Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.0398

High-fidelity quantum control using ion crystals in a Penning trap

Michael J. Biercuk, Hermann Uys, Aaron P. VanDevender, Nobuyasu Shiga, Wayne M. Itano, J. J. Bollinger

Published Jun 2, 2009• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss the use of two-dimensional $^{9}$Be$^{+}$ ion crystals for experimental tests of quantum control techniques. Our primary qubit is the 124 GHz ground-state electron spin flip transition, which we drive using microwaves. An ion crystal represents a spatial ensemble of qubits, but the effects of inhomogeneities across a typical crystal are small, and as such we treat the ensemble as a single effective spin. We are able to initialize the qubits in a simple state and perform a projective measurement on the system. We demonstrate full control of the qubit Bloch vector, performing arbitrary high-fidelity rotations ($τ_π\sim$200 $μ$s). Randomized Benchmarking demonstrates an error per gate (a Pauli-randomized $π/2$ and $π$ pulse pair) of $8\pm1\times10^{-4}$. Ramsey interferometry and spin-locking measurements are used to elucidate the limits of qubit coherence in the system, yielding a typical free-induction decay coherence time of $T_{2}\sim$2 ms, and a limiting $T_{1ρ}\sim$688 ms. These experimental specifications make ion crystals in a Penning trap ideal candidates for novel experiments in quantum control. As such, we briefly describe recent efforts aimed at studying the error-suppressing capabilities of dynamical decoupling pulse sequences, demonstrating an ability to extend qubit coherence and suppress phase errors. We conclude with a discussion of future avenues for experimental exploration, including the use of additional nuclear-spin-flip transitions for effective multiqubit protocols, and the potential for Coulomb crystals to form a useful testbed for studies of large-scale entanglement.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0906.0398

Related papers

High-fidelity quantum control using ion crystals in a Penning trap

Michael J. Biercuk, Hermann Uys, Aaron P. VanDevender +3 more

We provide an introduction to the use of ion crystals in a Penning trap for experiments in quantum information. Macroscopic Penning traps allow for the containment of a few to a few million atomic ions whose internal states may be used in quantum information experiments. Ions are laser Doppler cooled, and the mutual Coulomb repulsion of the ions leads to the formation of crystalline arrays. The structure and dimensionality of the resulting ion crystals may be tuned using a combination of control laser beams and external potentials. We discuss the use of two-dimensional $^{9}$Be$^{+}$ ion crystals for experimental tests of quantum control techniques. Our primary qubit is the 124 GHz ground-state electron spin flip transition, which we drive using microwaves. An ion crystal represents a spatial ensemble of qubits, but the effects of inhomogeneities across a typical crystal are small, and as such we treat the ensemble as a single effective spin. We are able to initialize the qubits in a simple state and perform a projective measurement on the system. We demonstrate full control of the qubit Bloch vector, performing arbitrary high-fidelity rotations ($\tau_{\pi}\sim$200 $\mu$s). Randomized Benchmarking demonstrates an error per gate (a Pauli-randomized $\pi/2$ and $\pi$ pulse pair) of $8\pm1\times10^{-4}$. Ramsey interferometry and spin-locking measurements are used to elucidate the limits of qubit coherence in the system, yielding a typical free-induction decay coherence time of $T_{2}\sim$2 ms, and a limiting $T_{1\rho}\sim$688 ms. These experimental specifications make ion crystals in a Penning trap ideal candidates for novel experiments in quantum control. As such, we briefly describe recent efforts aimed at studying the error-suppressing capabilities of dynamical decoupling pulse sequences, demonstrating an ability to extend qubit coherence and suppress phase errors. We conclude with a discussion of future avenues for experimental exploration, including the use of additional nuclear-spin-flip transitions for effective multiqubit protocols, and the potential for Coulomb crystals to form a useful testbed for studies of large-scale entanglement.

Quantum Information and Computation•Nov 1, 2009•54 citations

Programmable coherent site-selective spin control in rotating Penning-trap ion crystals

Nihar Makadia, Julian Y. Z. Jee, Gustavo Café de Miranda +4 more

Large ion crystals in Penning traps provide a platform for quantum simulation and sensing with hundreds of spins, but their continuous rigid-body rotation has so far limited flexible local qubit control. Here we demonstrate programmable coherent site-selective spin control across large rotating ${}^{9}\mathrm{Be}^{+}$ crystals in a Penning trap. A tightly focused off-resonant laser beam drives local $R_z$ phase rotations via differential AC Stark shifts. Beam steering synchronised with crystal rotation enables addressing of arbitrary ions throughout the crystal. Ramsey-based characterisation shows $R_z(π)$ gate fidelity of 0.950(4) and nearest-neighbour crosstalk error of 0.021(6). We demonstrate preparing spatially structured spin patterns, generating a biskyrmion spin texture in a single-layer crystal, and then extend the method to bilayer crystals where we perform layer-selective addressing operations. We further demonstrate dual-quadrature Ramsey sensing by imprinting a relative $π/2$ phase shift between spatial sub-ensembles, enabling simultaneous measurement of orthogonal spin components within a single experimental realisation. These results establish programmable local control in large rotating ion crystals, opening new routes for engineering spatially structured quantum states in multidimensional trapped-ion systems.

quant-pharXiv:2606.00940•Jun 2, 2026•0 citations

Individual qubit addressing of rotating ion crystals in a Penning trap

Anthony Polloreno, Ana María Rey, J. J. Bollinger

Trapped ions boast long coherence times and excellent gate fidelities, making them a useful platform for quantum information processing. Scaling to larger numbers of ion qubits in RF Paul traps demands great effort. Another technique for trapping ions is via a Penning trap where a 2D crystal of hundreds of ions is formed by controlling the rotation of the ions in the presence of a strong magnetic field. However, the rotation of the ion crystal makes single ion addressability a significant challenge. We propose a protocol that takes advantage of a deformable mirror to introduce AC Stark shift patterns that are static in the rotating frame of the crystal. Through numerical simulations we validate the potential of this protocol to perform high-fidelity single-ion gates in crystalline arrays of hundreds of ions.

arXiv:2203.05196•Mar 10, 2022•0 citations

Experimental Uhrig dynamical decoupling using trapped ions

Michael J. Biercuk, Hermann Uys, Aaron P. VanDevender +3 more

We present a detailed experimental study of the Uhrig dynamical decoupling (UDD) sequence in a variety of noise environments. Our qubit system consists of a crystalline array of ${^{9}\text{B}\text{e}}^{+}$ ions confined in a Penning trap. We use an electron-spin-flip transition as our qubit manifold and drive qubit rotations using a 124 GHz microwave system. We study the effect of the UDD sequence in mitigating phase errors and compare against the well known Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill-style multipulse spin echo as a function of pulse number, rotation axis, noise spectrum, and noise strength. Our results agree well with theoretical predictions for qubit decoherence in the presence of classical phase noise, accounting for the effect of finite-duration $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses. Finally, we demonstrate that the Uhrig sequence is more robust against systematic over- or under-rotation and detuning errors than is multipulse spin echo, despite the precise prescription for pulse timing in UDD.

arXiv:0902.2957•Physical Review A•Jun 25, 2009•149 citations

Individual qubit addressing of rotating ion crystals in a Penning trap

Anthony Polloreno, Ana María Rey, J. J. Bollinger

Trapped ions boast long coherence times and excellent gate fidelities, making them a useful platform for quantum information processing. Penning traps offer the possibility of trapping large two-dimensional crystals of several hundred ions. The ions are confined by controlling the rotation of the ion crystal in the presence of a strong magnetic field. However, the rotation of the ion crystal makes single ion addressability a significant challenge. We propose a protocol that takes advantage of a deformable mirror to introduce AC Stark shift patterns that are static in the rotating frame of the crystal. Through numerical simulations we validate the potential of this protocol to perform high-fidelity single-ion gates in crystalline arrays of hundreds of ions.

Physical Review Research•Jul 25, 2022•11 citations

Sideband cooling to the quantum ground state in a penning trap

Joseph F. Goodwin

For 35 years, laser-cooled trapped ions have been at the frontier of progress in quantum computing, quantum simulation and precision measurement, and remain one of the most valuable tools in these fields to this day. Most of these experiments are predicated upon or benefit from the ability to place ions in the motional quantum ground state, a technique that was first demonstrated in radiofrequency ion traps 25 years ago. For a range of crucial experiments that are impossible to conduct in radiofrequency traps or are not well suited to this architecture, Penning traps provide an important alternative. However, the performance of Penning traps had been limited by the fact that ground-state cooling was yet to be achieved in such a system. This thesis reports the first demonstration of resolved-sideband cooling in a Penning trap, for 40Ca+ions cooled with light at 729-nm, achieving a ground state occupation of 99% in one dimension. Demonstrations of the coherent manipulations possible at this level of confinement are presented. The ion heating rate is measured and although higher than might be expected given the unusually large ion-electrode distance remains amongst the lowest reported in any trap to date. Achieving this result required the development of a number of new experimental systems and major upgrades to the stability and reliability of the experiment, the details of which are also given. The thesis also presents theoretical work into the use of two-dimensional Coulomb crystals in a Penning trap as a resource for quantum information. Using the symmetries of the crystal, we find that it is possible to engineer complex entangled states, specifically two small quantum error correcting codes, using a very small number of global entangling pulses. Efficient entanglement protocols such as these are vital for the implementation of useful quantum error correction.

•Nov 1, 2014•1 citation
We discuss the use of two-dimensional 9^{9}9Be+^{+}+ ion crystals for experimental tests of quantum control techniques. Our primary qubit is the 124 GHz ground-state electron spin flip transition, which we drive using microwaves. An ion crystal represents a spatial ensemble of qubits, but the effects of inhomogeneities across a typical crystal are small, and as such we treat the ensemble as a single effective spin. We are able to initialize the qubits in a simple state and perform a projective measurement on the system. We demonstrate full control of the qubit Bloch vector, performing arbitrary high-fidelity rotations (τπ∼τ_π\simτπ​∼200 μμμs). Randomized Benchmarking demonstrates an error per gate (a Pauli-randomized π/2π/2π/2 and πππ pulse pair) of 8±1×10−48\pm1\times10^{-4}8±1×10−4. Ramsey interferometry and spin-locking measurements are used to elucidate the limits of qubit coherence in the system, yielding a typical free-induction decay coherence time of T2∼T_{2}\simT2​∼2 ms, and a limiting T1ρ∼T_{1ρ}\simT1ρ​∼688 ms. These experimental specifications make ion crystals in a Penning trap ideal candidates for novel experiments in quantum control. As such, we briefly describe recent efforts aimed at studying the error-suppressing capabilities of dynamical decoupling pulse sequences, demonstrating an ability to extend qubit coherence and suppress phase errors. We conclude with a discussion of future avenues for experimental exploration, including the use of additional nuclear-spin-flip transitions for effective multiqubit protocols, and the potential for Coulomb crystals to form a useful testbed for studies of large-scale entanglement.
We provide an introduction to the use of ion crystals in a Penning trap for experiments in quantum information. Macroscopic Penning traps allow for the containment of a few to a few million atomic ions whose internal states may be used in quantum information experiments. Ions are laser Doppler cooled, and the mutual Coulomb repulsion of the ions leads to the formation of crystalline arrays. The structure and dimensionality of the resulting ion crystals may be tuned using a combination of control laser beams and external potentials. We discuss the use of two-dimensional 9^{9}9Be+^{+}+ ion crystals for experimental tests of quantum control techniques. Our primary qubit is the 124 GHz ground-state electron spin flip transition, which we drive using microwaves. An ion crystal represents a spatial ensemble of qubits, but the effects of inhomogeneities across a typical crystal are small, and as such we treat the ensemble as a single effective spin. We are able to initialize the qubits in a simple state and perform a projective measurement on the system. We demonstrate full control of the qubit Bloch vector, performing arbitrary high-fidelity rotations ($\tau_{\pi}\sim$200 μ\muμs). Randomized Benchmarking demonstrates an error per gate (a Pauli-randomized π/2\pi/2π/2 and π\piπ pulse pair) of 8±1×10−48\pm1\times10^{-4}8±1×10−4. Ramsey interferometry and spin-locking measurements are used to elucidate the limits of qubit coherence in the system, yielding a typical free-induction decay coherence time of $T_{2}\sim$2 ms, and a limiting $T_{1\rho}\sim$688 ms. These experimental specifications make ion crystals in a Penning trap ideal candidates for novel experiments in quantum control. As such, we briefly describe recent efforts aimed at studying the error-suppressing capabilities of dynamical decoupling pulse sequences, demonstrating an ability to extend qubit coherence and suppress phase errors. We conclude with a discussion of future avenues for experimental exploration, including the use of additional nuclear-spin-flip transitions for effective multiqubit protocols, and the potential for Coulomb crystals to form a useful testbed for studies of large-scale entanglement.
Large ion crystals in Penning traps provide a platform for quantum simulation and sensing with hundreds of spins, but their continuous rigid-body rotation has so far limited flexible local qubit control. Here we demonstrate programmable coherent site-selective spin control across large rotating 9Be+{}^{9}\mathrm{Be}^{+}9Be+ crystals in a Penning trap. A tightly focused off-resonant laser beam drives local RzR_zRz​ phase rotations via differential AC Stark shifts. Beam steering synchronised with crystal rotation enables addressing of arbitrary ions throughout the crystal. Ramsey-based characterisation shows Rz(π)R_z(π)Rz​(π) gate fidelity of 0.950(4) and nearest-neighbour crosstalk error of 0.021(6). We demonstrate preparing spatially structured spin patterns, generating a biskyrmion spin texture in a single-layer crystal, and then extend the method to bilayer crystals where we perform layer-selective addressing operations. We further demonstrate dual-quadrature Ramsey sensing by imprinting a relative π/2π/2π/2 phase shift between spatial sub-ensembles, enabling simultaneous measurement of orthogonal spin components within a single experimental realisation. These results establish programmable local control in large rotating ion crystals, opening new routes for engineering spatially structured quantum states in multidimensional trapped-ion systems.
Trapped ions boast long coherence times and excellent gate fidelities, making them a useful platform for quantum information processing. Scaling to larger numbers of ion qubits in RF Paul traps demands great effort. Another technique for trapping ions is via a Penning trap where a 2D crystal of hundreds of ions is formed by controlling the rotation of the ions in the presence of a strong magnetic field. However, the rotation of the ion crystal makes single ion addressability a significant challenge. We propose a protocol that takes advantage of a deformable mirror to introduce AC Stark shift patterns that are static in the rotating frame of the crystal. Through numerical simulations we validate the potential of this protocol to perform high-fidelity single-ion gates in crystalline arrays of hundreds of ions.
We present a detailed experimental study of the Uhrig dynamical decoupling (UDD) sequence in a variety of noise environments. Our qubit system consists of a crystalline array of 9Be+{^{9}\text{B}\text{e}}^{+}9Be+ ions confined in a Penning trap. We use an electron-spin-flip transition as our qubit manifold and drive qubit rotations using a 124 GHz microwave system. We study the effect of the UDD sequence in mitigating phase errors and compare against the well known Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill-style multipulse spin echo as a function of pulse number, rotation axis, noise spectrum, and noise strength. Our results agree well with theoretical predictions for qubit decoherence in the presence of classical phase noise, accounting for the effect of finite-duration $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses. Finally, we demonstrate that the Uhrig sequence is more robust against systematic over- or under-rotation and detuning errors than is multipulse spin echo, despite the precise prescription for pulse timing in UDD.
Trapped ions boast long coherence times and excellent gate fidelities, making them a useful platform for quantum information processing. Penning traps offer the possibility of trapping large two-dimensional crystals of several hundred ions. The ions are confined by controlling the rotation of the ion crystal in the presence of a strong magnetic field. However, the rotation of the ion crystal makes single ion addressability a significant challenge. We propose a protocol that takes advantage of a deformable mirror to introduce AC Stark shift patterns that are static in the rotating frame of the crystal. Through numerical simulations we validate the potential of this protocol to perform high-fidelity single-ion gates in crystalline arrays of hundreds of ions.
For 35 years, laser-cooled trapped ions have been at the frontier of progress in quantum computing, quantum simulation and precision measurement, and remain one of the most valuable tools in these fields to this day. Most of these experiments are predicated upon or benefit from the ability to place ions in the motional quantum ground state, a technique that was first demonstrated in radiofrequency ion traps 25 years ago. For a range of crucial experiments that are impossible to conduct in radiofrequency traps or are not well suited to this architecture, Penning traps provide an important alternative. However, the performance of Penning traps had been limited by the fact that ground-state cooling was yet to be achieved in such a system. This thesis reports the first demonstration of resolved-sideband cooling in a Penning trap, for 40Ca+ions cooled with light at 729-nm, achieving a ground state occupation of 99% in one dimension. Demonstrations of the coherent manipulations possible at this level of confinement are presented. The ion heating rate is measured and although higher than might be expected given the unusually large ion-electrode distance remains amongst the lowest reported in any trap to date. Achieving this result required the development of a number of new experimental systems and major upgrades to the stability and reliability of the experiment, the details of which are also given. The thesis also presents theoretical work into the use of two-dimensional Coulomb crystals in a Penning trap as a resource for quantum information. Using the symmetries of the crystal, we find that it is possible to engineer complex entangled states, specifically two small quantum error correcting codes, using a very small number of global entangling pulses. Efficient entanglement protocols such as these are vital for the implementation of useful quantum error correction.