Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1011.5710

Dynamics of quantum vortices at finite temperature

Tod M. Wright

Published Nov 26, 2010• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this thesis, we perform investigations into the behaviour of finite-temperature degenerate Bose gases using a classical-field formalism, focussing in particular on the dynamics of quantum vortices in these systems. We demonstrate that the coherence of the classical field can be characterised by its temporal correlations, and discuss how the phase-symmetry-broken averages familiar from mean-field theories emerge from the field trajectories. We show that a finite-temperature condensate containing a precessing vortex in a cylindrically symmetric trap can be realised as an ergodic equilibrium of the classical-field theory, and demonstrate the identification of the rotationally symmetry-broken condensate orbital and core-filling thermal component from the field correlations. We then consider the nonequilibrium dynamics that result when such a precessing-vortex configuration is subjected to a static trap anisotropy which arrests its rotation, and observe novel coupled relaxation dynamics of the condensed and noncondensed components of the field. Finally, we consider the nucleation of vortices in an initially zero-temperature quasi-two-dimensional condensate stirred by a rotating trap anisotropy. We quantify the emergence of a rotating thermal component of the field, which drives the nucleation of vortices from condensate-surface oscillations, and study the relaxation and rotational equilibration of the initially turbulent collection of vortices. We find that thermal fluctuations of the field prevent the vortices from settling into a rigid crystalline lattice in this reduced dimensionality, and that true condensation in the field is completely destroyed by the disordered motion of vortices. We show, however, that the temporal correlations of the field distinguish the quasi-coherent vortex-liquid phase in the trap centre from the truly thermal material in its periphery.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1011.5710

Related papers

Vortices and vortex lattices at finite temperatures

Allan Griffin, Tetsuro Nikuni, E. Zaremba

The goal of creating and observing quantized vortices in trapped Bose gases arose almost immediately following the first achievements of Bose–Einstein condensation. The motivation for doing so was the obvious analogy with vortices in liquid helium and in type-II superconductors, and the fact that the quantization of circulation is directly associated with superfluid flow. It was recognized that the observation of quantized vortices could be taken as indisputable evidence for the existence of superfluidity in these systems. The review by Fetter and Svidzinsky (2001) contains a summary of the early experiments and the theoretical background for understanding the vortex state in a weakly interacting Bose gas based on the GP equation. This material will not be repeated here apart from those aspects that have a direct bearing on the focus of the present chapter, namely the properties of vortices at finite temperature. Although there have been some theoretical contributions to this subject, much remains to be done. The discussion in this chapter provides a framework for addressing the finite-temperature properties of vortex formation and vortex lattices in the context of the ZNG theory. The results in this chapter have not been published before, apart from those in subsection 9.8.1, which are based on Williams et al. (2002). There are several issues that relate to finite temperatures. First, there is the nucleation and formation of vortices from an initial highly nonequilibrium state. Second, there is the interaction of vortices with thermal excitations, which is responsible for the dissipative dynamics of a nonequilibrium vortex state. Third, there is the question of the final equilibrium state, with respect to the condensate and noncondensate densities in the vicinity of a vortex and to the geometrical arrangement of vortices in space.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 19, 2009•1 citation

Finite-temperature dynamics of a single vortex in a Bose-Einstein condensate: Equilibrium precession and rotational symmetry breaking

Tod M. Wright, Ashton S. Bradley, R. J. Ballagh

We consider a finite-temperature Bose-Einstein condensate in a quasi-two-dimensional trap containing a single precessing vortex. We find that such a configuration arises naturally as an ergodic equilibrium of the projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation, when constrained to a finite conserved angular momentum. In an isotropic trapping potential, the condensation of the classical field into an off-axis vortex state breaks the rotational symmetry of the system. We present a methodology to identify the condensate and the Goldstone mode associated with the broken rotational symmetry in the classical-field model. We also examine the variation in vortex trajectories and thermodynamic parameters of the field as the energy of the microcanonical field simulation is varied.

arXiv:0908.2551•Physical Review A•Nov 24, 2009•20 citations

Dynamical thermalization and vortex formation in stirred two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensates

Tod M. Wright, R. J. Ballagh, Ashton S. Bradley +2 more

We present a quantum-mechanical treatment of the mechanical stirring of Bose-Einstein condensates using classical field techniques. In our approach the condensate and excited modes are described using a Hamiltonian classical field method in which the atom number and (rotating frame) energy are strictly conserved. We simulate a $T=0$ quasi-two-dimensional condensate perturbed by a rotating anisotropic trapping potential. Vacuum fluctuations in the initial state provide an irreducible mechanism for breaking the initial symmetries of the condensate and seeding the subsequent dynamical instability. Highly turbulent motion develops and we quantify the emergence of a rotating thermal component that provides the dissipation necessary for the nucleation and motional damping of vortices in the condensate. Vortex lattice formation is not observed, rather the vortices assemble into a spatially disordered vortex liquid state. We discuss methods we have developed to identify the condensate in the presence of an irregular distribution of vortices, determine the thermodynamic parameters of the thermal component, and extract damping rates from the classical field trajectories.

arXiv:0808.3552•Physical Review A•Dec 2, 2008•29 citations

Finite-temperature dynamics of vortices in Bose-Einstein condensates

Sandeep Gautam, Arko Roy, Subroto Mukerjee

We study the dynamics of a single vortex and a pair of vortices in quasi two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensates at finite temperatures. To this end, we use the stochastic Gross--Pitaevskii equation, which is the Langevin equation for the Bose--Einstein condensate. For a pair of vortices, we study the dynamics of both the vortex-vortex and vortex-antivortex pairs, which are generated by rotating the trap and moving the Gaussian obstacle potential, respectively. Due to thermal fluctuations, the constituent vortices are not symmetrically generated with respect to each other at finite temperatures. This initial asymmetry coupled with the presence of random thermal fluctuations in the system can lead to different decay rates for the component vortices of the pair, especially in the case of two corotating vortices.

arXiv:1309.6205•Physical Review A•Jan 14, 2014•22 citations

Structure and stability of vortices in dilute Bose-Einstein condensates

Sami M. M. Virtanen

Since the first realizations of Bose-Einstein condensation in dilute alkali-atom vapours in 1995, these novel quantum gases have attracted wide interest. The main focus of the research has been on finding out the coherence and superfluidity properties of the condensates. From the theoretical point of view, these systems provide a rare possibility to model an interacting many-particle system exhaustively and quantitatively accurately from first-principles quantum field theories. However, the challenge of developing a correct and computationally feasible finite-temperature formalism still remains.\n\nThe coherence and superfluidity properties are intimately related to the existence and stability of quantized vortices. In this thesis, the structure and stability of vortex states in weakly interacting Bose-Einstein condensates is investigated within microscopic finite-temperature mean-field theories. An effective scheme for computationally solving the Bogoliubov-de Gennes quasiparticle eigenequations is developed, and applied to study the microscopic structure of vortex states in partially condensed vapours. In contrast to experimental observations and the predictions of the zero-temperature Bogoliubov approximation, stationary vortex states are found to be metastable within the self-consistent Popov approximation and its extensions even in the zero-temperature limit.\n\nThe reasons underlying this discrepancy are analysed in detail. A criterion for the validity of stationary mean-field approximations in modelling slowly time-dependent systems is derived, and applied to precessing off-axis vortex states. Under typical experimental conditions moving vortices are shown to be deformed due to the inability of the thermal cloud to follow the vortex core rigidly. Consequently, the validity of the commonly used stationary mean-field theories in describing such states is shown to be questionable. Finally, an analysis of uniformly precessing off-axis vortex states within a fully time-dependent Popov approximation is presented. Even dynamically deformed vortices are shown to become energetically metastable as the vortex core is partially filled with noncondensed gas in the course of thermalization. This self-stabilization mechanism of vortex states, shown to occur under very general circumstances, is an inherent property of all self-consistent formalisms having a structure similar to the Popov approximation. However, it is argued to be affected by the improper treatment of the noncondensate dynamics within these formalisms, and the need for a theory taking properly into account the coupled dynamics of the condensate and the noncondensate in modelling vortex states is emphasized. The computational scheme developed is also applied to investigate possibilities to energetically stabilize multiply quantized vortex states by piercing an externally rotated condensate with a blue-detuned laser beam.

•Apr 4, 2003•0 citations

Vortices in dilute Bose-Einstein condensates

Tapio Simula

Bose-Einstein condensation, first predicted by Bose and Einstein in 1924, was finally realized in dilute, weakly interacting gases of alkali atoms in 1995. A few years later, quantized vortices - intimately related to the phenomenon of superfluidity - were created and observed in these novel quantum many-body systems.\n\nIn this Thesis, vortices in dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates are studied theoretically and computationally using microscopic mean-field theory formalisms. Special emphasis is on the structure and the stability of vortices at finite temperatures. The formation of quantized circulation in Bose-Einstein condensates is investigated, as well as multiply quantized vorticity and the adiabaticity of the precessing motion of a vortex.\n\nThis research strongly relies on numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for the macroscopic condensate wavefunction and the coupled Bogoliubov equations and their variants for the collective quasiparticle excitation eigenmodes. The computed elementary excitation spectra are used, for instance, in determining the local stability of various condensate states. The vortex formation process is studied at finite temperatures in terms of the surface modes of the condensate providing the Landau critical velocities for the breakdown of superfluidity. Free energy calculations are used for determining the thermodynamic equilibrium states.\n\nSingly quantized, axisymmetric vortex states are found to be locally energetically stable even in the zero-temperature limit within the self-consistent finite-temperature approximations. This would imply for the vortex a precession direction opposite to that observed in the experiment. Adiabatic approximation of quantum mechanics is formulated for Bose-Einstein condensed systems and is applied to a case of a moving vortex line. The experimentally observed precessing motion of the vortex is found to be nonadiabatic. A method to create stable multiply quantized vortices using an additional pinning potential is presented. The computed critical trap rotation frequencies for vortex nucleation at finite temperatures are in agreement with experiments and the predictions of zero-temperature field theories.

•Jan 10, 2003•0 citations
In this thesis, we perform investigations into the behaviour of finite-temperature degenerate Bose gases using a classical-field formalism, focussing in particular on the dynamics of quantum vortices in these systems. We demonstrate that the coherence of the classical field can be characterised by its temporal correlations, and discuss how the phase-symmetry-broken averages familiar from mean-field theories emerge from the field trajectories. We show that a finite-temperature condensate containing a precessing vortex in a cylindrically symmetric trap can be realised as an ergodic equilibrium of the classical-field theory, and demonstrate the identification of the rotationally symmetry-broken condensate orbital and core-filling thermal component from the field correlations. We then consider the nonequilibrium dynamics that result when such a precessing-vortex configuration is subjected to a static trap anisotropy which arrests its rotation, and observe novel coupled relaxation dynamics of the condensed and noncondensed components of the field. Finally, we consider the nucleation of vortices in an initially zero-temperature quasi-two-dimensional condensate stirred by a rotating trap anisotropy. We quantify the emergence of a rotating thermal component of the field, which drives the nucleation of vortices from condensate-surface oscillations, and study the relaxation and rotational equilibration of the initially turbulent collection of vortices. We find that thermal fluctuations of the field prevent the vortices from settling into a rigid crystalline lattice in this reduced dimensionality, and that true condensation in the field is completely destroyed by the disordered motion of vortices. We show, however, that the temporal correlations of the field distinguish the quasi-coherent vortex-liquid phase in the trap centre from the truly thermal material in its periphery.
The goal of creating and observing quantized vortices in trapped Bose gases arose almost immediately following the first achievements of Bose–Einstein condensation. The motivation for doing so was the obvious analogy with vortices in liquid helium and in type-II superconductors, and the fact that the quantization of circulation is directly associated with superfluid flow. It was recognized that the observation of quantized vortices could be taken as indisputable evidence for the existence of superfluidity in these systems. The review by Fetter and Svidzinsky (2001) contains a summary of the early experiments and the theoretical background for understanding the vortex state in a weakly interacting Bose gas based on the GP equation. This material will not be repeated here apart from those aspects that have a direct bearing on the focus of the present chapter, namely the properties of vortices at finite temperature. Although there have been some theoretical contributions to this subject, much remains to be done. The discussion in this chapter provides a framework for addressing the finite-temperature properties of vortex formation and vortex lattices in the context of the ZNG theory. The results in this chapter have not been published before, apart from those in subsection 9.8.1, which are based on Williams et al. (2002). There are several issues that relate to finite temperatures. First, there is the nucleation and formation of vortices from an initial highly nonequilibrium state. Second, there is the interaction of vortices with thermal excitations, which is responsible for the dissipative dynamics of a nonequilibrium vortex state. Third, there is the question of the final equilibrium state, with respect to the condensate and noncondensate densities in the vicinity of a vortex and to the geometrical arrangement of vortices in space.
We consider a finite-temperature Bose-Einstein condensate in a quasi-two-dimensional trap containing a single precessing vortex. We find that such a configuration arises naturally as an ergodic equilibrium of the projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation, when constrained to a finite conserved angular momentum. In an isotropic trapping potential, the condensation of the classical field into an off-axis vortex state breaks the rotational symmetry of the system. We present a methodology to identify the condensate and the Goldstone mode associated with the broken rotational symmetry in the classical-field model. We also examine the variation in vortex trajectories and thermodynamic parameters of the field as the energy of the microcanonical field simulation is varied.
We present a quantum-mechanical treatment of the mechanical stirring of Bose-Einstein condensates using classical field techniques. In our approach the condensate and excited modes are described using a Hamiltonian classical field method in which the atom number and (rotating frame) energy are strictly conserved. We simulate a T=0T=0T=0 quasi-two-dimensional condensate perturbed by a rotating anisotropic trapping potential. Vacuum fluctuations in the initial state provide an irreducible mechanism for breaking the initial symmetries of the condensate and seeding the subsequent dynamical instability. Highly turbulent motion develops and we quantify the emergence of a rotating thermal component that provides the dissipation necessary for the nucleation and motional damping of vortices in the condensate. Vortex lattice formation is not observed, rather the vortices assemble into a spatially disordered vortex liquid state. We discuss methods we have developed to identify the condensate in the presence of an irregular distribution of vortices, determine the thermodynamic parameters of the thermal component, and extract damping rates from the classical field trajectories.
We study the dynamics of a single vortex and a pair of vortices in quasi two-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensates at finite temperatures. To this end, we use the stochastic Gross--Pitaevskii equation, which is the Langevin equation for the Bose--Einstein condensate. For a pair of vortices, we study the dynamics of both the vortex-vortex and vortex-antivortex pairs, which are generated by rotating the trap and moving the Gaussian obstacle potential, respectively. Due to thermal fluctuations, the constituent vortices are not symmetrically generated with respect to each other at finite temperatures. This initial asymmetry coupled with the presence of random thermal fluctuations in the system can lead to different decay rates for the component vortices of the pair, especially in the case of two corotating vortices.
Since the first realizations of Bose-Einstein condensation in dilute alkali-atom vapours in 1995, these novel quantum gases have attracted wide interest. The main focus of the research has been on finding out the coherence and superfluidity properties of the condensates. From the theoretical point of view, these systems provide a rare possibility to model an interacting many-particle system exhaustively and quantitatively accurately from first-principles quantum field theories. However, the challenge of developing a correct and computationally feasible finite-temperature formalism still remains.\n\nThe coherence and superfluidity properties are intimately related to the existence and stability of quantized vortices. In this thesis, the structure and stability of vortex states in weakly interacting Bose-Einstein condensates is investigated within microscopic finite-temperature mean-field theories. An effective scheme for computationally solving the Bogoliubov-de Gennes quasiparticle eigenequations is developed, and applied to study the microscopic structure of vortex states in partially condensed vapours. In contrast to experimental observations and the predictions of the zero-temperature Bogoliubov approximation, stationary vortex states are found to be metastable within the self-consistent Popov approximation and its extensions even in the zero-temperature limit.\n\nThe reasons underlying this discrepancy are analysed in detail. A criterion for the validity of stationary mean-field approximations in modelling slowly time-dependent systems is derived, and applied to precessing off-axis vortex states. Under typical experimental conditions moving vortices are shown to be deformed due to the inability of the thermal cloud to follow the vortex core rigidly. Consequently, the validity of the commonly used stationary mean-field theories in describing such states is shown to be questionable. Finally, an analysis of uniformly precessing off-axis vortex states within a fully time-dependent Popov approximation is presented. Even dynamically deformed vortices are shown to become energetically metastable as the vortex core is partially filled with noncondensed gas in the course of thermalization. This self-stabilization mechanism of vortex states, shown to occur under very general circumstances, is an inherent property of all self-consistent formalisms having a structure similar to the Popov approximation. However, it is argued to be affected by the improper treatment of the noncondensate dynamics within these formalisms, and the need for a theory taking properly into account the coupled dynamics of the condensate and the noncondensate in modelling vortex states is emphasized. The computational scheme developed is also applied to investigate possibilities to energetically stabilize multiply quantized vortex states by piercing an externally rotated condensate with a blue-detuned laser beam.
Bose-Einstein condensation, first predicted by Bose and Einstein in 1924, was finally realized in dilute, weakly interacting gases of alkali atoms in 1995. A few years later, quantized vortices - intimately related to the phenomenon of superfluidity - were created and observed in these novel quantum many-body systems.\n\nIn this Thesis, vortices in dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates are studied theoretically and computationally using microscopic mean-field theory formalisms. Special emphasis is on the structure and the stability of vortices at finite temperatures. The formation of quantized circulation in Bose-Einstein condensates is investigated, as well as multiply quantized vorticity and the adiabaticity of the precessing motion of a vortex.\n\nThis research strongly relies on numerically solving the Gross-Pitaevskii equation for the macroscopic condensate wavefunction and the coupled Bogoliubov equations and their variants for the collective quasiparticle excitation eigenmodes. The computed elementary excitation spectra are used, for instance, in determining the local stability of various condensate states. The vortex formation process is studied at finite temperatures in terms of the surface modes of the condensate providing the Landau critical velocities for the breakdown of superfluidity. Free energy calculations are used for determining the thermodynamic equilibrium states.\n\nSingly quantized, axisymmetric vortex states are found to be locally energetically stable even in the zero-temperature limit within the self-consistent finite-temperature approximations. This would imply for the vortex a precession direction opposite to that observed in the experiment. Adiabatic approximation of quantum mechanics is formulated for Bose-Einstein condensed systems and is applied to a case of a moving vortex line. The experimentally observed precessing motion of the vortex is found to be nonadiabatic. A method to create stable multiply quantized vortices using an additional pinning potential is presented. The computed critical trap rotation frequencies for vortex nucleation at finite temperatures are in agreement with experiments and the predictions of zero-temperature field theories.