Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1002.0869 · Physical Review A

Viscosity of strongly interacting quantum fluids: Spectral functions and sum rules

Edward Taylor, Mohit Randeria

Published May 11, 2010• 114 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The viscosity of strongly interacting systems is a topic of great interest in diverse fields. We focus here on the bulk and shear viscosities of nonrelativistic quantum fluids, with particular emphasis on strongly interacting ultracold Fermi gases. We use Kubo formulas for the bulk and shear viscosity spectral functions, $\ensuremath{\zeta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$, respectively, to derive exact, nonperturbative results. Our results include a microscopic connection between the shear viscosity $\ensuremath{\eta}$ and the normal-fluid density ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}$; sum rules for $\ensuremath{\zeta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and their evolution through the BCS-BEC crossover (where BEC denotes Bose-Einstein condensate); and universal high-frequency tails for $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and the dynamic structure factor $S(\mathbf{q},\ensuremath{\omega})$. We use our sum rules to show that, at unitarity, $\ensuremath{\zeta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ is identically zero and thus relate $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ to density-density correlations. We predict that frequency-dependent shear viscosity $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ of the unitary Fermi gas can be experimentally measured using Bragg spectroscopy.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.81.053610

Related papers

Viscosity and scale invariance in the unitary Fermi gas

Tilman Enss, R. Haussmann, W. Zwerger

We compute the shear viscosity of the unitary Fermi gas above the superfluid transition temperature, using a diagrammatic technique that starts from the exact Kubo formula. The formalism obeys a Ward identity associated with scale invariance which guarantees that the bulk viscosity vanishes identically. For the shear viscosity, vertex corrections and the associated Aslamazov-Larkin contributions are shown to be crucial to reproduce the full Boltzmann equation result in the high-temperature, low fugacity limit. The frequency dependent shear viscosity $\eta(\omega)$ exhibits a Drude-like transport peak and a power-law tail at large frequencies which is proportional to the Tan contact. The weight in the transport peak is given by the equilibrium pressure, in agreement with a sum rule due to Taylor and Randeria. Near the superfluid transition the peak width is of the order of $0.5 T_F$, thus invalidating a quasiparticle description. The ratio $\eta/s$ between the static shear viscosity and the entropy density exhibits a minimum near the superfluid transition temperature whose value is larger than the string theory bound $\hbar/(4\pi k_B)$ by a factor of about seven.

•Jan 20, 2016•164 citations

Bulk Viscosity and Contact Correlations in Attractive Fermi Gases

Tilman Enss

The bulk viscosity determines dissipation during hydrodynamic expansion. It vanishes in scale invariant fluids, while a nonzero value quantifies the deviation from scale invariance. For the dilute Fermi gas the bulk viscosity is given exactly by the correlation function of the contact density of local pairs. As a consequence, scale invariance is broken purely by pair fluctuations. These fluctuations give rise also to logarithmic terms in the bulk viscosity of the high-temperature nondegenerate gas. For the quantum degenerate regime I report numerical Luttinger-Ward results for the contact correlator and the dynamical bulk viscosity throughout the BEC-BCS crossover. The ratio of bulk to shear viscosity ζ/η is found to exceed the kinetic theory prediction in the quantum degenerate regime. Near the superfluid phase transition the bulk viscosity is enhanced by critical fluctuations and has observable effects on dissipative heating, expansion dynamics, and sound attenuation.

arXiv:1904.12772•Physical Review Letters•Nov 15, 2019•43 citations

Perfect fluids and bad metals: insights from ultracold Fermi gases

Hao Guo, Dan Wulin, Chih-Chun Chien +1 more

In this paper, we examine in a unified fashion dissipative transport in strongly correlated systems. We thereby demonstrate the connection between "bad metals" (such as the high temperature superconductors) and "perfect fluids" (such as the ultracold Fermi gases, near unitarity). One motivation of this work is to communicate to the high energy physics community some of the central unsolved problems in high $T_c$ superconductors. Because of interest in the nearly perfect fluidity of the cold gases and because of new tools such as the AdS/CFT correspondence, this better communication may lead to important progress in a variety of different fields. A second motivation is to draw attention to the great power of transport measurements which more directly reflect the excitation spectrum than, say, thermodynamics and thus strongly constrain microscopic theories of correlated fermionic superfluids. Our calculations show that bad metal and perfect fluid behavior is associated with the presence of a normal state excitation gap which suppresses the effective number of carriers leading to anomalously low conductivity and viscosity above the transition temperature $T_c$. Below $T_c$ we demonstrate that the condensate collective modes ("phonons") do not couple to transverse probes such as the shear viscosity. As a result, our calculated shear viscosity at low $T$ becomes arbitrarily small as observed in experiments. In both homogeneous and trap calculations we do not find the upturn in $η$ or $η/s$ (where $s$ is the entropy density) found in most theories. In the process of these studies we demonstrate compatibility with the transverse sum rule and find reasonable agreement with both viscosity and cuprate conductivity experiments.

arXiv:1009.4678•New Journal of Physics•Jul 26, 2011•34 citations

Hydrodynamic tails and a fluctuation bound on the bulk viscosity

Mauricio Martínez, Thomas Schäfer

We study the small frequency behavior of the bulk viscosity spectral function using stochastic fluid dynamics. We obtain a number of model independent results, including the long-time tail of the bulk stress correlation function and the leading nonanalyticity of the spectral function at small frequency. We also establish a lower bound on the bulk viscosity which is weakly dependent on assumptions regarding the range of applicability of fluid dynamics. The bound on the bulk viscosity $\ensuremath{\zeta}$ scales as ${\ensuremath{\zeta}}_{\mathrm{min}}\ensuremath{\sim}{(P\ensuremath{-}\frac{2}{3}\mathcal{E})}^{2}{\ensuremath{\sum}}_{i}{D}_{i}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$, where ${D}_{i}$ are the diffusion constants for energy and momentum and $P\ensuremath{-}\frac{2}{3}\mathcal{E}$, where $P$ is the pressure and $\mathcal{E}$ is the energy density, is a measure of scale breaking. Applied to the cold Fermi gas near unitarity, $|\ensuremath{\lambda}/{a}_{s}|\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1$, where $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is the thermal de Broglie wavelength and ${a}_{s}$ is the $s$-wave scattering length, this bound implies that the ratio of bulk viscosity to entropy density satisfies $\ensuremath{\zeta}/s\ensuremath{\gtrsim}0.1\ensuremath{\hbar}/{k}_{B}$. Here, $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ is Planck's constant and ${k}_{B}$ is Boltzmann's constant.

arXiv:1708.01548•Physical Review A•Dec 5, 2017•39 citations

High-temperature expansion of the viscosity in interacting quantum gases

Johannes Hofmann

The frequency-dependent shear and bulk viscosity spectral functions of an interacting Fermi gas at high temperature are computed using a systematic virial expansion of the stress tensor correlation function. The field-theoretical methods employed have interesting relations with many-body techniques, such as the Keldysh formalism and can be compared with numerical calculations.

arXiv:1905.05133•Physical Review A•Jan 16, 2020•42 citations

Focus on strongly correlated quantum fluids: from ultracold quantum gases to QCD plasmas

Allan W Adams, Lincoln D. Carr, Thomas Schäfer +2 more

The last few years have witnessed a dramatic convergence of three distinct lines of research concerned with different kinds of extreme quantum matter. Two of these involve new quantum fluids that can be studied in the laboratory, ultracold quantum gases and quantum chromodynamics (QCD) plasmas. Even though these systems involve vastly different energy scales, the physical properties of the two quantum fluids are remarkably similar. The third line of research is based on the discovery of a new theoretical tool for investigating the properties of extreme quantum matter, holographic dualties. The main goal of this focus issue is to foster communication and understanding between these three fields. We proceed to describe each in more detail. Ultracold quantum gases offer a new paradigm for the study of nonperturbative quantum many-body physics. With widely tunable interaction strength, spin composition, and temperature, using different hyperfine states one can model spin-1/2 fermions, spin-3/2 fermions, and many other spin structures of bosons, fermions, and mixtures thereof. Such systems have produced a revolution in the study of strongly interacting Fermi systems, for example in the Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) crossover region, where a close collaboration between experimentalists and theorists—typical in this field—enabled ground-breaking studies in an area spanning several decades. Half-way through this crossover, when the scattering length characterizing low-energy collisions diverges, one obtains a unitary quantum gas , which is universal and scale invariant. The unitary gas has close parallels in the hydrodynamics of QCD plasmas, where the ratio of viscosity to entropy density is extremely low and comparable to the minimum viscosity conjecture, an important prediction of AdS/CFT (see below). Exciting developments in the thermodynamic and transport properties of strongly interacting Fermi gases are of broad interdisciplinary appeal and include new studies of high temperature superfluidity, viscosity, spin-transport, spin-imbalanced mixtures, and three-component gases, this last having a close parallel to color superconductivity. Another system important for the field of strongly-interacting quantum fluids was revealed by analysis of data from the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory. Despite naive expectations based on asymptotic freedom that the deconfinement of quarks and gluons at high temperatures would lead to a weakly-interacting quark gluon plasma (QGP), the system appeared to be quite strongly coupled. Subsequent estimates of the viscosity-to-entropy ratio suggest that the system is tantalizingly close to the postulated bound from AdS/CFT calculations. The field is quite dynamic at the moment; new measurements are expected from upgraded detectors at RHIC, and an entirely new energy regime is being opened up by heavy ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN. On the theoretical side, much work remains to be done to extract the precise values of the transport coefficients, and to characterize the nature of quasi-particle excitations in the plasma. Finally, holographic dualities such as anti-de Sitter/conformal field theory (AdS/CFT) have opened a new theoretical window on strongly correlated fluids. Holography relates strongly-interacting quantum many-body systems to weakly-coupled semi-classical gravitational systems, replacing quasiparticles with geometry and translating various difficult questions about quantum fluids into simple and calculable geometric exercises. Already, some of the earliest lessons of holography, such as the conjectural bound on the viscosity-to-entropy ratio, have had a considerable impact on the theoretical and experimental study of strongly correlated fluids, from RHIC to ultracold atoms. More recently, the study of holographic superconductors, non-Fermi liquids and unitary quantum gases has touched off a flurry of interest in holography as a toolkit for studying strongly-correlated many-body systems more generally. Holography also allows us to use results from quantum fluids to study classical and quantum gravity; for example, the phase structure of a quantum many-body system translates into a rich classification of black holes in the dual space–time. Given both the rapid progress in applied holography and the exciting developments in ultracold quantum gases and QCD plasmas discussed above, the time is ripe for new collaborations across traditional lines of specialization. This focus issue explores the convergence between three heretofore separate areas of physics. Over forty research groups have contributed original work, and there will be a review article which complements these advances, overviewing them and presenting them in the context of all three fields and their interconnections. The review concludes with a list of open questions. This sets the tone for the present focus issue; namely, interdisciplinary dialog, openness, innovation, and possibility, an emphasis for which New Journal of Physics , an open-access journal of the highest quality, is especially fitted.

New Journal of Physics•Apr 23, 2013•5 citations
The viscosity of strongly interacting systems is a topic of great interest in diverse fields. We focus here on the bulk and shear viscosities of nonrelativistic quantum fluids, with particular emphasis on strongly interacting ultracold Fermi gases. We use Kubo formulas for the bulk and shear viscosity spectral functions, \ensuremathζ(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\zeta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathζ(\ensuremathω) and \ensuremathη(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathη(\ensuremathω), respectively, to derive exact, nonperturbative results. Our results include a microscopic connection between the shear viscosity \ensuremathη\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremathη and the normal-fluid density \ensuremathρn{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{n}\ensuremathρn​; sum rules for \ensuremathζ(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\zeta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathζ(\ensuremathω) and \ensuremathη(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathη(\ensuremathω) and their evolution through the BCS-BEC crossover (where BEC denotes Bose-Einstein condensate); and universal high-frequency tails for \ensuremathη(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathη(\ensuremathω) and the dynamic structure factor S(q,\ensuremathω)S(\mathbf{q},\ensuremath{\omega})S(q,\ensuremathω). We use our sum rules to show that, at unitarity, \ensuremathζ(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\zeta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathζ(\ensuremathω) is identically zero and thus relate \ensuremathη(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathη(\ensuremathω) to density-density correlations. We predict that frequency-dependent shear viscosity \ensuremathη(\ensuremathω)\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega})\ensuremathη(\ensuremathω) of the unitary Fermi gas can be experimentally measured using Bragg spectroscopy.
We compute the shear viscosity of the unitary Fermi gas above the superfluid transition temperature, using a diagrammatic technique that starts from the exact Kubo formula. The formalism obeys a Ward identity associated with scale invariance which guarantees that the bulk viscosity vanishes identically. For the shear viscosity, vertex corrections and the associated Aslamazov-Larkin contributions are shown to be crucial to reproduce the full Boltzmann equation result in the high-temperature, low fugacity limit. The frequency dependent shear viscosity η(ω)\eta(\omega)η(ω) exhibits a Drude-like transport peak and a power-law tail at large frequencies which is proportional to the Tan contact. The weight in the transport peak is given by the equilibrium pressure, in agreement with a sum rule due to Taylor and Randeria. Near the superfluid transition the peak width is of the order of 0.5TF0.5 T_F0.5TF​, thus invalidating a quasiparticle description. The ratio η/s\eta/sη/s between the static shear viscosity and the entropy density exhibits a minimum near the superfluid transition temperature whose value is larger than the string theory bound ℏ/(4πkB)\hbar/(4\pi k_B)ℏ/(4πkB​) by a factor of about seven.
The bulk viscosity determines dissipation during hydrodynamic expansion. It vanishes in scale invariant fluids, while a nonzero value quantifies the deviation from scale invariance. For the dilute Fermi gas the bulk viscosity is given exactly by the correlation function of the contact density of local pairs. As a consequence, scale invariance is broken purely by pair fluctuations. These fluctuations give rise also to logarithmic terms in the bulk viscosity of the high-temperature nondegenerate gas. For the quantum degenerate regime I report numerical Luttinger-Ward results for the contact correlator and the dynamical bulk viscosity throughout the BEC-BCS crossover. The ratio of bulk to shear viscosity ζ/η is found to exceed the kinetic theory prediction in the quantum degenerate regime. Near the superfluid phase transition the bulk viscosity is enhanced by critical fluctuations and has observable effects on dissipative heating, expansion dynamics, and sound attenuation.
In this paper, we examine in a unified fashion dissipative transport in strongly correlated systems. We thereby demonstrate the connection between "bad metals" (such as the high temperature superconductors) and "perfect fluids" (such as the ultracold Fermi gases, near unitarity). One motivation of this work is to communicate to the high energy physics community some of the central unsolved problems in high TcT_cTc​ superconductors. Because of interest in the nearly perfect fluidity of the cold gases and because of new tools such as the AdS/CFT correspondence, this better communication may lead to important progress in a variety of different fields. A second motivation is to draw attention to the great power of transport measurements which more directly reflect the excitation spectrum than, say, thermodynamics and thus strongly constrain microscopic theories of correlated fermionic superfluids. Our calculations show that bad metal and perfect fluid behavior is associated with the presence of a normal state excitation gap which suppresses the effective number of carriers leading to anomalously low conductivity and viscosity above the transition temperature TcT_cTc​. Below TcT_cTc​ we demonstrate that the condensate collective modes ("phonons") do not couple to transverse probes such as the shear viscosity. As a result, our calculated shear viscosity at low TTT becomes arbitrarily small as observed in experiments. In both homogeneous and trap calculations we do not find the upturn in ηηη or η/sη/sη/s (where sss is the entropy density) found in most theories. In the process of these studies we demonstrate compatibility with the transverse sum rule and find reasonable agreement with both viscosity and cuprate conductivity experiments.
We study the small frequency behavior of the bulk viscosity spectral function using stochastic fluid dynamics. We obtain a number of model independent results, including the long-time tail of the bulk stress correlation function and the leading nonanalyticity of the spectral function at small frequency. We also establish a lower bound on the bulk viscosity which is weakly dependent on assumptions regarding the range of applicability of fluid dynamics. The bound on the bulk viscosity $\ensuremath{\zeta}$ scales as ${\ensuremath{\zeta}}_{\mathrm{min}}\ensuremath{\sim}{(P\ensuremath{-}\frac{2}{3}\mathcal{E})}^{2}{\ensuremath{\sum}}_{i}{D}_{i}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$, where Di{D}_{i}Di​ are the diffusion constants for energy and momentum and $P\ensuremath{-}\frac{2}{3}\mathcal{E}$, where PPP is the pressure and E\mathcal{E}E is the energy density, is a measure of scale breaking. Applied to the cold Fermi gas near unitarity, $|\ensuremath{\lambda}/{a}_{s}|\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1$, where $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is the thermal de Broglie wavelength and as{a}_{s}as​ is the sss-wave scattering length, this bound implies that the ratio of bulk viscosity to entropy density satisfies $\ensuremath{\zeta}/s\ensuremath{\gtrsim}0.1\ensuremath{\hbar}/{k}_{B}$. Here, $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ is Planck's constant and kB{k}_{B}kB​ is Boltzmann's constant.
The last few years have witnessed a dramatic convergence of three distinct lines of research concerned with different kinds of extreme quantum matter. Two of these involve new quantum fluids that can be studied in the laboratory, ultracold quantum gases and quantum chromodynamics (QCD) plasmas. Even though these systems involve vastly different energy scales, the physical properties of the two quantum fluids are remarkably similar. The third line of research is based on the discovery of a new theoretical tool for investigating the properties of extreme quantum matter, holographic dualties. The main goal of this focus issue is to foster communication and understanding between these three fields. We proceed to describe each in more detail. Ultracold quantum gases offer a new paradigm for the study of nonperturbative quantum many-body physics. With widely tunable interaction strength, spin composition, and temperature, using different hyperfine states one can model spin-1/2 fermions, spin-3/2 fermions, and many other spin structures of bosons, fermions, and mixtures thereof. Such systems have produced a revolution in the study of strongly interacting Fermi systems, for example in the Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) crossover region, where a close collaboration between experimentalists and theorists—typical in this field—enabled ground-breaking studies in an area spanning several decades. Half-way through this crossover, when the scattering length characterizing low-energy collisions diverges, one obtains a unitary quantum gas , which is universal and scale invariant. The unitary gas has close parallels in the hydrodynamics of QCD plasmas, where the ratio of viscosity to entropy density is extremely low and comparable to the minimum viscosity conjecture, an important prediction of AdS/CFT (see below). Exciting developments in the thermodynamic and transport properties of strongly interacting Fermi gases are of broad interdisciplinary appeal and include new studies of high temperature superfluidity, viscosity, spin-transport, spin-imbalanced mixtures, and three-component gases, this last having a close parallel to color superconductivity. Another system important for the field of strongly-interacting quantum fluids was revealed by analysis of data from the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory. Despite naive expectations based on asymptotic freedom that the deconfinement of quarks and gluons at high temperatures would lead to a weakly-interacting quark gluon plasma (QGP), the system appeared to be quite strongly coupled. Subsequent estimates of the viscosity-to-entropy ratio suggest that the system is tantalizingly close to the postulated bound from AdS/CFT calculations. The field is quite dynamic at the moment; new measurements are expected from upgraded detectors at RHIC, and an entirely new energy regime is being opened up by heavy ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN. On the theoretical side, much work remains to be done to extract the precise values of the transport coefficients, and to characterize the nature of quasi-particle excitations in the plasma. Finally, holographic dualities such as anti-de Sitter/conformal field theory (AdS/CFT) have opened a new theoretical window on strongly correlated fluids. Holography relates strongly-interacting quantum many-body systems to weakly-coupled semi-classical gravitational systems, replacing quasiparticles with geometry and translating various difficult questions about quantum fluids into simple and calculable geometric exercises. Already, some of the earliest lessons of holography, such as the conjectural bound on the viscosity-to-entropy ratio, have had a considerable impact on the theoretical and experimental study of strongly correlated fluids, from RHIC to ultracold atoms. More recently, the study of holographic superconductors, non-Fermi liquids and unitary quantum gases has touched off a flurry of interest in holography as a toolkit for studying strongly-correlated many-body systems more generally. Holography also allows us to use results from quantum fluids to study classical and quantum gravity; for example, the phase structure of a quantum many-body system translates into a rich classification of black holes in the dual space–time. Given both the rapid progress in applied holography and the exciting developments in ultracold quantum gases and QCD plasmas discussed above, the time is ripe for new collaborations across traditional lines of specialization. This focus issue explores the convergence between three heretofore separate areas of physics. Over forty research groups have contributed original work, and there will be a review article which complements these advances, overviewing them and presenting them in the context of all three fields and their interconnections. The review concludes with a list of open questions. This sets the tone for the present focus issue; namely, interdisciplinary dialog, openness, innovation, and possibility, an emphasis for which New Journal of Physics , an open-access journal of the highest quality, is especially fitted.