In this work we consider some consequences of the Bohr-Sommerfeld-Hansson (Old or quasi-classical) quantum theory of the Newtonian gravity, i.e. of the "gravitational atom". We prove that in this case (for gravitational central force and quantized angular momentum) centrifugal acceleration becomes formally-theoretically dependent (proportional to fourth degree) of the mass of "gravitational electron" rotating around "gravitational nucleus" for any quantum number (state). It seemingly leads toward a paradoxical breaking of the relativistic equivalence principle which contradicts to real experimental data. We demonstrate that this equivalence principle breaking does not really appear in the (quasi classical) quantum theory, but that it necessary appears only in a hypothetical extension of the quantum theory that needs a classical like interpretation of the Bohr-Sommerfeld angular momentum quantization postulate. It is, in some sense, similar to Bell-Aspect analysis that points out that a hypothetical deterministic extension of the quantum mechanics, in distinction to usual quantum mechanics, can reproduce experimental data if and only if it is non-local (superluminal) in contradiction with relativistic locality (luminality) principle.
Belenchia et al. [Phys. Rev. D 98, 126009 (2018)] have analyzed a gedankenexperiment where two observers, Alice and Bob, attempt to communicate via superluminal signals using a superposition of massive particles dressed by Newtonian fields and a test particle as field detector. Quantum fluctuations in the particle motion and in the field prevent signaling or violations of quantum mechanics in this setup. We reformulate this thought experiment by considering gravitational waves emitted by an extended quadrupolar object as a detector for Newtonian tidal fields. We find that quantum fluctuations in the gravitational waves prevent signaling. In the Newtonian limit, rotating black holes behave as extended quadrupolar objects, as consequence of the strong equivalence principle. It follows that consistency of the Newtonian limit of general relativity with quantum mechanics requires the quantization of gravitational radiation, even when the waves originate in strong gravity sources.
The original approach for the self-consistent inclusion of gravity into quantum mechanics of a particle is developed. (There are no connections with second quantization.) The nonstandard action principle is constructed for the stationary situation: the quantum particle in a stationary state creating some nonclassical stationary gravitational field and interacting with it, The accompanying problem of covariantization of quantum operators is considered. The general theory is illustrated by the Newtonian-Schrödingerian and quasi classical limiting cases. The levels of applicability of ordinary quantum mechanics and the problems of measurements and interpretation of nonclassical gravity are discussed. The “uncertainty relations” connecting uncertainties of some “local” parts of curvature and those of the particle’s position and momentum are derived. The superposition principle is generalized on the base of some approximate action.
We extend the systematic calculation of an approximately relativistic Hamiltonian for center of mass and internal dynamics of an electromagnetically bound two-particle system by Sonnleitner and Barnett [Phys. Rev. A 98, 042106 (2018)] to the case including a weak post-Newtonian gravitational background field, described by the Eddington-Robertson parametrized post-Newtonian metric. Starting from a proper relativistic description of the situation, this approach allows us to systematically derive the coupling of the model system to gravity, instead of ``guessing'' it by means of classical notions of relativistic effects. We embed this technical result into a critical discussion concerning the problem of implementing and interpreting general couplings to the gravitational field and the connected problem of how to properly address the question concerning the validity of the Equivalence Principle in Quantum Mechanics.
We analyse the gravitational Aharonov-Bohm (AB) phase within the semiclassical framework. We first review the traditional non-relativistic approximation, where a particle of rest mass
m couples to the Newtonian potential via
Hint=mΦ, yielding a gauge-invariant phase analogous to the electromagnetic AB effect. We then show that this approximation fails when the particle's total energy varies between interferometer branches. A rigorous derivation from linearised general relativity reveals that in the weak-field, non-relativistic limit, gravity couples to the local energy density, not merely the rest mass. In a laser-driven atom interferometer, the two branches of the superposition differ by the location of an excitation energy
δE: either stored in the laser apparatus at
xL or carried by the atom at
xA(t). Under a gauge transformation
δhμν=−∂μξν−∂νξμ, the gravitational AB phase acquires a residual
δ(Δϕgrav)=−ℏc2δE[ξ0(xL,tf)−ξ0(xA(tf),tf)] for a purely temporal generator, which is generically nonzero. Since experiments such as Overstreet et al. (2022) measure a stable, reproducible gravitational AB phase, we are compelled to choose between two mutually exclusive possibilities. If gauge invariance (diffeomorphism invariance) is a fundamental principle, then the semiclassical framework is incomplete and a quantum theory of gravity is necessary. If, on the other hand, gauge invariance fails, then semiclassical gravity can be a complete theory. In this case, the gravitational potentials must be understood as real physical fields, and the gauge-dependent phase is a genuine observable, consistent with experiment. These two resolutions are mutually exclusive, and their implications for the nature of gravity and gauge symmetry are profound.
This paper argues that the case for “gravitizing” quantum theory is at least as strong as that for quantizing gravity. Accordingly, the principles of general relativity must influence, and actually change , the very formalism of quantum mechanics. Most particularly, an “Einsteinian”, rather than a “Newtonian” treatment of the gravitational field should be adopted, in a quantum system, in order that the principle of equivalence be fully respected. This leads to an expectation that quantum superpositions of states involving a significant mass displacement should have a finite lifetime, in accordance with a proposal previously put forward by Diósi and the author.
We develop a nonlinear quantum theory of Newtonian gravity consistent with an objective interpretation of the wavefunction. Inspired by the ideas of Schrodinger, and Bell, we seek a dimensional reduction procedure to map complex wavefunctions in configuration space onto a family of observable fields in space-time. Consideration of quasi-classical conservation laws selects the reduced one-body quantities as the basis for an explicit quasi-classical coarse-graining. These we interpret as describing the objective reality of the laboratory. Thereafter, we examine what may stand in the role of the usual Copenhagen observer to localise this quantity against macroscopic dispersion. Only a tiny change is needed, via a generically attractive self-potential. A nonlinear treatment of gravitational self-energy is thus advanced. This term sets a scale for all wavepackets. The Newtonian cosmology is thus closed, without need of an external observer. Finally, the concept of quantisation is re-interpreted as a nonlinear eigenvalue problem. To illustrate, we exhibit an elementary family of gravitationally self-bound solitary waves. Contrasting this theory with its canonically quantised analogue, we find that the given interpretation is empirically distinguishable, in principle. This result encourages deeper study of nonlinear field theories as a testable alternative to canonically quantised gravity.