Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0908.3015 · Physical Review Letters

Universal Thermometry for Quantum Simulation

Qi Zhou, Tin-Lun Ho

Published May 31, 2011• 58 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum simulation is a highly ambitious program in cold atom research currently being pursued in laboratories worldwide. The goal is to use cold atoms in optical lattices to simulate models for unsolved strongly correlated systems, so as to deduce their properties directly from experimental data. An important step in this effort is to determine the temperature of the system, which is essential for deducing all thermodynamic functions. This step, however, remains difficult for lattice systems at the moment. Here, we propose a method based on a generalized fluctuation-dissipation theorem. It does not rely on numerical simulations and gives a universal thermometry scheme for quantum gas systems including mixtures and spinor gases, provided that the local density approximation is valid.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.106.225301

Related papers

Fluctuation Thermometry of an Atom-Resolved Quantum Gas: Beyond the Fluctuation-Dissipation Theorem

Maxime Dixmerias, Joris Verstraten, Cyprien Daix +3 more

Thermometry is essential for studying many-body physics with ultracold atoms. Accurately measuring low temperatures in these systems, however, remains a significant challenge due to the absence of a universal thermometer. Most widely applicable methods, such as fitting of in situ density profiles, are limited by the requirement of global thermal equilibrium and inapplicability to homogeneous systems. In this Letter, we introduce a novel in situ thermometry for quantum gases, leveraging single-atom-resolved measurements via quantum gas microscopy, and demonstrate it on an ideal Fermi gas. By analyzing number fluctuations in probe volumes containing as little as one atom on average, we extract both global and local temperatures over a broad dynamic range. Our method does not rely on the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and is based instead on the exact relationship between number fluctuations and density-density correlations. In the low-temperature regime, it allows us to observe significant deviations from fluctuation-dissipation predictions, uncovering subextensive fluctuations. Our method is applicable to systems with arbitrary trapping potentials, requiring neither precise trap calibration nor global thermal equilibrium. This thermometer for quantum gases overcomes key limitations of existing techniques, paving the way for more accurate and versatile temperature measurements in ultracold quantum systems.

arXiv:2502.05132•Physical Review Letters•Jun 12, 2026•0 citations

Obtaining phase diagram and thermodynamic quantities of bulk systems from the densities of trapped gases

Tin-Lun Ho, Zhou, Qi

At present, many laboratories are performing experiments to simulate theoretical models of strongly correlated systems using cold atoms in optical lattices, a program referred to as "Quantum Simulation". It is hoped that these experiments will shed light on some long standing problems in condensed matter physics. The goal of Quantum Simulation is to obtain information of homogenous bulk systems. However, experiments are performed in confining traps. The non-uniformity of the trapping potential inevitably introduces different phases in the sample, making it difficult to deduce the properties of a single bulk phase. So far, there are no algorithms to use the experimental data to map out phase diagrams and important thermodynamic quantities. Here, we present an algorithm to achieve this goal. Apart from phase diagram, it also maps out entropy density, superfluid density of superfluids, and staggered magnetizations of anti-ferromagnets. Our scheme is exact within local density approximation.

arXiv:0901.0018•Dec 30, 2008•18 citations

Universal Cooling Scheme for Quantum Simulation

Tin-Lun Ho, Qi Zhou

At present, there is a worldwide effort to use cold atoms to simulate strongly correlated quantum many-body systems. It is hoped that these "simulations" will provide solutions to many unsolved problems. However, the relevant energy scales in most of these experiments are so small that one has to go to entropy regimes far below those achievable today. Here, we present a general scheme to extract entropy directly from the region of interest. The late stage of this process is equivalent to a continuous "evaporation", and is able to combat intrinsic heating of the system. For illustration, we show how to cool a weak coupling BCS superfluid (with $T_{c}\sim 10^{-10}$K) to $10^{-11}$K with this simple procedure, with entropy per particle as low as $5\times 10^{-4}k_{B}$ in the superfluid region.

arXiv:0911.5506•Nov 29, 2009•10 citations

Quantum simulation of thermodynamics: Maxwell relations for pair correlations

Rist, F., Raymon S. Watson, H. L. Nourse +2 more

Quantum simulators hold enormous promise for advancing the modelling of materials and understanding emergent physics, such as high temperature superconductivity and topological order. While correlation functions are, typically, straightforward to measure in quantum simulators, thermodynamic properties are not. This limits our ability to directly compare the results of quantum simulations to experiments on the materials being modelled. Maxwell relations are an extremely powerful tool for characterising complex materials, as they enable the determination of challenging-to-measure thermodynamic properties from more accessible ones. Here, we introduce generalised Maxwell relations that relate every thermodynamic quantity to a single local correlation function. We illustrate their utility by deducing the thermodynamic properties of several iconic quantum many-body models from pair correlation functions using the generalised Maxwell relations. We show that this {universal} approach is readily accessible in quantum simulators and suggest applications to condensed matter systems where thermodynamic measurements are challenging, such as atomically thin materials.

arXiv:2506.19407•Jun 24, 2025•0 citations

Thermometry of Cold Atoms in Optical Lattices via Artificial Gauge Fields

Tommaso Roscilde

Artificial gauge fields are a unique way of manipulating the motional state of cold atoms. Here we propose the use (practical or conceptual) of artificial gauge fields--obtained, e.g., experimentally via lattice shaking or conceptually via a Galilean transformation--to perform primary noise thermometry of cold atoms in optical lattices, not requiring any form of prior calibration. The proposed thermometric scheme relies on fundamental fluctuation--dissipation relations, connecting the global response to the variation of the applied gauge field and the fluctuation of quantities related to the momentum distribution (such as the average kinetic energy or the average current). We demonstrate gauge-field thermometry for several physical situations, including free fermions and interacting bosons. The proposed approach is extremely robust to quantum fluctuations-even in the vicinity of a quantum phase transition--when it relies on the thermal fluctuations of an emerging classical field, associated with the onset of Bose condensation or chiral order.

arXiv:1309.1938•Physical Review Letters•Mar 17, 2014•16 citations

Quantum Simulation with Cold Atoms in the Optical Lattices.

Yang‐Hao Chan

A quantum simulator is a well-controlled quantum system which can be used to simulate another quantum system. Quantum degenerate gases confined by optical standing waves(optical lattices) have been considered to simulate condensed matter systems. We focus on two issues in this problem. The first one is the realization of interesting quantum phases by engineering Hamiltonians with the cold atoms toolbox. Secondly, the systems we studied are often intractable to analytical methods, which makes it a crucial issue to solve them with numerical methods. For the first issue we find several interesting phases can be studied with cold atoms in optical lattices. We show that a $p$-wave superfluid is stablized through a dissipation blockade mechanism. This mechanism also induces a new insulator formed by $p$-wave Feshbach molecules. We find that the anisotropic nature of interaction between polar molecules or dipolar atoms can be used to realize two charge density waves with different patterns and a supersolid phase which has not been found conclusively in the condensed matter system. Finally, we propose to realize a long sought spin liquid phase with hard-core bosons subject to a spin-dependent lattice and Raman induced hoppings. For the second issue we choose to numerically study these systems with the so-called tensor network algorithm which is a variational method based on the matrix(tensor) product states product states which are designed to approximate generic wave functions from their entanglement properties. In general the tensor network algorithm has advantages that it is applicable beyond one dimension, and can be used to study physical properties in the thermodynamic limit directly. We apply this method to map out the phase diagrams of the above systems. Furthermore, we show that it is capable of capturing the phase diagram of a frustrated magnetism model, the Heisenberg model on a checkerboard lattice. The great controllability and isolation from the environment of a cold atom system offer a playground to study interesting physics in strongly correlated systems. Several proposed control schemes in this thesis have been demonstrated in experiments. By providing detailed evidence from numerical simulations, this work addresses practical routes to novel quantum phases.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations
Quantum simulation is a highly ambitious program in cold atom research currently being pursued in laboratories worldwide. The goal is to use cold atoms in optical lattices to simulate models for unsolved strongly correlated systems, so as to deduce their properties directly from experimental data. An important step in this effort is to determine the temperature of the system, which is essential for deducing all thermodynamic functions. This step, however, remains difficult for lattice systems at the moment. Here, we propose a method based on a generalized fluctuation-dissipation theorem. It does not rely on numerical simulations and gives a universal thermometry scheme for quantum gas systems including mixtures and spinor gases, provided that the local density approximation is valid.
Thermometry is essential for studying many-body physics with ultracold atoms. Accurately measuring low temperatures in these systems, however, remains a significant challenge due to the absence of a universal thermometer. Most widely applicable methods, such as fitting of in situ density profiles, are limited by the requirement of global thermal equilibrium and inapplicability to homogeneous systems. In this Letter, we introduce a novel in situ thermometry for quantum gases, leveraging single-atom-resolved measurements via quantum gas microscopy, and demonstrate it on an ideal Fermi gas. By analyzing number fluctuations in probe volumes containing as little as one atom on average, we extract both global and local temperatures over a broad dynamic range. Our method does not rely on the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and is based instead on the exact relationship between number fluctuations and density-density correlations. In the low-temperature regime, it allows us to observe significant deviations from fluctuation-dissipation predictions, uncovering subextensive fluctuations. Our method is applicable to systems with arbitrary trapping potentials, requiring neither precise trap calibration nor global thermal equilibrium. This thermometer for quantum gases overcomes key limitations of existing techniques, paving the way for more accurate and versatile temperature measurements in ultracold quantum systems.
At present, many laboratories are performing experiments to simulate theoretical models of strongly correlated systems using cold atoms in optical lattices, a program referred to as "Quantum Simulation". It is hoped that these experiments will shed light on some long standing problems in condensed matter physics. The goal of Quantum Simulation is to obtain information of homogenous bulk systems. However, experiments are performed in confining traps. The non-uniformity of the trapping potential inevitably introduces different phases in the sample, making it difficult to deduce the properties of a single bulk phase. So far, there are no algorithms to use the experimental data to map out phase diagrams and important thermodynamic quantities. Here, we present an algorithm to achieve this goal. Apart from phase diagram, it also maps out entropy density, superfluid density of superfluids, and staggered magnetizations of anti-ferromagnets. Our scheme is exact within local density approximation.
At present, there is a worldwide effort to use cold atoms to simulate strongly correlated quantum many-body systems. It is hoped that these "simulations" will provide solutions to many unsolved problems. However, the relevant energy scales in most of these experiments are so small that one has to go to entropy regimes far below those achievable today. Here, we present a general scheme to extract entropy directly from the region of interest. The late stage of this process is equivalent to a continuous "evaporation", and is able to combat intrinsic heating of the system. For illustration, we show how to cool a weak coupling BCS superfluid (with Tc∼10−10T_{c}\sim 10^{-10}Tc​∼10−10K) to 10−1110^{-11}10−11K with this simple procedure, with entropy per particle as low as 5×10−4kB5\times 10^{-4}k_{B}5×10−4kB​ in the superfluid region.
Quantum simulators hold enormous promise for advancing the modelling of materials and understanding emergent physics, such as high temperature superconductivity and topological order. While correlation functions are, typically, straightforward to measure in quantum simulators, thermodynamic properties are not. This limits our ability to directly compare the results of quantum simulations to experiments on the materials being modelled. Maxwell relations are an extremely powerful tool for characterising complex materials, as they enable the determination of challenging-to-measure thermodynamic properties from more accessible ones. Here, we introduce generalised Maxwell relations that relate every thermodynamic quantity to a single local correlation function. We illustrate their utility by deducing the thermodynamic properties of several iconic quantum many-body models from pair correlation functions using the generalised Maxwell relations. We show that this {universal} approach is readily accessible in quantum simulators and suggest applications to condensed matter systems where thermodynamic measurements are challenging, such as atomically thin materials.
Artificial gauge fields are a unique way of manipulating the motional state of cold atoms. Here we propose the use (practical or conceptual) of artificial gauge fields--obtained, e.g., experimentally via lattice shaking or conceptually via a Galilean transformation--to perform primary noise thermometry of cold atoms in optical lattices, not requiring any form of prior calibration. The proposed thermometric scheme relies on fundamental fluctuation--dissipation relations, connecting the global response to the variation of the applied gauge field and the fluctuation of quantities related to the momentum distribution (such as the average kinetic energy or the average current). We demonstrate gauge-field thermometry for several physical situations, including free fermions and interacting bosons. The proposed approach is extremely robust to quantum fluctuations-even in the vicinity of a quantum phase transition--when it relies on the thermal fluctuations of an emerging classical field, associated with the onset of Bose condensation or chiral order.
A quantum simulator is a well-controlled quantum system which can be used to simulate another quantum system. Quantum degenerate gases confined by optical standing waves(optical lattices) have been considered to simulate condensed matter systems. We focus on two issues in this problem. The first one is the realization of interesting quantum phases by engineering Hamiltonians with the cold atoms toolbox. Secondly, the systems we studied are often intractable to analytical methods, which makes it a crucial issue to solve them with numerical methods. For the first issue we find several interesting phases can be studied with cold atoms in optical lattices. We show that a ppp-wave superfluid is stablized through a dissipation blockade mechanism. This mechanism also induces a new insulator formed by ppp-wave Feshbach molecules. We find that the anisotropic nature of interaction between polar molecules or dipolar atoms can be used to realize two charge density waves with different patterns and a supersolid phase which has not been found conclusively in the condensed matter system. Finally, we propose to realize a long sought spin liquid phase with hard-core bosons subject to a spin-dependent lattice and Raman induced hoppings. For the second issue we choose to numerically study these systems with the so-called tensor network algorithm which is a variational method based on the matrix(tensor) product states product states which are designed to approximate generic wave functions from their entanglement properties. In general the tensor network algorithm has advantages that it is applicable beyond one dimension, and can be used to study physical properties in the thermodynamic limit directly. We apply this method to map out the phase diagrams of the above systems. Furthermore, we show that it is capable of capturing the phase diagram of a frustrated magnetism model, the Heisenberg model on a checkerboard lattice. The great controllability and isolation from the environment of a cold atom system offer a playground to study interesting physics in strongly correlated systems. Several proposed control schemes in this thesis have been demonstrated in experiments. By providing detailed evidence from numerical simulations, this work addresses practical routes to novel quantum phases.