Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0902.4475 · Physical Review Letters

Minimally Entangled Typical Quantum States at Finite Temperature

Steven R. White

Published May 11, 2009• 266 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce a class of states, called minimally entangled typical thermal states, designed to resemble a typical state of a quantum system at finite temperature with a bias towards classical (minimally entangled) properties. These states reveal in an intuitive way properties such as short-range order which may often be hidden. A finite-T density matrix renormalization group algorithm is presented which is only modestly slower than the T=0 density matrix renormalization group.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.102.190601

Related papers

Symmetric minimally entangled typical thermal states for canonical and grand-canonical ensembles

Moritz Binder, Thomas Barthel

Based on the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), strongly correlated quantum many-body systems at finite temperatures can be simulated by sampling over a certain class of pure matrix product states (MPS) called minimally entangled typical thermal states (METTS). When a system features symmetries, these can be utilized to substantially reduce MPS computation costs. It is conceptually straightforward to simulate canonical ensembles using symmetric METTS. In practice, it is important to alternate between different symmetric collapse bases to decrease autocorrelations in the Markov chain of METTS. To this purpose, we introduce symmetric Fourier and Haar-random block bases that are efficiently mixing. We also show how grand-canonical ensembles can be simulated efficiently with symmetric METTS. We demonstrate these approaches for spin-$1/2$ $XXZ$ chains and discuss how the choice of the collapse bases influences autocorrelations as well as the distribution of measurement values and, hence, convergence speeds.

arXiv:1701.03872•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 22, 2017•26 citations

Finite-temperature entanglement for low-dimensional quantum spin chains

Zhao‐Yu Sun, K.L. Yao, Wei Yao +2 more

Based on transfer-matrix density matrix renormalization group (TMRG) method, a general procedure to calculate the finite-temperature pairwise entanglement of low-dimensional quantum chains is proposed. The reduced pairwise density matrix is reconstructed with TMRG, and measures of quantum entanglement can be calculated from the pairwise density matrix. The finite-temperature entanglement of the diamond chain model and the spin trimerized model, which are two typical models revealing $1∕3$ plateaus in the magnetization curves, is calculated. For the diamond chain model, the anisotropy coefficient $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is found to have a great effect on the appearance of the magnetization plateau, and the plateau disappears when $\ensuremath{\Delta}=0.5$. Moreover, our results show that the pairwise entanglement can provide information complementary to that obtained from bulk properties. For the trimerized model, the temperature dependence of the pairwise entanglement is calculated, and the threshold temperature ${T}_{c}$, above which the thermal entanglement vanishes, is found to be independent of the external magnetic field $B$. In addition, the scaling behavior of the thermal entanglement is calculated in the Trotter space. With the augmentation of the system in the Trotter direction, we find that the low-temperature entanglement shows obvious variation in the vicinity of quantum phase transition (QPT) point ${B}_{c}$ and converges fast in noncritical regions, which provides another way to identify QPT of one-dimensional quantum systems.

Physical Review B•Jan 14, 2008•18 citations

Minimally entangled typical thermal states versus matrix product purifications for the simulation of equilibrium states and time evolution

Moritz Binder, Thomas Barthel

For the simulation of equilibrium states and finite-temperature response functions of strongly correlated quantum many-body systems, we compare the efficiencies of two different approaches in the framework of the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG). The first is based on matrix product purifications. The second, more recent one, is based on so-called minimally entangled typical thermal states (METTS). For the latter, we highlight the interplay of statistical and DMRG truncation errors, discuss the use of self-averaging effects, and describe schemes for the computation of response functions. For critical as well as gapped phases of the $\text{spin}\ensuremath{-}1/2$ XXZ chain and the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model, we assess the computation costs and accuracies of the two methods at different temperatures. For almost all considered cases, we find that, for the same computation cost, purifications yield more accurate results than METTS---often by orders of magnitude. The METTS algorithm becomes more efficient only for temperatures well below the system's energy gap. The exponential growth of the computation cost in the evaluation of response functions limits the attainable time scales in both methods and we find that in this regard, METTS do not outperform purifications.

arXiv:1411.3033•Physical Review B•Sep 10, 2015•42 citations

Matrix product state techniques for two-dimensional systems at finite temperature

Benedikt Bruognolo, Zhenyue Zhu, Steven R. White +1 more

The density matrix renormalization group is one of the most powerful numerical methods for computing ground-state properties of two-dimensional (2D) quantum lattice systems. Here we show its finite-temperature extensions are also viable for 2D, using the following strategy: At high temperatures, we combine density-matrix purification and numerical linked-cluster expansions to extract static observables directly in the thermodynamic limit. At low temperatures inaccessible to purification, we use the minimally entangled typical thermal state (METTS) algorithm on cylinders. We consider the triangular Heisenberg antiferromagnet as a first application, finding excellent agreement with other state of the art methods. In addition, we present a METTS-based approach that successfully extracts critical temperatures, and apply it to a frustrated lattice model. On a technical level, we compare two different schemes for performing imaginary-time evolution of 2D clusters, finding that a Suzuki-Trotter decomposition with swap gates is currently the most accurate and efficient.

arXiv:1705.05578•May 16, 2017•52 citations

Production of minimally entangled typical thermal states with the Krylov-space approach

G. Alvarez

The minimally entangled typical thermal states algorithm is applied to fermionic systems using the Krylov-space approach to evolve the system in imaginary time. The convergence of local observables is studied in a tight-binding system with a site-dependent potential. The temperature dependence of the superconducting correlations of the attractive Hubbard model is analyzed on chains, showing an exponential decay with distance and exponents proportional to the temperature at low temperatures, as expected. In addition, the nonlocal parity correlator is calculated at finite temperature. Other possible applications of the minimally entangled typical thermal states algorithm to fermionic systems are also discussed.

arXiv:1307.8034•Physical Review B•Jun 27, 2013•11 citations

Symmetric minimally entangled typical thermal states

Benedikt Bruognolo, Jan von Delft, Andreas Weichselbaum

We extend White's minimally entangled typically thermal states approach (METTS) to allow Abelian and non-Ablian symmetries to be exploited when computing finite-temperature response functions in one-dimensional (1D) quantum systems. Our approach, called SYMETTS, starts from a METTS sample of states that are not symmetry eigenstates, and generates from each a symmetry eigenstate. These symmetry states are then used to calculate dynamic response functions. SYMETTS is ideally suited to determine the low-temperature spectra of 1D quantum systems with high resolution. We employ this method to study a generalized diamond chain model for the natural mineral azurite $\mathrm{Cu}{}_{3}(\mathrm{CO}{}_{3}{)}_{2}({\mathrm{OH})}_{2}$, which features a plateau at $\frac{1}{3}$ in the magnetization curve at low temperatures. Our calculations provide new insight into the effects of temperature on magnetization and excitation spectra in the plateau phase, which can be fully understood in terms of the microscopic model.

arXiv:1506.03336•Physical Review B•Sep 2, 2015•19 citations
We introduce a class of states, called minimally entangled typical thermal states, designed to resemble a typical state of a quantum system at finite temperature with a bias towards classical (minimally entangled) properties. These states reveal in an intuitive way properties such as short-range order which may often be hidden. A finite-T density matrix renormalization group algorithm is presented which is only modestly slower than the T=0 density matrix renormalization group.
Based on the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), strongly correlated quantum many-body systems at finite temperatures can be simulated by sampling over a certain class of pure matrix product states (MPS) called minimally entangled typical thermal states (METTS). When a system features symmetries, these can be utilized to substantially reduce MPS computation costs. It is conceptually straightforward to simulate canonical ensembles using symmetric METTS. In practice, it is important to alternate between different symmetric collapse bases to decrease autocorrelations in the Markov chain of METTS. To this purpose, we introduce symmetric Fourier and Haar-random block bases that are efficiently mixing. We also show how grand-canonical ensembles can be simulated efficiently with symmetric METTS. We demonstrate these approaches for spin-1/21/21/2 XXZXXZXXZ chains and discuss how the choice of the collapse bases influences autocorrelations as well as the distribution of measurement values and, hence, convergence speeds.
Based on transfer-matrix density matrix renormalization group (TMRG) method, a general procedure to calculate the finite-temperature pairwise entanglement of low-dimensional quantum chains is proposed. The reduced pairwise density matrix is reconstructed with TMRG, and measures of quantum entanglement can be calculated from the pairwise density matrix. The finite-temperature entanglement of the diamond chain model and the spin trimerized model, which are two typical models revealing 1∕31∕31∕3 plateaus in the magnetization curves, is calculated. For the diamond chain model, the anisotropy coefficient $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is found to have a great effect on the appearance of the magnetization plateau, and the plateau disappears when $\ensuremath{\Delta}=0.5$. Moreover, our results show that the pairwise entanglement can provide information complementary to that obtained from bulk properties. For the trimerized model, the temperature dependence of the pairwise entanglement is calculated, and the threshold temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, above which the thermal entanglement vanishes, is found to be independent of the external magnetic field BBB. In addition, the scaling behavior of the thermal entanglement is calculated in the Trotter space. With the augmentation of the system in the Trotter direction, we find that the low-temperature entanglement shows obvious variation in the vicinity of quantum phase transition (QPT) point Bc{B}_{c}Bc​ and converges fast in noncritical regions, which provides another way to identify QPT of one-dimensional quantum systems.
For the simulation of equilibrium states and finite-temperature response functions of strongly correlated quantum many-body systems, we compare the efficiencies of two different approaches in the framework of the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG). The first is based on matrix product purifications. The second, more recent one, is based on so-called minimally entangled typical thermal states (METTS). For the latter, we highlight the interplay of statistical and DMRG truncation errors, discuss the use of self-averaging effects, and describe schemes for the computation of response functions. For critical as well as gapped phases of the $\text{spin}\ensuremath{-}1/2$ XXZ chain and the one-dimensional Bose-Hubbard model, we assess the computation costs and accuracies of the two methods at different temperatures. For almost all considered cases, we find that, for the same computation cost, purifications yield more accurate results than METTS---often by orders of magnitude. The METTS algorithm becomes more efficient only for temperatures well below the system's energy gap. The exponential growth of the computation cost in the evaluation of response functions limits the attainable time scales in both methods and we find that in this regard, METTS do not outperform purifications.
The density matrix renormalization group is one of the most powerful numerical methods for computing ground-state properties of two-dimensional (2D) quantum lattice systems. Here we show its finite-temperature extensions are also viable for 2D, using the following strategy: At high temperatures, we combine density-matrix purification and numerical linked-cluster expansions to extract static observables directly in the thermodynamic limit. At low temperatures inaccessible to purification, we use the minimally entangled typical thermal state (METTS) algorithm on cylinders. We consider the triangular Heisenberg antiferromagnet as a first application, finding excellent agreement with other state of the art methods. In addition, we present a METTS-based approach that successfully extracts critical temperatures, and apply it to a frustrated lattice model. On a technical level, we compare two different schemes for performing imaginary-time evolution of 2D clusters, finding that a Suzuki-Trotter decomposition with swap gates is currently the most accurate and efficient.
The minimally entangled typical thermal states algorithm is applied to fermionic systems using the Krylov-space approach to evolve the system in imaginary time. The convergence of local observables is studied in a tight-binding system with a site-dependent potential. The temperature dependence of the superconducting correlations of the attractive Hubbard model is analyzed on chains, showing an exponential decay with distance and exponents proportional to the temperature at low temperatures, as expected. In addition, the nonlocal parity correlator is calculated at finite temperature. Other possible applications of the minimally entangled typical thermal states algorithm to fermionic systems are also discussed.
We extend White's minimally entangled typically thermal states approach (METTS) to allow Abelian and non-Ablian symmetries to be exploited when computing finite-temperature response functions in one-dimensional (1D) quantum systems. Our approach, called SYMETTS, starts from a METTS sample of states that are not symmetry eigenstates, and generates from each a symmetry eigenstate. These symmetry states are then used to calculate dynamic response functions. SYMETTS is ideally suited to determine the low-temperature spectra of 1D quantum systems with high resolution. We employ this method to study a generalized diamond chain model for the natural mineral azurite Cu3(CO3)2(OH)2\mathrm{Cu}{}_{3}(\mathrm{CO}{}_{3}{)}_{2}({\mathrm{OH})}_{2}Cu3​(CO3​)2​(OH)2​, which features a plateau at 13\frac{1}{3}31​ in the magnetization curve at low temperatures. Our calculations provide new insight into the effects of temperature on magnetization and excitation spectra in the plateau phase, which can be fully understood in terms of the microscopic model.