Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1102.0955 · Physical Review A

Observables can be tailored to change the entanglement of any pure state

Nathan L. Harshman, Kedar S. Ranade

Published Jul 5, 2011• 101 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that, for a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, there exist observables that induce a tensor product structure such that the entanglement properties of any pure state can be tailored. In particular, we provide an explicit, finite method for constructing observables in an unstructured $d$-dimensional system so that an arbitrary known pure state has any Schmidt decomposition with respect to an induced bipartite tensor product structure. In effect, this article demonstrates that, in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, entanglement properties can always be shifted from the state to the observables and all pure states are equivalent as entanglement resources in the ideal case of complete control of observables.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.84.012303

Related papers

Disentangling tensor product structures

Antoine Soulas

As a contribution to the field of quantum mereology, we study how a change of tensor product structure in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space affects its entanglement properties. In particular, we ask whether, given a time-evolving state, there exists a tensor product structure in which no entanglement is generated. We give a concrete, constructive example of disentangling tensor product structure in the case of a C-NOT gate evolution between two qbits, before showing that this cannot be achieved for most time-evolving quantum states.

arXiv:2506.21173•International Journal of Quantum Information•Sep 12, 2025•2 citations

Entangled subspaces and quantum symmetries

Anthony J. Bracken

Entanglement is defined for each vector subspace of the tensor product of two finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, by applying the notion of operator entanglement to the projection operator onto that subspace. The operator Schmidt decomposition of the projection operator defines a string of Schmidt coefficients for each subspace, and this string is assumed to characterize its entanglement, so that a first subspace is more entangled than a second, if the Schmidt string of the second majorizes the Schmidt string of the first. The idea is applied to the antisymmetric and symmetric tensor products of a finite-dimensional Hilbert space with itself, and also to the tensor product of an angular momentum $j$ with a spin $1∕2$. When adapted to the subspaces of states of the nonrelativistic hydrogen atom with definite total angular momentum (orbital plus spin), within the space of bound states with a given total energy, this leads to a complete ordering of those subspaces by their Schmidt strings.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304132•Physical Review A•May 27, 2004•7 citations

Useful variants and perturbations of completely entangled subspaces and spans of unextendible product bases

Ritabrata Sengupta, Ajit Iqbal Singh

Finite-dimensional entanglement for pure states has been used extensively in quantum information theory. Depending on the tensor product structure, even a set of separable states can show non-intuitive characters. Two situations are well studied in the literature, namely, the unextendible product basis (UPB) by Bennett et al.4, and completely entangled subspaces explicitly given by Parthasarathy 22. More recently, Boyer et al.6, Boyer and Mor7 and Liss et al.21 studied spaces which have only finitely many pure product states. We carry this further and consider the problem of perturbing different spaces, such as the orthogonal complement of an UPB and also Parthasarathy’s completely entangled spaces, by taking linear spans with specified product vectors. To this end, we develop methods and theory of variations and perturbations of the linear spans of certain UPBs, their orthogonal complements, and also Parthasarathy’s completely entangled subspaces. Finally, we give examples of perturbations with infinitely many pure product states.

arXiv:2402.14697•Infinite Dimensional Analysis Quantum Probability and Related Topics•Jul 19, 2024•2 citations

On the relative quantum entanglement with respect to tensor product structure

Xulin Liu, C. P. Sun

Mathematical foundation of the novel concept of quantum tensor product by Zanardi et al is rigorously established. The concept of relative quantum entanglement is naturally introduced and its meaning is made clear both mathematically and physically. For a finite or an infinite dimensional vector space $W$ the so called tensor product partition (TPP) is introduced on $End(W)$, the set of endmorphisms of $W$, and a natural correspondence is constructed between the set of TPP's of $End(W)$ and the set of tensor product structures (TPS's) of $W$. As a byproduct, it is shown that an arbitrarily given wave function belonging to an n-dimensional Hilbert space, $n$ being not a prime number, can be interpreted as a separable state with respect to some man-made TPS, and thus a quantum entangled state of a many-body system with respect to the "God-given" TPS can be regarded as a quantum state without entanglement in some sense. The concept of standard set of observables is also introduced to probe the underlying structure of the object TPP and to establish its connection with practical physical measurement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410245•Oct 29, 2004•5 citations

Entanglement convertibility for infinite-dimensional pure bipartite states

Masaki Owari, Keiji Matsumoto, Mio Murao

It is shown that the order property of pure bipartite states under stochastic local operations and classical communications (SLOCC) changes radically when dimensionality shifts from finite to infinite. In contrast to finite-dimensional systems where there is no pure incomparable state, the existence of infinitely many mutually SLOCC incomparable states is shown for infinite-dimensional systems even under the bounded energy and finite information exchange condition. These results show that the effect of the infinite dimensionality of Hilbert space, the ``infinite workspace'' property, remains even in physically relevant infinite-dimensional systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406141•Physical Review A•Nov 23, 2004•12 citations

On the Relation Between Schmidt Coefficients and Entanglement

Paolo Aniello, Cosmo Lupo

We consider the Schmidt decomposition of a bipartite density operator induced by the Hilbert-Schmidt scalar product, and we study the relation between the Schmidt coefficients and entanglement. First, we define the Schmidt equivalence classes of bipartite states. Each class consists of all the density operators (in a given bipartite Hilbert space) sharing the same set of Schmidt coefficients. Next, we review the role played by the Schmidt coefficients with respect to the separability criterion known as the 'realignment' or 'computable cross norm' criterion; in particular, we highlight the fact that this criterion relies only on the Schmidt equivalence class of a state. Then, the relevance — with regard to the characterization of entanglement — of the 'symmetric polynomials' in the Schmidt coefficients and a new family of separability criteria that generalize the realignment criterion are discussed. Various interesting open problems are proposed.

arXiv:0812.4167•Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Aug 13, 2009•16 citations
We show that, for a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, there exist observables that induce a tensor product structure such that the entanglement properties of any pure state can be tailored. In particular, we provide an explicit, finite method for constructing observables in an unstructured ddd-dimensional system so that an arbitrary known pure state has any Schmidt decomposition with respect to an induced bipartite tensor product structure. In effect, this article demonstrates that, in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, entanglement properties can always be shifted from the state to the observables and all pure states are equivalent as entanglement resources in the ideal case of complete control of observables.
As a contribution to the field of quantum mereology, we study how a change of tensor product structure in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space affects its entanglement properties. In particular, we ask whether, given a time-evolving state, there exists a tensor product structure in which no entanglement is generated. We give a concrete, constructive example of disentangling tensor product structure in the case of a C-NOT gate evolution between two qbits, before showing that this cannot be achieved for most time-evolving quantum states.
Entanglement is defined for each vector subspace of the tensor product of two finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, by applying the notion of operator entanglement to the projection operator onto that subspace. The operator Schmidt decomposition of the projection operator defines a string of Schmidt coefficients for each subspace, and this string is assumed to characterize its entanglement, so that a first subspace is more entangled than a second, if the Schmidt string of the second majorizes the Schmidt string of the first. The idea is applied to the antisymmetric and symmetric tensor products of a finite-dimensional Hilbert space with itself, and also to the tensor product of an angular momentum jjj with a spin 1∕21∕21∕2. When adapted to the subspaces of states of the nonrelativistic hydrogen atom with definite total angular momentum (orbital plus spin), within the space of bound states with a given total energy, this leads to a complete ordering of those subspaces by their Schmidt strings.
Finite-dimensional entanglement for pure states has been used extensively in quantum information theory. Depending on the tensor product structure, even a set of separable states can show non-intuitive characters. Two situations are well studied in the literature, namely, the unextendible product basis (UPB) by Bennett et al.4, and completely entangled subspaces explicitly given by Parthasarathy 22. More recently, Boyer et al.6, Boyer and Mor7 and Liss et al.21 studied spaces which have only finitely many pure product states. We carry this further and consider the problem of perturbing different spaces, such as the orthogonal complement of an UPB and also Parthasarathy’s completely entangled spaces, by taking linear spans with specified product vectors. To this end, we develop methods and theory of variations and perturbations of the linear spans of certain UPBs, their orthogonal complements, and also Parthasarathy’s completely entangled subspaces. Finally, we give examples of perturbations with infinitely many pure product states.
Mathematical foundation of the novel concept of quantum tensor product by Zanardi et al is rigorously established. The concept of relative quantum entanglement is naturally introduced and its meaning is made clear both mathematically and physically. For a finite or an infinite dimensional vector space WWW the so called tensor product partition (TPP) is introduced on End(W)End(W)End(W), the set of endmorphisms of WWW, and a natural correspondence is constructed between the set of TPP's of End(W)End(W)End(W) and the set of tensor product structures (TPS's) of WWW. As a byproduct, it is shown that an arbitrarily given wave function belonging to an n-dimensional Hilbert space, nnn being not a prime number, can be interpreted as a separable state with respect to some man-made TPS, and thus a quantum entangled state of a many-body system with respect to the "God-given" TPS can be regarded as a quantum state without entanglement in some sense. The concept of standard set of observables is also introduced to probe the underlying structure of the object TPP and to establish its connection with practical physical measurement.
It is shown that the order property of pure bipartite states under stochastic local operations and classical communications (SLOCC) changes radically when dimensionality shifts from finite to infinite. In contrast to finite-dimensional systems where there is no pure incomparable state, the existence of infinitely many mutually SLOCC incomparable states is shown for infinite-dimensional systems even under the bounded energy and finite information exchange condition. These results show that the effect of the infinite dimensionality of Hilbert space, the ``infinite workspace'' property, remains even in physically relevant infinite-dimensional systems.
We consider the Schmidt decomposition of a bipartite density operator induced by the Hilbert-Schmidt scalar product, and we study the relation between the Schmidt coefficients and entanglement. First, we define the Schmidt equivalence classes of bipartite states. Each class consists of all the density operators (in a given bipartite Hilbert space) sharing the same set of Schmidt coefficients. Next, we review the role played by the Schmidt coefficients with respect to the separability criterion known as the 'realignment' or 'computable cross norm' criterion; in particular, we highlight the fact that this criterion relies only on the Schmidt equivalence class of a state. Then, the relevance — with regard to the characterization of entanglement — of the 'symmetric polynomials' in the Schmidt coefficients and a new family of separability criteria that generalize the realignment criterion are discussed. Various interesting open problems are proposed.