Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1105.2367 · Physical Review Letters

Comment on “Are There Traps in Quantum Control Landscapes?”

HERSCHEL A. RABITZ, Tak‐San Ho, Ruixing Long, Re-Bing Wu, Constantin Brif

Published May 8, 2012• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many quantum control problems are formulated as a search for an optimal field that maximizes a physical objective. This search is performed over a landscape defined as the objective as a function of the control field. A recent Letter [A. N. Pechen and D. J. Tannor, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 120402 (2011)] asserts that the existence of special landscape critical points (CPs) with trapping characteristics is "contrary to recent claims in the literature" and "can have profound implications for both theoretical and experimental quantum control studies." We show here that these assertions are inaccurate and misleading.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.108.198901

Related papers

Are there Traps in Quantum Control Landscapes?

Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen, David J. Tannor

There has been great interest in recent years in quantum control landscapes. Given an objective $J$ that depends on a control field $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ the dynamical landscape is defined by the properties of the Hessian ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{2}J/\ensuremath{\delta}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$ at the critical points $\ensuremath{\delta}J/\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\epsilon}=0$. We show that contrary to recent claims in the literature the dynamical control landscape can exhibit trapping behavior due to the existence of special critical points and illustrate this finding with an example of a 3-level $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ system. This observation can have profound implications for both theoretical and experimental quantum control studies.

arXiv:1508.05434•Physical Review Letters•Mar 22, 2011•107 citations

Higher-Order Traps in Quantum Control Landscapes of Physical Systems

Boris Olegovich Volkov, Anastasia Aleksandrovna Myachkova, I. M. Korolev +1 more

Abstract An important problem in quantum control is the analysis of quantum control landscapes and its trapping features. The notion of a trap in quantum control landscape was introduced in [H. Rabitz, M. Hsieh, C. Rosenthal, Quantum optimally controlled transition landscapes, Science 303, 1998 (2004)]. Later, the notion of higher-order traps was introduced [A. Pechen and D.J. Tannor, Are there traps in quantum control landscapes?, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 120402 (2011)] and such higher-order traps were shown to exist for a variety of important applications for physical systems such as for example Λ-atoms widely used in quantum optics and superconducting transmon qubit systems used as one of the potential platform for quantum computation. In this note, we provide several results on the existence of higher-order traps in quantum control landscapes.

Russian Microelectronics•Dec 1, 2025•0 citations

Higher-order traps for some strongly degenerate quantum control systems

Boris Olegovich Volkov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Quantum control is necessary for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems. An important problem in quantum control is to establish whether the control objective functional has trapping behaviour or no, namely if it has or no traps -- controls from which it is difficult to escape by local search optimization methods. Higher order traps were previously introduced in [A. N. Pechen, D. J. Tannor, "Are there traps in quantum control landscapes?", Phys. Rev. Lett., 106 (2011), 120402], where 3-rd order traps were found. In this note we show that traps of arbitrarily high order exist for controllable quantum systems with special symmetry in the Hamiltonian.

arXiv:2304.03355•Russian Mathematical Surveys•Jan 1, 2023•10 citations

Quantum Control Landscapes and Traps

Boris Olegovich Volkov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Abstract Quantum control is a necessary tool for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems for various tasks. Traps are points of local but not global optimum of the objective functional for a given quantum control problem. In a more general sense, traps are critical points of the objective functional which are hard to escape by local search algorithms. Here a review of some results of the analysis of possibility of having traps in landscapes of coherently controlled closed quantum systems is given. In one-qubit case, there are no traps. For special multilevel quantum systems, higher-order traps may appear.

Russian Microelectronics•Dec 1, 2023•1 citation

Singularities of quantum control landscapes

Re-Bing Wu, Ruixing Long, Jason Dominy +2 more

Quantum control landscape theory was formulated to assess the ease of finding optimal control fields in simulations and in the laboratory. The landscape is the observable as a function of the controls, and a primary goal of the theory is the analysis of landscape features. In what is referred to as the kinematic picture of the landscape, prior work showed that the landscapes are generally free of traps that could halt the search for an optimal control at a suboptimal observable value. The present paper considers the dynamical picture of the landscape, seeking the existence of singular controls, especially of a nonkinematic nature along with an assessment of whether they correspond to traps. We analyze the necessary and sufficient conditions for singular controls to be kinematic or nonkinematic critical solutions and the likelihood of their being encountered while maximizing an observable. An algorithm is introduced to seek singular controls on the landscape in simulations along with an associated Hessian landscape analysis. Simulations are performed for a large number of model finite-level quantum systems, showing that all the numerically identified kinematic and nonkinematic singular critical controls are not traps, in support of the prior empirical observations on the ease of finding high-quality optimal control fields.

arXiv:0907.2354•Physical Review A•Jul 9, 2012•63 citations

Ловушки высших порядков в задачах квантового управления для некоторых сильно вырожденных систем

Boris Olegovich Volkov, Alexander Nikolaevich Pechen

Quantum control is necessary for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems. An important problem in quantum control is to establish whether the control objective functional has trapping behaviour or no, namely if it has or no traps -- controls from which it is difficult to escape by local search optimization methods. Higher order traps were previously introduced in [A. N. Pechen, D. J. Tannor, "Are there traps in quantum control landscapes?", Phys. Rev. Lett., 106 (2011), 120402], where 3-rd order traps were found. In this note we show that traps of arbitrarily high order exist for controllable quantum systems with special symmetry in the Hamiltonian.

Успехи математических наук•Jan 1, 2023•2 citations
Many quantum control problems are formulated as a search for an optimal field that maximizes a physical objective. This search is performed over a landscape defined as the objective as a function of the control field. A recent Letter [A. N. Pechen and D. J. Tannor, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 120402 (2011)] asserts that the existence of special landscape critical points (CPs) with trapping characteristics is "contrary to recent claims in the literature" and "can have profound implications for both theoretical and experimental quantum control studies." We show here that these assertions are inaccurate and misleading.
There has been great interest in recent years in quantum control landscapes. Given an objective JJJ that depends on a control field $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$ the dynamical landscape is defined by the properties of the Hessian ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{2}J/\ensuremath{\delta}{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2}$ at the critical points $\ensuremath{\delta}J/\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\epsilon}=0$. We show that contrary to recent claims in the literature the dynamical control landscape can exhibit trapping behavior due to the existence of special critical points and illustrate this finding with an example of a 3-level $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ system. This observation can have profound implications for both theoretical and experimental quantum control studies.
Abstract An important problem in quantum control is the analysis of quantum control landscapes and its trapping features. The notion of a trap in quantum control landscape was introduced in [H. Rabitz, M. Hsieh, C. Rosenthal, Quantum optimally controlled transition landscapes, Science 303, 1998 (2004)]. Later, the notion of higher-order traps was introduced [A. Pechen and D.J. Tannor, Are there traps in quantum control landscapes?, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 120402 (2011)] and such higher-order traps were shown to exist for a variety of important applications for physical systems such as for example Λ-atoms widely used in quantum optics and superconducting transmon qubit systems used as one of the potential platform for quantum computation. In this note, we provide several results on the existence of higher-order traps in quantum control landscapes.
Quantum control is necessary for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems. An important problem in quantum control is to establish whether the control objective functional has trapping behaviour or no, namely if it has or no traps -- controls from which it is difficult to escape by local search optimization methods. Higher order traps were previously introduced in [A. N. Pechen, D. J. Tannor, "Are there traps in quantum control landscapes?", Phys. Rev. Lett., 106 (2011), 120402], where 3-rd order traps were found. In this note we show that traps of arbitrarily high order exist for controllable quantum systems with special symmetry in the Hamiltonian.
Abstract Quantum control is a necessary tool for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems for various tasks. Traps are points of local but not global optimum of the objective functional for a given quantum control problem. In a more general sense, traps are critical points of the objective functional which are hard to escape by local search algorithms. Here a review of some results of the analysis of possibility of having traps in landscapes of coherently controlled closed quantum systems is given. In one-qubit case, there are no traps. For special multilevel quantum systems, higher-order traps may appear.
Quantum control landscape theory was formulated to assess the ease of finding optimal control fields in simulations and in the laboratory. The landscape is the observable as a function of the controls, and a primary goal of the theory is the analysis of landscape features. In what is referred to as the kinematic picture of the landscape, prior work showed that the landscapes are generally free of traps that could halt the search for an optimal control at a suboptimal observable value. The present paper considers the dynamical picture of the landscape, seeking the existence of singular controls, especially of a nonkinematic nature along with an assessment of whether they correspond to traps. We analyze the necessary and sufficient conditions for singular controls to be kinematic or nonkinematic critical solutions and the likelihood of their being encountered while maximizing an observable. An algorithm is introduced to seek singular controls on the landscape in simulations along with an associated Hessian landscape analysis. Simulations are performed for a large number of model finite-level quantum systems, showing that all the numerically identified kinematic and nonkinematic singular critical controls are not traps, in support of the prior empirical observations on the ease of finding high-quality optimal control fields.
Quantum control is necessary for a variety of modern quantum technologies as it allows to optimally manipulate quantum systems. An important problem in quantum control is to establish whether the control objective functional has trapping behaviour or no, namely if it has or no traps -- controls from which it is difficult to escape by local search optimization methods. Higher order traps were previously introduced in [A. N. Pechen, D. J. Tannor, "Are there traps in quantum control landscapes?", Phys. Rev. Lett., 106 (2011), 120402], where 3-rd order traps were found. In this note we show that traps of arbitrarily high order exist for controllable quantum systems with special symmetry in the Hamiltonian.