Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0809.2622 · Physical Review Letters

No Deterministic Purification for Two Copies of a Noisy Entangled State

Anthony J. Short

Published May 4, 2009• 43 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider whether two copies of a noisy entangled state can be purified into a single copy with less noise using local operations and classical communication. We show that this is impossible to achieve with certainty when the states form a one parameter twirlable family (i.e., a local twirling operation exists that maps all states into the family, yet leaves the family itself invariant). This implies that two copies of a Werner state cannot be deterministically purified. Furthermore, due to the nature of the proof, it will hold not only in quantum theory, but in any nonlocal probabilistic theory. Hence two noisy Popescu-Rohrlich boxes (hypothetical devices more nonlocal than any quantum state) also cannot be purified.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.102.180502

Related papers

Purifying Noisy Entanglement Requires Collective Measurements

Noah Linden, Serge Massar, Sandu Popescu

Known entanglement purification protocols for mixed states use collective measurements on several copies of the state in order to increase the entanglement of some of them. We address the question of whether it is possible to purify the entanglement of a state by processing each copy separately. While this is possible for pure states, we show that this is impossible, in general, for mixed states. The importance of this result both conceptually and for experimental realization of purification is discussed. We also give explicit invariants of an entangled state of two qubits under local actions and classical communication.

arXiv:quant-ph/9805001•Physical Review Letters•Oct 12, 1998•122 citations

Entangled Mixed States and Local Purification

Adrian Kent

Linden, Massar, and Popescu have recently given an optimization argument to show that a single two-qubit Werner state, or any other mixture of the maximally entangled Bell states, cannot be purified by local operations and classical communications. We generalize their result and give a simple explanation. In particular, we show that no purification scheme using local operations and classical communications can produce a pure singlet from any mixed state of two spin- $1/2$ particles. More generally, no such scheme can produce a maximally entangled state of any pair of finite-dimensional systems from a generic mixed state. We also show that the Werner states belong to a large class of states whose fidelity cannot be increased by such a scheme.

arXiv:quant-ph/9805088•Physical Review Letters•Oct 5, 1998•97 citations

Power and Limitations of Distributed Quantum State Purification

Benchi Zhao, Yu-Ao Chen, Xuanqiang Zhao +3 more

Quantum state purification protocols, which mitigate noise by converting multiple copies of noisy quantum states into fewer copies with a lower noise level, have applications in quantum communication and computation with imperfect devices. Here, we systematically study the task of state purification in distributed quantum systems, demanding that purification be achieved by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We prove that, in the presence of depolarizing noise, no LOCC purification protocol starting from two copies can work blindly for all the states in three important sets: the set of all pure two-qubit states, the set of all two-qubit maximally entangled states, and the Bell basis. In stark contrast, we show that a targeted, single-state purification is always achievable in the presence of depolarizing noise, and we provide an explicit analytical LOCC protocol for every given two-qubit state. For arbitrary finite sets of pure states and arbitrary noise profiles, we develop an optimization-based algorithm that systematically designs LOCC purification protocols, and we demonstrate it through concrete examples. Overall, our results identify both fundamental limitations and practical noise-reduction strategies for distributed quantum information processing.

arXiv:2509.08691•Physical Review Letters•Feb 2, 2026•3 citations

Nonlocal operations: Purification, storage, compression, tomography, and probabilistic implementation

Wolfgang Dür, J. I. Cirac

We provide several applications of a previously introduced isomorphism between physical operations acting on two systems and entangled states [Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 544 (2001)]. We show (i) how to implement (weakly) nonlocal two-qubit unitary operations with a small amount of entanglement; (ii) that a known, noisy, nonlocal unitary operation as well as an unknown, noisy, local unitary operation can be purified; (iii) how to perform the tomography of arbitrary, unknown, nonlocal operations; (iv) that a set of local unitary operations as well as a set of nonlocal unitary operations can be stored and compressed; and (v) how to implement probabilistically two-qubit gates for photons. We also show how to compress a set of bipartite entangled states locally, as well as how to implement certain nonlocal measurements using a small amount of entanglement. Finally, we generalize some of our results to multiparty systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0012148•Physical Review A•Jun 15, 2001•69 citations

Purification of two-qubit mixed states

E. Jané

We find the necessary and sufficient condition under which two two-qubit mixed states can be purified into a pure maximally entangled state by local operations and classical communication. The optimal protocol for such transformation is obtained. This result leads to a necessary and sufficient condition for the exact purification of $n$ copies of a two-qubit state.

arXiv:quant-ph/0205107•Quantum Information and Computation•Aug 1, 2002•12 citations

Necessary and sufficient condition for distillability with unit fidelity from finite copies of a mixed state: The most efficient purification protocol

Ping‐Xing Chen, Lin-Mei Liang, Cheng-Zu Li +1 more

It is well known that any entangled mixed state in $2\ensuremath{\bigotimes}2$ systems can be purified via infinite copies of the mixed state. But, can one distill a pure maximally entangled state from finite copies of a mixed state in any bipartite system by local operation and classical communication? This is more meaningful in practical application. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for this distillability. This condition requires that there exist distillable subspaces. According to this condition, one can judge easily whether a mixed state is distillable or not. We also analyze some properties of distillable subspaces, and discuss the most efficient purification protocol. Finally, we discuss the distillable enanglement of a two-qubit system for the case of finite copies.

arXiv:quant-ph/0110045•Physical Review A•Aug 21, 2002•13 citations
We consider whether two copies of a noisy entangled state can be purified into a single copy with less noise using local operations and classical communication. We show that this is impossible to achieve with certainty when the states form a one parameter twirlable family (i.e., a local twirling operation exists that maps all states into the family, yet leaves the family itself invariant). This implies that two copies of a Werner state cannot be deterministically purified. Furthermore, due to the nature of the proof, it will hold not only in quantum theory, but in any nonlocal probabilistic theory. Hence two noisy Popescu-Rohrlich boxes (hypothetical devices more nonlocal than any quantum state) also cannot be purified.
Known entanglement purification protocols for mixed states use collective measurements on several copies of the state in order to increase the entanglement of some of them. We address the question of whether it is possible to purify the entanglement of a state by processing each copy separately. While this is possible for pure states, we show that this is impossible, in general, for mixed states. The importance of this result both conceptually and for experimental realization of purification is discussed. We also give explicit invariants of an entangled state of two qubits under local actions and classical communication.
Linden, Massar, and Popescu have recently given an optimization argument to show that a single two-qubit Werner state, or any other mixture of the maximally entangled Bell states, cannot be purified by local operations and classical communications. We generalize their result and give a simple explanation. In particular, we show that no purification scheme using local operations and classical communications can produce a pure singlet from any mixed state of two spin- 1/21/21/2 particles. More generally, no such scheme can produce a maximally entangled state of any pair of finite-dimensional systems from a generic mixed state. We also show that the Werner states belong to a large class of states whose fidelity cannot be increased by such a scheme.
Quantum state purification protocols, which mitigate noise by converting multiple copies of noisy quantum states into fewer copies with a lower noise level, have applications in quantum communication and computation with imperfect devices. Here, we systematically study the task of state purification in distributed quantum systems, demanding that purification be achieved by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We prove that, in the presence of depolarizing noise, no LOCC purification protocol starting from two copies can work blindly for all the states in three important sets: the set of all pure two-qubit states, the set of all two-qubit maximally entangled states, and the Bell basis. In stark contrast, we show that a targeted, single-state purification is always achievable in the presence of depolarizing noise, and we provide an explicit analytical LOCC protocol for every given two-qubit state. For arbitrary finite sets of pure states and arbitrary noise profiles, we develop an optimization-based algorithm that systematically designs LOCC purification protocols, and we demonstrate it through concrete examples. Overall, our results identify both fundamental limitations and practical noise-reduction strategies for distributed quantum information processing.
We provide several applications of a previously introduced isomorphism between physical operations acting on two systems and entangled states [Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 544 (2001)]. We show (i) how to implement (weakly) nonlocal two-qubit unitary operations with a small amount of entanglement; (ii) that a known, noisy, nonlocal unitary operation as well as an unknown, noisy, local unitary operation can be purified; (iii) how to perform the tomography of arbitrary, unknown, nonlocal operations; (iv) that a set of local unitary operations as well as a set of nonlocal unitary operations can be stored and compressed; and (v) how to implement probabilistically two-qubit gates for photons. We also show how to compress a set of bipartite entangled states locally, as well as how to implement certain nonlocal measurements using a small amount of entanglement. Finally, we generalize some of our results to multiparty systems.
We find the necessary and sufficient condition under which two two-qubit mixed states can be purified into a pure maximally entangled state by local operations and classical communication. The optimal protocol for such transformation is obtained. This result leads to a necessary and sufficient condition for the exact purification of nnn copies of a two-qubit state.
It is well known that any entangled mixed state in $2\ensuremath{\bigotimes}2$ systems can be purified via infinite copies of the mixed state. But, can one distill a pure maximally entangled state from finite copies of a mixed state in any bipartite system by local operation and classical communication? This is more meaningful in practical application. We give a necessary and sufficient condition for this distillability. This condition requires that there exist distillable subspaces. According to this condition, one can judge easily whether a mixed state is distillable or not. We also analyze some properties of distillable subspaces, and discuss the most efficient purification protocol. Finally, we discuss the distillable enanglement of a two-qubit system for the case of finite copies.