arXiv:0909.3505 · Physical Review Letters

Vacuum Degeneracy of a Circuit QED System in the Ultrastrong Coupling Regime

Pierre Nataf, Cristiano Ciuti

Published Jan 15, 2010• 126 citations

Abstract

We investigate theoretically the quantum vacuum properties of a chain of N superconducting Josephson atoms inductively coupled to a transmission line resonator. We derive the quantum field Hamiltonian for such a circuit QED system, showing that, due to the type and strength of the interaction, a quantum phase transition can occur with a twice degenerate quantum vacuum above a critical coupling. In the finite-size case, the degeneracy is lifted, with an energy splitting decreasing exponentially with increasing values of g{2}N{2}, where g is the dimensionless vacuum Rabi coupling per artificial atom. We determine analytically the ultrastrong coupling asymptotic expression of the two degenerate vacua for an arbitrary number of artificial atoms and of resonator modes. In the ultrastrong coupling regime the degeneracy is protected with respect to random fluctuations of the transition energies of the Josephson elements.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevlett.104.023601

Related papers

Protected Quantum Computation with Multiple Resonators in Ultrastrong Coupling Circuit QED

Pierre Nataf, Cristiano Ciuti

We investigate theoretically the dynamical behavior of a qubit obtained with the two ground eigenstates of an ultrastrong coupling circuit-QED system consisting of a finite number of Josephson fluxonium atoms inductively coupled to a transmission line resonator. We show a universal set of quantum gates by using multiple transmission line resonators (each resonator represents a single qubit). We discuss the intrinsic "anisotropic" nature of noise sources for fluxonium artificial atoms. Through a master equation treatment with colored noise and many-level dynamics, we prove that, for a general class of anisotropic noise sources, the coherence time of the qubit and the fidelity of the quantum operations can be dramatically improved in an optimal regime of ultrastrong coupling, where the ground state is an entangled photonic "cat" state.

arXiv:1106.1159Physical Review LettersNov 2, 2011121 citations

Resilience of the quantum Rabi model in circuit QED

Vladimir Manucharyan, Alexandre Baksic, Cristiano Ciuti

In circuit quantum electrodynamics (circuit QED), an artificial 'circuit atom' can couple to a quantized microwave radiation much stronger than its real atomic counterpart. The celebrated quantum Rabi model describes the simplest interaction of a two-level system with a single-mode boson field. When the coupling is large enough, the bare multilevel structure of a realistic circuit atom cannot be ignored even if the circuit is strongly anharmonic. We explored this situation theoretically for flux (fluxonium) and charge (Cooper pair box) type multi-level circuits tuned to their respective flux/charge degeneracy points. We identified which spectral features of the quantum Rabi model survive and which are renormalized for large coupling. Despite significant renormalization of the low-energy spectrum in the fluxonium case, the key quantum Rabi feature—nearly-degenerate vacuum consisting of an atomic state entangled with a multi-photon field—appears in both types of circuits when the coupling is sufficiently large. Like in the quantum Rabi model, for very large couplings the entanglement spectrum is dominated by only two, nearly equal eigenvalues, in spite of the fact that a large number of bare atomic states are actually involved in the atom-resonator ground state. We interpret the emergence of the two-fold degeneracy of the vacuum of both circuits as an environmental suppression of flux/charge tunneling due to their dressing by virtual low-/high-impedance photons in the resonator. For flux tunneling, the dressing is nothing else than the shunting of a Josephson atom with a large capacitance of the resonator. Suppression of charge tunneling is a manifestation of the dynamical Coulomb blockade of transport in tunnel junctions connected to resistive leads.

arXiv:1612.03096Journal of Physics A Mathematical and TheoreticalJun 23, 201724 citations

Vacuum-induced symmetry breaking in a superconducting quantum circuit

Luigi Garziano, Roberto Stassi, A. Ridolfo +2 more

The ultrastrong-coupling regime, where the atom-cavity coupling rate reaches a considerable fraction of the cavity or atom transition frequencies, has been reported in a flux qubit superconducting quantum circuit coupled to an on-chip coplanar resonator. In this regime situations may arise where the resonator field $\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{X}=\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{a}+{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{a}}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$ acquires a nonzero expectation value in the system ground state. We demonstrate that, in this case, the parity symmetry of an additional artificial atom with an even potential is broken by the interaction with the resonator. Such a mechanism is analogous to the Higgs mechanism where the gauge symmetry of the weak force's gauge bosons is broken by the nonzero vacuum expectation value of the Higgs field. The results presented here open the way to controllable experiments on symmetry-breaking mechanisms induced by nonzero vacuum expectation values. Moreover, the mechanism proposed here can be used as a probe of the ground-state macroscopic coherence emerging from quantum phase transitions with vacuum degeneracy.

arXiv:1406.5119Physical Review AOct 13, 201458 citations

Controlling Discrete and Continuous Symmetries in “Superradiant” Phase Transitions with Circuit QED Systems

Alexandre Baksic, Cristiano Ciuti

We explore theoretically the physics of a collection of two-level systems coupled to a single-mode bosonic field in the nonstandard configuration where each (artificial) atom is coupled to both field quadratures of the boson mode. We show that such an unusual coupling scheme can be implemented in circuit QED systems, where artificial Josephson atoms are coupled both capacitively and inductively to a superconducting resonator. We demonstrate that it is possible to pass from a discrete, paritylike Z(2) symmetry to a continuous U(1) with the appearance of photonic Goldstone and amplitude modes above a critical point even in the ultrastrong coupling regime (where the rotating wave approximation for the interaction between field and two-level systems is no longer applicable). We determine the rich phase diagram showing "superradiant" phases with different symmetries and phase boundaries of both first and second order.

Physical Review LettersApr 29, 2014132 citations

Circuit QED spectra in the ultrastrong coupling regime: How they differ from cavity QED

Samuel Napoli, Alberto Mercurio, Daniele Lamberto +3 more

Cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED) investigates the interaction between resonator-confined radiation and natural atoms. Similar phenomena can be explored using superconducting artificial atoms coupled to microwave resonators. Here, we examine incoherent and coherent spectra in a circuit QED system consisting of a flux qubit coupled to an LC resonator, considering different coupling configurations to the output transmission line. Although such systems can be effectively described by the quantum Rabi model, we demonstrate that the choice of the coupling between the resonator and the input-output channel can significantly affect the emission properties, particularly in the ultrastrong coupling regime. Specifically, we show that when the resonator is capacitively coupled with the input-output transmission line, the spectral features at zero flux offset can be mapped onto those of the cavity QED model. However, this correspondence breaks down for the mutual inductive coupling case. Extending our analysis to the parity-symmetry broken regime of the flux qubit, we further highlight how capacitive and inductive coupling mechanisms lead to distinct spectral features, emphasizing the necessity of a careful input-output treatment for an accurate description of the emission processes.

arXiv:2408.16558Physical Review ResearchMay 23, 20254 citations

Is the quantum Rabi model adequate in circuit QED for any atom-resonator coupling?

Vladimir Manucharyan, Alexandre Baksic, Cristiano Ciuti

In quantum electrodynamics, an artificial circuit can couple to a quantized microwave radiation much stronger than its real atomic counterpart. The celebrated quantum Rabi model describes the simplest interaction of a two-level system with a single-mode boson field. When the coupling is arbitrary large, the bare multilevel structure of a realistic atom cannot be ignored even if the is strongly anharmonic. We explored this situation theoretically for flux (fluxonium) and charge (Cooper pair box) type multi-level atoms at maximal frustration and identified which spectral features of the quantum Rabi model survive and which are renormalized for arbitrary large coupling. We provide a quantitative comparison with the ideal quantum Rabi model by inspecting not only the energy level spectrum, but also the entanglement spectrum. Despite significant renormalization of the low-energy energy spectrum in the fluxonium case, the key quantum Rabi feature -- nearly-degenerate vacuum consisting of an atomic state entangled with a multi-photon field -- appears in both circuits when the coupling is sufficiently large. Like in the quantum Rabi model, for very large couplings the entanglement spectrum is dominated by only two, nearly equal eigenvalues, in spite of the fact that a large number of bare atomic states are actually involved in the ground state. We interpret the emergence of the vacuum degeneracy in both circuits as an environmental suppression of flux/charge tunneling due to their dressing by virtual low-/high-impedance photons in the resonator. For flux tunneling, the dressing is nothing else than the shunting of a Josephson atom with a large capacitance of the resonator. Suppression of charge tunneling appears to have the same origin as the dynamical Coulomb blockade of transport in tunnel junctions connected to resistive leads.

Dec 9, 20160 citations