We continue our numerical study of quantum belief propagation initiated in [Phys. Rev. A 77, 052318 (2008)]. We demonstrate how the method can be expressed in terms of an effective thermal potential that materializes when the system presents quantum correlations, but is insensitive to classical correlations. The thermal potential provides an efficient means to assess the precision of belief propagation on graphs with no loops. We illustrate these concepts using the one-dimensional quantum Ising model and compare our results with exact solutions. We also use the method to study the transverse field quantum Ising spin glass for which we obtain a phase diagram that is largely in agreement with the one obtained in [Phys. Rev. B 78, 134424 (2008).] using a different approach. Finally, we introduce the coarse-grained belief propagation (CGBP) algorithm to improve belief propagation at low temperatures. This method combines the reliability of belief propagation at high temperatures with the ability of entanglement renormalization to efficiently describe low-energy subspaces of quantum systems with local interactions. With CGBP, thermodynamic properties of quantum systems can be calculated with a high degree of accuracy at all temperatures.
We continue our numerical study of quantum belief propagation initiated in [Phys. Rev. A 77, 052318 (2008)]. We demonstrate how the method can be expressed in terms of an effective thermal potential that materializes when the system presents quantum correlations, but is insensitive to classical correlations. The thermal potential provides an efficient means to assess the precision of belief propagation on graphs with no loops. We illustrate these concepts using the one-dimensional quantum Ising model and compare our results with exact solutions. We also use the method to study the transverse field quantum Ising spin glass for which we obtain a phase diagram that is largely in agreement with the one obtained in [Phys. Rev. B 78, 134424 (2008).] using a different approach. Finally, we introduce the coarse-grained belief propagation (CGBP) algorithm to improve belief propagation at low temperatures. This method combines the reliability of belief propagation at high temperatures with the ability of entanglement renormalization to efficiently describe low-energy subspaces of quantum systems with local interactions. With CGBP, thermodynamic properties of quantum systems can be calculated with a high degree of accuracy at all temperatures.
Belief propagation---a powerful heuristic method to solve inference problems involving a large number of random variables---was recently generalized to quantum theory. Like its classical counterpart, this algorithm is exact on trees when the appropriate independence conditions are met and is expected to provide reliable approximations when operated on loopy graphs. In this paper, we benchmark the performances of loopy quantum belief propagation (QBP) in the context of finite-temperature quantum many-body physics. Our results indicate that QBP provides reliable estimates of the high-temperature correlation function when the typical loop size in the graph is large. As such, it is suitable, e.g., for the study of quantum spin glasses on Bethe lattices and the decoding of sparse quantum error correction codes.
Belief propagation (BP) provides a scalable heuristic for contracting tensor networks on loopy graphs, but its success in quantum many-body settings has largely rested on empirical evidence. Developing upon a recently introduced cluster-expansion framework for tensor networks, we rigorously study the applicability of BP to many-body quantum systems. For a state represented as a PEPS satisfying a ``loop-decay" condition, we prove that BP supplemented by cluster corrections approximates local observables with exponentially small relative error, and we give explicit formulas expressing local expectation values as BP predictions dressed by connected clusters intersecting the observable region. This representation establishes a direct link between cluster corrections and physical correlation functions. As a result, we show that ``loop-decay" \emph{necessarily implies} exponential decay of connected correlations, yielding sharp, rigorous criteria for when BP can and cannot succeed, and ruling out its validity at critical points. Numerical simulations of the two- and three-dimensional transverse field Ising model at zero and finite temperature confirm our analytical predictions, demonstrating quantitative accuracy deep in gapped phases and systematic failure near criticality.
Belief propagation -- a powerful heuristic method to solve inference problems involving a large number of random variables -- was recently generalized to quantum theory. Like its classical counterpart, this algorithm is exact on trees when the appropriate independence conditions are met and is expected to provide reliable approximations when operated on loopy graphs. In this paper, we benchmark the performances of loopy quantum belief propagation (QBP) in the context of finite-tempereture quantum many-body physics. Our results indicate that QBP provides reliable estimates of the high-temperature correlation function when the typical loop size in the graph is large. As such, it is suitable e.g. for the study of quantum spin glasses on Bethe lattices and the decoding of sparse quantum error correction codes.
The relationship between the mean-field approximations in various interacting models of statistical physics and measures of classical and quantum correlations is explored. We present a method that allows us to find an upper bound for the total amount of correlations (and hence entanglement) in a physical system in thermal equilibrium at some temperature in terms of its free energy and internal energy. This method is first illustrated by using two qubits interacting through the Heisenberg coupling, where entanglement and correlations can be computed exactly. It is then applied to the one-dimensional (1D) Ising model in a transverse magnetic field, for which entanglement and correlations cannot be obtained by exact methods. We analyse the behaviour of correlations in various regimes and identify critical regions, comparing them with already known results. Finally, we present a general discussion of the effects of entanglement on the macroscopic, thermodynamical features of solid-state systems. In particular, we exploit the fact that a d -dimensional quantum system in thermal equilibrium can be made to correspond to a ( d +1)-dimensional classical system in equilibrium to substitute all entanglement for classical correlations.
Tensor networks have attracted much attention as a powerful tool for modeling quantum many-body systems. Their contraction is a significant challenge, however, especially in highly connected networks, as memory requirements become prohibitive and the optimal contraction order is increasingly hard to find. The belief propagation (BP) algorithm has emerged as an alternative to exact contraction. Being formulated in a graph-agnostic way, it offers great flexibility, but its accuracy suffers in the presence of loops. In this work, we combine BP with the DMRG algorithm to solve ground-state problems, thereby extending DMRG to higher dimensions and arbitrary lattices. We demonstrate the viability of BP-DMRG on the transverse-field Ising model on a 2×2 hexagonal lattice, finding that it produces states with a fidelity between 0.9 and 0.99 to the true ground state, and energy estimates with a relative error between 10−2 and 10−3. Additionally, BP-DMRG can find ground states on randomly generated lattices, with fidelity improving as the transverse field increases. We conclude with a discussion of the limitations we encounter when using belief propagation, highlighting that the TFI tensor network operators lead to larger errors during BP iterations in BP-DMRG.
Simulating many-body quantum systems on a classical computer is difficult due to the large number of degrees of freedom, causing the computational complexity to grow exponentially with system size. Tensor Networks (TN) is a framework that breaks down large tensors into a network of smaller tensors, enabling efficient simulation of certain many-body quantum systems. To calculate expectation values of local observables or simulate nearest-neighbor interactions, a contraction of the entire network is needed. This is a known hard problem, which cannot be done exactly for systems with spatial dimension D>1 and is the major bottleneck in all tensor-network based algorithms. Various approximate-contraction algorithms have been suggested, all with their strengths and weaknesses. Nevertheless, contracting a 2D TN remains a major numerical challenge, limiting the use of TN techniques for many interesting systems.
Recently, a close connection between TN and Probabilistic Graphical Models (PGM) has been shown. In the PGM framework, marginals of complicated probability distributions can be approximated using iterative message passing algorithms such as Belief Propagation (BP). The BP algorithm can be adapted to the TN framework as an efficient contraction algorithm. While BP is extremely efficient and easy to parallelize, it often yields inaccurate results for highly correlated quantum states or frustrated systems. To overcome this, we suggest the BlockBP algorithm, which coarse-grains the system into blocks and performs BP between them.
This thesis focuses on: (i) development and implementation of the BlockBP algorithm for infinite lattices; (ii) using this algorithm to study the anti-ferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the Kagome lattice in the thermodynamic limit - a frustrated 2D model that is difficult to simulate using existing numerical methods.