The Deutsch–Jozsa problem: de-quantisation and entanglement

Shigeru Nakayama, Peng Gang

Jie Sun, Songfeng Lu, Fang Liu +1 more

Alastair A. Abbott

Quantum computation has shown much promise at providing, at least in some cases, a significant advantage over classical computation. However, the nature of quantum computation is still far from being well understood. In order to develop quantum algorithms effectively, it is important to understand the true nature of the differences between classical and quantum computation. We investigate these differences more closely by looking at de-quantising quantum algorithms into classical counterparts which retain the benefit provided by, and thought to be intrinsic to, the quantum algorithms. We extend a previous de-quantisation of Deutsch’s problem to show that in some situations the quantum algorithm solving the Deutsch-Jozsa problem can be de-quantised into an equivalent classical one. We quantify the entanglement in this problem and show that the inability to easily extend the de-quantisation to the general case is a result of the entanglement destroying the concise classical state description needed to de-quantise such a black-box algorithm. We further show that the quantum Fourier transform, an important process in many quantum algorithms, in its standard form is de-quantisable. This highlights key misconceptions about both the quantum Fourier transform and quantum computation itself. In such cases it is the linearity of quantum mechanics which allows constructing quantum algorithms which offer advantage over classical algorithms. The careful investigation of de-quantisation in relation to these problems allows a deeper insight into the nature of quantum computation.

Tomasz Arodź

Cristian S. Calude, Matteo Cavaliere, Radu Mardare

Deutsch's problem is the simplest and most frequently examined example of computational problem used to demonstrate the superiority of quantum computing over classical computing. Deutsch's quantum algorithm has been claimed to be faster than any classical ones solving the same problem, only to be discovered later that this was not the case. Various de-quantised solutions for Deutsch's quantum algorithm—classical solutions which are as efficient as the quantum one—have been proposed in the literature. These solutions are based on the possibility of classically simulating "superpositions", a key ingredient of quantum algorithms, in particular, Deutsch's algorithm. The de-quantisation proposed in this note is based on a classical simulation of the quantum measurement achieved with a model of observed system. As in some previous de-quantisations of Deutsch's quantum algorithm, the resulting de-quantised algorithm is deterministic. Finally, we classify observers (as finite state automata) that can solve the problem in terms of their "observational power".

Zhengjun Cao, Jeffrey K. Uhlmann, Lihua Liu