Optical lattices have emerged as ideal simulators for Hubbard models of strongly correlated materials, such as the high-temperature superconducting cuprates. In optical lattice experiments, microscopic parameters such as the interaction strength between particles are well known and easily tunable. Unfortunately, this benefit of using optical lattices to study Hubbard models comes with one clear disadvantage: the energy scales in atomic systems are typically nanokelvin compared with kelvin in solids, with a correspondingly miniscule temperature scale required to observe exotic phases such as d -wave superconductivity. The ultra-low temperatures necessary to reach the regime in which optical lattice simulation can have an impact—the domain in which our theoretical understanding fails—have been a barrier to progress in this field. To move forward, a concerted effort is required to develop new techniques for cooling and, by extension, techniques to measure even lower temperatures. This paper will be devoted to discussing the concepts of cooling and thermometry, fundamental sources of heat in optical lattice experiments, and a review of proposed and implemented thermometry and cooling techniques.
Optical lattices have emerged as ideal simulators for Hubbard models of strongly correlated materials, such as the high-temperature superconducting cuprates. In optical lattice experiments, microscopic parameters such as the interaction strength between particles are well known and easily tunable. Unfortunately, this benefit of using optical lattices to study Hubbard models comes with one clear disadvantage: the energy scales in atomic systems are typically nanokelvin compared with kelvin in solids, with a correspondingly miniscule temperature scale required to observe exotic phases such as d -wave superconductivity. The ultra-low temperatures necessary to reach the regime in which optical lattice simulation can have an impact—the domain in which our theoretical understanding fails—have been a barrier to progress in this field. To move forward, a concerted effort is required to develop new techniques for cooling and, by extension, techniques to measure even lower temperatures. This paper will be devoted to discussing the concepts of cooling and thermometry, fundamental sources of heat in optical lattice experiments, and a review of proposed and implemented thermometry and cooling techniques.
An outstanding problem in physics is how to understand strongly interacting quantum many-body systems such as the quark-gluon plasma, neutron stars, superfluid 4He, and the high-temperature superconducting cuprates. The physics approach to this problem is to reduce these complex systems to minimal models that are believed to retain relevant phenomenology. For example, the Hubbard model — the focus of this thesis — describes quantum particles tunneling between sites of a lattice with on-site interactions. The Hubbard model is conjectured to describe the low-energy charge and spin properties of high-temperature superconducting cuprates. Thus far, there are no analytic solutions to the Hubbard model, and numerical calculations are difficult and even impossible in some regimes (e.g., the Fermi-Hubbard model away from half-filling). Therefore, whether the Hubbard model is a minimal model for the cuprates remains unresolved. In the face of these difficulties, a new approach has emerged — quantum simulation. The premise of quan-tum simulation is to perform experiments on a quantum system that is well-described by the model we are trying to study, has tunable parameters, and is easily probed. Ultracold atoms trapped in optical lattices are an ideal candidate for quantum simulation of the Hubbard models. This thesis describes work on two such systems: a 87Rb (boson) optical lattice experiment in the group of Brian DeMarco at the University
A key challenge for optical lattice experiments focused on simulating models of strongly correlated electronic solids has been achieving lower temperatures. Although cooling of lattice-well vibrational states has been demonstrated, the motion of atoms through the lattice, characterized by their quasimomentum, has not been cooled directly. Furthermore, quasimomentum equilibration, which is necessary for cooling, has remained unexplored. Here, we use quasimomentum-selective stimulated Raman transitions to directly measure rethermalization rates and cool quasimomentum for a bosonic lattice Hubbard gas. The measured relaxation rate is consistent with a short-range, two-particle scattering model without free parameters at high lattice depths, despite an apparent violation of the Mott-Ioffe-Regel (MIR) bound. Efficient cooling exceeding heating rates is achieved by iteratively removing high quasimomentum atoms from the lattice. Our results may have implications for models of unusual transport phenomena in materials with strong interactions, such as heavy fermion materials and transition metal oxides, and the cooling method we have developed is applicable to any species, including fermionic atoms.
One of the major challenges in realizing antiferromagnetic and superfluid phases in optical lattices is the ability to cool fermions. We determine constraints on the entropy for observing these phases in two-dimensional Hubbard models using determinantal quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We find that an entropy per particle approximately = ln2 is sufficient to observe the insulating gap in the repulsive Hubbard model at half-filling, or the pairing pseudogap in the attractive case. Observing antiferromagnetic correlations or superfluidity in 2D systems requires a further reduction in entropy by a factor of 3 or more. In contrast with higher dimensions, we find that adiabatic cooling is not useful to achieve the required low temperatures. We also show that double-occupancy measurements are useful for thermometry for temperatures greater than the nearest-neighbor hopping energy.
Ultracold atoms in optical lattices can provide faithful analog realizations of the Hubbard model and many of its variants. Recently, these simulators have been augmented with improved programmable controls that enable new routes to state preparation, new kinds of dynamics, and, by extension, access to new observables. I will discuss two examples where such tools have enabled simulations that challenge classical numerical techniques: first, a sampling problem involving non-interacting bosons on a lattice that is closely related to boson sampling; and second, the preparation of low temperature equilibrium states of interacting spinful fermions on a lattice. These simulations have the potential to enhance our understanding of quantum many body physics, including practical problems of interest in material design relating to strongly correlated quantum materials. However, fully harnessing their capabilities in the regime where exact classical numerical simulations are absent requires new, precision probes of the relevant microscopic or thermodynamic quantities.
This thesis describes experiments performed on a gas of lithium atoms in an optical lattice which are relevant to the low-temperature physics of the Hubbard model. The Hubbard model is perhaps the most intensively studied model of fermionic particles on a lattice, both because it is the simplest such model which seriously challenges modern theoretical tools, and because it is a candidate model for describing high-temperature superconductivity in cuprate materials. The challenges associated with numerical simulations of the Hubbard model have motivated “quantum simulations” of the type described in this thesis, in which a well-controlled physical system is engineered to mimic the model, allowing its properties to be determined through experiments. Historically, however, such experiments could not access the low-temperature regime of the Hubbard model most relevant to open questions on materials like cuprates, where modern computational techniques cannot yet definitively characterize the physics. We developed a novel set of cooling techniques which allowed our experiment to access this regime. These techniques are based on adiabatic conversion between a band insulator, which can be prepared with very low entropies using single-atom-resolved control and detection techniques now common in ultracold atomic physics, and various quantum fluids, including Hubbard systems. We then performed the first experiments in this new regime of the Hubbard model, focusing on the anomalous “pseudogapped” metallic state. This state is predicted to exist by computational methods, and is believed to mimic the eponymous state in cuprates which gives rise to high-temperature superconductivity upon cooling. Nevertheless, its properties and mechanisms remain poorly understood. We developed several new measurements that enabled an observation of the pseudogap and which yielded novel data on its thermodynamics, linking the pseudogap to an anomaly in the equation of state. These experiments demonstrate a new mode of operating fermionic quantum gas experiments, in which single-atom-resolved controls, rather than bulk techniques like evaporative cooling, are leveraged to access low temperatures in a sample of several hundred atoms. They also signal the arrival of quantum simulators in a regime of poorly-understood emergent low-temperature phenomena that are relevant to the electronic properties of solids, concretely demonstrating the utility of quantum simulation in addressing frontier problems in quantum many-body physics.
The present thesis is devoted to the study of physical phenomena emerging from strong correlations in strongly interacting quantum many-body systems with several components. Hubbard models are widely used as minimal models which take into account the interactions between particles and they have been studied in relation to phenomena such as Mott localization, unconventional superconductivity, quantum magnetism and many others. All of these striking phenomena share their origin from the strong correlations among fermions induced by their mutual interactions. Furthermore, condensed matter models are usually realized only in an approximate fashion in actual solid-state systems, making the situation all the more puzzling and hard to be treated analytically or numerically. Therefore, a great effort has been performed to simulate Hubbard models in a system of atoms cooled down to ultra low temperatures and trapped in optical lattices. The most peculiar feature of cold atoms experiments consists in the possibility of tuning relevant physical parameters of the systems, as the density or the interactions among atoms, using laser and/or magnetic fields. This paved the way to the observation of fundamental quantum states of matter as the weakly interacting Bose-Einstein condensate, the super fluid to Mott insulator transition, the super fluid BEC-BCS crossover, the Mott transition in systems of composite fermions and so on. Hence, it is considered of great interest establishing connections between the quantum simulations cold atomic toolbox and systems realized in solid-state physics...