Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1103.5058

Communication cost of simulating entanglement swapping

Nicolas Brunner, Cyril Branciard, Nicolas Gisin, Denis Rosset

Published Mar 25, 2011• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement appears in two different ways in quantum mechanics, namely as a property of states and as a property of measurement outcomes in joint measurements. By combining these two aspects of entanglement, it is possible to generate nonlocality between particles that never interacted, using the protocol of entanglement swapping. We investigate the communication cost of classically simulating this process. While the communication cost of simulating nonlocal correlations of entangled states appears to be generally quite low, we show here that infinite communication is required to simulate entanglement swapping. This result is derived in the scenario of bilocality, where distant sources of particles are assumed to be independent, and takes advantage of a previous result of Massar et al. [Phys. Rev. A {\bf 63}, 052305 (2001)]. Our result implies that any classical model simulating entanglement swapping must either assume that (i) infinite shared randomness is available between any two locations in the universe, or that (ii) infinite communication takes place.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1103.5058

Related papers

Classical Simulation of Entanglement Swapping with Bounded Communication

Cyril Branciard, Nicolas Brunner, Harry Buhrman +5 more

Entanglement appears under two different forms in quantum theory, namely, as a property of states of joint systems and as a property of measurement eigenstates in joint measurements. By combining these two aspects of entanglement, it is possible to generate nonlocality between particles that never interacted, using the protocol of entanglement swapping. We show that even in the more constraining bilocal scenario where distant sources of particles are assumed to be independent, i.e., to share no prior randomness, entanglement swapping can be simulated classically with bounded communication, using only 9 bits in total. Our result thus provides an upper bound on the nonlocality of the entanglement swapping process.

arXiv:1203.0445•Physical Review Letters•Sep 4, 2012•58 citations

Tensor norms and the classical communication complexity of nonlocal quantum measurement

Yaoyun Shi

Nonlocality is at the heart of quantum information processing. In this paper we investigate the minimum amount of classical communication required to simulate a nonlocal quantum measurement. We derive general upper bounds, which in turn translate to systematic classical simulations of quantum communication protocols.As a concrete application, we prove that any quantum communication protocol with shared entanglement for computing a Boolean function can be simulated by a classical protocol whose cost does not depend on the amount of the shared entanglement. This implies that if the cost of communication is a constant, quantum and classical protocols, with shared entanglement and shared coins, respectively, compute the same class of functions.Furthermore, we describe a new class of efficient quantum communication protocols based on fast quantum algorithms. While some of them have efficient classical simulations by our method, others appear to be good candidates for separating quantum v.s. classical protocols, and quantum protocols with v.s. without shared entanglement.Yet another application is in the context of simulating quantum correlations using local hidden variable models augmented with classical communications. We give a constant cost, approximate simulation of quantum correlations when the number of correlated variables is a constant, while the dimension of the entanglement and the number of possible measurements can be arbitrary.Our upper bounds are expressed in terms of some tensor norms on the measurement operator. Those norms capture the nonlocality of bipartite operators in their own way and may be of independent interest and further applications.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•May 22, 2005•5 citations

Quantum communication and Bell nonlocality require infinite classical communication to simulate

Carlos de Gois, Thyago S. R. Santos, Carlos Vieira

A quantum system of any fixed dimension can be prepared in a continuum of states, yet it cannot be used to transmit an unlimited amount of classical information. Similarly, the correlations observed between measurement outcomes on separate parts of a shared quantum system can be stronger than classical correlations, but they cannot transmit information. These fundamental limitations suggest that the statistics observed from quantum communication and quantum correlations may admit a simulation using a finite amount of classical communication. This expectation is confirmed in the smallest nontrivial quantum dimension, with two classical bits being necessary and sufficient to exactly simulate qubit communication and all correlations between qubits. Despite significant efforts during the previous decades, this remained the only solved case. Here we resolve both problems for every quantum dimension. The solution reveals an unexpected qualitative transition starting at dimension four: no finite amount of classical communication can exactly simulate ququart communication nor all quantum correlations of two entangled ququarts, even with unlimited shared randomness. One might have expected this transition, if it existed, to appear already for qutrits. Instead, we construct an explicit protocol that exactly simulates qutrit communication using $357$ classical bits, and consequently, all correlations of two entangled qutrits.

quant-pharXiv:2609.04182•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations

Communication cost in simulating unknown entangled states

Kelvin Onggadinata, Paweł Kurzyński, Dagomir Kaszlikowski

We demonstrate how to universally simulate ensemble statistics of projective local measurements on any $n$-qubit state shared among $n$ observers with classical communication and shared randomness. Our technique originates from protocols designed to simulate quantum nonlocality [in Horizons of the Mind (Springer, Cham, 2014)] and classical simulation of quantum circuits [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 070501 (2015)]. The protocol preserves three crucial aspects of the simulated quantum scenario in contrast to other approaches: no involvement of additional parties, none of the observers knows the global state of the system, and local measurement settings remain undisclosed. The simulation cost grows exponentially with the number of observers.

arXiv:2402.11610•Physical Review A•Sep 24, 2024•1 citation

Approximate simulation of entanglement with a linear cost of communication

A. Montina

Bell's theorem implies that the outcomes of local measurements on two maximally entangled systems cannot be simulated without classical communication between the parties. The communication cost is finite for $n$ Bell states, but it grows exponentially in $n$. Three simple protocols are presented that provide approximate simulations for low-dimensional entangled systems and require a linearly growing amount of communication. We have tested them by performing some simulations for a family of measurements. The maximal error is less than $1%$ in three dimensions and grows sublinearly with the number of entangled bits in the range numerically tested. One protocol is the multidimensional generalization of the exact Toner-Bacon [Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 187904 (2003)] model for a single Bell state. The other two protocols are generalizations of an alternative exact model, which we derive from the Kochen-Specker [J. Math. Mech. 17, 59 (1967)] scheme for simulating single-qubit measurements. These protocols can give some indication for finding optimal one-way communication protocols that classically simulate entanglement and quantum channels. Furthermore they can be useful for deciding if a quantum communication protocol provides an advantage on classical protocols.

arXiv:1107.4647•Physical Review A•Oct 5, 2011•8 citations

Bilocal versus nonbilocal correlations in entanglement-swapping experiments

Cyril Branciard, Denis Rosset, Nicolas Gisin +1 more

Entanglement swapping is a process by which two initially independent quantum systems can become entangled and generate nonlocal correlations. To characterize such correlations, we compare them to those predicted by bilocal models, where systems that are initially independent are described by uncorrelated states. We extend in this paper the analysis of bilocal correlations initiated in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 170401 (2010)]. In particular, we derive new Bell-type inequalities based on the bilocality assumption in different scenarios, we study their possible quantum violations, and we analyze their resistance to experimental imperfections. The bilocality assumption, being stronger than Bell's standard local causality assumption, lowers the requirements for the demonstration of quantumness in entanglement-swapping experiments.

arXiv:1112.4502•Physical Review A•Mar 19, 2012•257 citations
Entanglement appears in two different ways in quantum mechanics, namely as a property of states and as a property of measurement outcomes in joint measurements. By combining these two aspects of entanglement, it is possible to generate nonlocality between particles that never interacted, using the protocol of entanglement swapping. We investigate the communication cost of classically simulating this process. While the communication cost of simulating nonlocal correlations of entangled states appears to be generally quite low, we show here that infinite communication is required to simulate entanglement swapping. This result is derived in the scenario of bilocality, where distant sources of particles are assumed to be independent, and takes advantage of a previous result of Massar et al. [Phys. Rev. A {\bf 63}, 052305 (2001)]. Our result implies that any classical model simulating entanglement swapping must either assume that (i) infinite shared randomness is available between any two locations in the universe, or that (ii) infinite communication takes place.
Entanglement appears under two different forms in quantum theory, namely, as a property of states of joint systems and as a property of measurement eigenstates in joint measurements. By combining these two aspects of entanglement, it is possible to generate nonlocality between particles that never interacted, using the protocol of entanglement swapping. We show that even in the more constraining bilocal scenario where distant sources of particles are assumed to be independent, i.e., to share no prior randomness, entanglement swapping can be simulated classically with bounded communication, using only 9 bits in total. Our result thus provides an upper bound on the nonlocality of the entanglement swapping process.
Nonlocality is at the heart of quantum information processing. In this paper we investigate the minimum amount of classical communication required to simulate a nonlocal quantum measurement. We derive general upper bounds, which in turn translate to systematic classical simulations of quantum communication protocols.As a concrete application, we prove that any quantum communication protocol with shared entanglement for computing a Boolean function can be simulated by a classical protocol whose cost does not depend on the amount of the shared entanglement. This implies that if the cost of communication is a constant, quantum and classical protocols, with shared entanglement and shared coins, respectively, compute the same class of functions.Furthermore, we describe a new class of efficient quantum communication protocols based on fast quantum algorithms. While some of them have efficient classical simulations by our method, others appear to be good candidates for separating quantum v.s. classical protocols, and quantum protocols with v.s. without shared entanglement.Yet another application is in the context of simulating quantum correlations using local hidden variable models augmented with classical communications. We give a constant cost, approximate simulation of quantum correlations when the number of correlated variables is a constant, while the dimension of the entanglement and the number of possible measurements can be arbitrary.Our upper bounds are expressed in terms of some tensor norms on the measurement operator. Those norms capture the nonlocality of bipartite operators in their own way and may be of independent interest and further applications.
A quantum system of any fixed dimension can be prepared in a continuum of states, yet it cannot be used to transmit an unlimited amount of classical information. Similarly, the correlations observed between measurement outcomes on separate parts of a shared quantum system can be stronger than classical correlations, but they cannot transmit information. These fundamental limitations suggest that the statistics observed from quantum communication and quantum correlations may admit a simulation using a finite amount of classical communication. This expectation is confirmed in the smallest nontrivial quantum dimension, with two classical bits being necessary and sufficient to exactly simulate qubit communication and all correlations between qubits. Despite significant efforts during the previous decades, this remained the only solved case. Here we resolve both problems for every quantum dimension. The solution reveals an unexpected qualitative transition starting at dimension four: no finite amount of classical communication can exactly simulate ququart communication nor all quantum correlations of two entangled ququarts, even with unlimited shared randomness. One might have expected this transition, if it existed, to appear already for qutrits. Instead, we construct an explicit protocol that exactly simulates qutrit communication using 357357357 classical bits, and consequently, all correlations of two entangled qutrits.
We demonstrate how to universally simulate ensemble statistics of projective local measurements on any nnn-qubit state shared among nnn observers with classical communication and shared randomness. Our technique originates from protocols designed to simulate quantum nonlocality [in Horizons of the Mind (Springer, Cham, 2014)] and classical simulation of quantum circuits [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 070501 (2015)]. The protocol preserves three crucial aspects of the simulated quantum scenario in contrast to other approaches: no involvement of additional parties, none of the observers knows the global state of the system, and local measurement settings remain undisclosed. The simulation cost grows exponentially with the number of observers.
Bell's theorem implies that the outcomes of local measurements on two maximally entangled systems cannot be simulated without classical communication between the parties. The communication cost is finite for nnn Bell states, but it grows exponentially in nnn. Three simple protocols are presented that provide approximate simulations for low-dimensional entangled systems and require a linearly growing amount of communication. We have tested them by performing some simulations for a family of measurements. The maximal error is less than 11%1 in three dimensions and grows sublinearly with the number of entangled bits in the range numerically tested. One protocol is the multidimensional generalization of the exact Toner-Bacon [Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 187904 (2003)] model for a single Bell state. The other two protocols are generalizations of an alternative exact model, which we derive from the Kochen-Specker [J. Math. Mech. 17, 59 (1967)] scheme for simulating single-qubit measurements. These protocols can give some indication for finding optimal one-way communication protocols that classically simulate entanglement and quantum channels. Furthermore they can be useful for deciding if a quantum communication protocol provides an advantage on classical protocols.
Entanglement swapping is a process by which two initially independent quantum systems can become entangled and generate nonlocal correlations. To characterize such correlations, we compare them to those predicted by bilocal models, where systems that are initially independent are described by uncorrelated states. We extend in this paper the analysis of bilocal correlations initiated in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 170401 (2010)]. In particular, we derive new Bell-type inequalities based on the bilocality assumption in different scenarios, we study their possible quantum violations, and we analyze their resistance to experimental imperfections. The bilocality assumption, being stronger than Bell's standard local causality assumption, lowers the requirements for the demonstration of quantumness in entanglement-swapping experiments.