ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{9}$ with 10 extreme points. Every interior point of these faces is a separable state which has a unique decomposition into 10 product states, even though the ranks of the state and its partial transpose are 5 and 7, respectively. We also note that the number 10 is greater than $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4$, to disprove a conjecture on the lengths of qubit-qudit separable states. This face is inscribed in the corresponding face of the convex set of all PPT states so that subsimplices ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{k}$ of ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{9}$ share the boundary if and only if $k\ensuremath{\le}5$. This enables us to find a large class of $2\ensuremath{\bigotimes}4$ PPT entangled edge states with rank 5.

arXiv:1307.1362•Physical Review A•Aug 20, 2013•16 citations
We solve the open question of the existence of four-qubit entangled symmetric states with positive partial transpositions (PPT states). We reach this goal with two different approaches. First, we propose a half-analytical--half-numerical method that allows us to construct multipartite PPT entangled symmetric states (PPTESSs) from the qubit-qudit PPT entangled states. Second, we adapt the algorithm allowing us to search for extremal elements in the convex set of bipartite PPT states [Phys. Rev. A 76, 034304 (2007)] to the multipartite scenario. With its aid we search for extremal four-qubit PPTESSs and show that generically they have ranks (5,7,8)(5,7,8)(5,7,8). Finally, we provide an exhaustive characterization of these states with respect to their separability properties.
From both theoretical and experimental points of view symmetric states constitute an important class of multipartite states. Still, entanglement properties of these states, in particular those with positive partial transposition (PPT), lack a systematic study. Aiming at filling in this gap, we have recently affirmatively answered the open question of existence of four-qubit entangled symmetric states with PPT and thoroughly characterized entanglement properties of such states [J. Tura et al., Phys. Rev. A 85, 060302(R) (2012)]. With the present contribution we continue on characterizing PPT entangled symmetric states. On the one hand, we present all the results of our previous work in a detailed way. On the other hand, we generalize them to systems consisting of an arbitrary number of qubits. In particular, we provide criteria for separability of such states formulated in terms of their ranks. Interestingly, for most of the cases, the symmetric states are either separable or typically separable. Then, edge states in these systems are studied, showing in particular that to characterize generic PPT entangled states with four and five qubits, it is enough to study only those that assume few (respectively, two and three) specific configurations of ranks. Finally, we numerically search for extremal PPT entangled states in such systems consisting of up to 23 qubits. One can clearly notice regularity behind the ranks of such extremal states, and, in particular, for systems composed of odd numbers of qubits we find a single configuration of ranks for which there are extremal states.
We have studied mixed quantum states in the system of three qubits with the property that all their partial transposes are positive; these are called PPT states. We classify a PPT state by the ranks of the state itself and its three single partial transposes. We have studied especially the rank 4444 and rank 5555 entangled PPT states.We find two distinct classes of rank four states, identified by a real valued quadratic expression invariant under local sln\\slnsln transformations, mathematically equivalent to continuous Lorentz transformations. This quadratic Lorentz invariant is non-zero for one class of states (type 1) and zero for the other class (type 2). We present analytical constructions of states of both types, general enough to reproduce all the rank four PPT states we have found numerically.There are six product vectors in a generic five dimensional subspace. The product vectors are used to define SL invariants of the state and its partial transposes. We find four distinct classes of states based which invariants are conserved or not under partial transposition.We find that a state is in the equivalence class of a symmetric state when its invariants are conserved under a partial transposition, and we have shown how to transform the state into its symmetric form through Lorentz transformations.The dimensions and geometry of extremal rank 5555 PPT states has also been examined. We find that states of different types lie on surfaces of rank 5555 different dimensions. And the surfaces touch the simplex of separable states in different ways
The equivalence between absolutely separable states and absolutely positive partial transposed (PPT) states in general remains an open problem in quantum entanglement theory. In this work, we study an analogous question for symmetric multiqubit states. We show that symmetric absolutely PPT (SAPPT) states (symmetric states that remain PPT after any symmetry-preserving unitary evolution) are not always symmetric absolutely separable by providing explicit counterexamples. More precisely, we construct a family of entangled five-qubit SAPPT states. Similar counterexamples for larger odd numbers of qubits are identified.
In this master thesis I study the extremal positive partial transpose (PPT) states of the three qubit (2times2times2)(2times2times2)(2times2times2) system using numerical methods. Using two algorithms which locate PPT states of a specified rank and extremal PPT states respectively, I have located numerical examples of extremal PPT states with a variety of ranks. These numerical results confirm the analytical result that all PPT states of rank less than four are separable. I also derive an upper limit on the ranks of extremal PPT states. The extremal PPT states of lowest rank, the rank four states, were studied in more detail. These states were confirmed to be biseparable in accordance with both previous analytical and numerical results. The range and kernel of these states were examined for product vectors, but none were found. In an attempt to parametrize the SLotimesotimesotimesSL equivalence classes of these extremal rank four states I have studied an analytical method to construct such states based on unextendible product bases (UPBs). This method can be used to create PPT states from a single equivalence class where, by design, the kernel of all states contain a UPB and the range contains no product vectors. All states where the range is not spanned by a basis of product vectors are necessarily entangled. I also present a numerical method for creating extremal rank four states that are symmetric under various combinations of partial transposes. Numerical examination of these states reveal no product vectors in neither range nor kernel. The existence of rank four states with and without product vectors in their kernel implies the existence of at least two equivalence classes. To get a better impression of these equivalence classes I construct quantities that are invariant under SLotimesotimesotimesSL transformations and must therefore have the same value for all states in the same equivalence class. Calculating the values of these invariants for all the rank four extremal states I have generated gives a seemingly continuous range of values. This indicates that there is an infinite number of equivalence classes likely described by one or more continuous variables. The invariants also revealed an interesting set of states that may belong to a single equivalence class, where one invariant is zero and the others have identical values. This was the only equivalence class where more than one of my states were included. There is obviously something special about this class, but I do not know what it is.
We have studied mixed states in the system of three qubits with the property that all their partial transposes are positive; these are called PPT states. We classify a PPT state by the ranks of the state itself and its three single partial transposes. In random numerical searches, we find entangled PPT states with a large variety of rank combinations. For ranks equal to five or higher, we find both extremal and nonextremal PPT states of nearly every rank combination, with the restriction that the square sum of the four ranks of an extremal PPT state can be at most 193. We have studied especially the rank-four entangled PPT states, which are found to have rank four for every partial transpose. These states are all extremal because of the previously known result that every PPT state of rank three or less is separable. We find two distinct classes of rank-4444 entangled PPT states, identified by a real valued quadratic expression invariant under local SL(2,C)\text{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})SL(2,C) transformations, mathematically equivalent to Lorentz transformations. This quadratic Lorentz invariant is nonzero for one class of states (type I in our terminology) and zero for the other class (type II). The previously known states based on unextendible product bases are a nongeneric subclass of the type-I states. We present analytical constructions of states of both types, general enough to reproduce all the rank-4444 PPT states we have found numerically. We can not exclude the possibility that there exist nongeneric rank-four PPT states that we do not find in our random numerical searches.
We construct faces of the convex set of all $2\ensuremath{\bigotimes}4$ bipartite separable states, which are affinely isomorphic to the simplex ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{9}$ with 10 extreme points. Every interior point of these faces is a separable state which has a unique decomposition into 10 product states, even though the ranks of the state and its partial transpose are 5 and 7, respectively. We also note that the number 10 is greater than $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4$, to disprove a conjecture on the lengths of qubit-qudit separable states. This face is inscribed in the corresponding face of the convex set of all PPT states so that subsimplices ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{k}$ of ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{9}$ share the boundary if and only if $k\ensuremath{\le}5$. This enables us to find a large class of $2\ensuremath{\bigotimes}4$ PPT entangled edge states with rank 5.