A new law of physics is proposed, defined on the cosmological scale but with significant implications for the microscale. Motivated by nonlinear dynamical systems theory and black-hole thermodynamics, the Invariant Set Postulate proposes that cosmological states of physical reality belong to a non-computable fractal state-space geometry I , invariant under the action of some subordinate deterministic causal dynamics D I . An exploratory analysis is made of a possible causal realistic framework for quantum physics based on key properties of I . For example, sparseness is used to relate generic counterfactual states to points p ∉ I of unreality, thus providing a geometric basis for the essential contextuality of quantum physics and the role of the abstract Hilbert Space in quantum theory. Also, self-similarity, described in a symbolic setting, provides a possible realistic perspective on the essential role of complex numbers and quaternions in quantum theory. A new interpretation is given to the standard ‘mysteries’ of quantum theory: superposition, measurement, non-locality, emergence of classicality and so on. It is proposed that heterogeneities in the fractal geometry of I are manifestations of the phenomenon of gravity. Since quantum theory is inherently blind to the existence of such state-space geometries, the analysis here suggests that attempts to formulate unified theories of physics within a conventional quantum-theoretic framework are misguided, and that a successful quantum theory of gravity should unify the causal non-Euclidean geometry of space–time with the atemporal fractal geometry of state space. The task is not to make sense of the quantum axioms by heaping more structure, more definitions, more science fiction imagery on top of them, but to throw them away wholesale and start afresh. We should be relentless in asking ourselves: From what deep physical principles might we derive this exquisite structure? These principles should be crisp, they should be compelling. They should stir the soul. Chris Fuchs ( Gilder 2008 , p. 335)
A new law of physics is proposed, defined on the cosmological scale but with significant implications for the microscale. Motivated by nonlinear dynamical systems theory and black-hole thermodynamics, the Invariant Set Postulate proposes that cosmological states of physical reality belong to a non-computable fractal state-space geometry I , invariant under the action of some subordinate deterministic causal dynamics D I . An exploratory analysis is made of a possible causal realistic framework for quantum physics based on key properties of I . For example, sparseness is used to relate generic counterfactual states to points p ∉ I of unreality, thus providing a geometric basis for the essential contextuality of quantum physics and the role of the abstract Hilbert Space in quantum theory. Also, self-similarity, described in a symbolic setting, provides a possible realistic perspective on the essential role of complex numbers and quaternions in quantum theory. A new interpretation is given to the standard ‘mysteries’ of quantum theory: superposition, measurement, non-locality, emergence of classicality and so on. It is proposed that heterogeneities in the fractal geometry of I are manifestations of the phenomenon of gravity. Since quantum theory is inherently blind to the existence of such state-space geometries, the analysis here suggests that attempts to formulate unified theories of physics within a conventional quantum-theoretic framework are misguided, and that a successful quantum theory of gravity should unify the causal non-Euclidean geometry of space–time with the atemporal fractal geometry of state space. The task is not to make sense of the quantum axioms by heaping more structure, more definitions, more science fiction imagery on top of them, but to throw them away wholesale and start afresh. We should be relentless in asking ourselves: From what deep physical principles might we derive this exquisite structure? These principles should be crisp, they should be compelling. They should stir the soul. Chris Fuchs ( Gilder 2008 , p. 335)
A realistic measurement-free theory for the quantum physics of multiple qubits is proposed. This theory is based on a symbolic representation of a fractal state-space geometry which is invariant under the action of deterministic and locally causal dynamics. This symbolic representation is constructed from self-similar families of quaternionic operators. Using number-theoretic properties of the cosine function, the statistical properties of the symbolic representation of the invariant set are shown to be consistent with the contextual requirements of the Kochen-Specker theorem, are not constrained by Bell inequalities, and mirror the statistics of entangled qubits. These number-theoretic properties in turn reflect the sparseness of the invariant set in state space, and relate to the metaphysical notion of counterfactual incompleteness. Using the concept of probability, the complex Hilbert Space can be considered the completion of this symbolic representation into the state space continuum. As a result, it is proposed that the complex Hilbert Space should merely be considered a computational convenience in the light of the algorithmic intractability of the invariant set geometry, and consequently the superposed state should not be considered a fundamental aspect of physical theory. The physical basis for the proposed theory is relativistic gravity; for example the symbols used to describe the invariant set themselves label gravitationally distinct cosmological space-times. This implies that the very notion of a `quantum theory of gravity' may be profoundly misguided - erroneously putting the quantum cart before the gravitational horse. Here some elements of an alternative `gravitational theory of the quantum' are proposed, based on a deterministic and locally causal theory of gravity which extends general relativity by being geometric in both space-time and state space.
A new hypothesis is proposed about the nature of physical reality at its most primitive level. The hypothesis is framed in terms of invariance, a concept that forms the very bedrock of physics. Specifically, the Invariant Set Hypothesis proposes that states of physical reality are precisely those belonging to a non-computable fractal subset I of state space, invariant under the action of some subordinate deterministic causal dynamics D . The Invariant Set Hypothesis provides a geometric framework for a new perspective on quantum physics.
Elements of a novel theory of quantum physics are developed, synthesising the role of symbolism in describing quantum measurement and in the topological representation of fractal invariant sets in nonlinear dynamical systems theory. In this synthesis, the universe U is treated as an isolated deterministic dynamical system evolving precisely on a measure-zero fractal invariant subset IU of its state space. A non-classical approach to the physics of U is developed by treating the geometry of IU as more primitive than dynamical evolution equations on IU. A specific symbolic representation of IU is constructed which encodes quaternionic multiplication and from which the statistical properties of complex Hilbert Space vectors are emergent. The Hilbert Space itself arises as the singular limit of Invariant Set Theory as a fractal parameter N→∞. Although the Hilbert Space of quantum theory is counterfactually complete, the measure-zero set IU is counterfactually incomplete, no matter how large is N. Such incompleteness allows reinterpretations of familiar quantum phenomena, consistent with realism and local causality. The non-computable nature of IU ensures that these reinterpretations are neither conspiratorial nor retrocausal and, through a homeomorphism with the ring of 2N-adic integers, are robust to noise and hence not fine tuned. The non-commutativity of Hilbert Space observables emerges from the symbolic representation of IU through the generic number-theoretic incommensurateness of ϕ/π and cosϕ. Invariant Set Theory implies a much stronger synergy between cosmology and quantum physics than exists in contemporary theory, suggesting a novel approach to synthesising gravitational and quantum physics and providing new perspectives on the dark universe and information loss in black holes.
The synthesis of quantum and gravitational physics is sought through a finite, realistic, locally causal theory where gravity plays a vital role not only during decoherent measurement but also during non-decoherent unitary evolution. Invariant set theory is built on geometric properties of a compact fractal-like subset IU of cosmological state space on which the universe is assumed to evolve and from which the laws of physics are assumed to derive. Consistent with the primacy of IU, a non-Euclidean (and hence non-classical) state-space metric gp is defined, related to the p-adic metric of number theory where p is a large but finite Pythagorean prime. Uncertain states on IU are described using complex Hilbert states, but only if their squared amplitudes are rational and corresponding complex phase angles are rational multiples of 2π. Such Hilbert states are necessarily gp-distant from states with either irrational squared amplitudes or irrational phase angles. The gappy fractal nature of IU accounts for quantum complementarity and is characterised numerically by a generic number-theoretic incommensurateness between rational angles and rational cosines of angles. The Bell inequality, whose violation would be inconsistent with local realism, is shown to be gp-distant from all forms of the inequality that are violated in any finite-precision experiment. The delayed-choice paradox is resolved through the computational irreducibility of IU. The Schrödinger and Dirac equations describe evolution on IU in the singular limit at p=∞. By contrast, an extension of the Einstein field equations on IU is proposed which reduces smoothly to general relativity as p→∞. Novel proposals for the dark universe and the elimination of classical space-time singularities are given and experimental implications outlined.
This paper draws on a number of Roger Penrose's ideas—including the non-Hamiltonian phase-space flow of the Hawking Box, conformal cyclic cosmology, non-computability, and gravitationally induced quantum state reduction—in order to propose a radically unconventional approach to quantum gravity: Invariant Set Theory (IST). In IST, the fundamental laws of physics describe the geometry of the phase portrait of the universe as a whole: “quantum” process is associated with fine-scale fractal geometry, “gravitational” process with larger-scale heterogeneous geometry. With this, it becomes possible to explain the experimental violation of Bell inequalities without having to abandon key ingredients of general relativity: determinism and local causality. Ensembles in IST can be described by complex Hilbert states over a finite set ℂp of complex numbers, where p is a large finite integer. The quantum mechanics of finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces is emergent as a singular limit when p→∞. A small modification to the field equations of general relativity is proposed to make it consistent with IST.
Invariant Set Theory (IST) is a realistic, locally causal theory of fundamental physics which assumes a much stronger synergy between cosmology and quantum physics than exists in contemporary theory. In IST the (quasi-cyclic) universe U is treated as a deterministic dynamical system evolving precisely on a measure-zero fractal invariant subset IU of its state space. In this approach, the geometry of IU, and not a set of differential evolution equations in space-time MU, provides the most primitive description of the laws of physics. As such, IST is non-classical. The geometry of IU is based on Cantor sets of space-time trajectories in state space, homeomorphic to the algebraic set of p-adic integers, for large but finite p. In IST, the non-commutativity of position and momentum observables arises from number theory - in particular the non-commensurateness of ϕ and cosϕ. The complex Hilbert Space and the relativistic Dirac Equation respectively are shown to describe IU, and evolution on IU, in the singular limit of IST at p=∞; particle properties such as de Broglie relationships arise from the helical geometry of trajectories on IU in the neighbourhood of MU. With the p-adic metric as a fundamental measure of distance on IU, certain key perturbations which seem conspiratorially small relative to the more traditional Euclidean metric, take points away from IU and are therefore unphysically large. This allows (the ψ-epistemic) IST to evade the Bell and Pusey et al theorems without fine tuning or other objections. In IST, the problem of quantum gravity becomes one of combining the pseudo-Riemannian metric of MU with the p-adic metric of IU. A generalisation of the field equations of general relativity which can achieve this is proposed.