Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1005.2420

Comment on "Inequivalence between the Schrodinger equation and the Madelung hydrodynamic equations"

V. Hushwater

Published May 13, 2010• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the paper with the above-noted title, T. C. Wallstrom claims that the description of the particle's motion as a certain "conservative" diffusion is not equivalent to quantum mechanics in spite of the fact that the Madelung "hydrodynamic" equations, which provide the description of such a diffusion, can be converted to the Schroedinger equation. He pointed out that such a stochastic theory can be regarded as equivalent to conventional quantum mechanics only if they can derive from it not just the Madelung equations but also the condition that the circulation of the "probability fluid" is always quantized, which is equivalent the condition for the single-valuedness of the wave function. We, however, show that the single-valuedness of the wave function required in quantum mechanics, is not an auxiliary condition but a property of all local solutions of the Schrodinger equation. Based on the one-to-one correspondence between local solutions of the Schroedinger and the Madelung equations this means that the quantization of the circulation of the "probability fluid" is a property of all solutions of the Madelung equations.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1005.2420

Related papers

Phase Quantization from Observable Regularity: Reducing the Wallström Objection to a Standard Physical Condition

Adrian Rohr

This paper presents a complete derivation of the Schrodinger equation from the Onsager-Machlup stochastic variational principle, rigorously resolving the longstanding Wallstrom objection. Wallstrom proved that hydrodynamic equations derived via the Madelung transformation do not uniquely determine quantum mechanics unless phase circulation is quantized. We demonstrate that the quantization condition (the integral of the gradient of S along a closed loop equals 2pin*hbar) emerges as a necessary consequence of requiring finite action and topological stability of coherent structures. Configurations with non-integer winding numbers are shown to lead to divergent action costs or inadmissible multi-sheeted spatial representations. For nodal configurations where the probability density vanishes, we show that the smoothness of the probability current independently forces integer winding numbers, excluding non-quantized solutions recently constructed in the literature. This establishes the Schrodinger equation as the unique and inevitable description of probability fluid dynamics under the calibration D = hbar/(2m). Finally, the framework provides testable experimental predictions regarding wave packet spreading and interference visibility in the presence of environmental noise.

•Feb 16, 2026•0 citations

A Suggested Answer To Wallstrom's Criticism: Zitterbewegung Stochastic Mechanics I

Maaneli Derakhshani

Wallstrom's criticism of existing formulations of stochastic mechanics is that they fail to derive the empirical predictions of orthodox quantum mechanics because they require an ad hoc quantization condition on the postulated velocity potential, \emph{S}, in order to derive Schrödinger wave functions. We propose an answer to this criticism by modifying the Nelson-Yasue formulation of non-relativistic stochastic mechanics for a spinless particle with the following hypothesis: a spinless Nelson-Yasue particle of rest mass $m$ continuously undergoes a driven steady-state oscillation of `zitterbewegung' (\emph{zbw}) frequency, $ω_{c}=\left(1/\hbar\right)mc^{2}$, in its instantaneous mean forward (and backward) translational rest frame. With this hypothesis we show that, in the lab frame, \emph{S} arises from imposing the constraint of conservative diffusions on the time-symmetrized steady-state phase of the \emph{zbw} particle, satisfies the required quantization condition, and evolves in time by the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations (when generalized to describe a statistical ensemble of \emph{zbw} particles). From the mathematical equivalence of Schrödinger's equation with the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations plus the quantization condition, Schrödinger wave functions for a spinless particle (in and excluding external fields) are thereby recovered. We also apply this `zitterbewegung stochastic mechanics' (ZSM) to the case of a central potential and show that it predicts angular momentum quantization. This paper sets the foundation for Part II, which will (primarily) work out the many-particle version of ZSM.

arXiv:1510.06391•Oct 22, 2015•6 citations

A Suggested Answer To Wallstrom's Criticism (I): Zitterbewegung Stochastic Mechanics

Maaneli Derakhshani

Wallstrom's criticism of existing formulations of stochastic mechanics is that they fail to derive the empirical predictions of orthodox quantum mechanics because they require an ad hoc quantization condition on the postulated velocity potential, \emph{S}, in order to derive Schr\odinger wave functions. We propose an answer to this criticism by modifying the Nelson-Yasue formulation of non-relativistic stochastic mechanics for a spinless particle with the following hypothesis: a spinless Nelson-Yasue particle of rest mass $m$ continuously undergoes a driven steady-state oscillation of `zitterbewegung' (\emph{zbw}) frequency, $\omega_{c}=\left(1/\hbar\right)mc^{2}$, in its instantaneous mean forward (and backward) translational rest frame. With this hypothesis we show that, in the lab frame, \emph{S} arises from imposing the constraint of conservative diffusions on the time-symmetrized steady-state phase of the \emph{zbw} particle, satisfies the required quantization condition, and evolves in time by the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations (when generalized to describe a statistical ensemble of \emph{zbw} particles). From the mathematical equivalence of Schr\odinger's equation with the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations plus the quantization condition, Schr\odinger wave functions for a spinless particle (in and excluding external fields) are thereby recovered. We also apply this `zitterbewegung stochastic mechanics' (ZSM) to the case of a central potential and show that it predicts angular momentum quantization. This paper sets the foundation for Part II, which will (primarily) work out the many-particle version of ZSM.

•Oct 22, 2015•5 citations

Inequivalence between the Schrödinger equation and the Madelung hydrodynamic equations

Timothy C. Wallstrom

By differentiating the Schr\"odinger equation and separating the real amd imaginary parts, one obtains the Madelung hydrodynamic equations, which have inspired numerous classical interpretations of quantum mechanics. Such interpretations frequently assume that these equations are equivalent to the Schr\"odinger equation, and thus provide an alternative basis for quantum mechanics. This paper proves that this is incorrect: to recover the Schr\"odinger equation, one must add by hand a quantization condition, as in the old quantum theory. The implications for various alternative interpretations of quantum mechanics are discussed.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1994•210 citations

Circle-valued phase and the Wallstrom quantization condition in Madelung hydrodynamics

Vaibhav Pandey

Madelung showed that the Schrodinger equation can be rewritten, away from the zeros of the wave function, as hydrodynamic equations for a density and a velocity potential. Wallstrom [Phys. Rev. A 49, 1613 (1994)] showed that the rewriting is not an equivalence: the hydrodynamic system admits solutions whose circulation around nodes is an arbitrary real multiple of h/m, and equivalence requires imposing circulation quantization loop by loop, by hand. We examine a single kinematic postulate, the compact-phase postulate: the phase is fundamentally circle-valued, and the circle has action-circumference h. We prove three statements. First, a continuous circle-valued phase field winds an integer number of times around every loop in the node complement, so the fractional-circulation solutions are excluded kinematically. Second, compactness alone quantizes circulation in an arbitrary unit; the postulated circumference fixes the unit to h/m, and the circumference h is displayed independently by measured ladders in superconducting rings (h/2e) and in superfluid helium (h/m), and by the Aharonov-Bohm period (h/e), all in coherent-condensate systems. Third, under an integer-free regularity condition at the nodes, the postulate together with the Madelung equations is equivalent to exact scalar quantum mechanics at strong-solution (H1_loc) grade. We state the caveat explicitly: over the node complement, given continuity, the circle-valued phase is logically equivalent to the quantization condition it subsumes. The gain is at the level of axioms: one universal kinematic postulate with a calibrated, independently measured unit in place of a per-solution family of integral constraints.

•Aug 14, 2026•0 citations

On the hydrodynamic interpretation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics

James Day

The Madelung equations express the Schrödinger equation as a continuity equation and modified Hamilton–Jacobi equation. These equations are equivalent to the Euler equations for a compressible, potential flow, when classical pressure per unit density is replaced by the quantum potential per unit mass. We extend this hydrodynamic interpretation by quantising a single, spinless, non-relativistic particle constrained to a surface wave with small slope. The wave is distinct from the wave function and, in order to reproduce the Schrödinger equation, it must satisfy the kinematic boundary condition for a free surface advected by twice the Madelung velocity field.

Comptes Rendus Physique•Apr 2, 2026•1 citation
In the paper with the above-noted title, T. C. Wallstrom claims that the description of the particle's motion as a certain "conservative" diffusion is not equivalent to quantum mechanics in spite of the fact that the Madelung "hydrodynamic" equations, which provide the description of such a diffusion, can be converted to the Schroedinger equation. He pointed out that such a stochastic theory can be regarded as equivalent to conventional quantum mechanics only if they can derive from it not just the Madelung equations but also the condition that the circulation of the "probability fluid" is always quantized, which is equivalent the condition for the single-valuedness of the wave function. We, however, show that the single-valuedness of the wave function required in quantum mechanics, is not an auxiliary condition but a property of all local solutions of the Schrodinger equation. Based on the one-to-one correspondence between local solutions of the Schroedinger and the Madelung equations this means that the quantization of the circulation of the "probability fluid" is a property of all solutions of the Madelung equations.
This paper presents a complete derivation of the Schrodinger equation from the Onsager-Machlup stochastic variational principle, rigorously resolving the longstanding Wallstrom objection. Wallstrom proved that hydrodynamic equations derived via the Madelung transformation do not uniquely determine quantum mechanics unless phase circulation is quantized. We demonstrate that the quantization condition (the integral of the gradient of S along a closed loop equals 2pin*hbar) emerges as a necessary consequence of requiring finite action and topological stability of coherent structures. Configurations with non-integer winding numbers are shown to lead to divergent action costs or inadmissible multi-sheeted spatial representations. For nodal configurations where the probability density vanishes, we show that the smoothness of the probability current independently forces integer winding numbers, excluding non-quantized solutions recently constructed in the literature. This establishes the Schrodinger equation as the unique and inevitable description of probability fluid dynamics under the calibration D = hbar/(2m). Finally, the framework provides testable experimental predictions regarding wave packet spreading and interference visibility in the presence of environmental noise.
Wallstrom's criticism of existing formulations of stochastic mechanics is that they fail to derive the empirical predictions of orthodox quantum mechanics because they require an ad hoc quantization condition on the postulated velocity potential, \emph{S}, in order to derive Schrödinger wave functions. We propose an answer to this criticism by modifying the Nelson-Yasue formulation of non-relativistic stochastic mechanics for a spinless particle with the following hypothesis: a spinless Nelson-Yasue particle of rest mass mmm continuously undergoes a driven steady-state oscillation of `zitterbewegung' (\emph{zbw}) frequency, ωc=(1/ℏ)mc2ω_{c}=\left(1/\hbar\right)mc^{2}ωc​=(1/ℏ)mc2, in its instantaneous mean forward (and backward) translational rest frame. With this hypothesis we show that, in the lab frame, \emph{S} arises from imposing the constraint of conservative diffusions on the time-symmetrized steady-state phase of the \emph{zbw} particle, satisfies the required quantization condition, and evolves in time by the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations (when generalized to describe a statistical ensemble of \emph{zbw} particles). From the mathematical equivalence of Schrödinger's equation with the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations plus the quantization condition, Schrödinger wave functions for a spinless particle (in and excluding external fields) are thereby recovered. We also apply this `zitterbewegung stochastic mechanics' (ZSM) to the case of a central potential and show that it predicts angular momentum quantization. This paper sets the foundation for Part II, which will (primarily) work out the many-particle version of ZSM.
Wallstrom's criticism of existing formulations of stochastic mechanics is that they fail to derive the empirical predictions of orthodox quantum mechanics because they require an ad hoc quantization condition on the postulated velocity potential, \emph{S}, in order to derive Schr\odinger wave functions. We propose an answer to this criticism by modifying the Nelson-Yasue formulation of non-relativistic stochastic mechanics for a spinless particle with the following hypothesis: a spinless Nelson-Yasue particle of rest mass mmm continuously undergoes a driven steady-state oscillation of `zitterbewegung' (\emph{zbw}) frequency, ωc=(1/ℏ)mc2\omega_{c}=\left(1/\hbar\right)mc^{2}ωc​=(1/ℏ)mc2, in its instantaneous mean forward (and backward) translational rest frame. With this hypothesis we show that, in the lab frame, \emph{S} arises from imposing the constraint of conservative diffusions on the time-symmetrized steady-state phase of the \emph{zbw} particle, satisfies the required quantization condition, and evolves in time by the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations (when generalized to describe a statistical ensemble of \emph{zbw} particles). From the mathematical equivalence of Schr\odinger's equation with the Hamilton-Jacobi-Madelung equations plus the quantization condition, Schr\odinger wave functions for a spinless particle (in and excluding external fields) are thereby recovered. We also apply this `zitterbewegung stochastic mechanics' (ZSM) to the case of a central potential and show that it predicts angular momentum quantization. This paper sets the foundation for Part II, which will (primarily) work out the many-particle version of ZSM.
By differentiating the Schr\"odinger equation and separating the real amd imaginary parts, one obtains the Madelung hydrodynamic equations, which have inspired numerous classical interpretations of quantum mechanics. Such interpretations frequently assume that these equations are equivalent to the Schr\"odinger equation, and thus provide an alternative basis for quantum mechanics. This paper proves that this is incorrect: to recover the Schr\"odinger equation, one must add by hand a quantization condition, as in the old quantum theory. The implications for various alternative interpretations of quantum mechanics are discussed.
Madelung showed that the Schrodinger equation can be rewritten, away from the zeros of the wave function, as hydrodynamic equations for a density and a velocity potential. Wallstrom [Phys. Rev. A 49, 1613 (1994)] showed that the rewriting is not an equivalence: the hydrodynamic system admits solutions whose circulation around nodes is an arbitrary real multiple of h/m, and equivalence requires imposing circulation quantization loop by loop, by hand. We examine a single kinematic postulate, the compact-phase postulate: the phase is fundamentally circle-valued, and the circle has action-circumference h. We prove three statements. First, a continuous circle-valued phase field winds an integer number of times around every loop in the node complement, so the fractional-circulation solutions are excluded kinematically. Second, compactness alone quantizes circulation in an arbitrary unit; the postulated circumference fixes the unit to h/m, and the circumference h is displayed independently by measured ladders in superconducting rings (h/2e) and in superfluid helium (h/m), and by the Aharonov-Bohm period (h/e), all in coherent-condensate systems. Third, under an integer-free regularity condition at the nodes, the postulate together with the Madelung equations is equivalent to exact scalar quantum mechanics at strong-solution (H1_loc) grade. We state the caveat explicitly: over the node complement, given continuity, the circle-valued phase is logically equivalent to the quantization condition it subsumes. The gain is at the level of axioms: one universal kinematic postulate with a calibrated, independently measured unit in place of a per-solution family of integral constraints.
The Madelung equations express the Schrödinger equation as a continuity equation and modified Hamilton–Jacobi equation. These equations are equivalent to the Euler equations for a compressible, potential flow, when classical pressure per unit density is replaced by the quantum potential per unit mass. We extend this hydrodynamic interpretation by quantising a single, spinless, non-relativistic particle constrained to a surface wave with small slope. The wave is distinct from the wave function and, in order to reproduce the Schrödinger equation, it must satisfy the kinematic boundary condition for a free surface advected by twice the Madelung velocity field.