Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0907.4646 · Physical Review B

Approximating strongly correlated wave functions with correlator product states

Hitesh J. Changlani, Jesse Kinder, Cyrus J. Umrigar, Garnet Kin‐Lic Chan

Published Dec 22, 2009• 122 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We describe correlator product states, a class of numerically efficient many-body wave functions to describe strongly correlated wave functions in any dimension. Correlator product states introduce direct correlations between physical degrees of freedom in a simple way, yet provide the flexibility to describe a wide variety of systems. We show that many interesting wave functions can be mapped exactly onto correlator product states, including Laughlin's quantum Hall wave function, Kitaev's toric code states, and Huse and Elser's frustrated spin states. We also outline the relationship between correlator product states and other common families of variational wave functions such as matrix product states, tensor product states, and resonating valence-bond states. Variational calculations for the Heisenberg and spinless Hubbard models demonstrate the promise of correlator product states for describing both two-dimensional and fermion correlations. Even in one-dimensional systems, correlator product states are competitive with matrix product states for a fixed number of variational parameters.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.80.245116

Related papers

Unifying neural-network quantum states and correlator product states via tensor networks

Stephen R. L. Clark

Abstract Correlator product states (CPS) are a powerful and very broad class of states for quantum lattice systems whose (unnormalised) amplitudes in a fixed basis can be sampled exactly and efficiently. They work by gluing together states of overlapping clusters of sites on the lattice, called correlators. Recently Carleo and Troyer (2017 Science 355 602) introduced a new type sampleable ansatz called neural-network quantum states (NQS) that are inspired by the restricted Boltzmann model used in machine learning. By employing the formalism of tensor networks we show that NQS are a special form of CPS with novel properties. Diagramatically a number of simple observations become transparent. Namely, that NQS are CPS built from extensively sized GHZ-form correlators making them uniquely unbiased geometrically. The appearance of GHZ correlators also relates NQS to canonical polyadic decompositions of tensors. Another immediate implication of the NQS equivalence to CPS is that we are able to formulate exact NQS representations for a wide range of paradigmatic states, including superpositions of weighed-graph states, the Laughlin state, toric code states, and the resonating valence bond state. These examples reveal the potential of using higher dimensional hidden units and a second hidden layer in NQS. The major outlook of this study is the elevation of NQS to correlator operators allowing them to enhance conventional well-established variational Monte Carlo approaches for strongly correlated fermions.

arXiv:1710.03545•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jan 29, 2018•79 citations

Nonstochastic algorithms for Jastrow-Slater and correlator product state wave functions

Eric Neuscamman, Hitesh J. Changlani, Jesse Kinder +1 more

Jastrow-Slater and correlator product state wave functions, two classes of quantum many-body wave functions, are commonly studied using Monte Carlo methods with the associated drawbacks of stochastic error. Here we show that efficient nonstochastic algorithms for these wave functions exist, both for observable evaluation and for optimization. The algorithms rely on the structure of these states as a product of local, commuting, invertible operators acting on a simple reference wave function. We describe the nonstochastic energy evaluation and optimization algorithms, and demonstrate them with applications to the Heisenberg and spinless and full Hubbard models. Our results demonstrate that the nonstochastic algorithms yield optimized wave functions and energies very close to those obtained with the variational Monte Carlo algorithm. Such algorithms provide new criteria for identifying new classes of wave functions for efficient computational simulation.

arXiv:1008.4945•Physical Review B•Nov 17, 2011•32 citations

Capturing long range correlations in two-dimensional quantum lattice systems using correlator product states

Sarah Al-Assam, Stephen R. L. Clark, Christopher J. Foot +1 more

We study the suitability of correlator product states for describing ground-state properties of two-dimensional spin models. Our ansatz for the many-body wave function takes the form of either plaquette or bond correlator product states, and the energy is optimized by varying the correlators using Monte Carlo minimization. For the Ising model, we find that plaquette correlators are best for estimating the energy, while bond correlators capture the expected long range correlations and critical behavior of the system more faithfully. For the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model, however, plaquettes outperform bond correlators at describing both local and long range correlations because of the substantially larger number of local parameters they contain. These observations have quantitative implications for the application of correlator product states to other more complex systems, and they give important heuristic insights, in particular, the necessity of carefully tailoring the choice of correlators to the system considered, and its interactions and symmetries.

arXiv:1107.0936•Physical Review B•Nov 10, 2011•21 citations

Disentangling Tensor Network States with Deep Neural Network

Chaohui Fan, Bo Zhan, Yuntian Gu +5 more

We introduce Neural Tensor Network States ($ν$TNS), a variational many-body wave-function ansatz that integrates deep neural networks with tensor-network architectures. In the $ν$TNS framework, a neural network serves as a disentangler of the wave-function, transforming the physical degrees of freedom into renormalized variables with much less entanglement. The renormalized state is then efficiently encoded by a back-flow tensor network. This construction yields a compact yet highly expressive representation of strongly correlated quantum states. Using convolutional neural networks combined with matrix product states as a concrete implementation, we obtain state-of-the-art variational energies for the spin-$1/2$ $J_1$-$J_2$ Heisenberg model on the square lattice at the highly frustrated point $J_2/J_1=0.5$, for systems up to $20\times 20$ with periodic boundary conditions. Finite-size scaling of spin, dimer, and plaquette correlations exhibits power-law decay without magnetic or valence-bond long-range order, consistent with a gapless quantum spin-liquid ground state at that point.This $ν$TNS framework is flexible and naturally extensible to other neural and tensor-network structures, offering a general platform for investigating strongly correlated quantum many-body systems.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2603.14425•Mar 17, 2026•7 citations

Correlated valence-bond states

Yu‐Cheng Lin, Ying Tang, Jie Lou +1 more

We study generalizations of the singlet-sector amplitude-product (AP) states in the valence-bond basis of $S=1/2$ quantum spin systems. In the standard AP states, the weight of a tiling of the system into valence bonds (singlets of two spins) is a product of amplitudes depending on the length of the bonds. We here introduce correlated AP (CAP) states, in which the AP is further multiplied by factors depending on two bonds connected to a pair of sites (here nearest neighbors). While the standard AP states can describe a phase transition between an antiferromagnetic (N\'eel) state and a valence-bond solid (VBS) in one dimension (which we also study here), in two dimensions it cannot describe VBS order. With the CAP states, N\'eel-VBS transitions are realized as a function of some parameter describing the bond correlations. We here study such phase transitions of CAP wave functions on the square lattice. We find examples of direct first-order N\'eel-VBS transitions, as well as cases where there is an extended U(1) spin liquid phase intervening between the N\'eel and VBS states. In the latter case the transitions are continuous and we extract critical exponents and address the issue of a possible emergent U(1) symmetry in the near-critical VBS. We also consider variationally optimized CAP states for the standard Heisenberg model in one and two dimensions and the $J$-$Q$ model in two dimensions, with the latter including four-spin interactions ($Q$) in addition to the Heisenberg exchange ($J$) and harboring VBS order for large $Q/J$. The optimized CAP states lead to significantly lower variational energies than the simple AP states for these models.

arXiv:1206.6803•Physical Review B•Oct 10, 2012•14 citations

Simulating quantum systems on classical computers with matrix product states

Adrian Kleine, Ulrich Schollwöck

In this thesis, the numerical simulation of strongly-interacting many-body quantum-mechanical systems using matrix product states (MPS) is considered. Compared to classical systems, quantum many-body systems possess an exponentially enlarged number of degrees of freedom, significantly complicating a simulation on a classical computer. Matrix-Product-States are a novel representation of arbitrary quantum many-body states. Using quantum information theory, it is possible to show that Matrix-Product-States provide a polynomial-sized representation of one-dimensional quantum systems, thus allowing an efficient simulation of one-dimensional quantum system on classical computers. Matrix-Product-States form the conceptual framework of the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG). Based upon this connection, deeper understanding of the density matrix renormalization group can be obtained. After a general introduction in the first chapter of this thesis, the second chapter deals with Matrix-Product-States, focusing on the development of fast and stable algorithms. It is possible to extend the Matrix-Product-States approach to be able to represent arbitrary operators, the so-called Matrix-Product-Operators, which allows a fast and flexible calculation of arbitrary expectation values. To obtain algorithms to efficiently calculate groundstates, the density-matrix renormalization group is reformulated using the Matrix-Product-States framework. Further, time-dependent problems are considered. Two different algorithms are presented, one based on a Trotter decomposition of the time-evolution operator, the other one on Krylov subspaces. Finally, the evaluation of dynamical spectral functions is discussed, and a correction vector-based method is presented. In the following chapters, the methods presented in the second chapter, are applied to a number of different physical problems. The third chapter deals with the existence of chiral phases in isotropic one-dimensional quantum spin systems. A preceding analytical study based on a mean-field approach indicated the possible existence of those phases in an isotopic Heisenberg model with a frustrating zig-zag interaction and a magnetic field. In this thesis, the existence of the chiral phases will be shown numerically by using Matrix-Product-States-based algorithms. A key effect of interacting one-dimensional quantum-mechanical many-body systems is the spin-charge separation. However, up to now only signs of the spin-charge separation have been observed in experiments. In the fourth chapter, we propose an experiment using ultracold atomic gases in optical lattices, which allows a well controlled observation of the spin-charge separation (of different hyperfine states of the ultracold atoms) with current state of the art experimental techniques. Ultracold atoms in optical lattices are well described by (Bose)-Hubbard models. In order to support this proposal, we present numerical results for realistic system parameters. Matrix-Product-States are an excellent tool for the simulation of one-dimensional quantum systems, however, they are not well suited for the simulation of higher dimensional systems. For strongly-correlated systems, for instance cuprates-based high-temperature superconductors, quantum fluctuations play an essential role. Classical mean-field theories neglect any kind of fluctuations, thus they are not suitable to describe strongly-correlated systems. The dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) fully takes local quantum fluctuations into account but neglects any kind of spatial fluctuations. The many-body problem on the lattice is mapped onto an impurity problem, which needs to be solved self-consistently. In the last chapter of this thesis, Matrix-Product-States-based algorithms are used to solve the impurity problem of the dynamical mean-field theory. We present results for a Hubbard model on a one-dimensional lattice and on a Bethe lattice obtained by the dynamical mean-field and compare them with exact results.

•Jan 1, 2010•1 citation
We describe correlator product states, a class of numerically efficient many-body wave functions to describe strongly correlated wave functions in any dimension. Correlator product states introduce direct correlations between physical degrees of freedom in a simple way, yet provide the flexibility to describe a wide variety of systems. We show that many interesting wave functions can be mapped exactly onto correlator product states, including Laughlin's quantum Hall wave function, Kitaev's toric code states, and Huse and Elser's frustrated spin states. We also outline the relationship between correlator product states and other common families of variational wave functions such as matrix product states, tensor product states, and resonating valence-bond states. Variational calculations for the Heisenberg and spinless Hubbard models demonstrate the promise of correlator product states for describing both two-dimensional and fermion correlations. Even in one-dimensional systems, correlator product states are competitive with matrix product states for a fixed number of variational parameters.
Abstract Correlator product states (CPS) are a powerful and very broad class of states for quantum lattice systems whose (unnormalised) amplitudes in a fixed basis can be sampled exactly and efficiently. They work by gluing together states of overlapping clusters of sites on the lattice, called correlators. Recently Carleo and Troyer (2017 Science 355 602) introduced a new type sampleable ansatz called neural-network quantum states (NQS) that are inspired by the restricted Boltzmann model used in machine learning. By employing the formalism of tensor networks we show that NQS are a special form of CPS with novel properties. Diagramatically a number of simple observations become transparent. Namely, that NQS are CPS built from extensively sized GHZ-form correlators making them uniquely unbiased geometrically. The appearance of GHZ correlators also relates NQS to canonical polyadic decompositions of tensors. Another immediate implication of the NQS equivalence to CPS is that we are able to formulate exact NQS representations for a wide range of paradigmatic states, including superpositions of weighed-graph states, the Laughlin state, toric code states, and the resonating valence bond state. These examples reveal the potential of using higher dimensional hidden units and a second hidden layer in NQS. The major outlook of this study is the elevation of NQS to correlator operators allowing them to enhance conventional well-established variational Monte Carlo approaches for strongly correlated fermions.
Jastrow-Slater and correlator product state wave functions, two classes of quantum many-body wave functions, are commonly studied using Monte Carlo methods with the associated drawbacks of stochastic error. Here we show that efficient nonstochastic algorithms for these wave functions exist, both for observable evaluation and for optimization. The algorithms rely on the structure of these states as a product of local, commuting, invertible operators acting on a simple reference wave function. We describe the nonstochastic energy evaluation and optimization algorithms, and demonstrate them with applications to the Heisenberg and spinless and full Hubbard models. Our results demonstrate that the nonstochastic algorithms yield optimized wave functions and energies very close to those obtained with the variational Monte Carlo algorithm. Such algorithms provide new criteria for identifying new classes of wave functions for efficient computational simulation.
We study the suitability of correlator product states for describing ground-state properties of two-dimensional spin models. Our ansatz for the many-body wave function takes the form of either plaquette or bond correlator product states, and the energy is optimized by varying the correlators using Monte Carlo minimization. For the Ising model, we find that plaquette correlators are best for estimating the energy, while bond correlators capture the expected long range correlations and critical behavior of the system more faithfully. For the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model, however, plaquettes outperform bond correlators at describing both local and long range correlations because of the substantially larger number of local parameters they contain. These observations have quantitative implications for the application of correlator product states to other more complex systems, and they give important heuristic insights, in particular, the necessity of carefully tailoring the choice of correlators to the system considered, and its interactions and symmetries.
We introduce Neural Tensor Network States (νννTNS), a variational many-body wave-function ansatz that integrates deep neural networks with tensor-network architectures. In the νννTNS framework, a neural network serves as a disentangler of the wave-function, transforming the physical degrees of freedom into renormalized variables with much less entanglement. The renormalized state is then efficiently encoded by a back-flow tensor network. This construction yields a compact yet highly expressive representation of strongly correlated quantum states. Using convolutional neural networks combined with matrix product states as a concrete implementation, we obtain state-of-the-art variational energies for the spin-1/21/21/2 J1J_1J1​-J2J_2J2​ Heisenberg model on the square lattice at the highly frustrated point J2/J1=0.5J_2/J_1=0.5J2​/J1​=0.5, for systems up to 20×2020\times 2020×20 with periodic boundary conditions. Finite-size scaling of spin, dimer, and plaquette correlations exhibits power-law decay without magnetic or valence-bond long-range order, consistent with a gapless quantum spin-liquid ground state at that point.This νννTNS framework is flexible and naturally extensible to other neural and tensor-network structures, offering a general platform for investigating strongly correlated quantum many-body systems.
We study generalizations of the singlet-sector amplitude-product (AP) states in the valence-bond basis of S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 quantum spin systems. In the standard AP states, the weight of a tiling of the system into valence bonds (singlets of two spins) is a product of amplitudes depending on the length of the bonds. We here introduce correlated AP (CAP) states, in which the AP is further multiplied by factors depending on two bonds connected to a pair of sites (here nearest neighbors). While the standard AP states can describe a phase transition between an antiferromagnetic (N\'eel) state and a valence-bond solid (VBS) in one dimension (which we also study here), in two dimensions it cannot describe VBS order. With the CAP states, N\'eel-VBS transitions are realized as a function of some parameter describing the bond correlations. We here study such phase transitions of CAP wave functions on the square lattice. We find examples of direct first-order N\'eel-VBS transitions, as well as cases where there is an extended U(1) spin liquid phase intervening between the N\'eel and VBS states. In the latter case the transitions are continuous and we extract critical exponents and address the issue of a possible emergent U(1) symmetry in the near-critical VBS. We also consider variationally optimized CAP states for the standard Heisenberg model in one and two dimensions and the JJJ-QQQ model in two dimensions, with the latter including four-spin interactions (QQQ) in addition to the Heisenberg exchange (JJJ) and harboring VBS order for large Q/JQ/JQ/J. The optimized CAP states lead to significantly lower variational energies than the simple AP states for these models.
In this thesis, the numerical simulation of strongly-interacting many-body quantum-mechanical systems using matrix product states (MPS) is considered. Compared to classical systems, quantum many-body systems possess an exponentially enlarged number of degrees of freedom, significantly complicating a simulation on a classical computer. Matrix-Product-States are a novel representation of arbitrary quantum many-body states. Using quantum information theory, it is possible to show that Matrix-Product-States provide a polynomial-sized representation of one-dimensional quantum systems, thus allowing an efficient simulation of one-dimensional quantum system on classical computers. Matrix-Product-States form the conceptual framework of the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG). Based upon this connection, deeper understanding of the density matrix renormalization group can be obtained. After a general introduction in the first chapter of this thesis, the second chapter deals with Matrix-Product-States, focusing on the development of fast and stable algorithms. It is possible to extend the Matrix-Product-States approach to be able to represent arbitrary operators, the so-called Matrix-Product-Operators, which allows a fast and flexible calculation of arbitrary expectation values. To obtain algorithms to efficiently calculate groundstates, the density-matrix renormalization group is reformulated using the Matrix-Product-States framework. Further, time-dependent problems are considered. Two different algorithms are presented, one based on a Trotter decomposition of the time-evolution operator, the other one on Krylov subspaces. Finally, the evaluation of dynamical spectral functions is discussed, and a correction vector-based method is presented. In the following chapters, the methods presented in the second chapter, are applied to a number of different physical problems. The third chapter deals with the existence of chiral phases in isotropic one-dimensional quantum spin systems. A preceding analytical study based on a mean-field approach indicated the possible existence of those phases in an isotopic Heisenberg model with a frustrating zig-zag interaction and a magnetic field. In this thesis, the existence of the chiral phases will be shown numerically by using Matrix-Product-States-based algorithms. A key effect of interacting one-dimensional quantum-mechanical many-body systems is the spin-charge separation. However, up to now only signs of the spin-charge separation have been observed in experiments. In the fourth chapter, we propose an experiment using ultracold atomic gases in optical lattices, which allows a well controlled observation of the spin-charge separation (of different hyperfine states of the ultracold atoms) with current state of the art experimental techniques. Ultracold atoms in optical lattices are well described by (Bose)-Hubbard models. In order to support this proposal, we present numerical results for realistic system parameters. Matrix-Product-States are an excellent tool for the simulation of one-dimensional quantum systems, however, they are not well suited for the simulation of higher dimensional systems. For strongly-correlated systems, for instance cuprates-based high-temperature superconductors, quantum fluctuations play an essential role. Classical mean-field theories neglect any kind of fluctuations, thus they are not suitable to describe strongly-correlated systems. The dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) fully takes local quantum fluctuations into account but neglects any kind of spatial fluctuations. The many-body problem on the lattice is mapped onto an impurity problem, which needs to be solved self-consistently. In the last chapter of this thesis, Matrix-Product-States-based algorithms are used to solve the impurity problem of the dynamical mean-field theory. We present results for a Hubbard model on a one-dimensional lattice and on a Bethe lattice obtained by the dynamical mean-field and compare them with exact results.