Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1001.2150 · Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

Evidence of macroscopically entangled protons in a mixed isotope crystal of KHpD1−pCO3

F. Fillaux, Alain Cousson, Matthias Josef Gutmann

Published Jan 12, 2010• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We examine whether protons and deuterons in a crystal of KH(0.76)D(0.24)CO(3) at 300 K are particles or matter waves. The neutron scattering function measured over a broad range of reciprocal space reveals the enhanced diffraction pattern anticipated for antisymmetrized macroscopic states for protons (fermions). These features exclude a statistical distribution of protons and deuterons. Raman spectra are consistent with a mixture of KHCO(3) and KDCO(3) sublattices whose isomorphous structures are independent of the isotope content. We propose a theoretical framework for decoherence-free proton and deuteron states.

DOI
10.1088/0953-8984/22/4/045402

Related papers

Proton transfer across hydrogen bonds: From reaction path to Schrödinger's cat

F. Fillaux, Alain Cousson, Matthias Josef Gutmann

Abstract We review recent studies of the interconversion mechanism of OH···O hydrogen-bonded centrosymmetric dimers through proton transfer in the prototype crystals of potassium hydrogen carbonate (KHCO3) and benzoic acid (C6H5COOH). The point at issue is whether the proton distributions at various temperatures arise from classical statistical mixtures of tautomers or quantum mechanical superposition states. A related issue is whether it is possible to probe a quantum superposition without inducing decoherence and classicality. We show that neutron diffraction can realize decoherence-free measurements for strictly defined scattering geometries and thus evidence macroscopic quantum correlations. We present a theoretical framework for decoherence-free macroscopically entangled states of the sublattice of protons. The neutron diffraction cross-section of protons is enhanced by a factor of ~45, compared to regular Bragg diffraction, and quantum correlations are observed with remarkable contrast. At elevated temperatures, up to 300 K, quantum correlations are unaffected by proton transfer. The crystal is a coherent superposition of macroscopic tunnelling states, like Schrödinger's cat in a superposition of dead and alive states.

Pure and Applied Chemistry•Jan 1, 2007•22 citations

QUANTUM COHERENCE IN NEUTRON SCATTERING ON PROTONS

E. Karlsson

Several recent observations of closely spaced hydrogen nuclei in condensed matter systems — water, polymers and metal hydrides — indicate that they cannot be considered as independent quantum objects when observed over very short time intervals. According to these measurements, pairs (or possibly small clusters) of protons or deuterons seem to be quantum correlated, and are able to preserve their mutual quantum phase relations over times of the order of femtoseconds even in strongly perturbing liquid or solid environments. These new experimental results are mainly based on scattering of neutrons with time windows in the atto- and femtosecond range, but there also exists corroborating evidence from other spectroscopies. When the width of the observational time window is increased above a characteristic value, the quantum coherence effects are seen to disappear. This time limit marks the onset of decoherence as the mutual phase relations between the particles are gradually lost. Possible reasons for short-time entanglement of nuclei in condensed matter systems, as well as mechanisms for its decoherence will be discussed.

Modern Physics Letters B•Mar 30, 2004•5 citations

Scattering by Entangled Spatial and Spin Degrees of Freedom

E. Karlsson, Stephen William Lovesey

Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons show an interesting anomaly, which is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples. Previously we demonstrated that quantum correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes lead to entanglement in scattering and a reduction in the scattered intensity. The viability of short-lived quantum correlations as the cause of the observed anomalies is further explored and found to be entirely feasible. General features of the basic premiss, that quantum entanglement reduces the scattered signal, are discussed and the interpretation of the neutron scattering experiments is set in context to related work on other systems. For the experiments in question, the duration of a scattering event, τ s , is a fraction of a femtosecond which is extremely short compared to solid-state relaxation times. Increasing τ s , by suitably changing experimental conditions, restores the intensity to the standard value calculated from the single atom cross-section and concentration of particles. Our physical picture of the restoration is evolution with increasing τ s from a pure state of the particles (described by a wavefunction) to a mixed state (described by a density matrix) that is created, through decoherence, by steadily engaging the solid-state environment of the particles.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 2002•54 citations

Neutron Compton scattering by proton and deuteron systems with entangled spatial and spin degrees of freedom

E. Karlsson, Stephen William Lovesey

Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons have shown an interesting anomaly, which is apparently absent when the hydrogen isotopes are replaced by heavier particles. The anomaly is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples; specifically, the intensity per hydrogen isotope in bulk samples is smaller than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated hydrogen isotope. Short-lived correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes have been proposed as an explanation of the anomaly. The correlations involve entanglements of the degrees of freedom created by the requirements of quantum mechanics applied to identical particles. By using energetic neutrons to perform Compton scattering experiments on the hydrogen isotopes, the time scale of the experimental probe covers the region of ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}16}--{10}^{\ensuremath{-}15}\mathrm{s}$ where entangled states might still be expected to survive. The proposed explanation is pursued here by reporting the cross section for Compton scattering, also known as deep inelastic scattering, by two identical nuclei occupying nonequivalent states. The model reproduces the observed dependence of the cross section on energy transfer, in which intensity accumulates at the recoil energy of a single nucleus. Several features of the model demand that the intensity at the recoil energy is indeed less than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated nucleus. Although the pair approximation used here is unquestionably a first approximation to real many-body entanglements, it is a compelling explanation of all the observations, including the restoration of the normal cross section at longer observation times achieved by moving to longer scattering times.

Physical Review A•May 17, 2000•67 citations

NEUTRON SCATTERING BY ENTANGLED SPATIAL AND SPIN DEGREES OF FREEDOM

E. Karlsson, Stephen William Lovesey

A theoretical interpretation of a set of neutron scattering experiments on protons and deuterons is presented in terms of quantum entanglement of spatial and spin degrees of freedom. A soluble model for the scattering of pairs of particles is developed, and it is applied to hydrogen in different condensed matter environments. Decoherence limits the lifetime of quantum entanglement to times of the order of 10 -15 s.

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology•Oct 1, 2002•1 citation

Quantum information in neutron-proton scattering from the $M$ matrix

Linjun Xie, Jinniu Hu, Ying Zhang +1 more

We study quantum-information aspects of neutron--proton scattering in the spin-space $M$-matrix framework. Four representative classes of input states are considered, namely diagonal mixed states, separable pure states, general two-qubit pure states, and a special Schmidt-like entangled subclass. For each class, ensemble-averaged output mutual information, reduced-state linear entropy, negativity, and geometric quantum discord are calculated in the relative momentum-- scattering angle plane. The results show that the outgoing spin correlations are governed jointly by scattering kinematics and by the structure of the incoming quantum ensemble. Input states with stronger intrinsic coherence or entanglement give larger maxima and higher minima in the mutual information, negativity, and geometric quantum discord. The enhanced regions of the mutual information and geometric discord depend on the input states, while the negativity maximum remains concentrated in the high-momentum backward-scattering region. These results extend earlier studies based on product-state entanglement power and provide an ensemble-based description of how spin correlations in neutron--proton scattering arise from the interplay between input-state structure and scattering dynamics.

nucl-thCross-listedarXiv:2608.30356•Physical Review C•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations
We examine whether protons and deuterons in a crystal of KH(0.76)D(0.24)CO(3) at 300 K are particles or matter waves. The neutron scattering function measured over a broad range of reciprocal space reveals the enhanced diffraction pattern anticipated for antisymmetrized macroscopic states for protons (fermions). These features exclude a statistical distribution of protons and deuterons. Raman spectra are consistent with a mixture of KHCO(3) and KDCO(3) sublattices whose isomorphous structures are independent of the isotope content. We propose a theoretical framework for decoherence-free proton and deuteron states.
Abstract We review recent studies of the interconversion mechanism of OH···O hydrogen-bonded centrosymmetric dimers through proton transfer in the prototype crystals of potassium hydrogen carbonate (KHCO3) and benzoic acid (C6H5COOH). The point at issue is whether the proton distributions at various temperatures arise from classical statistical mixtures of tautomers or quantum mechanical superposition states. A related issue is whether it is possible to probe a quantum superposition without inducing decoherence and classicality. We show that neutron diffraction can realize decoherence-free measurements for strictly defined scattering geometries and thus evidence macroscopic quantum correlations. We present a theoretical framework for decoherence-free macroscopically entangled states of the sublattice of protons. The neutron diffraction cross-section of protons is enhanced by a factor of ~45, compared to regular Bragg diffraction, and quantum correlations are observed with remarkable contrast. At elevated temperatures, up to 300 K, quantum correlations are unaffected by proton transfer. The crystal is a coherent superposition of macroscopic tunnelling states, like Schrödinger's cat in a superposition of dead and alive states.
Several recent observations of closely spaced hydrogen nuclei in condensed matter systems — water, polymers and metal hydrides — indicate that they cannot be considered as independent quantum objects when observed over very short time intervals. According to these measurements, pairs (or possibly small clusters) of protons or deuterons seem to be quantum correlated, and are able to preserve their mutual quantum phase relations over times of the order of femtoseconds even in strongly perturbing liquid or solid environments. These new experimental results are mainly based on scattering of neutrons with time windows in the atto- and femtosecond range, but there also exists corroborating evidence from other spectroscopies. When the width of the observational time window is increased above a characteristic value, the quantum coherence effects are seen to disappear. This time limit marks the onset of decoherence as the mutual phase relations between the particles are gradually lost. Possible reasons for short-time entanglement of nuclei in condensed matter systems, as well as mechanisms for its decoherence will be discussed.
Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons show an interesting anomaly, which is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples. Previously we demonstrated that quantum correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes lead to entanglement in scattering and a reduction in the scattered intensity. The viability of short-lived quantum correlations as the cause of the observed anomalies is further explored and found to be entirely feasible. General features of the basic premiss, that quantum entanglement reduces the scattered signal, are discussed and the interpretation of the neutron scattering experiments is set in context to related work on other systems. For the experiments in question, the duration of a scattering event, τ s , is a fraction of a femtosecond which is extremely short compared to solid-state relaxation times. Increasing τ s , by suitably changing experimental conditions, restores the intensity to the standard value calculated from the single atom cross-section and concentration of particles. Our physical picture of the restoration is evolution with increasing τ s from a pure state of the particles (described by a wavefunction) to a mixed state (described by a density matrix) that is created, through decoherence, by steadily engaging the solid-state environment of the particles.
Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons have shown an interesting anomaly, which is apparently absent when the hydrogen isotopes are replaced by heavier particles. The anomaly is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples; specifically, the intensity per hydrogen isotope in bulk samples is smaller than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated hydrogen isotope. Short-lived correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes have been proposed as an explanation of the anomaly. The correlations involve entanglements of the degrees of freedom created by the requirements of quantum mechanics applied to identical particles. By using energetic neutrons to perform Compton scattering experiments on the hydrogen isotopes, the time scale of the experimental probe covers the region of ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}16}--{10}^{\ensuremath{-}15}\mathrm{s}$ where entangled states might still be expected to survive. The proposed explanation is pursued here by reporting the cross section for Compton scattering, also known as deep inelastic scattering, by two identical nuclei occupying nonequivalent states. The model reproduces the observed dependence of the cross section on energy transfer, in which intensity accumulates at the recoil energy of a single nucleus. Several features of the model demand that the intensity at the recoil energy is indeed less than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated nucleus. Although the pair approximation used here is unquestionably a first approximation to real many-body entanglements, it is a compelling explanation of all the observations, including the restoration of the normal cross section at longer observation times achieved by moving to longer scattering times.
Quantum information in neutron-proton scattering from the MMM matrix
We study quantum-information aspects of neutron--proton scattering in the spin-space MMM-matrix framework. Four representative classes of input states are considered, namely diagonal mixed states, separable pure states, general two-qubit pure states, and a special Schmidt-like entangled subclass. For each class, ensemble-averaged output mutual information, reduced-state linear entropy, negativity, and geometric quantum discord are calculated in the relative momentum-- scattering angle plane. The results show that the outgoing spin correlations are governed jointly by scattering kinematics and by the structure of the incoming quantum ensemble. Input states with stronger intrinsic coherence or entanglement give larger maxima and higher minima in the mutual information, negativity, and geometric quantum discord. The enhanced regions of the mutual information and geometric discord depend on the input states, while the negativity maximum remains concentrated in the high-momentum backward-scattering region. These results extend earlier studies based on product-state entanglement power and provide an ensemble-based description of how spin correlations in neutron--proton scattering arise from the interplay between input-state structure and scattering dynamics.