In the study of open quantum systems, the polaron transformation has recently attracted a renewed interest as it offers the possibility to explore the strong system-bath coupling regime. Despite this interest, a clear and unambiguous analysis of the regimes of validity of the polaron transformation is still lacking. Here we provide such a benchmark, comparing second order perturbation theory results in the original untransformed frame, the polaron frame, and the variational extension with numerically exact path integral calculations of the equilibrium reduced density matrix. Equilibrium quantities allow a direct comparison of the three methods without invoking any further approximations as is usually required in deriving master equations. It is found that the second order results in the original frame are accurate for weak system-bath coupling; the results deteriorate when the bath cut-off frequency decreases. The full polaron results are accurate for the entire range of coupling for a fast bath but only in the strong coupling regime for a slow bath. The variational method is capable of interpolating between these two methods and is valid over a much broader range of parameters.
In the study of open quantum systems, the polaron transformation has recently attracted a renewed interest as it offers the possibility to explore the strong system-bath coupling regime. Despite this interest, a clear and unambiguous analysis of the regimes of validity of the polaron transformation is still lacking. Here we provide such a benchmark, comparing second order perturbation theory results in the original untransformed frame, the polaron frame, and the variational extension with numerically exact path integral calculations of the equilibrium reduced density matrix. Equilibrium quantities allow a direct comparison of the three methods without invoking any further approximations as is usually required in deriving master equations. It is found that the second order results in the original frame are accurate for weak system-bath coupling; the results deteriorate when the bath cut-off frequency decreases. The full polaron results are accurate for the entire range of coupling for a fast bath but only in the strong coupling regime for a slow bath. The variational method is capable of interpolating between these two methods and is valid over a much broader range of parameters.
Understanding the dynamics of open quantum systems in strong coupling and non-Markovian regimes remains a formidable theoretical challenge. One popular and well-established method of approximation in these circumstances is provided by the polaron master equation (PME). In this work, we re-evaluate and extend the validity of the PME to capture the impact of non-Markovian polaron dressing, induced by non-equilibrium open system dynamics. By comparing with numerically exact techniques, we confirm that while the standard PME successfully predicts the dynamics of system observables that commute with the polaron transformation (e.g., populations in the Pauli z-basis), it can struggle to fully capture those that do not (e.g., coherences). This limitation stems from the mixing of system and environment degrees of freedom inherent to the polaron transformation, which affects the accuracy of calculated expectation values within the polaron frame. Employing the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection operator formalism, we introduce correction terms that provide an accurate description of observables that do not commute with the transformation. We demonstrate the significance of the correction terms in two cases, the canonical spin-boson model and a dissipative time-dependent Landau-Zener protocol, where they are shown to impact the system dynamics on both short and long timescales.
Calculation of the equilibrium state of an open quantum system interacting with a bath remains a challenge to this day, mostly due to a huge number of bath degrees of freedom. Here, we present an analytical expression for the reduced density operator in terms of an effective Hamiltonian for a high temperature case. Comparing with numerically exact results, we show that our theory is accurate for slow baths and up to intermediate system-bath coupling strengths. Our results demonstrate that the equilibrium state does not depend on the shape of spectral density in the slow bath regime. The key quantity in our theory is the effective coupling between the states, which depends exponentially on the ratio of the reorganization energy to temperature and, thus, has opposite temperature dependence than could be expected from the small polaron transformation.
Recent development of theoretical method for dissipative quantum transport has achieved notable progresses in the weak or strong electron-phonon coupling regime. However, a generalized theory for dissipative quantum transport in a wide parameter space had not been established. In this work, a variational polaron theory for dissipative quantum transport in a wide range of electron-phonon coupling is developed. The optimal polaron transformation is determined by the optimization of the Feynman-Bogoliubov upper bound of free energy. The free energy minimization ends up with an optimal mean-field Hamiltonian and a minimal interaction Hamiltonian. Hence, second-order perturbation can be applied to the transformed system, resulting in an accurate and efficient method for the treatment of dissipative quantum transport with different electron-phonon coupling strength. Numerical benchmark calculation on a single site model coupled to one phonon mode is presented.
A central challenge in the theory of open quantum systems is the development of theoretical frameworks capable of accurately describing large, strongly interacting quantum many-body systems in the regime of strong system-bath interactions. In this work, we take a step toward this goal by formulating a polaron-transformed version of the canonically consistent quantum master equation (CCQME) [T. Becker \emph{et~al.}, Phys. Rev. Lett. \textbf{129}, 200403 (2022)]. The CCQME extends beyond standard weak coupling approaches while retaining the same numerical complexity as conventional quantum master equations, thereby enabling the treatment of large quantum systems. The polaron transformation further enhances the accessible system-bath interaction strengths, allowing us to move from moderate to ultra-strong interaction regimes. We present a unified and transparent derivation of these two approaches and combine them to obtain the polar-transformed CCQME (PT-CCQME). Applying our method to the paradigmatic spin boson model, we find excellent agreement with numerically exact time-evolving matrix product operator (TEMPO) simulations. Finally, we predict an initial-state-independent \emph{slowing} down of thermalization in the strong-coupling regime of the spin-boson model.
We extend and benchmark the recently developed Effective-Hamiltonian (EFFH) method [PRX Quantum 4, 020307 (2023)] as an approximation to the equilibrium state (``mean-force Gibbs state'') of a quantum system at strong coupling to a thermal bath. The EFFH method is an approximate framework. Through a combination of the reaction-coordinate mapping, a polaron transformation, and a controlled truncation, it imprints the system-bath coupling parameters into the system's Hamiltonian. First, we develop a variational EFFH technique. In this method, the system's parameters are renormalized by both the system-bath coupling parameters (as in the original EFFH approach) and bath temperature. Second, adopting the generalized spin-boson model, we benchmark the equilibrium state from the EFFH treatment against numerically exact simulations and demonstrate a good agreement for both polarization and coherences using the Brownian spectral function. Third, we contrast the (normal and variational) EFFH approach with the familiar (normal and variational) polaron treatment. We show that the two methods predict a similar structure for the equilibrium state, albeit the EFFH approach offers the advantage of simpler calculations and closed-form analytical results. Altogether, we argue that for temperatures comparable to the system's frequencies, the EFFH methodology provides a good approximation for the mean-force Gibbs state in the full range of system-bath coupling, from ultraweak to ultrastrong.
While the quantum regression theorem (QRT) is the standard tool for computing multi-time correlation functions in open quantum systems, it relies on system-bath separability and an environment that remains in equilibrium, assumptions that are violated once dynamical correlations develop. Using the projection operator formalism, we derive an extension to the QRT that explicitly incorporates these correlation-induced corrections, enabling us to capture multi-time correlation functions in non-Markovian regimes. We apply this framework to the variational polaron master equation for the spin-boson model in ohmic and super-ohmic regimes, where the polaron transformation mixes system-bath degrees of freedom to produce a non-thermal effective environment. Benchmarking against numerically exact tensor-network simulations, we demonstrate quantitative agreement for single- and two-time observables, including linear-response spectra, even at strong coupling. Our approach broadens the reach of analytic master equations to multi-time observables in strong-coupling and non-Markovian regimes, where environmental memory effects and system-bath correlations are crucial.