Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1006.4720 · Physical Review Letters

Four-Body Efimov Effect for Three Fermions and a Lighter Particle

Yvan Castin, Christophe Mora, Ludovic Pricoupenko

Published Nov 23, 2010• 89 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study three same-spin-state fermions of mass M interacting with a distinguishable particle of mass m in the unitary limit where the interaction has a zero range and an infinite s-wave scattering length. We predict an interval of mass ratio 13.384<M/m<13.607 where there exists a purely four-body Efimov effect, leading to the occurrence of weakly bound tetramers without Efimov trimers.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.105.223201

Related papers

Absence of a four-body Efimov effect in the 2+2 fermionic problem

Shimpei Endo, Yvan Castin

In the free three-dimensional space, we consider a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ fermions of some species or in some internal state and a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions of another species or in another state. There is a resonant $s$-wave interaction (that is, of zero range and infinite scattering length) between fermions in different pairs and no interaction within the same pair. We study whether this $2+2$ fermionic system can exhibit (as the $3+1$ fermionic system) a four-body Efimov effect in the absence of three-body Efimov effect, that is, the mass ratio $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ between $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ and $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions and its inverse are both smaller than 13.6069\dots{}. For this purpose, we investigate scale invariant zero-energy solutions of the four-body Schr\"odinger equation, that is, positively homogeneous functions of the coordinates of degree $s\ensuremath{-}7/2$, where $s$ is a generalized Efimov exponent that becomes purely imaginary in the presence of a four-body Efimov effect. Using rotational invariance in momentum space, it is found that the allowed values of $s$ are such that $M(s)$ has a zero eigenvalue; here the operator $M(s)$, that depends on the total angular momentum $\ensuremath{\ell}$, acts on functions of two real variables (the cosine of the angle between two wave vectors and the logarithm of the ratio of their moduli), and we write it explicitly in terms of an integral matrix kernel. We have performed a spectral analysis of $M(s)$, analytical and for an arbitrary imaginary $s$ for the continuous spectrum and numerical and limited to $s=0$ and $\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremath{\le}12$ for the discrete spectrum. We conclude that no eigenvalue of $M(0)$ crosses zero over the mass ratio interval $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\in}[1;13.6069\ensuremath{\cdots}]$, even if, in the parity sector ${(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{\ensuremath{\ell}}$, the continuous spectrum of $M(s)$ has everywhere a zero lower border. As a consequence, there is no possibility of a four-body Efimov effect for the $2+2$ fermions. We also enunciated a conjecture for the fourth virial coefficient of the unitary spin-$1/2$ Fermi gas, inspired from the known analytical form of the third cluster coefficient and involving the integral over the imaginary $s$ axis of $s$ times the logarithmic derivative of the determinant of $M(s)$ summed over all angular momenta. The conjectured value is in contradiction with the experimental results.

arXiv:1507.05580•Physical Review A•Nov 24, 2015•30 citations

Five-Body Efimov Effect and Universal Pentamer in Fermionic Mixtures

Betzalel Bazak, Dmitry S. Petrov

We show that four heavy fermions interacting resonantly with a lighter atom (4+1 system) become Efimovian at mass ratio 13.279(2), which is smaller than the corresponding 2+1 and 3+1 thresholds. We thus predict the five-body Efimov effect for this system in the regime where any of its subsystem is non-Efimovian. For smaller mass ratios we show the existence and calculate the energy of a universal 4+1 pentamer state, which continues the series of the 2+1 trimer predicted by Kartavtsev and Malykh and 3+1 tetramer discovered by Blume. We also show that the effective-range correction for the light-heavy interaction has a strong effect on all these states and larger effective ranges increase their tendency to bind.

arXiv:1612.09341•Physical Review Letters•Feb 23, 2017•47 citations

Universality and scaling limit of weakly-bound tetramers

M. R. Hadizadeh, Marcelo Takeshi Yamashita, Lauro Tomio +2 more

The occurrence of a new limit cycle in few-body physics, expressing a universal scaling function relating the binding energies of two successive tetramer states, is revealed by considering a renormalized zero-range two-body interaction in bound state of four identical bosons. The tetramer energy spectrum is obtained by adding a boson to an Efimov bound state with energy B3 in the unitary limit (for zero two-body binding energy or infinite two-body scattering length). Each excited Nth tetramer energy B(N)4 is shown to slide along a scaling function as a short-range four-body scale is changed, emerging from the 3+1 threshold for a universal ratio B4(N)/B3 = 4.6, which does not depend on N. The new scale can also be revealed by a resonance in the atom-trimer recombination process.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•6 citations

Four-body Efimov effect in a Born-Oppenheimer model

Sadhan K. Adhikari, A. C. Fonseca

The possibility of a zero-energy Efimov effect is investigated in a model consisting of three identical heavy particles and a lighter one, when the light-heavy interaction leads to a zero-energy bound state for the two-heavy---one-light subsystem. The model is solved in the Born-Oppenheimer approximation with the light-heavy interaction taken to be a separable $s$-wave potential of Yamaguchi form. The heavy-heavy interaction is short range and, if attractive, is to be taken weak enough to support no two- or three-heavy-particle bound states. The relevant parameter is the potential strength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ of the light-heavy interaction which for $\ensuremath{\lambda}={\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}$ supports a single zero-energy light-heavy bound state. If the first zero-energy bound state of the two-heavy---one-light subsystem occurs for $\ensuremath{\lambda}={\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ such that $|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{\ensuremath{'}}|<|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}|$, there are no Efimov four-body bound states. On the contrary, if the chosen heavy-heavy potential is repulsive enough to prevent the existence of three-body bound states for $|\ensuremath{\lambda}|<|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}|$, then as $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}$ a few four-body Efimov states may emerge but their number remains finite. These states disappear for $|\ensuremath{\lambda}|\ensuremath{\gtrsim}|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}|$ as the three-body cut overrides them.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 15, 1981•19 citations

The third virial coefficient of a two-component unitary Fermi gas across an Efimov-effect threshold

Chao Gao, Shimpei Endo, Yvan Castin

We consider a mixture of two single-spin-state fermions with an interaction of negligible range and infinite s-wave scattering length.By varying the mass ratio α across αc 13.6069 one can switch on and off the Efimov effect.We determine analytically the third cluster coefficient of the gas.We show that it is a smooth function of α across αc since, unexpectedly, the three-body parameter characterizing the interaction is relevant even on the non-Efimovian side α < αc.

arXiv:1412.1974•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jan 1, 2015•23 citations

Bound States in a Quasi-Two-Dimensional Fermi Gas

Jesper Levinsen, Meera M. Parish

We consider the problem of $N$ identical fermions of mass ${m}_{\ensuremath{\uparrow}}$ and one distinguishable particle of mass ${m}_{\ensuremath{\downarrow}}$ interacting via short-range interactions in a confined quasi-two-dimensional (quasi-2D) geometry. For $N=2$ and mass ratios ${m}_{\ensuremath{\uparrow}}/{m}_{\ensuremath{\downarrow}}<13.6$, we find non-Efimov trimers that smoothly evolve from 2D to 3D. In the limit of strong 2D confinement, we show that the energy of the $N+1$ system can be approximated by an effective two-channel model. We use this approximation to solve the $3+1$ problem and we find that a bound tetramer can exist for mass ratios ${m}_{\ensuremath{\uparrow}}/{m}_{\ensuremath{\downarrow}}$ as low as 5 for strong confinement, thus providing the first example of a universal, non-Efimov tetramer involving three identical fermions.

arXiv:1207.0459•Physical Review Letters•Jan 29, 2013•42 citations
We study three same-spin-state fermions of mass M interacting with a distinguishable particle of mass m in the unitary limit where the interaction has a zero range and an infinite s-wave scattering length. We predict an interval of mass ratio 13.384<M/m<13.607 where there exists a purely four-body Efimov effect, leading to the occurrence of weakly bound tetramers without Efimov trimers.
In the free three-dimensional space, we consider a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ fermions of some species or in some internal state and a pair of identical $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions of another species or in another state. There is a resonant sss-wave interaction (that is, of zero range and infinite scattering length) between fermions in different pairs and no interaction within the same pair. We study whether this 2+22+22+2 fermionic system can exhibit (as the 3+13+13+1 fermionic system) a four-body Efimov effect in the absence of three-body Efimov effect, that is, the mass ratio $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ between $\ensuremath{\uparrow}$ and $\ensuremath{\downarrow}$ fermions and its inverse are both smaller than 13.6069\dots{}. For this purpose, we investigate scale invariant zero-energy solutions of the four-body Schr\"odinger equation, that is, positively homogeneous functions of the coordinates of degree $s\ensuremath{-}7/2$, where sss is a generalized Efimov exponent that becomes purely imaginary in the presence of a four-body Efimov effect. Using rotational invariance in momentum space, it is found that the allowed values of sss are such that M(s)M(s)M(s) has a zero eigenvalue; here the operator M(s)M(s)M(s), that depends on the total angular momentum $\ensuremath{\ell}$, acts on functions of two real variables (the cosine of the angle between two wave vectors and the logarithm of the ratio of their moduli), and we write it explicitly in terms of an integral matrix kernel. We have performed a spectral analysis of M(s)M(s)M(s), analytical and for an arbitrary imaginary sss for the continuous spectrum and numerical and limited to s=0s=0s=0 and $\ensuremath{\ell}\ensuremath{\le}12$ for the discrete spectrum. We conclude that no eigenvalue of M(0)M(0)M(0) crosses zero over the mass ratio interval $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\in}[1;13.6069\ensuremath{\cdots}]$, even if, in the parity sector ${(\ensuremath{-}1)}^{\ensuremath{\ell}}$, the continuous spectrum of M(s)M(s)M(s) has everywhere a zero lower border. As a consequence, there is no possibility of a four-body Efimov effect for the 2+22+22+2 fermions. We also enunciated a conjecture for the fourth virial coefficient of the unitary spin-1/21/21/2 Fermi gas, inspired from the known analytical form of the third cluster coefficient and involving the integral over the imaginary sss axis of sss times the logarithmic derivative of the determinant of M(s)M(s)M(s) summed over all angular momenta. The conjectured value is in contradiction with the experimental results.
We show that four heavy fermions interacting resonantly with a lighter atom (4+1 system) become Efimovian at mass ratio 13.279(2), which is smaller than the corresponding 2+1 and 3+1 thresholds. We thus predict the five-body Efimov effect for this system in the regime where any of its subsystem is non-Efimovian. For smaller mass ratios we show the existence and calculate the energy of a universal 4+1 pentamer state, which continues the series of the 2+1 trimer predicted by Kartavtsev and Malykh and 3+1 tetramer discovered by Blume. We also show that the effective-range correction for the light-heavy interaction has a strong effect on all these states and larger effective ranges increase their tendency to bind.
The occurrence of a new limit cycle in few-body physics, expressing a universal scaling function relating the binding energies of two successive tetramer states, is revealed by considering a renormalized zero-range two-body interaction in bound state of four identical bosons. The tetramer energy spectrum is obtained by adding a boson to an Efimov bound state with energy B3 in the unitary limit (for zero two-body binding energy or infinite two-body scattering length). Each excited Nth tetramer energy B(N)4 is shown to slide along a scaling function as a short-range four-body scale is changed, emerging from the 3+1 threshold for a universal ratio B4(N)/B3 = 4.6, which does not depend on N. The new scale can also be revealed by a resonance in the atom-trimer recombination process.
The possibility of a zero-energy Efimov effect is investigated in a model consisting of three identical heavy particles and a lighter one, when the light-heavy interaction leads to a zero-energy bound state for the two-heavy---one-light subsystem. The model is solved in the Born-Oppenheimer approximation with the light-heavy interaction taken to be a separable sss-wave potential of Yamaguchi form. The heavy-heavy interaction is short range and, if attractive, is to be taken weak enough to support no two- or three-heavy-particle bound states. The relevant parameter is the potential strength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ of the light-heavy interaction which for $\ensuremath{\lambda}={\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}$ supports a single zero-energy light-heavy bound state. If the first zero-energy bound state of the two-heavy---one-light subsystem occurs for $\ensuremath{\lambda}={\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ such that $|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{\ensuremath{'}}|<|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}|$, there are no Efimov four-body bound states. On the contrary, if the chosen heavy-heavy potential is repulsive enough to prevent the existence of three-body bound states for $|\ensuremath{\lambda}|<|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}|$, then as $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}$ a few four-body Efimov states may emerge but their number remains finite. These states disappear for $|\ensuremath{\lambda}|\ensuremath{\gtrsim}|{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{c}|$ as the three-body cut overrides them.
We consider the problem of NNN identical fermions of mass ${m}_{\ensuremath{\uparrow}}$ and one distinguishable particle of mass ${m}_{\ensuremath{\downarrow}}$ interacting via short-range interactions in a confined quasi-two-dimensional (quasi-2D) geometry. For N=2N=2N=2 and mass ratios ${m}_{\ensuremath{\uparrow}}/{m}_{\ensuremath{\downarrow}}<13.6$, we find non-Efimov trimers that smoothly evolve from 2D to 3D. In the limit of strong 2D confinement, we show that the energy of the N+1N+1N+1 system can be approximated by an effective two-channel model. We use this approximation to solve the 3+13+13+1 problem and we find that a bound tetramer can exist for mass ratios ${m}_{\ensuremath{\uparrow}}/{m}_{\ensuremath{\downarrow}}$ as low as 5 for strong confinement, thus providing the first example of a universal, non-Efimov tetramer involving three identical fermions.