Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1203.2675

Quantum Simpsons Paradox and High Order Bell-Tsirelson Inequalities

Yaoyun Shi

Published Mar 12, 2012• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The well-known Simpson's Paradox, or Yule-Simpson Effect, in statistics is often illustrated by the following thought experiment: A drug may be found in a trial to increase the survival rate for both men and women, but decrease the rate for all the subjects as a whole. This paradoxical reversal effect has been found in numerous datasets across many disciplines, and is now included in most introductory statistics textbooks. In the language of the drug trial, the effect is impossible, however, if both treatment groups' survival rates are higher than both control groups'. Here we show that for quantum probabilities, such a reversal remains possible. In particular, a "quantum drug", so to speak, could be life-saving for both men and women yet deadly for the whole population. We further identify a simple inequality on conditional probabilities that must hold classically but is violated by our quantum scenarios, and completely characterize the maximum quantum violation. As polynomial inequalities on entries of the density operator, our inequalities are of degree 6.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1203.2675

Related papers

Experimental investigation of quantum Simpson's paradox

Yulong Li, Jian‐Shun Tang, Yi‐Tao Wang +9 more

The well-known Simpson's paradox, or Yule-Simpson (YS) effect, is often encountered in social-science and medical-science statistics. It occurs when the correlations present in different groups are reversed if the groups are combined. Simpson's paradox also exists in quantum measurements. In this Brief Report, we experimentally realized two analogous effects: the quantum-classical YS effect and the quantum-quantum YS effect in the quantum-dot system. We also compared the probability of obtaining those two effects under identical quantum measurements and found that the quantum-quantum YS effect is more likely to occur than the quantum-classical YS effect.

Physical Review A•Jul 24, 2013•9 citations

ON THE POTENTIAL INFLUENCE OF QUANTUM NOISE ON MEASURING EFFECTIVENESS IN CLINICAL TRIALS

Dominik Janzing, Thomas Beth

To test the effectiveness of a drug, the medical researcher can instruct two randomly selected groups of patients to take the drug or not to take it. Each group should comply with the instructions exactly or else the causal effect cannot be identified satisfactorily. This holds true even when those who do not comply are identified afterwards, since latent factors such as patient's personality can influence both his decision and his physical response. However, one can still give bounds on the effectiveness of the drug depending on the rate of compliance. They are described by 16 inequalities. Remarkably, the proofs for these bounds given in the literature rely on models that represent all relevant latent factors influencing patient's behavior by hidden classical variables. In a strong analogy to the violation of Bell's inequality, half of the inequalities fail if patient behavior is influenced by latent quantum processes (e.g. in his nervous system). Quantum effects could fake an increase in the recovery rate by about 13%, although the drug would hurt as many patients as it would help if everyone took it. We show that the other eight inequalities remain true even in the quantum case. We do not present a realistic model showing the above effect. We only point out that the physics of decision-making could be relevant for the causal interpretation of every-day life statistical data. Our derivation of the remaining eight inequalities suggests how to avoid problematic hidden-variable models in classical causal reasoning by representing all latent factors by quantum systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208006•International Journal of Quantum Information•Apr 1, 2006•3 citations

Simpson’s paradox in cross-platform quantum deviceanalysis: A methodological case study using Josephsonjunction decoherence data

Mahgoub A. Salih

Abstract Cross-platform comparison of quantum devices requires careful statistical methodologyto avoid spurious conclusions. We present a methodological case study demonstrating howSimpson’s paradox can arise in meta-analyses of superconducting circuit data. We introducetwo physically motivated scaling parameters—a dimensionless normalized temperature T∗ =kBT/hf and a resistance-like decoherence parameter A = (hf/eIc)(ln Q/2π)—and applythem to a secondary analysis of published data from Transmon, SNS, and SINIS devices(N = 10 data points from 3 studies).Across the pooled dataset, we observe a strong correlation (r = 0.910) between A and T∗.However, we demonstrate that this correlation is a statistical artifact arising from completeconfounding between temperature and device type: the three platforms operate in nonoverlappingtemperature regimes, and within-group correlations are consistently negative(though not statistically significant given the small sample sizes of n = 3–4 per group).Mixed-effects modeling indicates that platform identity accounts for the dominant share ofvariance in A (ICC ≈ 0.98), though we caution that variance component estimates from onlyk = 3 groups carry substantial uncertainty.Our analysis serves as a methodological warning for cross-platform data aggregation inquantum physics, illustrating how pooled correlations can reverse direction when data aredisaggregated—a hallmark of Simpson’s paradox. The proposed scaling framework may proveuseful for future benchmarking, but we emphasize that the current data are insufficient totest any hypothesis of universal thermodynamic scaling. We outline experimental conditionsnecessary for such tests, including overlapping temperature ranges and controlled singledevicesweeps.This work is intended as a methodological case study rather than a test of aphysical scaling law

•Feb 4, 2026•0 citations

Tsirelson bounds for quantum correlations with indefinite causal order

Zixuan Liu, Giulio Chiribella

Quantum theory is in principle compatible with processes that violate causal inequalities, an analogue of Bell inequalities that constrain the correlations observed by sets of parties operating in a definite causal order. Since the introduction of causal inequalities, determining their maximum quantum violation, analogue to Tsirelson’s bound for Bell inequalities, has remained an open problem. Here we provide a general method for bounding the violation of arbitrary causal inequalities, establishing limits to the correlations achievable by arbitrary local experiments and by arbitrary quantum processes with indefinite causal order. We prove that the maximum violation is generally smaller than the algebraic maximum of the corresponding correlation, and determine Tsirelson-like bounds for a class of causal inequalities including some of the most paradigmatic examples. Our results motivate a search for physical principles characterizing the boundary of the set of quantum correlations with indefinite causal order. Quantum theory has been shown to be compatible with processes violating a definite causal order, but no detailed analysis of the maximum allowed degree of violation has been carried out so far. Here, the authors fill this gap by providing the analogue of Tsirelson’s bound for the violation of causal inequalities.

arXiv:2403.02749•Nature Communications•Apr 7, 2025•17 citations

Extremal Tsirelson Inequalities

Victor Barizien, Jean-Daniel Bancal

It is well known that the set of statistics that can be observed in a Bell-type experiment is limited by quantum theory. Unfortunately, tools are missing to identify the precise boundary of this set. Here, we propose to study the set of quantum statistics from a dual perspective. By considering all Bell expressions saturated by a given realization, we show that the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt expression can be decomposed in terms of extremal Tsirelson inequalities that we identify. This brings novel insight into the geometry of the quantum set in the (2,2,2) scenario. Furthermore, this allows us to identify all the Bell expressions that are able to self-test the Tsirelson realization.

arXiv:2401.12791•Physical Review Letters•Jul 2, 2024•5 citations

Bell's inequality: Physics meets Probability

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We remind the viewpoint that violation of Bell's inequality might be interpreted not only as an evidence of the alternative -- either nonlocality or ``death of reality'' (under the assumption the quantum mechanics is incomplete). Violation of Bell's type inequalities is a well known sufficient condition of incompatibility of random variables -- impossibility to realize them on a single probability space. Thus, in fact, we should take into account an additional interpretation of violation of Bell's inequality -- a few pairs of random variables (two dimensional vector variables) involved in the EPR-Bohm experiment are incompatible. They could not be realized on a single Kolmogorov probability space. Thus one can choose between: a) completeness of quantum mechanics; b) nonlocality; c) `` death of reality''; d) non-Kolmogorovness. In any event, violation of Bell's inequality has a variety of possible interpretations. Hence, it could not be used to derive the unique conclusion on the relation between quantum and classical models.

arXiv:0709.3909•Sep 25, 2007•50 citations
The well-known Simpson's Paradox, or Yule-Simpson Effect, in statistics is often illustrated by the following thought experiment: A drug may be found in a trial to increase the survival rate for both men and women, but decrease the rate for all the subjects as a whole. This paradoxical reversal effect has been found in numerous datasets across many disciplines, and is now included in most introductory statistics textbooks. In the language of the drug trial, the effect is impossible, however, if both treatment groups' survival rates are higher than both control groups'. Here we show that for quantum probabilities, such a reversal remains possible. In particular, a "quantum drug", so to speak, could be life-saving for both men and women yet deadly for the whole population. We further identify a simple inequality on conditional probabilities that must hold classically but is violated by our quantum scenarios, and completely characterize the maximum quantum violation. As polynomial inequalities on entries of the density operator, our inequalities are of degree 6.
The well-known Simpson's paradox, or Yule-Simpson (YS) effect, is often encountered in social-science and medical-science statistics. It occurs when the correlations present in different groups are reversed if the groups are combined. Simpson's paradox also exists in quantum measurements. In this Brief Report, we experimentally realized two analogous effects: the quantum-classical YS effect and the quantum-quantum YS effect in the quantum-dot system. We also compared the probability of obtaining those two effects under identical quantum measurements and found that the quantum-quantum YS effect is more likely to occur than the quantum-classical YS effect.
To test the effectiveness of a drug, the medical researcher can instruct two randomly selected groups of patients to take the drug or not to take it. Each group should comply with the instructions exactly or else the causal effect cannot be identified satisfactorily. This holds true even when those who do not comply are identified afterwards, since latent factors such as patient's personality can influence both his decision and his physical response. However, one can still give bounds on the effectiveness of the drug depending on the rate of compliance. They are described by 16 inequalities. Remarkably, the proofs for these bounds given in the literature rely on models that represent all relevant latent factors influencing patient's behavior by hidden classical variables. In a strong analogy to the violation of Bell's inequality, half of the inequalities fail if patient behavior is influenced by latent quantum processes (e.g. in his nervous system). Quantum effects could fake an increase in the recovery rate by about 13%, although the drug would hurt as many patients as it would help if everyone took it. We show that the other eight inequalities remain true even in the quantum case. We do not present a realistic model showing the above effect. We only point out that the physics of decision-making could be relevant for the causal interpretation of every-day life statistical data. Our derivation of the remaining eight inequalities suggests how to avoid problematic hidden-variable models in classical causal reasoning by representing all latent factors by quantum systems.
Abstract Cross-platform comparison of quantum devices requires careful statistical methodologyto avoid spurious conclusions. We present a methodological case study demonstrating howSimpson’s paradox can arise in meta-analyses of superconducting circuit data. We introducetwo physically motivated scaling parameters—a dimensionless normalized temperature T∗ =kBT/hf and a resistance-like decoherence parameter A = (hf/eIc)(ln Q/2π)—and applythem to a secondary analysis of published data from Transmon, SNS, and SINIS devices(N = 10 data points from 3 studies).Across the pooled dataset, we observe a strong correlation (r = 0.910) between A and T∗.However, we demonstrate that this correlation is a statistical artifact arising from completeconfounding between temperature and device type: the three platforms operate in nonoverlappingtemperature regimes, and within-group correlations are consistently negative(though not statistically significant given the small sample sizes of n = 3–4 per group).Mixed-effects modeling indicates that platform identity accounts for the dominant share ofvariance in A (ICC ≈ 0.98), though we caution that variance component estimates from onlyk = 3 groups carry substantial uncertainty.Our analysis serves as a methodological warning for cross-platform data aggregation inquantum physics, illustrating how pooled correlations can reverse direction when data aredisaggregated—a hallmark of Simpson’s paradox. The proposed scaling framework may proveuseful for future benchmarking, but we emphasize that the current data are insufficient totest any hypothesis of universal thermodynamic scaling. We outline experimental conditionsnecessary for such tests, including overlapping temperature ranges and controlled singledevicesweeps.This work is intended as a methodological case study rather than a test of aphysical scaling law
Quantum theory is in principle compatible with processes that violate causal inequalities, an analogue of Bell inequalities that constrain the correlations observed by sets of parties operating in a definite causal order. Since the introduction of causal inequalities, determining their maximum quantum violation, analogue to Tsirelson’s bound for Bell inequalities, has remained an open problem. Here we provide a general method for bounding the violation of arbitrary causal inequalities, establishing limits to the correlations achievable by arbitrary local experiments and by arbitrary quantum processes with indefinite causal order. We prove that the maximum violation is generally smaller than the algebraic maximum of the corresponding correlation, and determine Tsirelson-like bounds for a class of causal inequalities including some of the most paradigmatic examples. Our results motivate a search for physical principles characterizing the boundary of the set of quantum correlations with indefinite causal order. Quantum theory has been shown to be compatible with processes violating a definite causal order, but no detailed analysis of the maximum allowed degree of violation has been carried out so far. Here, the authors fill this gap by providing the analogue of Tsirelson’s bound for the violation of causal inequalities.
It is well known that the set of statistics that can be observed in a Bell-type experiment is limited by quantum theory. Unfortunately, tools are missing to identify the precise boundary of this set. Here, we propose to study the set of quantum statistics from a dual perspective. By considering all Bell expressions saturated by a given realization, we show that the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt expression can be decomposed in terms of extremal Tsirelson inequalities that we identify. This brings novel insight into the geometry of the quantum set in the (2,2,2) scenario. Furthermore, this allows us to identify all the Bell expressions that are able to self-test the Tsirelson realization.
We remind the viewpoint that violation of Bell's inequality might be interpreted not only as an evidence of the alternative -- either nonlocality or ``death of reality'' (under the assumption the quantum mechanics is incomplete). Violation of Bell's type inequalities is a well known sufficient condition of incompatibility of random variables -- impossibility to realize them on a single probability space. Thus, in fact, we should take into account an additional interpretation of violation of Bell's inequality -- a few pairs of random variables (two dimensional vector variables) involved in the EPR-Bohm experiment are incompatible. They could not be realized on a single Kolmogorov probability space. Thus one can choose between: a) completeness of quantum mechanics; b) nonlocality; c) `` death of reality''; d) non-Kolmogorovness. In any event, violation of Bell's inequality has a variety of possible interpretations. Hence, it could not be used to derive the unique conclusion on the relation between quantum and classical models.