Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0904.3556 · Physical Review Letters

Thresholds for Topological Codes in the Presence of Loss

Thomas M. Stace, S. D. Barrett, Andrew C. Doherty

Published May 18, 2009• 155 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many proposals for quantum information processing are subject to detectable loss errors. In this Letter, we show that topological error correcting codes, which protect against computational errors, are also extremely robust against losses. We present analytical results showing that the maximum tolerable loss rate is 50%, which is determined by the square-lattice bond percolation threshold. This saturates the bound set by the no-cloning theorem. Our numerical results support this and show a graceful trade-off between tolerable thresholds for computational and loss errors.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.102.200501

Related papers

Loss Tolerance in Topological Quantum Codes

Thomas M. Stace

Many proposals for fault tolerant quantum computation (FTQC) suffer detectable loss processes. This includes schemes based on optics, trapped atoms or ions and atomic ensembles [1]. Here we show that topological FTQC schemes, which are known to have high error thresholds, are also extremely robust against losses. We demonstrate that these schemes tolerate loss rates up to 24.9%, determined by bond percolation on a cubic lattice. Our numerical results show that these schemes retain good performance when loss and computational errors are simultaneously present.

International Conference on Quantum Information•Jan 1, 2011•3 citations

Fault Tolerant Quantum Computation with Very High Threshold for Loss Errors

S. D. Barrett, Thomas M. Stace

Many proposals for fault tolerant quantum computation (FTQC) suffer detectable loss processes. Here we show that topological FTQC schemes, which are known to have high error thresholds, are also extremely robust against losses. We demonstrate that these schemes tolerate loss rates up to 24.9%, determined by bond percolation on a cubic lattice. Our numerical results show that these schemes retain good performance when loss and computational errors are simultaneously present.

arXiv:1005.2456•Physical Review Letters•Nov 9, 2010•164 citations

Error correction and degeneracy in surface codes suffering loss

Thomas M. Stace, S. D. Barrett

Many proposals for quantum information processing are subject to detectable loss errors. In this paper, we give a detailed account of recent results in which we showed that topological quantum memories can simultaneously tolerate both loss errors and computational errors, with a graceful tradeoff between the threshold for each. We further discuss a number of subtleties that arise when implementing error correction on topological memories. We particularly focus on the role played by degeneracy in the matching algorithms and present a systematic study of its effects on thresholds. We also discuss some of the implications of degeneracy for estimating phase transition temperatures in the random bond Ising model.

arXiv:0912.1159•Physical Review A•Feb 18, 2010•89 citations

Analytical percolation theory for topological color codes under qubit loss

David Amaro, Jemma Bennett, Davide Vodola +1 more

Quantum information theory has shown strong connections with classical statistical physics. For example, quantum error correcting codes like the surface and the color code present a tolerance to qubit loss that is related to the classical percolation threshold of the lattices where the codes are defined. Here we explore such connection to study analytically the tolerance of the color code when the protocol introduced in Vodola et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 060501 (2018)] to correct qubit losses is applied. This protocol is based on the removal of the lost qubit from the code, a neighboring qubit, and the lattice edges where these two qubits reside. We first obtain analytically the average fraction of edges $r(p)$ that the protocol erases from the lattice to correct a fraction $p$ of qubit losses. Then, the threshold ${p}_{c}$ below which the logical information is protected corresponds to the value of $p$ at which $r(p)$ equals the bond-percolation threshold of the lattice. Moreover, we prove that the logical information is protected if and only if the set of lost qubits does not include the entire support of any logical operator. The results presented here open a route to an analytical understanding of the effects of qubit losses in topological quantum error codes.

arXiv:1907.12684•Physical Review A•Mar 13, 2020•8 citations

Twins Percolation for Qubit Losses in Topological Color Codes

Davide Vodola, David Amaro, Miguel Angel Martin-Delgado +1 more

In this Letter, we establish and explore a new connection between quantum information theory and classical statistical mechanics by studying the problem of qubit losses in 2D topological color codes. We introduce a protocol to cope with qubit losses, which is based on the identification and removal of a twin qubit from the code, and which guarantees the recovery of a valid three-colorable and trivalent reconstructed color code. Moreover, we show that determining the corresponding qubit loss error threshold is equivalent to a new generalized classical percolation problem. We numerically compute the associated qubit loss thresholds for two families of 2D color code and find that with p=0.461±0.005 these are close to satisfying the fundamental limit of 50% as imposed by the no-cloning theorem. Our findings reveal a new connection between topological color codes and percolation theory, show high robustness of color codes against qubit loss, and are directly relevant for implementations of topological quantum error correction in various physical platforms.

arXiv:1802.04545•Physical Review Letters•Aug 6, 2018•18 citations

Performance of topological codes for quantum error correction

Fern H. E. Watson

In this thesis we present three main contributions to the field of topological quantum error correcting codes. We focus on some of the properties of such codes required for fault-tolerant quantum computation. Prior work has concentrated on determining error rate thresholds of particular models, but increasingly other parameters are gaining prominence. One of these is the overhead -- the quantity of a named resource required to achieve a desired level of performance from the code. We characterise the qubit overhead of the toric code in a fault-tolerant setting. These results provide a general framework for determining the overhead for other code constructions with more complicated noise models. Next we introduce a decoding algorithm, applicable to topological codes in a qudit architecture, specifically those where fault-tolerance is achieved through repeated syndrome measurements. It is computationally light and capable of decoding qudits of arbitrarily high dimension with negligible increase in its run time. The threshold of the decoder is limited by the percolation of the syndromes. Using local matching techniques we are able to overcome this limitation, increasing the threshold by almost a factor of two for high qudit dimensions. Finally, we turn our attention to a second family of topological quantum codes: the colour codes. In three and higher spatial dimensions such codes can support transversal non-Clifford gates. We show, using a technique that we call a star-bipartition of the vertices of the lattice, that any existing qubit colour code lattice can be used to define a qudit colour code. By generalising the notion of triorthogonal matrices we derive analogous transversality properties in the qudit codes.

•Jul 1, 2015•2 citations
Many proposals for quantum information processing are subject to detectable loss errors. In this Letter, we show that topological error correcting codes, which protect against computational errors, are also extremely robust against losses. We present analytical results showing that the maximum tolerable loss rate is 50%, which is determined by the square-lattice bond percolation threshold. This saturates the bound set by the no-cloning theorem. Our numerical results support this and show a graceful trade-off between tolerable thresholds for computational and loss errors.
Many proposals for fault tolerant quantum computation (FTQC) suffer detectable loss processes. This includes schemes based on optics, trapped atoms or ions and atomic ensembles [1]. Here we show that topological FTQC schemes, which are known to have high error thresholds, are also extremely robust against losses. We demonstrate that these schemes tolerate loss rates up to 24.9%, determined by bond percolation on a cubic lattice. Our numerical results show that these schemes retain good performance when loss and computational errors are simultaneously present.
Many proposals for quantum information processing are subject to detectable loss errors. In this paper, we give a detailed account of recent results in which we showed that topological quantum memories can simultaneously tolerate both loss errors and computational errors, with a graceful tradeoff between the threshold for each. We further discuss a number of subtleties that arise when implementing error correction on topological memories. We particularly focus on the role played by degeneracy in the matching algorithms and present a systematic study of its effects on thresholds. We also discuss some of the implications of degeneracy for estimating phase transition temperatures in the random bond Ising model.
Quantum information theory has shown strong connections with classical statistical physics. For example, quantum error correcting codes like the surface and the color code present a tolerance to qubit loss that is related to the classical percolation threshold of the lattices where the codes are defined. Here we explore such connection to study analytically the tolerance of the color code when the protocol introduced in Vodola et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 060501 (2018)] to correct qubit losses is applied. This protocol is based on the removal of the lost qubit from the code, a neighboring qubit, and the lattice edges where these two qubits reside. We first obtain analytically the average fraction of edges r(p)r(p)r(p) that the protocol erases from the lattice to correct a fraction ppp of qubit losses. Then, the threshold pc{p}_{c}pc​ below which the logical information is protected corresponds to the value of ppp at which r(p)r(p)r(p) equals the bond-percolation threshold of the lattice. Moreover, we prove that the logical information is protected if and only if the set of lost qubits does not include the entire support of any logical operator. The results presented here open a route to an analytical understanding of the effects of qubit losses in topological quantum error codes.
In this Letter, we establish and explore a new connection between quantum information theory and classical statistical mechanics by studying the problem of qubit losses in 2D topological color codes. We introduce a protocol to cope with qubit losses, which is based on the identification and removal of a twin qubit from the code, and which guarantees the recovery of a valid three-colorable and trivalent reconstructed color code. Moreover, we show that determining the corresponding qubit loss error threshold is equivalent to a new generalized classical percolation problem. We numerically compute the associated qubit loss thresholds for two families of 2D color code and find that with p=0.461±0.005 these are close to satisfying the fundamental limit of 50% as imposed by the no-cloning theorem. Our findings reveal a new connection between topological color codes and percolation theory, show high robustness of color codes against qubit loss, and are directly relevant for implementations of topological quantum error correction in various physical platforms.
In this thesis we present three main contributions to the field of topological quantum error correcting codes. We focus on some of the properties of such codes required for fault-tolerant quantum computation. Prior work has concentrated on determining error rate thresholds of particular models, but increasingly other parameters are gaining prominence. One of these is the overhead -- the quantity of a named resource required to achieve a desired level of performance from the code. We characterise the qubit overhead of the toric code in a fault-tolerant setting. These results provide a general framework for determining the overhead for other code constructions with more complicated noise models. Next we introduce a decoding algorithm, applicable to topological codes in a qudit architecture, specifically those where fault-tolerance is achieved through repeated syndrome measurements. It is computationally light and capable of decoding qudits of arbitrarily high dimension with negligible increase in its run time. The threshold of the decoder is limited by the percolation of the syndromes. Using local matching techniques we are able to overcome this limitation, increasing the threshold by almost a factor of two for high qudit dimensions. Finally, we turn our attention to a second family of topological quantum codes: the colour codes. In three and higher spatial dimensions such codes can support transversal non-Clifford gates. We show, using a technique that we call a star-bipartition of the vertices of the lattice, that any existing qubit colour code lattice can be used to define a qudit colour code. By generalising the notion of triorthogonal matrices we derive analogous transversality properties in the qudit codes.