Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1112.6356 · Physical Review A

Position-momentum uncertainty relations based on moments of arbitrary order

Steeve Zozor, M. Portesi, Pablo Sánchez-Moreno, J. S. Dehesa

Published May 6, 2011• 41 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The position-momentum uncertainty-like inequality based on moments of arbitrary order for $d$-dimensional quantum systems, which is a generalization of the celebrated Heisenberg formulation of the uncertainty principle, is improved here by use of the R\'enyi-entropy-based uncertainty relation. The accuracy of the resulting lower bound is physico-computationally analyzed for the two main prototypes in $d$-dimensional physics: the hydrogenic and oscillator-like systems.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.83.052107

Related papers

On moments-based Heisenberg inequalities

Steeve Zozor, M. Portesi, Pablo Sánchez-Moreno +1 more

In this paper we revisit the quantitative formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The primary version of this principle establishes the impossibility of refined simultaneous measurement of position x and momentum u for a (1-dimensional) quantum particle in terms of variances: <||x||^2> <||u||^2> ≥ 1/4. Since this inequality applies provided each variance exists, some authors proposed entropic versions of this principle as an alternative (employing Shannon's or Rényi's entropies). As another alternative, we consider moments-based formulations and show that inequalities involving moments of orders other than 2 can be found. Our procedure is based on the Rényi entropic versions of the Heisenberg relation together with the search for the maximal entropy un- der statistical moments' constraints ( <||x||^a> and <||u||^b> ). Our result improves a relation proposed very recently by Dehesa et al. [1] where the same approach was used but starting with the Shannon version of the entropic uncertainty relation. Furthermore, we show that when a = b, the best bound we can find with our approach coincides with that of Ref. [1] and, in addition, for a = b = 2 the variance-based Heisenberg relation is recovered. Finally, we illustrate our results in the cases of d-dimensional hydrogenic systems.

•Jul 4, 2010•0 citations

Entropic uncertainty measures for large dimensional hydrogenic systems

David Puertas‐Centeno, Nico Μ. Τemme, I. V. Toranzo +1 more

The entropic moments of the probability density of a quantum system in position and momentum spaces describe not only some fundamental and/or experimentally accessible quantities of the system but also the entropic uncertainty measures of Rényi type, which allow one to find the most relevant mathematical formalizations of the position-momentum Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, the entropic uncertainty relations. It is known that the solution of difficult three-dimensional problems can be very well approximated by a series development in 1/D in similar systems with a non-standard dimensionality D; moreover, several physical quantities of numerous atomic and molecular systems have been numerically shown to have values in the large-D limit comparable to the corresponding ones provided by the three-dimensional numerical self-consistent field methods. The D-dimensional hydrogenic atom is the main prototype of the physics of multidimensional many-electron systems. In this work, we rigorously determine the leading term of the Rényi entropies of the D-dimensional hydrogenic atom at the limit of large D. As a byproduct, we show that our results saturate the known position-momentum Rényi-entropy-based uncertainty relations.

arXiv:1709.09489•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 2017•26 citations

Generalized position-momentum uncertainty products: Inclusion of moments with negative order and application to atoms

Juan Carlos Angulo

Rigorous and universal relationships among radial expectation values of any $D$-dimensional quantum-mechanical system are obtained, using R\'enyi-like position-momentum inequalities in an information-theoretical framework. Although the results are expressed in terms of four moments (two in position space and two in the momentum one), especially interesting are the cases that provide expressions of uncertainty in terms of products $\ensuremath{\langle}{r}^{a}\ensuremath{\rangle}{}^{1/a}\ensuremath{\langle}{p}^{b}\ensuremath{\rangle}{}^{1/b}$, widely considered in the literature, including the famous Heisenberg relationship $\ensuremath{\langle}{r}^{2}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ensuremath{\langle}{p}^{2}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ensuremath{\geqslant}{D}^{2}/4$. Improved bounds for these products have recently been provided, but are always restricted to positive orders $a,b>0$. The interesting part of this work are the inequalities for negative orders. A study of these relationships is carried out for atomic systems in their ground state. Some results are given in terms of relevant physical quantities, including the kinetic and electron-nucleus attraction energies, the diamagnetic susceptibility, and the height of the peak of the Compton profile, among others.

Physical Review A•Jun 7, 2011•10 citations

On moments-based Heisenberg inequalities

Steeve Zozor, M. Portesi, Pablo Sánchez-Moreno +4 more

In this paper we revisit the quantitative formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The primary version of this principle establishes the impossibility of refined simultaneous measurement of position x and momentum u for a (1‐dimensional) quantum particle in terms of variances: 〈‖x‖2〉〈‖u‖2〉⩾1/4. Since this inequality applies provided each variance exists, some authors proposed entropic versions of this principle as an alternative (employing Shannon’s or Rényi’s entropies). As another alternative, we consider moments‐based formulations and show that inequalities involving moments of orders other than 2 can be found. Our procedure is based on the Rényi entropic versions of the Heisenberg relation together with the search for the maximal entropy under statistical moments’ constraints (〈‖x‖a〉 and 〈‖u‖b〉). Our result improves a relation proposed very recently by Dehesa et al.. [1] where the same approach was used but starting with the Shannon version of the entropic uncertainty relation. Furthermore, we show that when a =b, the best bound we can find with our approach coincides with that of Ref. [1] and, in addition, for a = b = 2 the variance‐based Heisenberg relation is recovered. Finally, we illustrate our results in the cases of d‐dimensional hydrogenic systems.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Heisenberg-like uncertainty measures for D-dimensional hydrogenic systems at large D

I. V. Toranzo, A. Martínez-Finkelshtein, J. S. Dehesa

The radial expectation values of the probability density of a quantum system in position and momentum spaces allow one to describe numerous physical quantities of the system as well as to find generalized Heisenberg-like uncertainty relations and to bound entropic uncertainty measures. It is known that the position and momentum expectation values of the main prototype of the D-dimensional Coulomb systems, the D-dimensional hydrogenic system, can be expressed in terms of some generalized hypergeometric functions of the type p+1Fp(z) evaluated at unity with p = 2 and p = 3, respectively. In this work we determine the position and momentum expectation values in the limit of large D for all hydrogenic states from ground to very excited (Rydberg) ones in terms of the spatial dimensionality and the hyperquantum numbers of the state under consideration. This is done by means of two different approaches to calculate the leading term of the special functions 3F21 and 5F41 involved in the large D limit of the position and momentum quantities. Then, these quantities are used to obtain the generalized Heisenberg-like and logarithmic uncertainty relations, and some upper and lower bounds to the entropic uncertainty measures (Shannon, Rényi, Tsallis) of the D-dimensional hydrogenic system.

arXiv:1609.01113•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2016•12 citations

Heisenberg and Entropic Uncertainty Measures for Large-Dimensional Harmonic Systems

David Puertas‐Centeno, I. V. Toranzo, J. S. Dehesa

The D-dimensional harmonic system (i.e., a particle moving under the action of a quadratic potential) is, together with the hydrogenic system, the main prototype of the physics of multidimensional quantum systems. In this work, we rigorously determine the leading term of the Heisenberg-like and entropy-like uncertainty measures of this system as given by the radial expectation values and the Rényi entropies, respectively, at the limit of large D. The associated multidimensional position-momentum uncertainty relations are discussed, showing that they saturate the corresponding general ones. A conjecture about the Shannon-like uncertainty relation is given, and an interesting phenomenon is observed: the Heisenberg-like and Rényi-entropy-based equality-type uncertainty relations for all of the D-dimensional harmonic oscillator states in the pseudoclassical ( D → ∞ ) limit are the same as the corresponding ones for the hydrogenic systems, despite the so different character of the oscillator and Coulomb potentials.

arXiv:1704.03677•Entropy•Apr 9, 2017•18 citations
The position-momentum uncertainty-like inequality based on moments of arbitrary order for ddd-dimensional quantum systems, which is a generalization of the celebrated Heisenberg formulation of the uncertainty principle, is improved here by use of the R'enyi-entropy-based uncertainty relation. The accuracy of the resulting lower bound is physico-computationally analyzed for the two main prototypes in ddd-dimensional physics: the hydrogenic and oscillator-like systems.
In this paper we revisit the quantitative formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The primary version of this principle establishes the impossibility of refined simultaneous measurement of position x and momentum u for a (1-dimensional) quantum particle in terms of variances: <||x||^2> <||u||^2> ≥ 1/4. Since this inequality applies provided each variance exists, some authors proposed entropic versions of this principle as an alternative (employing Shannon's or Rényi's entropies). As another alternative, we consider moments-based formulations and show that inequalities involving moments of orders other than 2 can be found. Our procedure is based on the Rényi entropic versions of the Heisenberg relation together with the search for the maximal entropy un- der statistical moments' constraints ( <||x||^a> and <||u||^b> ). Our result improves a relation proposed very recently by Dehesa et al. [1] where the same approach was used but starting with the Shannon version of the entropic uncertainty relation. Furthermore, we show that when a = b, the best bound we can find with our approach coincides with that of Ref. [1] and, in addition, for a = b = 2 the variance-based Heisenberg relation is recovered. Finally, we illustrate our results in the cases of d-dimensional hydrogenic systems.
The entropic moments of the probability density of a quantum system in position and momentum spaces describe not only some fundamental and/or experimentally accessible quantities of the system but also the entropic uncertainty measures of Rényi type, which allow one to find the most relevant mathematical formalizations of the position-momentum Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, the entropic uncertainty relations. It is known that the solution of difficult three-dimensional problems can be very well approximated by a series development in 1/D in similar systems with a non-standard dimensionality D; moreover, several physical quantities of numerous atomic and molecular systems have been numerically shown to have values in the large-D limit comparable to the corresponding ones provided by the three-dimensional numerical self-consistent field methods. The D-dimensional hydrogenic atom is the main prototype of the physics of multidimensional many-electron systems. In this work, we rigorously determine the leading term of the Rényi entropies of the D-dimensional hydrogenic atom at the limit of large D. As a byproduct, we show that our results saturate the known position-momentum Rényi-entropy-based uncertainty relations.
Rigorous and universal relationships among radial expectation values of any DDD-dimensional quantum-mechanical system are obtained, using R\'enyi-like position-momentum inequalities in an information-theoretical framework. Although the results are expressed in terms of four moments (two in position space and two in the momentum one), especially interesting are the cases that provide expressions of uncertainty in terms of products $\ensuremath{\langle}{r}^{a}\ensuremath{\rangle}{}^{1/a}\ensuremath{\langle}{p}^{b}\ensuremath{\rangle}{}^{1/b}$, widely considered in the literature, including the famous Heisenberg relationship $\ensuremath{\langle}{r}^{2}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ensuremath{\langle}{p}^{2}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ensuremath{\geqslant}{D}^{2}/4$. Improved bounds for these products have recently been provided, but are always restricted to positive orders a,b>0a,b>0a,b>0. The interesting part of this work are the inequalities for negative orders. A study of these relationships is carried out for atomic systems in their ground state. Some results are given in terms of relevant physical quantities, including the kinetic and electron-nucleus attraction energies, the diamagnetic susceptibility, and the height of the peak of the Compton profile, among others.
In this paper we revisit the quantitative formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The primary version of this principle establishes the impossibility of refined simultaneous measurement of position x and momentum u for a (1‐dimensional) quantum particle in terms of variances: 〈‖x‖2〉〈‖u‖2〉⩾1/4. Since this inequality applies provided each variance exists, some authors proposed entropic versions of this principle as an alternative (employing Shannon’s or Rényi’s entropies). As another alternative, we consider moments‐based formulations and show that inequalities involving moments of orders other than 2 can be found. Our procedure is based on the Rényi entropic versions of the Heisenberg relation together with the search for the maximal entropy under statistical moments’ constraints (〈‖x‖a〉 and 〈‖u‖b〉). Our result improves a relation proposed very recently by Dehesa et al.. [1] where the same approach was used but starting with the Shannon version of the entropic uncertainty relation. Furthermore, we show that when a =b, the best bound we can find with our approach coincides with that of Ref. [1] and, in addition, for a = b = 2 the variance‐based Heisenberg relation is recovered. Finally, we illustrate our results in the cases of d‐dimensional hydrogenic systems.
The radial expectation values of the probability density of a quantum system in position and momentum spaces allow one to describe numerous physical quantities of the system as well as to find generalized Heisenberg-like uncertainty relations and to bound entropic uncertainty measures. It is known that the position and momentum expectation values of the main prototype of the D-dimensional Coulomb systems, the D-dimensional hydrogenic system, can be expressed in terms of some generalized hypergeometric functions of the type p+1Fp(z) evaluated at unity with p = 2 and p = 3, respectively. In this work we determine the position and momentum expectation values in the limit of large D for all hydrogenic states from ground to very excited (Rydberg) ones in terms of the spatial dimensionality and the hyperquantum numbers of the state under consideration. This is done by means of two different approaches to calculate the leading term of the special functions 3F21 and 5F41 involved in the large D limit of the position and momentum quantities. Then, these quantities are used to obtain the generalized Heisenberg-like and logarithmic uncertainty relations, and some upper and lower bounds to the entropic uncertainty measures (Shannon, Rényi, Tsallis) of the D-dimensional hydrogenic system.
The D-dimensional harmonic system (i.e., a particle moving under the action of a quadratic potential) is, together with the hydrogenic system, the main prototype of the physics of multidimensional quantum systems. In this work, we rigorously determine the leading term of the Heisenberg-like and entropy-like uncertainty measures of this system as given by the radial expectation values and the Rényi entropies, respectively, at the limit of large D. The associated multidimensional position-momentum uncertainty relations are discussed, showing that they saturate the corresponding general ones. A conjecture about the Shannon-like uncertainty relation is given, and an interesting phenomenon is observed: the Heisenberg-like and Rényi-entropy-based equality-type uncertainty relations for all of the D-dimensional harmonic oscillator states in the pseudoclassical ( D → ∞ ) limit are the same as the corresponding ones for the hydrogenic systems, despite the so different character of the oscillator and Coulomb potentials.