Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0909.0584 · Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment

Symmetry relations for multifractal spectra at random critical points

Cécile Monthus, Bertrand Berche, Christophe Chatelain

Published Dec 3, 2009• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Random critical points are generically characterized by multifractal properties. In the field of Anderson localization, Mirlin, Fyodorov, Mildenberger and Evers [Phys. Rev. Lett 97, 046803 (2006)] have proposed that the singularity spectrum $f(α)$ of eigenfunctions satisfies the exact symmetry $f(2d-α)=f(α)+d-α$ at any Anderson transition. In the present paper, we analyse the physical origin of this symmetry in relation with the Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation relations of large deviation functions that are well-known in the field of non-equilibrium dynamics: the multifractal spectrum of the disordered model corresponds to the large deviation function of the rescaling exponent $γ=(α-d)$ along a renormalization trajectory in the effective time $t=\ln L$. We conclude that the symmetry discovered on the specific example of Anderson transitions should actually be satisfied at many other random critical points after an appropriate translation. For many-body random phase transitions, where the critical properties are usually analyzed in terms of the multifractal spectrum $H(a)$ and of the moments exponents X(N) of two-point correlation function [A. Ludwig, Nucl. Phys. B330, 639 (1990)], the symmetry becomes $H(2X(1) -a)= H(a) + a-X(1)$, or equivalently $Δ(N)=Δ(1-N)$ for the anomalous parts $Δ(N) \equiv X(N)-NX(1)$. We present numerical tests in favor of this symmetry for the 2D random $Q-$state Potts model with various $Q$.

DOI
10.1088/1742-5468/2009/12/p12002

Related papers

Multifractal statistics of the local order parameter at random critical points: Application to wetting transitions with disorder

Cécile Monthus, Thomas Garel

Disordered systems present multifractal properties at criticality. In particular, as discovered by Ludwig [A.W.W. Ludwig, Nucl. Phys. B 330, 639 (1990)] in the case of a diluted two-dimensional Potts model, the moments rho(q) (r) of the local order parameter rho(r) scale with a set x(q) of nontrivial exponents x(q) not = qx(1). We reexamine these ideas to incorporate more recent findings: (i) whenever a multifractal measure w(r) normalized over space sum(r) w(r) = 1 occurs in a random system, it is crucial to distinguish between the typical values and the disorder-averaged values of the generalized moments Y(q) = sum(r) w(q) (r), since they may scale with different generalized dimensions D(q) and D(q), and (ii), as discovered by Wiseman and Domany [S. Wiseman and E. Domany, Phys. Rev. E 52, 3469 (1995)], the presence of an infinite correlation length induces a lack of self-averaging at critical points for thermodynamic observables, in particular for the order parameter. After this general discussion, valid for any random critical point, we apply these ideas to random polymer models that can be studied numerically for large sizes and good statistics over the samples. We study the bidimensional wetting or the Poland-Scheraga DNA model with loop exponents c = 1.5 (marginal disorder) and c = 1.75 (relevant disorder). Finally, we argue that the presence of finite Griffiths-ordered clusters at criticality determines the asymptotic value x(q-->infinity) = d and the minimal value alpha(min) = D(q-->infinity) = d - x(1) of the typical multifractal spectrum f(alpha).

arXiv:0705.0223•Physical Review E•Aug 21, 2007•14 citations

Generalized surface multifractality in two-dimensional disordered systems

Serafim S. Babkin, Jonas F. Karcher, I. S. Burmistrov +1 more

Recently, a concept of generalized multifractality, which characterizes fluctuations and correlations of critical eigenstates, was introduced and explored for all 10 symmetry classes of disordered systems. Here, by using the nonlinear sigma-model ($\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$) field theory, we extend the theory of generalized multifractality to boundaries of systems at criticality. Our numerical simulations on two-dimensional systems of symmetry classes A, C, and AII fully confirm the analytical predictions of pure-scaling observables and Weyl symmetry relations between critical exponents of surface generalized multifractality. This demonstrates the validity of the $\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$ for the description of Anderson-localization critical phenomena, not only in the bulk but also on the boundary. The critical exponents strongly violate generalized parabolicity, in analogy with earlier results for the bulk, corroborating the conclusion that the considered Anderson-localization critical points are not described by conformal field theories. We further derive relations between generalized surface multifractal spectra and linear combinations of Lyapunov exponents of a strip in quasi-one-dimensional geometry, which hold under the assumption of invariance with respect to a logarithmic conformal map. Our numerics demonstrate that these relations hold with an excellent accuracy. Taken together, our results indicate an intriguing situation: the conformal invariance is broken but holds partially at critical points of Anderson localization.

arXiv:2306.09455•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 18, 2023•7 citations

Connecting finite-size scaling and renormalization-group flows in Anderson localization on random graphs

Ignacio García-Mata, Weitao Chen, John Martin +2 more

We investigate the relation between two complementary descriptions of the Anderson transition on small-world random graphs: finite-size scaling of eigenfunction moments and renormalization-group (RG) flows of multifractal dimensions $D_q$. The RG flows recover the qualitative structure previously reported for the information dimension $D_1$, while their extension to other $D_q$ with smaller moment orders $q<1/2$ confirms the strongly multifractal nature of the localized phase characterized by a clear separation between multifractal and localized behaviors at strong disorder. On the other hand, we show that we can construct another beta function characterizing the flow of eigenfunction moments, whose collapse onto a single function across different disorder strengths provides a clear confirmation of single-parameter scaling property. These results indicate that the family of RG trajectories observed for the information dimension $D_1$ need not imply two-parameter scaling and Kosterlitz-Thouless like critical behavior. To characterize these properties, one should consider different observables, such as large $q>1/2$ and small $q<1/2$ eigenfunction moments, which are associated with distinct critical behaviors, in particular different critical exponents.

cond-mat.dis-nnCross-listedarXiv:2609.31872•Sep 29, 2026

Multifractal finite-size scaling and universality at the Anderson transition

Alberto Rodríguez, Louella J. Vasquez, Keith Slevin +1 more

We describe a new multifractal finite-size scaling (MFSS) procedure and its application to the Anderson localization-delocalization transition. MFSS permits the simultaneous estimation of the critical parameters and the multifractal exponents. Simulations of system sizes up to ${L}^{3}={120}^{3}$ and involving nearly ${10}^{6}$ independent wave functions have yielded unprecedented precision for the critical disorder ${W}_{c}=16.530(16.524,16.536)$ and the critical exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}=1.590(1.579,1.602)$. We find that the multifractal exponents ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{q}$ exhibit a previously predicted symmetry relation and we confirm the nonparabolic nature of their spectrum. We explain in detail the MFSS procedure first introduced in our Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 046403 (2010)] and, in addition, we show how to take account of correlations in the simulation data. The MFSS procedure is applicable to any continuous phase transition exhibiting multifractal fluctuations in the vicinity of the critical point.

arXiv:1107.5736•Physical Review B•Oct 31, 2011•180 citations

Critical exponent and multifractality of states at the Anderson transition

Bernhard Krämer

Based on the assumptions of the existence of a one-paramter scaling law for a self-averaging scaling variable, and on a finite correlation length for the randomness, the lower bound for the critical exponent of the Anderson transition derived earlier by Chayes et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2999 (1986)] for uncorrelated disorder is generalized to the case of spatially correlated disorder. The bound is determined by the system-size dependence of the number of the random variables that are necessary to describe the transition. It is speculated how to relate the critical exponent to the multifractal properties of the states near the critical point. Exponents of several models are estimated and compared with numerical scaling calculations.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1993•15 citations

Many-body-localization transition: strong multifractality spectrum for matrix elements of local operators

Cécile Monthus

Abstract For short-ranged disordered quantum models in one dimension, the many-body-localization is analyzed via the adaptation to the many-body context (Serbyn et al 2015 Phys. Rev . X 5 041047) of the Thouless point of view on the Anderson transition: the question is whether a local interaction between two long chains is able to reshuffle completely the eigenstates (delocalized phase with a volume-law entanglement) or whether the hybridization between tensor states remains limited (many-body-localized phase with an area-law entanglement). The central object is thus the level of hybridization induced by the matrix elements of local operators, as compared with the difference of diagonal energies. The multifractal analysis of these matrix elements of local operators is used to analyze the corresponding statistics of resonances. Our main conclusion is that the critical point is characterized by the strong-multifractality spectrum f ( 0 ⩽ α ⩽ 2 ) = α 2 , well known in the context of Anderson localization in spaces of effective infinite dimensionality, where the size of the Hilbert space grows exponentially with the volume. Finally, the possibility of a delocalized non-ergodic phase near criticality is discussed.

arXiv:1603.04701•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Jul 1, 2016•44 citations
Random critical points are generically characterized by multifractal properties. In the field of Anderson localization, Mirlin, Fyodorov, Mildenberger and Evers [Phys. Rev. Lett 97, 046803 (2006)] have proposed that the singularity spectrum f(α)f(α)f(α) of eigenfunctions satisfies the exact symmetry f(2d−α)=f(α)+d−αf(2d-α)=f(α)+d-αf(2d−α)=f(α)+d−α at any Anderson transition. In the present paper, we analyse the physical origin of this symmetry in relation with the Gallavotti-Cohen fluctuation relations of large deviation functions that are well-known in the field of non-equilibrium dynamics: the multifractal spectrum of the disordered model corresponds to the large deviation function of the rescaling exponent γ=(α−d)γ=(α-d)γ=(α−d) along a renormalization trajectory in the effective time t=ln⁡Lt=\ln Lt=lnL. We conclude that the symmetry discovered on the specific example of Anderson transitions should actually be satisfied at many other random critical points after an appropriate translation. For many-body random phase transitions, where the critical properties are usually analyzed in terms of the multifractal spectrum H(a)H(a)H(a) and of the moments exponents X(N) of two-point correlation function [A. Ludwig, Nucl. Phys. B330, 639 (1990)], the symmetry becomes H(2X(1)−a)=H(a)+a−X(1)H(2X(1) -a)= H(a) + a-X(1)H(2X(1)−a)=H(a)+a−X(1), or equivalently Δ(N)=Δ(1−N)Δ(N)=Δ(1-N)Δ(N)=Δ(1−N) for the anomalous parts Δ(N)≡X(N)−NX(1)Δ(N) \equiv X(N)-NX(1)Δ(N)≡X(N)−NX(1). We present numerical tests in favor of this symmetry for the 2D random Q−Q-Q−state Potts model with various QQQ.
Disordered systems present multifractal properties at criticality. In particular, as discovered by Ludwig [A.W.W. Ludwig, Nucl. Phys. B 330, 639 (1990)] in the case of a diluted two-dimensional Potts model, the moments rho(q) (r) of the local order parameter rho(r) scale with a set x(q) of nontrivial exponents x(q) not = qx(1). We reexamine these ideas to incorporate more recent findings: (i) whenever a multifractal measure w(r) normalized over space sum(r) w(r) = 1 occurs in a random system, it is crucial to distinguish between the typical values and the disorder-averaged values of the generalized moments Y(q) = sum(r) w(q) (r), since they may scale with different generalized dimensions D(q) and D(q), and (ii), as discovered by Wiseman and Domany [S. Wiseman and E. Domany, Phys. Rev. E 52, 3469 (1995)], the presence of an infinite correlation length induces a lack of self-averaging at critical points for thermodynamic observables, in particular for the order parameter. After this general discussion, valid for any random critical point, we apply these ideas to random polymer models that can be studied numerically for large sizes and good statistics over the samples. We study the bidimensional wetting or the Poland-Scheraga DNA model with loop exponents c = 1.5 (marginal disorder) and c = 1.75 (relevant disorder). Finally, we argue that the presence of finite Griffiths-ordered clusters at criticality determines the asymptotic value x(q-->infinity) = d and the minimal value alpha(min) = D(q-->infinity) = d - x(1) of the typical multifractal spectrum f(alpha).
Recently, a concept of generalized multifractality, which characterizes fluctuations and correlations of critical eigenstates, was introduced and explored for all 10 symmetry classes of disordered systems. Here, by using the nonlinear sigma-model ($\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$) field theory, we extend the theory of generalized multifractality to boundaries of systems at criticality. Our numerical simulations on two-dimensional systems of symmetry classes A, C, and AII fully confirm the analytical predictions of pure-scaling observables and Weyl symmetry relations between critical exponents of surface generalized multifractality. This demonstrates the validity of the $\mathrm{NL}\ensuremath{\sigma}\mathrm{M}$ for the description of Anderson-localization critical phenomena, not only in the bulk but also on the boundary. The critical exponents strongly violate generalized parabolicity, in analogy with earlier results for the bulk, corroborating the conclusion that the considered Anderson-localization critical points are not described by conformal field theories. We further derive relations between generalized surface multifractal spectra and linear combinations of Lyapunov exponents of a strip in quasi-one-dimensional geometry, which hold under the assumption of invariance with respect to a logarithmic conformal map. Our numerics demonstrate that these relations hold with an excellent accuracy. Taken together, our results indicate an intriguing situation: the conformal invariance is broken but holds partially at critical points of Anderson localization.
We investigate the relation between two complementary descriptions of the Anderson transition on small-world random graphs: finite-size scaling of eigenfunction moments and renormalization-group (RG) flows of multifractal dimensions DqD_qDq​. The RG flows recover the qualitative structure previously reported for the information dimension D1D_1D1​, while their extension to other DqD_qDq​ with smaller moment orders q<1/2q<1/2q<1/2 confirms the strongly multifractal nature of the localized phase characterized by a clear separation between multifractal and localized behaviors at strong disorder. On the other hand, we show that we can construct another beta function characterizing the flow of eigenfunction moments, whose collapse onto a single function across different disorder strengths provides a clear confirmation of single-parameter scaling property. These results indicate that the family of RG trajectories observed for the information dimension D1D_1D1​ need not imply two-parameter scaling and Kosterlitz-Thouless like critical behavior. To characterize these properties, one should consider different observables, such as large q>1/2q>1/2q>1/2 and small q<1/2q<1/2q<1/2 eigenfunction moments, which are associated with distinct critical behaviors, in particular different critical exponents.
We describe a new multifractal finite-size scaling (MFSS) procedure and its application to the Anderson localization-delocalization transition. MFSS permits the simultaneous estimation of the critical parameters and the multifractal exponents. Simulations of system sizes up to L3=1203{L}^{3}={120}^{3}L3=1203 and involving nearly 106{10}^{6}106 independent wave functions have yielded unprecedented precision for the critical disorder Wc=16.530(16.524,16.536){W}_{c}=16.530(16.524,16.536)Wc​=16.530(16.524,16.536) and the critical exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}=1.590(1.579,1.602)$. We find that the multifractal exponents ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{q}$ exhibit a previously predicted symmetry relation and we confirm the nonparabolic nature of their spectrum. We explain in detail the MFSS procedure first introduced in our Letter [Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 046403 (2010)] and, in addition, we show how to take account of correlations in the simulation data. The MFSS procedure is applicable to any continuous phase transition exhibiting multifractal fluctuations in the vicinity of the critical point.
Based on the assumptions of the existence of a one-paramter scaling law for a self-averaging scaling variable, and on a finite correlation length for the randomness, the lower bound for the critical exponent of the Anderson transition derived earlier by Chayes et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2999 (1986)] for uncorrelated disorder is generalized to the case of spatially correlated disorder. The bound is determined by the system-size dependence of the number of the random variables that are necessary to describe the transition. It is speculated how to relate the critical exponent to the multifractal properties of the states near the critical point. Exponents of several models are estimated and compared with numerical scaling calculations.
Abstract For short-ranged disordered quantum models in one dimension, the many-body-localization is analyzed via the adaptation to the many-body context (Serbyn et al 2015 Phys. Rev . X 5 041047) of the Thouless point of view on the Anderson transition: the question is whether a local interaction between two long chains is able to reshuffle completely the eigenstates (delocalized phase with a volume-law entanglement) or whether the hybridization between tensor states remains limited (many-body-localized phase with an area-law entanglement). The central object is thus the level of hybridization induced by the matrix elements of local operators, as compared with the difference of diagonal energies. The multifractal analysis of these matrix elements of local operators is used to analyze the corresponding statistics of resonances. Our main conclusion is that the critical point is characterized by the strong-multifractality spectrum f ( 0 ⩽ α ⩽ 2 ) = α 2 , well known in the context of Anderson localization in spaces of effective infinite dimensionality, where the size of the Hilbert space grows exponentially with the volume. Finally, the possibility of a delocalized non-ergodic phase near criticality is discussed.