Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1104.2212 · New Journal of Physics

Experimental amplification of an entangled photon: what if the detection loophole is ignored?

Enrico Pomarico, Bruno Sanguinetti, Pavel Sekatski, Hugo Zbinden, Nicolas Gisin

Published Jun 17, 2011• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The experimental verification of quantum features, such as entanglement, at large scales is extremely challenging because of environment-induced decoherence. Indeed, measurement techniques for demonstrating the quantumness of multiparticle systems in the presence of losses are difficult to define, and if they are not sufficiently accurate they can provide wrong conclusions. We present a Bell test where one photon of an entangled pair is amplified and then detected by threshold detectors, whose signals undergo postselection. The amplification is performed by a classical machine, which produces a fully separable micro–macro state. However, by adopting such a technique one can surprisingly observe a violation of the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt inequality. This is due to the fact that ignoring the detection loophole opened by the postselection and the system losses can lead to misinterpretations, such as claiming micro–macro entanglement in a setup where evidently it is not present. By using threshold detectors and postselection, one can only infer the entanglement of the initial pair of photons, and so micro–micro entanglement, as is further confirmed by the violation of a nonseparability criterion for bipartite systems. How to detect photonic micro–macro entanglement in the presence of losses with the currently available technology remains an open question.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/13/6/063031

Related papers

Experimental amplification of an entangled photon: what if the detection loophole is ignored?

Enrico Pomarico, Bruno Sanguinetti, Pavel Sekatski +2 more

The experimental verification of quantum features, such as entanglement, at large scales is extremely challenging because of environment-induced decoherence. Indeed, measurement techniques for demonstrating the quantumness of multiparticle systems in the presence of losses are difficult to define and, if not sufficiently accurate, they provide wrong conclusions. We present a Bell test where one photon of an entangled pair is amplified and then detected by threshold detectors, whose signals undergo postselection. The amplification is performed by a classical machine, which produces a fully separable micro-macro state. However, by adopting such a technique, one can surprisingly observe a violation of the CHSH inequality. This is due to the fact that ignoring the detection loophole, opened by the postselection and the system losses, can lead to misinterpretations, such as claiming the micro-macro entanglement in a setup where evidently there is not. By using threshold detectors and postselection, one can only infer the entanglement of the initial pair of photons, so micro-micro entanglement, as it is further confirmed by the violation of a non-separability criterion for bipartite systems. How to detect photonic micro-macro entanglement in the presence of losses with currently available technology remains an open question.

•Jan 1, 2011•27 citations

Cloning entangled photons to scales one can see

Pavel Sekatski, Bruno Sanguinetti, Enrico Pomarico +2 more

By amplifying photonic qubits it is possible to produce states that contain enough photons to be seen with the human eye, potentially bringing quantum effects to macroscopic scales [P. Sekatski, N. Brunner, C. Branciard, N. Gisin, and C. Simon, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 113601 (2009)]. In this paper we theoretically study quantum states obtained by amplifying one side of an entangled photon pair with different types of optical cloning machines for photonic qubits. We propose a detection scheme that involves lossy threshold detectors (such as the human eye) on the amplified side and conventional photon detectors on the other side. We show that correlations obtained with such coarse-grained measurements prove the entanglement of the initial photon pair and do not prove the entanglement of the amplified state. We emphasize the importance of the detection loophole in Bell violation experiments by giving a simple preparation technique for separable states that violate a Bell inequality without closing this loophole. Finally, we analyze the genuine entanglement of the amplified states and its robustness to losses before, during, and after amplification.

arXiv:1005.5083•Physical Review A•Nov 15, 2010•45 citations

Entanglement criteria for micro-macroscopic systems

Chiara Vitelli, Fabio Sciarrino, F. De Martini +1 more

We discuss the conclusions that can be drawn on a recent experimental micro-macro entanglement test [F. De Martini et. al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 253601 (2008)]. The system under investigation is generated through optical parametric amplification of one photon belonging to an entangled pair. The adopted entanglement criterion allows to infer the presence of entanglement before losses, that occur on the macrostate, under specific assumptions. In particular, an a priori knowledge of the system that generates the micro-macro pair is necessary to exclude a class of separable states that can reproduce the obtained experimental results. Finally, we discuss the feasibility of a micro-macro “genuine” entanglement test on the analyzed system by considering different strategies, which show that in principle a fraction , proportional to the number of photons that survive the lossy process, of the original entanglement persists in any losses regime. PACS numbers: 03.67.Mn, 03.65.Ud, 03.67.Bg

•Jun 22, 2010•0 citations

Towards loophole-free Bell inequality test with preselected unsymmetrical singlet states of light

Magdalena Stobińska, Falk Töppel, Pavel Sekatski +1 more

Can a Bell test with no detection loophole be demonstrated for multiphoton entangled states of light within the current technology? We examine the possibility of a postselection-free Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH)-Bell inequality test with an unsymmetrical polarization singlet. To that end we employ a preselection procedure which is performed prior to the test. It allows using imperfect (coarse-grained) binary photodetection in the test. We show an example of a preselection scheme which improves violation of the CHSH inequality with the micro-macro polarization singlet produced by the optimal quantum cloning. The preselection is realized by a quantum filter which is believed not to be useful for this purpose.

arXiv:1304.7460•Physical Review A•Feb 21, 2014•9 citations

Experimental Bell-inequality violation without the postselection loophole

G. Lima, Giuseppe Vallone, Andrea Chiuri +2 more

We report on an experimental violation of the Bell-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (Bell-CHSH) inequality using energy-time-entangled photons. The experiment is not free of the locality and detection loopholes but is the first violation of the Bell-CHSH inequality using energy-time entangled photons which is free of the postselection loophole described by Aerts et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 2872 (1999)].

arXiv:0912.4151•Physical Review A•Apr 19, 2010•46 citations

Entanglement criteria for microscopic-macroscopic systems

Nicolò Spagnolo, Chiara Vitelli, Fabio Sciarrino +1 more

We discuss the conclusions that can be drawn on a recent experimental micro-macro entanglement test [De Martini, Sciarrino, and Vitelli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 253601 (2008)]. The system under investigation is generated through optical parametric amplification of one photon belonging to an entangled pair. The adopted entanglement criterion makes it possible to infer the presence of entanglement before losses that occur on the macrostate under a specific assumption. In particular, an a priori knowledge of the system that generates the micro-macro pair is necessary to exclude a class of separable states that can reproduce the obtained experimental results. Finally, we discuss the feasibility of a micro-macro ``genuine'' entanglement test on the analyzed system by considering different strategies, which show that in principle a fraction $\ensuremath{\varepsilon}$, proportional to the number of photons that survive the lossy process, of the original entanglement persists in any loss regime.

arXiv:1006.4325•Physical Review A•Nov 1, 2010•23 citations
The experimental verification of quantum features, such as entanglement, at large scales is extremely challenging because of environment-induced decoherence. Indeed, measurement techniques for demonstrating the quantumness of multiparticle systems in the presence of losses are difficult to define, and if they are not sufficiently accurate they can provide wrong conclusions. We present a Bell test where one photon of an entangled pair is amplified and then detected by threshold detectors, whose signals undergo postselection. The amplification is performed by a classical machine, which produces a fully separable micro–macro state. However, by adopting such a technique one can surprisingly observe a violation of the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt inequality. This is due to the fact that ignoring the detection loophole opened by the postselection and the system losses can lead to misinterpretations, such as claiming micro–macro entanglement in a setup where evidently it is not present. By using threshold detectors and postselection, one can only infer the entanglement of the initial pair of photons, and so micro–micro entanglement, as is further confirmed by the violation of a nonseparability criterion for bipartite systems. How to detect photonic micro–macro entanglement in the presence of losses with the currently available technology remains an open question.
The experimental verification of quantum features, such as entanglement, at large scales is extremely challenging because of environment-induced decoherence. Indeed, measurement techniques for demonstrating the quantumness of multiparticle systems in the presence of losses are difficult to define and, if not sufficiently accurate, they provide wrong conclusions. We present a Bell test where one photon of an entangled pair is amplified and then detected by threshold detectors, whose signals undergo postselection. The amplification is performed by a classical machine, which produces a fully separable micro-macro state. However, by adopting such a technique, one can surprisingly observe a violation of the CHSH inequality. This is due to the fact that ignoring the detection loophole, opened by the postselection and the system losses, can lead to misinterpretations, such as claiming the micro-macro entanglement in a setup where evidently there is not. By using threshold detectors and postselection, one can only infer the entanglement of the initial pair of photons, so micro-micro entanglement, as it is further confirmed by the violation of a non-separability criterion for bipartite systems. How to detect photonic micro-macro entanglement in the presence of losses with currently available technology remains an open question.
By amplifying photonic qubits it is possible to produce states that contain enough photons to be seen with the human eye, potentially bringing quantum effects to macroscopic scales [P. Sekatski, N. Brunner, C. Branciard, N. Gisin, and C. Simon, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 113601 (2009)]. In this paper we theoretically study quantum states obtained by amplifying one side of an entangled photon pair with different types of optical cloning machines for photonic qubits. We propose a detection scheme that involves lossy threshold detectors (such as the human eye) on the amplified side and conventional photon detectors on the other side. We show that correlations obtained with such coarse-grained measurements prove the entanglement of the initial photon pair and do not prove the entanglement of the amplified state. We emphasize the importance of the detection loophole in Bell violation experiments by giving a simple preparation technique for separable states that violate a Bell inequality without closing this loophole. Finally, we analyze the genuine entanglement of the amplified states and its robustness to losses before, during, and after amplification.
We discuss the conclusions that can be drawn on a recent experimental micro-macro entanglement test [F. De Martini et. al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 253601 (2008)]. The system under investigation is generated through optical parametric amplification of one photon belonging to an entangled pair. The adopted entanglement criterion allows to infer the presence of entanglement before losses, that occur on the macrostate, under specific assumptions. In particular, an a priori knowledge of the system that generates the micro-macro pair is necessary to exclude a class of separable states that can reproduce the obtained experimental results. Finally, we discuss the feasibility of a micro-macro “genuine” entanglement test on the analyzed system by considering different strategies, which show that in principle a fraction , proportional to the number of photons that survive the lossy process, of the original entanglement persists in any losses regime. PACS numbers: 03.67.Mn, 03.65.Ud, 03.67.Bg
Can a Bell test with no detection loophole be demonstrated for multiphoton entangled states of light within the current technology? We examine the possibility of a postselection-free Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH)-Bell inequality test with an unsymmetrical polarization singlet. To that end we employ a preselection procedure which is performed prior to the test. It allows using imperfect (coarse-grained) binary photodetection in the test. We show an example of a preselection scheme which improves violation of the CHSH inequality with the micro-macro polarization singlet produced by the optimal quantum cloning. The preselection is realized by a quantum filter which is believed not to be useful for this purpose.
We discuss the conclusions that can be drawn on a recent experimental micro-macro entanglement test [De Martini, Sciarrino, and Vitelli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 253601 (2008)]. The system under investigation is generated through optical parametric amplification of one photon belonging to an entangled pair. The adopted entanglement criterion makes it possible to infer the presence of entanglement before losses that occur on the macrostate under a specific assumption. In particular, an a priori knowledge of the system that generates the micro-macro pair is necessary to exclude a class of separable states that can reproduce the obtained experimental results. Finally, we discuss the feasibility of a micro-macro ``genuine'' entanglement test on the analyzed system by considering different strategies, which show that in principle a fraction $\ensuremath{\varepsilon}$, proportional to the number of photons that survive the lossy process, of the original entanglement persists in any loss regime.