Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0912.4349 · Physical Review A

Not all pure entangled states are useful for sub-shot-noise interferometry

Philipp Hyllus, Otfried Gühne, Augusto Smerzi

Published Jul 30, 2010• 134 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the connection between the shot-noise limit in linear interferometers and particle entanglement. In particular, we ask whether sub-shot-noise sensitivity can be reached with all pure entangled input states of $N$ particles if they can be optimized with local operations. Results on the optimal local transformations allow us to show that for $N=2$ all pure entangled states can be made useful for sub-shot-noise interferometry while for $N>2$ this is not the case. We completely classify the useful entangled states available in a bosonic two-mode interferometer. We apply our results to several states, in particular to multiparticle singlet states and to cluster states. The latter turn out to be practically useless for sub-shot-noise interferometry. Our results are based on the Cramer-Rao bound and the Fisher information.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.82.012337

Related papers

Fisher information and multiparticle entanglement

Philipp Hyllus, Wiesław Laskowski, Roland Krischek +5 more

The Fisher information $F$ gives a limit to the ultimate precision achievable in a phase estimation protocol. It has been shown recently that the Fisher information for a linear two-mode interferometer cannot exceed the number of particles if the input state is separable. As a direct consequence, with such input states the shot-noise limit is the ultimate limit of precision. In this work, we go a step further by deducing bounds on $F$ for several multiparticle entanglement classes. These bounds imply that genuine multiparticle entanglement is needed for reaching the highest sensitivities in quantum interferometry. We further compute similar bounds on the average Fisher information $\overline{F}$ for collective spin operators, where the average is performed over all possible spin directions. We show that these criteria detect different sets of states and illustrate their strengths by considering several examples, also using experimental data. In particular, the criterion based on $\overline{F}$ is able to detect certain bound entangled states.

arXiv:1006.4366•Physical Review A•Feb 16, 2012•593 citations

Sub–shot-noise sensitivities without entanglement

Fabio Benatti, Daniel Braun

We critically analyze the commonly maintained statement that entanglement is necessary to beat the shot-noise limit or standard quantum limit (SQL) in the sensitivity with which certain parameters can be measured in interferometric experiments. We consider in detail three different physical realizations of a beam splitter and a Mach-Zehnder interferometer using photons, massive bosons, and distinguishable spins or qubits. We study several input states and the corresponding definitions of entanglement. We show that mode entanglement is not required for photons or massive bosons for beating the SQL. In particular, with a fluctuating number of two-mode bosons, the shot-noise limit can be beaten by nonentangled bosonic states with all bosons in one mode. As a consequence, the trivially present entanglement due to symmetrization that appears when writing bosonic states in terms of individual particles is a useful resource for precision measurements.

arXiv:1109.0206•Physical Review A•Jan 31, 2013•34 citations

Sensitivity bounds for interferometry with Ising Hamiltonians

Yan Li, Luca Pezzè, Weidong Li +1 more

Sensitivity bounds for a generic interferometric phase estimation problem are the shot noise and the Heisenberg limits. The shot noise is the highest sensitivity that can be reached with separable states, while the Heisenberg limit is the ultimate bound in sensitivity which can be saturated with entangled states. The scaling of these bounds with the number of particles $N$ entering the interferometer depends on the specific Hamiltonian governing the same interferometer. In typical cases, the Hamiltonian is linear, and the shot-noise and Heisenberg limits scale with ${N}^{\ensuremath{-}1/2}$ and with ${N}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, respectively. With interferometers described by generic, nonlinear Hamiltonian, the scalings with the number of particles can be rather different. Here we study the shot-noise and Heisenberg limits of Ising-like Hamiltonians in the presence of longitudinal and transverse fields, both in the nearest-neighbor and in the fully connected spin interaction cases. We provide the explicit forms of the states saturating the shot-noise and Heisenberg limits. These results can be relevant not only for precision measurement purposes but also to characterize quantum phase transitions and, more generally, the witnessing of multipartite entanglement.

Physical Review A•Feb 21, 2019•16 citations

On the connection between quantum nonlocality and phase sensitivity of two-mode entangled Fock state superpositions

Kaushik Parasuram Seshadreesan, Christoph F. Wildfeuer, Moochan B. Kim +2 more

In two-mode interferometry, for a given total photon number N, entangled Fock state superpositions of the form (Formula presented.) have been considered for phase estimation. Indeed all such states are maximally mode-entangled and violate a Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) inequality. However, they differ in their optimal phase estimation capabilities as given by their quantum Fisher informations. The quantum Fisher information is the largest for the N00N state (Formula presented.) and decreases for the other states with decreasing photon number difference between the two modes. We ask the question whether for any particular Clauser–Horne (CH) (or CHSH) inequality, the maximal values of the CH (or the CHSH) functional for the states of the above type follow the same trend as their quantum Fisher informations, while also violating the classical bound whenever the states are capable of sub-shot-noise phase estimation, so that the violation can be used to quantify sub-shot-noise sensitivity. We explore CH and CHSH inequalities in a homodyne setup. Our results show that the amount of violation in those nonlocality tests may not be used to quantify sub-shot-noise sensitivity of the above states.

Civil War Book Review•Mar 1, 2016•1 citation

Quantum interferometry in multimode systems

Jan Chwedeńczuk

We consider the situation when the signal propagating through each arm of an interferometer has a complicated multimode structure. We demonstrate that the shot-noise level for such a setup is the same as for the common two-mode case for as long as the interferometric transformation treats each arm as a whole and does not penetrate its inner structure. We find the relation between the particle entanglement and the possibility to surpass the shot-noise limit of the phase estimation. Our results are general---they apply to pure and mixed states of identical and distinguishable particles (or combinations of both) for a fixed and fluctuating number of particles. An important result is that the method for detecting the entanglement often used in a two-mode system---based on the measurement of the visibility of fringes and the population imbalance fluctuations---can give misleading results when applied to the multimode case. Our main result is that the additional modes do not boost the sensitivity for as long as they are not interacting. Therefore, the improvement above the shot-noise level established for the two-mode systems can safely be treated as an entanglement criterion also in the complex multimode case.

arXiv:1706.01700•Physical Review A•Sep 12, 2017•2 citations

Useful Multiparticle Entanglement and Sub-Shot-Noise Sensitivity in Experimental Phase Estimation

Roland Krischek, Christian Schwemmer, Witlef Wieczorek +4 more

We experimentally demonstrate a general criterion to identify entangled states useful for the estimation of an unknown phase shift with a sensitivity higher than the shot-noise limit. We show how to exploit this entanglement on the examples of a maximum likelihood as well as of a Bayesian phase estimation protocol. Using an entangled four-photon state we achieve a phase sensitivity clearly beyond the shot-noise limit. Our detailed comparison of methods and quantum states for entanglement enhanced metrology reveals the connection between multiparticle entanglement and sub-shot-noise uncertainty, both in a frequentist and in a Bayesian phase estimation setting.

arXiv:1108.6002•Physical Review Letters•Aug 19, 2011•125 citations
We investigate the connection between the shot-noise limit in linear interferometers and particle entanglement. In particular, we ask whether sub-shot-noise sensitivity can be reached with all pure entangled input states of NNN particles if they can be optimized with local operations. Results on the optimal local transformations allow us to show that for N=2N=2N=2 all pure entangled states can be made useful for sub-shot-noise interferometry while for N>2N>2N>2 this is not the case. We completely classify the useful entangled states available in a bosonic two-mode interferometer. We apply our results to several states, in particular to multiparticle singlet states and to cluster states. The latter turn out to be practically useless for sub-shot-noise interferometry. Our results are based on the Cramer-Rao bound and the Fisher information.
The Fisher information FFF gives a limit to the ultimate precision achievable in a phase estimation protocol. It has been shown recently that the Fisher information for a linear two-mode interferometer cannot exceed the number of particles if the input state is separable. As a direct consequence, with such input states the shot-noise limit is the ultimate limit of precision. In this work, we go a step further by deducing bounds on FFF for several multiparticle entanglement classes. These bounds imply that genuine multiparticle entanglement is needed for reaching the highest sensitivities in quantum interferometry. We further compute similar bounds on the average Fisher information F‾\overline{F}F for collective spin operators, where the average is performed over all possible spin directions. We show that these criteria detect different sets of states and illustrate their strengths by considering several examples, also using experimental data. In particular, the criterion based on F‾\overline{F}F is able to detect certain bound entangled states.
We critically analyze the commonly maintained statement that entanglement is necessary to beat the shot-noise limit or standard quantum limit (SQL) in the sensitivity with which certain parameters can be measured in interferometric experiments. We consider in detail three different physical realizations of a beam splitter and a Mach-Zehnder interferometer using photons, massive bosons, and distinguishable spins or qubits. We study several input states and the corresponding definitions of entanglement. We show that mode entanglement is not required for photons or massive bosons for beating the SQL. In particular, with a fluctuating number of two-mode bosons, the shot-noise limit can be beaten by nonentangled bosonic states with all bosons in one mode. As a consequence, the trivially present entanglement due to symmetrization that appears when writing bosonic states in terms of individual particles is a useful resource for precision measurements.
Sensitivity bounds for a generic interferometric phase estimation problem are the shot noise and the Heisenberg limits. The shot noise is the highest sensitivity that can be reached with separable states, while the Heisenberg limit is the ultimate bound in sensitivity which can be saturated with entangled states. The scaling of these bounds with the number of particles NNN entering the interferometer depends on the specific Hamiltonian governing the same interferometer. In typical cases, the Hamiltonian is linear, and the shot-noise and Heisenberg limits scale with ${N}^{\ensuremath{-}1/2}$ and with ${N}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, respectively. With interferometers described by generic, nonlinear Hamiltonian, the scalings with the number of particles can be rather different. Here we study the shot-noise and Heisenberg limits of Ising-like Hamiltonians in the presence of longitudinal and transverse fields, both in the nearest-neighbor and in the fully connected spin interaction cases. We provide the explicit forms of the states saturating the shot-noise and Heisenberg limits. These results can be relevant not only for precision measurement purposes but also to characterize quantum phase transitions and, more generally, the witnessing of multipartite entanglement.
In two-mode interferometry, for a given total photon number N, entangled Fock state superpositions of the form (Formula presented.) have been considered for phase estimation. Indeed all such states are maximally mode-entangled and violate a Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) inequality. However, they differ in their optimal phase estimation capabilities as given by their quantum Fisher informations. The quantum Fisher information is the largest for the N00N state (Formula presented.) and decreases for the other states with decreasing photon number difference between the two modes. We ask the question whether for any particular Clauser–Horne (CH) (or CHSH) inequality, the maximal values of the CH (or the CHSH) functional for the states of the above type follow the same trend as their quantum Fisher informations, while also violating the classical bound whenever the states are capable of sub-shot-noise phase estimation, so that the violation can be used to quantify sub-shot-noise sensitivity. We explore CH and CHSH inequalities in a homodyne setup. Our results show that the amount of violation in those nonlocality tests may not be used to quantify sub-shot-noise sensitivity of the above states.
We consider the situation when the signal propagating through each arm of an interferometer has a complicated multimode structure. We demonstrate that the shot-noise level for such a setup is the same as for the common two-mode case for as long as the interferometric transformation treats each arm as a whole and does not penetrate its inner structure. We find the relation between the particle entanglement and the possibility to surpass the shot-noise limit of the phase estimation. Our results are general---they apply to pure and mixed states of identical and distinguishable particles (or combinations of both) for a fixed and fluctuating number of particles. An important result is that the method for detecting the entanglement often used in a two-mode system---based on the measurement of the visibility of fringes and the population imbalance fluctuations---can give misleading results when applied to the multimode case. Our main result is that the additional modes do not boost the sensitivity for as long as they are not interacting. Therefore, the improvement above the shot-noise level established for the two-mode systems can safely be treated as an entanglement criterion also in the complex multimode case.
We experimentally demonstrate a general criterion to identify entangled states useful for the estimation of an unknown phase shift with a sensitivity higher than the shot-noise limit. We show how to exploit this entanglement on the examples of a maximum likelihood as well as of a Bayesian phase estimation protocol. Using an entangled four-photon state we achieve a phase sensitivity clearly beyond the shot-noise limit. Our detailed comparison of methods and quantum states for entanglement enhanced metrology reveals the connection between multiparticle entanglement and sub-shot-noise uncertainty, both in a frequentist and in a Bayesian phase estimation setting.