Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0910.1847 · New Journal of Physics

Limits of quantum speedup in photosynthetic light harvesting

Stephan Hoyer, Mohan Sarovar, K. Birgitta Whaley

Published Jun 30, 2010• 163 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It has been suggested that excitation transport in photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes features speedups analogous to those found in quantum algorithms. Here we compare the dynamics in these light-harvesting systems to the dynamics of quantum walks, in order to elucidate the limits of such quantum speedups. For the Fenna–Matthews–Olson complex of green sulfur bacteria, we show that while there is indeed speedup at short times, this is short lived (70 fs) despite longer-lived (ps) quantum coherence. Remarkably, this timescale is independent of the details of the decoherence model. More generally, we show that the distinguishing features of light-harvesting complexes not only limit the extent of quantum speedup but also reduce the rates of diffusive transport. These results suggest that quantum coherent effects in biological systems are optimized for efficiency or robustness rather than the more elusive goal of quantum speedup.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/12/6/065041

Related papers

Understanding and manipulating electronic quantum coherence in photosynthetic light-harvesting

Stephan Hoyer

Ultrafast spectroscopy experiments show that photosynthetic systems can preserve quantum beats in the process of electronic energy transfer between pigments, even at room temperature. But what does this discovery imply for biology - and for quantum mechanics? This dissertation examines photosynthesis through the tools of quantum information science. We evaluate to what extent photosynthesis can be thought of as a type of quantum technology, and consider how we can apply experimental tools widely used for quantum technologies (state tomography and coherent control) to photosynthesis. Throughout, we use the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex of greens sulfur bacteria as a model photosynthetic pigment-protein complex.In Part I, we evaluate two mechanisms for the possible biological relevance of quantum coherent motion. First, we consider the extent to which dynamics in light-harvesting systems exhibit the quantum speedups characteristic of quantum algorithms and quantum walks. Second, we demonstrate a ratchet effect in electronic energy transfer enabled by partially coherent dynamics. To do so, we build a new model of energy transfer between weakly coupled light-harvesting complexes to understand how electronic coherence arises under natural conditions.In Part II, we present proposals for experimental probes of light harvesting dynamics with ultrafast spectroscopy. We show how the signal from pump-probe spectroscopy can be formally inverted to determine the excited state electronic density matrix. Finally, we examine the feasiblity of coherent control experiments on light-harvesting systems, and provide two realistic targets feasible with present-day technology.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Distribution of entanglement in light-harvesting complexes and their quantum efficiency

Francesca Fassioli, Alexandra Olaya-Castro

Recent evidence of electronic coherence during energy transfer in photosynthetic antenna complexes has reinvigorated the discussion about whether coherence and/or entanglement have any practical functionality for these molecular systems. Here we investigate quantitative relationships between the quantum yield of a light-harvesting complex and the distribution of entanglement among its components. Our study focuses on the entanglement yield or average entanglement surviving a time scale comparable to the average excitation trapping time. We consider the Fenna–Matthews–Olson (FMO) protein of green sulfur bacteria as a prototype system and show that there is an inverse relationship between the quantum efficiency and the average entanglement between distant donor sites. Our results suggest that long-lasting electronic coherence among distant donors might help in the modulation of the light-harvesting function.

arXiv:1003.3610•New Journal of Physics•Aug 11, 2010•117 citations

Quantum Entanglement in Fenna—Matthews—Olson Photosynthetic Light—Harvesting complexes: A Short Review of Analysis Methods

Bruno González-Soria, Francisco Delgado

Abstract The Fenna-Matthews-Olson light-harvesting complexes have become a center of attention due to their high excitation energy transfer efficiency, which may surpass 98%. Experimental results reveal the presence of quantum entanglement in the protein structure, which seems to be associated to such a remarkably high efficiency. Notably, Redfield and Lindblad master equations have been already used to model the chromophore excitation in the protein complex as well as its interactions with the environment. The entanglement arising during the process has been quantified through several measures. This work provides a short review of methods used to model the above described system. It is also discussed the introduction of two nonconventional measures addresed to quantify the emergent entanglement.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 1, 2020•6 citations

How can the green sulfur bacteria use quantum computing for light harvesting?

D. Drakova, G. Doyen

Long lasting coherence in photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes has been observed even at physiological temperatures. Experiments have demonstrated quantum coherent behaviour in the long-time operation of the D-Wave quantum computer as well. Quantum coherence is the common feature between the two phenomena. An explanations for eight orders of magnitude discrepancy between the single flux qubit coherence time and the long-time quantum behaviour of an array of thousand flux qubits in the quantum computer was suggested within a theory where the flux qubits are coupled to an environment of particles called gravonons of high density of states The coherent evolution is in high dimensional spacetime and can be understood as a solution of Schroedinger's time-dependent equation. Explanations for the quantum beats observed in 2D Fourier transform electronic spectroscopy of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein complex in the green sulfur bacteria are presently sought in constructing transport theories based on quantum master equations where 'good' molecular vibrations ('coloured noise') in the chlorophyll and the surrounding protein scaffold knock the exciton oscillations back into coherence. These 'good' vibrations are claimed to have developed in three billion years of natural selection. These theories, however, face the discomforting experimental observation that "attempts to scramble vibrational modes or to shift resonances with isotopic substitution miserably failed to affect the beating signals". As a possible way out of this dilemma we adopted the formalism of the quantum computation to the quantum beats in the FMO protein complex.

arXiv:1605.06149•May 11, 2016•2 citations

Evolutionary Design in Biological Quantum Computing

Gábor Vattay, Stuart Alan Kauffman

The unique capability of quantum mechanics to evolve alternative possibilities in parallel is appealing and over the years a number of quantum algorithms have been developed offering great computational benefits. Systems coupled to the environment lose quantum coherence quickly and realization of schemes based on unitarity might be impossible. Recent discovery of room temperature quantum coherence in light harvesting complexes opens up new possibilities to borrow concepts from biology to use quantum effects for computational purposes. While it has been conjectured that light harvesting complexes such as the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex in the green sulfur bacteria performs an efficient quantum search similar to the quantum Grover's algorithm the analogy has yet to be established. In this work we show that quantum dissipation plays an essential role in the quantum search performed in the FMO complex and it is fundamentally different from known algorithms. In the FMO complex not just the optimal level of phase breaking is present to avoid both quantum localization and Zeno trapping but it can harness quantum dissipation as well to speed the process even further up. With detailed quantum calculations taking into account both phase breaking and quantum dissipation we show that the design of the FMO complex has been evolutionarily optimized and works faster than pure quantum or classical-stochastic algorithms. Inspired by the findings we introduce a new computational concept based on decoherent quantum evolution. While it is inspired by light harvesting systems, the new computational devices can also be realized on different material basis opening new magnitude scales for miniaturization and speed.

arXiv:1311.4688•Nov 19, 2013•3 citations

Quantum entanglement phenomena in photosynthetic light harvesting complexes

K. Birgitta Whaley, Mohan Sarovar, Akihito Ishizaki

We review recent theoretical calculations of quantum entanglement in photosynthetic light harvesting complexes. These works establish, for the first time, a manifestation of this characteristically quantum mechanical phenomenon in biologically functional structures. We begin by summarizing calculations on model biomolecular systems that aim to reveal non-trivial characteristics of quantum entanglement in non-equilibrium biological environments. We then discuss and compare several calculations performed recently of excitonic dynamics in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson light harvesting complex and of the electronic entanglement present in this widely studied pigment-protein structure. We point out the commonalities between the derived results and also identify and explain the differences. We also discuss recent work that examines entanglement in the structurally more intricate light harvesting complex II (LHCII). During this overview, we take the opportunity to clarify several subtle issues relating to entanglement in such biomolecular systems, including the role of entanglement in biological function, the complexity of dynamical modeling that is required to capture the salient features of entanglement in such biomolecular systems, and the relationship between entanglement and other quantum mechanical features that are observed and predicted in light harvesting complexes. Finally, we suggest possible extensions of the current work and also review the options for experimental confirmation of the predicted entanglement phenomena in light harvesting complexes.

arXiv:1012.4059•Procedia Chemistry•Jan 1, 2011•30 citations
It has been suggested that excitation transport in photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes features speedups analogous to those found in quantum algorithms. Here we compare the dynamics in these light-harvesting systems to the dynamics of quantum walks, in order to elucidate the limits of such quantum speedups. For the Fenna–Matthews–Olson complex of green sulfur bacteria, we show that while there is indeed speedup at short times, this is short lived (70 fs) despite longer-lived (ps) quantum coherence. Remarkably, this timescale is independent of the details of the decoherence model. More generally, we show that the distinguishing features of light-harvesting complexes not only limit the extent of quantum speedup but also reduce the rates of diffusive transport. These results suggest that quantum coherent effects in biological systems are optimized for efficiency or robustness rather than the more elusive goal of quantum speedup.
Ultrafast spectroscopy experiments show that photosynthetic systems can preserve quantum beats in the process of electronic energy transfer between pigments, even at room temperature. But what does this discovery imply for biology - and for quantum mechanics? This dissertation examines photosynthesis through the tools of quantum information science. We evaluate to what extent photosynthesis can be thought of as a type of quantum technology, and consider how we can apply experimental tools widely used for quantum technologies (state tomography and coherent control) to photosynthesis. Throughout, we use the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex of greens sulfur bacteria as a model photosynthetic pigment-protein complex.In Part I, we evaluate two mechanisms for the possible biological relevance of quantum coherent motion. First, we consider the extent to which dynamics in light-harvesting systems exhibit the quantum speedups characteristic of quantum algorithms and quantum walks. Second, we demonstrate a ratchet effect in electronic energy transfer enabled by partially coherent dynamics. To do so, we build a new model of energy transfer between weakly coupled light-harvesting complexes to understand how electronic coherence arises under natural conditions.In Part II, we present proposals for experimental probes of light harvesting dynamics with ultrafast spectroscopy. We show how the signal from pump-probe spectroscopy can be formally inverted to determine the excited state electronic density matrix. Finally, we examine the feasiblity of coherent control experiments on light-harvesting systems, and provide two realistic targets feasible with present-day technology.
Recent evidence of electronic coherence during energy transfer in photosynthetic antenna complexes has reinvigorated the discussion about whether coherence and/or entanglement have any practical functionality for these molecular systems. Here we investigate quantitative relationships between the quantum yield of a light-harvesting complex and the distribution of entanglement among its components. Our study focuses on the entanglement yield or average entanglement surviving a time scale comparable to the average excitation trapping time. We consider the Fenna–Matthews–Olson (FMO) protein of green sulfur bacteria as a prototype system and show that there is an inverse relationship between the quantum efficiency and the average entanglement between distant donor sites. Our results suggest that long-lasting electronic coherence among distant donors might help in the modulation of the light-harvesting function.
Abstract The Fenna-Matthews-Olson light-harvesting complexes have become a center of attention due to their high excitation energy transfer efficiency, which may surpass 98%. Experimental results reveal the presence of quantum entanglement in the protein structure, which seems to be associated to such a remarkably high efficiency. Notably, Redfield and Lindblad master equations have been already used to model the chromophore excitation in the protein complex as well as its interactions with the environment. The entanglement arising during the process has been quantified through several measures. This work provides a short review of methods used to model the above described system. It is also discussed the introduction of two nonconventional measures addresed to quantify the emergent entanglement.
Long lasting coherence in photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes has been observed even at physiological temperatures. Experiments have demonstrated quantum coherent behaviour in the long-time operation of the D-Wave quantum computer as well. Quantum coherence is the common feature between the two phenomena. An explanations for eight orders of magnitude discrepancy between the single flux qubit coherence time and the long-time quantum behaviour of an array of thousand flux qubits in the quantum computer was suggested within a theory where the flux qubits are coupled to an environment of particles called gravonons of high density of states The coherent evolution is in high dimensional spacetime and can be understood as a solution of Schroedinger's time-dependent equation. Explanations for the quantum beats observed in 2D Fourier transform electronic spectroscopy of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein complex in the green sulfur bacteria are presently sought in constructing transport theories based on quantum master equations where 'good' molecular vibrations ('coloured noise') in the chlorophyll and the surrounding protein scaffold knock the exciton oscillations back into coherence. These 'good' vibrations are claimed to have developed in three billion years of natural selection. These theories, however, face the discomforting experimental observation that "attempts to scramble vibrational modes or to shift resonances with isotopic substitution miserably failed to affect the beating signals". As a possible way out of this dilemma we adopted the formalism of the quantum computation to the quantum beats in the FMO protein complex.
The unique capability of quantum mechanics to evolve alternative possibilities in parallel is appealing and over the years a number of quantum algorithms have been developed offering great computational benefits. Systems coupled to the environment lose quantum coherence quickly and realization of schemes based on unitarity might be impossible. Recent discovery of room temperature quantum coherence in light harvesting complexes opens up new possibilities to borrow concepts from biology to use quantum effects for computational purposes. While it has been conjectured that light harvesting complexes such as the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex in the green sulfur bacteria performs an efficient quantum search similar to the quantum Grover's algorithm the analogy has yet to be established. In this work we show that quantum dissipation plays an essential role in the quantum search performed in the FMO complex and it is fundamentally different from known algorithms. In the FMO complex not just the optimal level of phase breaking is present to avoid both quantum localization and Zeno trapping but it can harness quantum dissipation as well to speed the process even further up. With detailed quantum calculations taking into account both phase breaking and quantum dissipation we show that the design of the FMO complex has been evolutionarily optimized and works faster than pure quantum or classical-stochastic algorithms. Inspired by the findings we introduce a new computational concept based on decoherent quantum evolution. While it is inspired by light harvesting systems, the new computational devices can also be realized on different material basis opening new magnitude scales for miniaturization and speed.
We review recent theoretical calculations of quantum entanglement in photosynthetic light harvesting complexes. These works establish, for the first time, a manifestation of this characteristically quantum mechanical phenomenon in biologically functional structures. We begin by summarizing calculations on model biomolecular systems that aim to reveal non-trivial characteristics of quantum entanglement in non-equilibrium biological environments. We then discuss and compare several calculations performed recently of excitonic dynamics in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson light harvesting complex and of the electronic entanglement present in this widely studied pigment-protein structure. We point out the commonalities between the derived results and also identify and explain the differences. We also discuss recent work that examines entanglement in the structurally more intricate light harvesting complex II (LHCII). During this overview, we take the opportunity to clarify several subtle issues relating to entanglement in such biomolecular systems, including the role of entanglement in biological function, the complexity of dynamical modeling that is required to capture the salient features of entanglement in such biomolecular systems, and the relationship between entanglement and other quantum mechanical features that are observed and predicted in light harvesting complexes. Finally, we suggest possible extensions of the current work and also review the options for experimental confirmation of the predicted entanglement phenomena in light harvesting complexes.