Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0907.5588 · Physica Scripta

Resolution of the Klein paradox

Abdulaziz D Alhaidari

Published Jan 14, 2011• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a resolution of the Klein paradox within the framework of one-particle relativistic quantum mechanics. Not only reflection becomes total but the vacuum remains neutral as well. This is accomplished by replacing the physical pair production process with virtual negative energy ‘incidence’ within the barrier in a similar manner to what is done with virtual sources in optics and image charges in electrostatics.

DOI
10.1088/0031-8949/83/02/025001

Related papers

Virtual beams and the Klein paradox for the Klein-Gordon equation

Alberto Molgado, Ociel Morales, José A. Vallejo

Whenever we consider any relativistic quantum wave equation we are confronted with the Klein paradox, which asserts that incident particles will suffer a surplus of reflection when dispersed by a discontinuous potential. Following recent results on the Dirac equation, we propose a solution to this paradox for the Klein-Gordon case by introducing virtual beams in a natural well-posed generalization of the method of images in the theory of partial differential equations. Thus, our solution considers a global reflection coefficient obtained from the two contributions, the reflected particles plus the incident virtual particles. Despite its simplicity, this method allows a reasonable understanding of the paradox within the context of the quantum relativistic theory of particles (according to the original setup for the Klein paradox) and without resorting to any quantum field theoretic issues.

arXiv:1602.00190•Revista Mexicana de Física E•Apr 10, 2018•6 citations

Klein Paradox in the Pilot Wave Interpretation

John F. Dodaro

The de Broglie-Bohm pilot wave interpretation of quantum mechanics is shown to provide a consistent explanation for a single relativistic particle (more accurately, a single particle process since pair production is addressed). This is accomplished by incorporating the Feynman-Stueckelberg interpretation of anti-matter. The lack of conserved probability and existence of negative energy solutions is studied through this interpretation. We discuss the resolution of Klein's original paradox through the pilot wave interpretation, and similarly analyze the potential barrier problem. Simulations are presented for a wave packet incident on potential steps & barriers of various heights.

arXiv:1312.1377•Dec 4, 2013•0 citations

Barrier paradox in the Klein zone

Stefano De Leo, PIETRO P. ROTELLI

We study the solutions for a one-dimensional electrostatic potential in the Dirac equation when the incoming wave packet exhibits the Klein paradox (pair production). With a barrier potential we demonstrate the existence of multiple reflections (and transmissions). The antiparticle solutions which are necessarily localized within the barrier region create new pairs with each reflection at the potential walls. Consequently we encounter a new ``paradox'' for the barrier because successive outgoing wave amplitudes grow geometrically.

arXiv:hep-th/0607176•Physical Review A•Apr 20, 2006•41 citations

KLEIN PARADOX FOR OPTICAL SCATTERING FROM EXCITED TARGETS

Orlando Panella, Y. N. Srivastava, A. Widom

The well-known Klein paradox for the relativistic Dirac wave equation consists in the computation of possible "negative probabilities" induced by certain potentials in some regimes of energy. The paradox may be resolved by employing the notion of electron–positron pair production in which the number of electrons present in a process can increase. The Klein paradox also exists in the Maxwell's equations viewed as the wave equation for photons. In a medium containing "inverted energy populations" of excited atoms, e.g. in a LASER medium, one may again compute possible "negative probabilities." The resolution of the electromagnetic Klein paradox is that when the atoms decay, the final state may contain more photons then were contained the initial state. The optical theorem total cross-section for scattering photons from excited state atoms may then be computed as negative within a frequency band with matter induced amplification.

arXiv:0711.0704•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Jun 30, 2006•1 citation

Klein paradox for bosons, wave packets and negative tunnelling times

X. Gutiérrez de la Cal, M. Alkhateeb, M. Ll. Pons +2 more

We analyse a little known aspect of the Klein paradox. A Klein-Gordon boson appears to be able to cross a supercritical rectangular barrier without being reflected, while spending there a negative amount of time. The transmission mechanism is demonstrably acausal, yet an attempt to construct the corresponding causal solution of the Klein-Gordon equation fails. We relate the causal solution to a divergent multiple-reflections series, and show that the problem is remedied for a smooth barrier, where pair production at the energy equal to a half of the barrier's height is enhanced yet remains finite.

arXiv:2107.09374•Scientific Reports•Nov 5, 2020•9 citations

New Resolution of Klein Paradox by Modified Dirac Equations

Grigori G. Karapetyan

We present a new resolution of the Klein paradox by considering the problem of electron incidence on a step potential barrier using modified Dirac equations (MDE). Contrary to the generally accepted interpretation, which is based on the Dirac equation (DE) and predicts electron tunneling through an infinitely high barrier, our calculations show that tunneling is impossible if the electron kinetic energy is less than the barrier height. We propose to investigate MDE as an alternative DE relativistic quantum mechanical equation for spin ½ particles․

Armenian Journal of Physics•Sep 11, 2024•0 citations
We present a resolution of the Klein paradox within the framework of one-particle relativistic quantum mechanics. Not only reflection becomes total but the vacuum remains neutral as well. This is accomplished by replacing the physical pair production process with virtual negative energy ‘incidence’ within the barrier in a similar manner to what is done with virtual sources in optics and image charges in electrostatics.
Whenever we consider any relativistic quantum wave equation we are confronted with the Klein paradox, which asserts that incident particles will suffer a surplus of reflection when dispersed by a discontinuous potential. Following recent results on the Dirac equation, we propose a solution to this paradox for the Klein-Gordon case by introducing virtual beams in a natural well-posed generalization of the method of images in the theory of partial differential equations. Thus, our solution considers a global reflection coefficient obtained from the two contributions, the reflected particles plus the incident virtual particles. Despite its simplicity, this method allows a reasonable understanding of the paradox within the context of the quantum relativistic theory of particles (according to the original setup for the Klein paradox) and without resorting to any quantum field theoretic issues.
The de Broglie-Bohm pilot wave interpretation of quantum mechanics is shown to provide a consistent explanation for a single relativistic particle (more accurately, a single particle process since pair production is addressed). This is accomplished by incorporating the Feynman-Stueckelberg interpretation of anti-matter. The lack of conserved probability and existence of negative energy solutions is studied through this interpretation. We discuss the resolution of Klein's original paradox through the pilot wave interpretation, and similarly analyze the potential barrier problem. Simulations are presented for a wave packet incident on potential steps & barriers of various heights.
We study the solutions for a one-dimensional electrostatic potential in the Dirac equation when the incoming wave packet exhibits the Klein paradox (pair production). With a barrier potential we demonstrate the existence of multiple reflections (and transmissions). The antiparticle solutions which are necessarily localized within the barrier region create new pairs with each reflection at the potential walls. Consequently we encounter a new ``paradox'' for the barrier because successive outgoing wave amplitudes grow geometrically.
The well-known Klein paradox for the relativistic Dirac wave equation consists in the computation of possible "negative probabilities" induced by certain potentials in some regimes of energy. The paradox may be resolved by employing the notion of electron–positron pair production in which the number of electrons present in a process can increase. The Klein paradox also exists in the Maxwell's equations viewed as the wave equation for photons. In a medium containing "inverted energy populations" of excited atoms, e.g. in a LASER medium, one may again compute possible "negative probabilities." The resolution of the electromagnetic Klein paradox is that when the atoms decay, the final state may contain more photons then were contained the initial state. The optical theorem total cross-section for scattering photons from excited state atoms may then be computed as negative within a frequency band with matter induced amplification.
We analyse a little known aspect of the Klein paradox. A Klein-Gordon boson appears to be able to cross a supercritical rectangular barrier without being reflected, while spending there a negative amount of time. The transmission mechanism is demonstrably acausal, yet an attempt to construct the corresponding causal solution of the Klein-Gordon equation fails. We relate the causal solution to a divergent multiple-reflections series, and show that the problem is remedied for a smooth barrier, where pair production at the energy equal to a half of the barrier's height is enhanced yet remains finite.
We present a new resolution of the Klein paradox by considering the problem of electron incidence on a step potential barrier using modified Dirac equations (MDE). Contrary to the generally accepted interpretation, which is based on the Dirac equation (DE) and predicts electron tunneling through an infinitely high barrier, our calculations show that tunneling is impossible if the electron kinetic energy is less than the barrier height. We propose to investigate MDE as an alternative DE relativistic quantum mechanical equation for spin ½ particles․