Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0904.0050 · Physical Review B

Rigorous upper bound on the critical temperature of dilute Bose gases

Robert Seiringer, Daniel Ueltschi

Published Jul 2, 2009• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We prove exponential decay of the off-diagonal correlation function in the two-dimensional homogeneous Bose gas when ${a}^{2}\ensuremath{\rho}$ is small and the temperature $T$ satisfies $T>\frac{4\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\rho}}{\text{ln}|\text{ln}({a}^{2}\ensuremath{\rho})|}$. Here, $a$ is the scattering length of the repulsive interaction potential and $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is the density. To the leading order in ${a}^{2}\ensuremath{\rho}$, this bound agrees with the expected critical temperature for superfluidity. In the three-dimensional Bose gas, exponential decay is proved when $\frac{T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{\text{c}}^{(0)}}{{T}_{\text{c}}^{(0)}}>5\sqrt{a{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{1/3}}$, where ${T}_{\text{c}}^{(0)}$ is the critical temperature of the ideal gas. While this condition is not expected to be sharp, it gives a rigorous upper bound on the critical temperature for Bose-Einstein condensation.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.80.014502

Related papers

The free energy of a dilute two-dimensional Bose gas

Simon Mayer

We study the interacting homogeneous Bose gas in two spatial dimensions in the thermodynamic limit at fixed density. We shall be concerned with some mathematical aspects of this complicated problem in many-body quantum mechanics. More specifically, we consider the dilute limit where the scattering length of the interaction potential, which is a measure for the effective range of the potential, is small compared to the average distance between the particles. We are interested in a setting with positive (i.e., non-zero) temperature. After giving a survey of the relevant literature in the field, we provide some facts and examples to set expectations for the two-dimensional system. The crucial difference to the three-dimensional system is that there is no Bose–Einstein condensate at positive temperature due to the Hohenberg–Mermin–Wagner theorem. However, it turns out that an asymptotic formula for the free energy holds similarly to the three-dimensional case. We motivate this formula by considering a toy model with δ interaction potential. By restricting this model Hamiltonian to certain trial states with a quasi-condensate we obtain an upper bound for the free energy that still has the quasi-condensate fraction as a free parameter. When minimizing over the quasi-condensate fraction, we obtain the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless critical temperature for superfluidity, which plays an important role in our rigorous contribution. The mathematically rigorous result that we prove concerns the specific free energy in the dilute limit. We give upper and lower bounds on the free energy in terms of the free energy of the non-interacting system and a correction term coming from the interaction. Both bounds match and thus we obtain the leading term of an asymptotic approximation in the dilute limit, provided the thermal wavelength of the particles is of the same order (or larger) than the average distance between the particles. The remarkable feature of this result is its generality: the correction term depends on the interaction potential only through its scattering length and it holds for all nonnegative interaction potentials with finite scattering length that are measurable. In particular, this allows to model an interaction of hard disks.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

The free energy of the two-dimensional dilute Bose gas. II. Upper bound

Simon Mayer, Robert Seiringer

We prove an upper bound on the free energy of a two-dimensional homogeneous Bose gas in the thermodynamic limit. We show that for a2ρ ≪ 1 and βρ ≳ 1, the free energy per unit volume differs from the one of the non-interacting system by at most 4πρ2|lna2ρ|−1(2−[1−βc/β]+2) to leading order, where a is the scattering length of the two-body interaction potential, ρ is the density, β is the inverse temperature, and βc is the inverse Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless critical temperature for superfluidity. In combination with the corresponding matching lower bound proved by Deuchert et al. [Forum Math. Sigma 8, e20 (2020)], this shows equality in the asymptotic expansion.

arXiv:2002.08281•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 2020•11 citations

Critical temperature of dilute Bose gases

Volker Betz, Daniel Ueltschi

We compute the critical temperature of Bose-Einstein condensation in dilute three-dimensional homogeneous Bose gases. Our method involves the models of spatial permutations and should be exact to lowest order in the scattering length of the particle interactions. We find that the change in the critical temperature, $\ensuremath{\Delta}{T}_{\mathrm{c}}/{T}_{\mathrm{c}}^{(0)}$, behaves as $ca{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{1/3}$ with $c=\ensuremath{-}2.33$. This contradicts the current consensus among physicists.

arXiv:0910.3558•Physical Review A•Feb 17, 2010•23 citations

Higher-order evaluation of the critical temperature for interacting homogeneous dilute Bose gases

F. Cruz, Marcus Benghi Pinto, Rudnei O. Ramos +1 more

We use the nonperturbative linear $\ensuremath{\delta}$ expansion method to evaluate analytically the coefficients ${c}_{1}$ and ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}$ that appear in the expansion for the transition temperature for a dilute, homogeneous, three-dimensional Bose gas given by ${T}_{c}{=T}_{0}({1+c}_{1}{\mathrm{an}}^{1/3}+[{c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}\mathrm{ln}{(an}^{1/3}{)+c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}]{a}^{2}{n}^{2/3}{+O(a}^{3}n)),$ where ${T}_{0}$ is the result for an ideal gas, a is the s-wave scattering length, and n is the number density. In a previous work the same method has been used to evaluate ${c}_{1}$ to order ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{2}$ with the result ${c}_{1}=3.06.$ Here, we push the calculation to the next two orders obtaining ${c}_{1}=2.45$ at order ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{3}$ and ${c}_{1}=1.48$ at order ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{4}.$ Analyzing the topology of the graphs involved we discuss how our results relate to other nonperturbative analytical methods such as the self-consistent resummation and the $1/N$ approximations. At the same orders we obtain ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=101.4,$ ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=98.2,$ and ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=82.9.$ Our analytical results seem to support the recent Monte Carlo estimates ${c}_{1}=1.32\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.02$ and ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=75.7\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.4.$

arXiv:cond-mat/0112306•Physical Review A•May 9, 2002•52 citations

1/ N -expansion for the critical temperature of the Bose gas

Orest Hryhorchak, V. Pastukhov

We revised the large- N expansion for a three-dimensional Bose system with short-range repulsion in normal phase. Particularly, for the model potential that is characterised only by the s -wave scattering length a the full numerical calculations of the critical temperature in the 1 / N -approximation as a function of the gas parameter a n 1 / 3 are performed. Additionally to the well-known result in the dilute limit we estimated analytically the leading-order strong-coupling behavior of the Bose-Einstein condensation transition temperature. It is shown that the critical temperature shift of the non-ideal Bose gas grows at small a n 1 / 3 , reaches some maximal value and then falls down becoming negative.

arXiv:1704.08968•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 1, 2017•4 citations

Upper bound for the free energy of dilute Bose gases at low temperature

Florian Haberberger, Christian Hainzl, Benjamin Schlein +1 more

We consider a Bose gas at density ρ > 0 , interacting through a repulsive potential V ∈ L 2 ( R 3 ) with scattering length a > 0 . We prove an upper bound for the free energy of the system, valid at low temperature T ≲ ρ a . Combined with the recent lower bound obtained in [18] , our estimate resolves the free energy per unit volume up to and including the Lee–Huang–Yang order a ρ 2 ( ρ a 3 ) 1 / 2 .

arXiv:2405.03378•Advances in Mathematics•Feb 3, 2026•20 citations
We prove exponential decay of the off-diagonal correlation function in the two-dimensional homogeneous Bose gas when a2\ensuremathρ{a}^{2}\ensuremath{\rho}a2\ensuremathρ is small and the temperature TTT satisfies T>4\ensuremathπ\ensuremathρln∣ln(a2\ensuremathρ)∣T>\frac{4\ensuremath{\pi}\ensuremath{\rho}}{\text{ln}|\text{ln}({a}^{2}\ensuremath{\rho})|}T>ln∣ln(a2\ensuremathρ)∣4\ensuremathπ\ensuremathρ​. Here, aaa is the scattering length of the repulsive interaction potential and \ensuremathρ\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremathρ is the density. To the leading order in a2\ensuremathρ{a}^{2}\ensuremath{\rho}a2\ensuremathρ, this bound agrees with the expected critical temperature for superfluidity. In the three-dimensional Bose gas, exponential decay is proved when T\ensuremath−Tc(0)Tc(0)>5a\ensuremathρ1/3\frac{T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{\text{c}}^{(0)}}{{T}_{\text{c}}^{(0)}}>5\sqrt{a{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{1/3}}Tc(0)​T\ensuremath−Tc(0)​​>5a\ensuremathρ1/3​, where Tc(0){T}_{\text{c}}^{(0)}Tc(0)​ is the critical temperature of the ideal gas. While this condition is not expected to be sharp, it gives a rigorous upper bound on the critical temperature for Bose-Einstein condensation.
We study the interacting homogeneous Bose gas in two spatial dimensions in the thermodynamic limit at fixed density. We shall be concerned with some mathematical aspects of this complicated problem in many-body quantum mechanics. More specifically, we consider the dilute limit where the scattering length of the interaction potential, which is a measure for the effective range of the potential, is small compared to the average distance between the particles. We are interested in a setting with positive (i.e., non-zero) temperature. After giving a survey of the relevant literature in the field, we provide some facts and examples to set expectations for the two-dimensional system. The crucial difference to the three-dimensional system is that there is no Bose–Einstein condensate at positive temperature due to the Hohenberg–Mermin–Wagner theorem. However, it turns out that an asymptotic formula for the free energy holds similarly to the three-dimensional case. We motivate this formula by considering a toy model with δ interaction potential. By restricting this model Hamiltonian to certain trial states with a quasi-condensate we obtain an upper bound for the free energy that still has the quasi-condensate fraction as a free parameter. When minimizing over the quasi-condensate fraction, we obtain the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless critical temperature for superfluidity, which plays an important role in our rigorous contribution. The mathematically rigorous result that we prove concerns the specific free energy in the dilute limit. We give upper and lower bounds on the free energy in terms of the free energy of the non-interacting system and a correction term coming from the interaction. Both bounds match and thus we obtain the leading term of an asymptotic approximation in the dilute limit, provided the thermal wavelength of the particles is of the same order (or larger) than the average distance between the particles. The remarkable feature of this result is its generality: the correction term depends on the interaction potential only through its scattering length and it holds for all nonnegative interaction potentials with finite scattering length that are measurable. In particular, this allows to model an interaction of hard disks.
We prove an upper bound on the free energy of a two-dimensional homogeneous Bose gas in the thermodynamic limit. We show that for a2ρ ≪ 1 and βρ ≳ 1, the free energy per unit volume differs from the one of the non-interacting system by at most 4πρ2|lna2ρ|−1(2−[1−βc/β]+2) to leading order, where a is the scattering length of the two-body interaction potential, ρ is the density, β is the inverse temperature, and βc is the inverse Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless critical temperature for superfluidity. In combination with the corresponding matching lower bound proved by Deuchert et al. [Forum Math. Sigma 8, e20 (2020)], this shows equality in the asymptotic expansion.
We compute the critical temperature of Bose-Einstein condensation in dilute three-dimensional homogeneous Bose gases. Our method involves the models of spatial permutations and should be exact to lowest order in the scattering length of the particle interactions. We find that the change in the critical temperature, $\ensuremath{\Delta}{T}_{\mathrm{c}}/{T}_{\mathrm{c}}^{(0)}$, behaves as $ca{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{1/3}$ with $c=\ensuremath{-}2.33$. This contradicts the current consensus among physicists.
We use the nonperturbative linear $\ensuremath{\delta}$ expansion method to evaluate analytically the coefficients c1{c}_{1}c1​ and ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}$ that appear in the expansion for the transition temperature for a dilute, homogeneous, three-dimensional Bose gas given by ${T}_{c}{=T}_{0}({1+c}_{1}{\mathrm{an}}^{1/3}+[{c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{'}}\mathrm{ln}{(an}^{1/3}{)+c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}]{a}^{2}{n}^{2/3}{+O(a}^{3}n)),$ where T0{T}_{0}T0​ is the result for an ideal gas, a is the s-wave scattering length, and n is the number density. In a previous work the same method has been used to evaluate c1{c}_{1}c1​ to order ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{2}$ with the result c1=3.06.{c}_{1}=3.06.c1​=3.06. Here, we push the calculation to the next two orders obtaining c1=2.45{c}_{1}=2.45c1​=2.45 at order ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{3}$ and c1=1.48{c}_{1}=1.48c1​=1.48 at order ${\ensuremath{\delta}}^{4}.$ Analyzing the topology of the graphs involved we discuss how our results relate to other nonperturbative analytical methods such as the self-consistent resummation and the 1/N1/N1/N approximations. At the same orders we obtain ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=101.4,$ ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=98.2,$ and ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=82.9.$ Our analytical results seem to support the recent Monte Carlo estimates ${c}_{1}=1.32\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.02$ and ${c}_{2}^{\ensuremath{''}}=75.7\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.4.$
We revised the large- N expansion for a three-dimensional Bose system with short-range repulsion in normal phase. Particularly, for the model potential that is characterised only by the s -wave scattering length a the full numerical calculations of the critical temperature in the 1 / N -approximation as a function of the gas parameter a n 1 / 3 are performed. Additionally to the well-known result in the dilute limit we estimated analytically the leading-order strong-coupling behavior of the Bose-Einstein condensation transition temperature. It is shown that the critical temperature shift of the non-ideal Bose gas grows at small a n 1 / 3 , reaches some maximal value and then falls down becoming negative.