Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0907.0977

Locality and the classical limit of quantum systems

Tom Banks

Published Jul 6, 2009• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

I argue that conventional estimates of the criterion for classical behavior of a macroscopic body are incorrect in most circumstances,because they do not take into account the locality of interactions, which characterizes the behavior of all systems described approximately by local quantum field theory. The deviations from classical behavior of a macroscopic body, except for those that can be described as classical uncertainties in the initial values of macroscopic variables,are {\it exponentially} small as a function of the volume of the macro-system in microscopic units. Conventional estimates are correct only when the internal degrees of freedom of the macrosystem are in their ground state, and the classical motion of collective coordinates is adiabatic. Otherwise, the system acts as its own environment and washes out quantum phase correlations between different classical states of its collective coordinates. I suggest that it is likely that we can only achieve meso-scopic superpositions, for systems which have topological variables, and for which we can couple to those variables without exciting phonons.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0907.0977

Related papers

Locality and the classical limit of quantum mechanics

Tom Banks

I argue that conventional estimates of the criterion for classical behavior of a macroscopic body are incorrect, because they do not take into account the locality of interactions, which characterizes the behavior of all systems described approximately by local quantum field theory. Black holes are the only localized objects which do not have such a description. The deviations from classical behavior of a macroscopic body, except for those which can be described as classical uncertainties in the initial values of macroscopic variables,are {\it exponentially} small as a function of the volume of the macro-system in microscopic units.

arXiv:0809.3764•Sep 22, 2008•1 citation

From quantum to classical by numbers

D. Sokolovski, S. Brouard, Daniel Alonso

We follow Kofler and Brukner (2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 180403) in studying the conditions under which a classical picture emerges from the results of not too accurate quantum measurements made on large macroscopic objects. We show that for such objects, consisting of a large number of microscopic elements obeying quantum laws, the Central Limit theorem guarantees the existence of classical values for collective variables, even if the corresponding operators do not commute. Owing to localisation of the overall wave function in any chosen representation, these values can be measured to a small relative error without significantly altering the state of the object. We study a simple model, which includes a rudimentary observer capable of detecting in the coordinate space the position of a macroscopic pointer. The pointer can be employed to measure such quantities, not directly accessible to the observer, as linear or angular momenta. A purely classical picture arises provided the measurements are made on macroscopic objects. Results of measurements, made on small quantum objects, cannot be predicted with certainty, but acquire certain objectivity when encoded in macroscopic pointers’ positions accessible to all observers. Our estimates show that the classical conditions could, in principle, be realised for systems with number of constituent parts of the order of the Avogadro constant. It is possible that the approach captures the essential features of the quantum-to-classical behaviour, although its extension to more realistic systems is likely to be required.

New Journal of Physics•Nov 20, 2019•2 citations

Disentanglement of quantum wave functions: Answer to ‘‘Comment on ‘Unified dynamics for microscopic and macroscopic systems’ ’’

G. C. Ghirardi, A. Rimini, T. Weber

It is shown that the assumption of a stochastic localization process for the quantum wave function is essentially different from the suppression of coherence over macroscopic distances arising from the interaction with the environment and allows for a conceptually complete derivation of the classical behavior of macroscopic bodies.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 15, 1987•98 citations

Connecting the quantum and classical worlds

Barbara Drossel

By considering (non‐relativistic) quantum mechanics as it is done in practice in particular in condensed‐matter physics, it is argued that a deterministic, unitary time evolution within a chosen Hilbert space always has a limited scope, leaving a lot of room for embedding the quantum‐classical transition into our current theories without recurring to difficult‐to‐accept interpretations of quantum mechanics. Nonunitary projections to initial and final states, the breaking of time‐reversal symmetry, a change of Hilbert space, and the introduction of classical concepts such as external potentials or localized atomic nuclei are widespread in quantum mechanical calculations. Furthermore, quantum systems require classical environments that enable the symmetry breaking that is necessary for creating the atomic configurations of molecules and crystals. This paper argues that such classical environments are provided by finite‐temperature macroscopic systems in which the range of quantum correlations and entanglement is limited. This leads to classical behavior on larger scales, and to collapse‐like events in all dynamical processes that become coupled to the thermalized degrees of freedom. image

arXiv:1609.04427•Annalen der Physik•Dec 21, 2016•4 citations

Born's rule yields classical states and classical mechanics

Timothy J. Hollowood

It is shown that Schrodinger's equation and Born's rule are sufficient to ensure that the states of macroscopic collective coordinate subsystems are microscopically localized in phase space and that the localized state follows the classical trajectory with random quantum noise that is indistinguishable from the pseudo-random noise of classical Brownian motion. This happens because in realistic systems the localization rate determined by the coupling to the environment is greater than the Lyapunov exponent that governs chaotic spreading in phase space. For realistic systems, the trajectories of the collective coordinate subsystem are at the same time an "unravelling" and a set of "consistent/decoherent histories". Different subsystems have their own stochastic dynamics that generally knit together to form a global dynamics, although in certain contrived thought experiments, most notably Wigner's friend, in the contrary, there is observer complementarity.

arXiv:1906.06072•Jun 14, 2019•1 citation

Emergent classicality and wavefunction branching in an isolated quantum many-body system

Saúl Pilatowsky-Cameo, Jordan Cotler, Daniel Ranard +1 more

Decoherence in quantum systems is conventionally modeled as the effect of interactions with an external environment. However, such a prescription excludes isolated many-body systems, which are also expected to display classical behavior at macroscopic scales. In isolated systems, decoherence must emerge internally from microscopic degrees of freedom that are invisible to the macroscopic description. Here we explicitly show that classicality can emerge in such a fashion. We consider a weakly disordered, $3$-local chaotic kicked top of $N$ qubits, where the collective spin sector serves as the macroscopic description, while the microscopic permutation sector acts as an internal bath, decohering the collective spin sector. Starting from closed unitary dynamics, we derive and numerically confirm an effective Lindblad equation for the collective spin variables. In the thermodynamic limit these reduced dynamics converge to a classical chaotic Fokker--Planck equation with vanishingly small diffusion on the spherical phase space, producing a quantum-classical correspondence beyond the Ehrenfest time. The chaotic dynamics evolve the pure many-body wavefunction into continuously branching components associated with distinct classical trajectories. These branches acquire nearly orthogonal microscopic records in the permutation sector, preventing quantum interferences and ensuring the corresponding histories remain consistent.

quant-pharXiv:2609.19254•Sep 18, 2026•0 citations
I argue that conventional estimates of the criterion for classical behavior of a macroscopic body are incorrect in most circumstances,because they do not take into account the locality of interactions, which characterizes the behavior of all systems described approximately by local quantum field theory. The deviations from classical behavior of a macroscopic body, except for those that can be described as classical uncertainties in the initial values of macroscopic variables,are {\it exponentially} small as a function of the volume of the macro-system in microscopic units. Conventional estimates are correct only when the internal degrees of freedom of the macrosystem are in their ground state, and the classical motion of collective coordinates is adiabatic. Otherwise, the system acts as its own environment and washes out quantum phase correlations between different classical states of its collective coordinates. I suggest that it is likely that we can only achieve meso-scopic superpositions, for systems which have topological variables, and for which we can couple to those variables without exciting phonons.
I argue that conventional estimates of the criterion for classical behavior of a macroscopic body are incorrect, because they do not take into account the locality of interactions, which characterizes the behavior of all systems described approximately by local quantum field theory. Black holes are the only localized objects which do not have such a description. The deviations from classical behavior of a macroscopic body, except for those which can be described as classical uncertainties in the initial values of macroscopic variables,are {\it exponentially} small as a function of the volume of the macro-system in microscopic units.
We follow Kofler and Brukner (2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 180403) in studying the conditions under which a classical picture emerges from the results of not too accurate quantum measurements made on large macroscopic objects. We show that for such objects, consisting of a large number of microscopic elements obeying quantum laws, the Central Limit theorem guarantees the existence of classical values for collective variables, even if the corresponding operators do not commute. Owing to localisation of the overall wave function in any chosen representation, these values can be measured to a small relative error without significantly altering the state of the object. We study a simple model, which includes a rudimentary observer capable of detecting in the coordinate space the position of a macroscopic pointer. The pointer can be employed to measure such quantities, not directly accessible to the observer, as linear or angular momenta. A purely classical picture arises provided the measurements are made on macroscopic objects. Results of measurements, made on small quantum objects, cannot be predicted with certainty, but acquire certain objectivity when encoded in macroscopic pointers’ positions accessible to all observers. Our estimates show that the classical conditions could, in principle, be realised for systems with number of constituent parts of the order of the Avogadro constant. It is possible that the approach captures the essential features of the quantum-to-classical behaviour, although its extension to more realistic systems is likely to be required.
By considering (non‐relativistic) quantum mechanics as it is done in practice in particular in condensed‐matter physics, it is argued that a deterministic, unitary time evolution within a chosen Hilbert space always has a limited scope, leaving a lot of room for embedding the quantum‐classical transition into our current theories without recurring to difficult‐to‐accept interpretations of quantum mechanics. Nonunitary projections to initial and final states, the breaking of time‐reversal symmetry, a change of Hilbert space, and the introduction of classical concepts such as external potentials or localized atomic nuclei are widespread in quantum mechanical calculations. Furthermore, quantum systems require classical environments that enable the symmetry breaking that is necessary for creating the atomic configurations of molecules and crystals. This paper argues that such classical environments are provided by finite‐temperature macroscopic systems in which the range of quantum correlations and entanglement is limited. This leads to classical behavior on larger scales, and to collapse‐like events in all dynamical processes that become coupled to the thermalized degrees of freedom. image
It is shown that Schrodinger's equation and Born's rule are sufficient to ensure that the states of macroscopic collective coordinate subsystems are microscopically localized in phase space and that the localized state follows the classical trajectory with random quantum noise that is indistinguishable from the pseudo-random noise of classical Brownian motion. This happens because in realistic systems the localization rate determined by the coupling to the environment is greater than the Lyapunov exponent that governs chaotic spreading in phase space. For realistic systems, the trajectories of the collective coordinate subsystem are at the same time an "unravelling" and a set of "consistent/decoherent histories". Different subsystems have their own stochastic dynamics that generally knit together to form a global dynamics, although in certain contrived thought experiments, most notably Wigner's friend, in the contrary, there is observer complementarity.
Decoherence in quantum systems is conventionally modeled as the effect of interactions with an external environment. However, such a prescription excludes isolated many-body systems, which are also expected to display classical behavior at macroscopic scales. In isolated systems, decoherence must emerge internally from microscopic degrees of freedom that are invisible to the macroscopic description. Here we explicitly show that classicality can emerge in such a fashion. We consider a weakly disordered, 333-local chaotic kicked top of NNN qubits, where the collective spin sector serves as the macroscopic description, while the microscopic permutation sector acts as an internal bath, decohering the collective spin sector. Starting from closed unitary dynamics, we derive and numerically confirm an effective Lindblad equation for the collective spin variables. In the thermodynamic limit these reduced dynamics converge to a classical chaotic Fokker--Planck equation with vanishingly small diffusion on the spherical phase space, producing a quantum-classical correspondence beyond the Ehrenfest time. The chaotic dynamics evolve the pure many-body wavefunction into continuously branching components associated with distinct classical trajectories. These branches acquire nearly orthogonal microscopic records in the permutation sector, preventing quantum interferences and ensuring the corresponding histories remain consistent.