Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0807.1834 · New Journal of Physics

Creating and verifying a quantum superposition in a micro-optomechanical system

Dustin Kleckner, Igor Pikovski, Evan R. Jeffrey, L. J. P. Ament, E. R. Eliel, Jeroen van den Brink, Dirk Bouwmeester

Published Sep 30, 2008• 137 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Micro-optomechanical systems are central to a number of recent proposals for realizing quantum mechanical effects in relatively massive systems. Here, we focus on a particular class of experiments which aim to demonstrate massive quantum superpositions, although the obtained results should be generalizable to similar experiments. We analyze in detail the effects of finite temperature on the interpretation of the experiment, and obtain a lower bound on the degree of non-classicality of the cantilever. Although it is possible to measure the quantum decoherence time when starting from finite temperature, an unambiguous demonstration of a quantum superposition requires the mechanical resonator to be in or near the ground state. This can be achieved by optical cooling of the fundamental mode, which also provides a method to measure the mean phonon number in that mode. We also calculate the rate of environmentally induced decoherence and estimate the timescale for gravitational collapse mechanisms as proposed by Penrose and Diosi. In view of recent experimental advances, practical considerations for the realization of the described experiment are discussed.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/10/9/095020

Related papers

Towards Macroscopic Quantum Effects Using Optomechanical and Optical Systems

Roohollah Ghobadi

In this thesis, I studied two different approaches which are promising for creating macroscopic quantum superpositions. The first approach, which is the main focus of this thesis, is based on optomechanical systems. The basic challenge to realize quantum effects in optomechanical systems, is considered to be the weak optomechanical coupling rate compared to the decoherence rates of the system caused by the cavity and mechanical damping. To enhance the optomechanical coupling it has been suggested to pump the cavity with coherent laser light \cite{Vitali07}. By this method the strong coupling regime in which the optomechanical coupling rate exceeds all decoherence rates has been demonstrated very recently \cite{Verhagen12,Groblacher09}. It is also known that the optomechanical systems may exhibit nonlinear behaviours such as bistability. After introducing the basic ideas of optomechanical systems in chapter 1, in chapter 2 we studied the connection between optomechanical entanglement and bistability. In chapter 3, we studied the drawback of using a laser to enhance the interaction. We studied the effect of the laser phase noise, as an additional decoherence channel, on the optomechanical entanglement. We have shown that the system is very sensitive to this new source of decoherence and the sensitivity is maximum in the bistable threshold. We discussed that our results are independent of how we model the laser phase noise. In chapter 4, we studied single photon optomechanics. In this regime, we proposed a new scheme to enhance the optomechanical coupling based on post selection. Our scheme is potentially promising to create a superposition of the massive oscillator in different motional states. We also discussed the potential application of our scheme to test some decoherence models. The second approach that we consider in this thesis is based on amplifying single photons with high gain to create micro-macro superpositions . In chapter 5, we discussed the De Martini scheme. We then present our scheme for creating optical micro-macro superposition and discussed its experimental realization under realistic conditions when losses are taken into account.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Limitations of a measurement-assisted optomechanical route to quantum macroscopicity of superposition states

Andrew Carlisle, Hyukjoon Kwon, Hyunseok Jeong +2 more

Optomechanics is currently believed to provide a promising route towards the achievement of genuine quantum effects at the large, massive-system scale. By using a recently proposed figure of merit that is well suited to address continuous-variable systems, in this paper we analyze the requirements needed for the state of a mechanical mode (embodied by an end-cavity cantilever or a membrane placed within an optical cavity) to be qualified as macroscopic. We show that according to the phase-space-based criterion that we have chosen for our quantitative analysis, the state achieved through strong single-photon radiation-pressure coupling to a quantized field of light and conditioned by measurements operated on the latter might be interpreted as macroscopically quantum. In general, though, genuine macroscopic quantum superpositions appear to be possible only under quite demanding experimental conditions.

arXiv:1411.7980•Physical Review A•Aug 26, 2015•7 citations

Open System Dynamics in Quantum Optomechanics

Dan Mei Hu

In this dissertation, I theoretically investigate the open system dynamics of cavity optomechanical systems in the quantum limit, where a mechanical resonator couples to a cavity mode via radiation pressure force. Recent developments in nano-fabrication and cooling techniques make it possible to optically control and manipulate the motion of micro- and nano-mechanical resonator. Several experiments have demonstrated the possibility of preparing macroscopic mechanical resonators into their quantum ground state, which makes optomechanical systems an ideal candidate for studying the quantum behavior of macroscopic objects. One important direction in quantum optomechanics is the study of the decoherence of optomechanical system due to the interaction with their external environments. This dissertation explores the decoherence effects by considering the influence of the radiation pressure coupling on the interaction between optomechanical system and its environments. Because the effects of the nonlinear interaction vary with the optomechanical coupling strength, three different interaction regimes are fully studied here: the weak coupling, the intermediate coupling and the strong coupling.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

QUANTUM MICRO-MECHANICS WITH ULTRACOLD ATOMS

Thierry Botter, Daniel W. C. Brooks, Subhadeep Gupta +5 more

In many experiments isolated atoms and ions have been inserted into high-finesse optical resonators for the study of fundamental quantum optics and quantum information. Here, we introduce another application of such a system, as the realization of cavity optomechanics where the collective motion of an atomic ensemble serves the role of a moveable optical element in an optical resonator. Compared with other optomechanical systems, such as those incorporating nanofabricated cantilevers or the large cavity mirrors of gravitational observatories, our cold-atom realization offers direct access to the quantum regime. We describe experimental investigations of optomechanical effects, such as the bistability of collective atomic motion and the first quantification of measurement backaction for a macroscopic object, and discuss future directions for this nascent field.

arXiv:0810.3841•International Conference on Atomic Physics (ICAP)•Mar 1, 2009•3 citations

Quantum superposition on nano-mechanical oscillator

Wan, Chuanqi

The probing of the quantum nature of a macroscopic object is an open problem. Approaches in preparing quantum superposition towards a larger scale, which has been progressively accessible in a variety of experimental implementations, may detect new physics or extend the boundary of quantum theory. Development on a nano-mechanical system in the framework of quantum optics and information theory has opened new research directions. It paves ways to manipulate the wavefunction of a massive particle over a large spatial range and probe its quantum behavior to an unprecedented precision. In this thesis, quantum superposition on a mechanical system is studied theoretically in the light of possible implementations under current techniques in order to test superposition principle and the quantum nature of gravity in the mesoscopic region. The work includes two lines of study. In the first line, the motion of the center of mass (c.m.) of the mechanical system is coupled to its internal spin system magnetically, and a Ramsey scheme is developed based on coherent spin control. The wavepacket of the test object, under a spin-dependent force, may then be delocalized to a macroscopic scale. A gravity induced dynamical phase (accrued solely on the spin state, and measured through a Ramsey scheme) is used to reveal the above spatially delocalized superposition of the spin-nano-object composite system that arises during the scheme. A remarkable immunity to the motional noise in the c.m. (initially in a thermal state with moderate cooling) and also a dynamical decoupling nature of the scheme itself is revealed. A careful examination of the perturbation effect due to setup imperfection and environment-induced decoherence is performed, which shows that the Ramsey fringes have a high tolerance on those unwanted faults under realistic experimental conditions. The scheme also facilitates a gravimetry protocol that potentially could be developed for a novel on-chip gravimeter with a precision of $10^{-6}g/\sqrt{\text{Hz}}$. In the second line, an opto-mechanical experiment is proposed to entangle the motion of two mechanical oscillators through their mutual gravitational interaction. The feasibility of such an experiment is critically examined within the framework of cavity optomechanics. It is shown that within the decoherence time of mechanical noise and potentially gravitational induced state collapse, entanglement between mirrors could be obtained when the initial state of the cavity field is prepared in some particular states. Strategies that give enhancement to entanglement generation rate are studied in light of quantum estimation theory. It is shown that for a cavity initially in a coherent state, the resulting entanglement generation rate would be enhanced linearly with the amplitude of the coherent state. Lastly, it shows that in the proposed setup Casimir effect would significantly affect the gravity-induced entanglement. A proper shield can eliminate the detrimental effect of Casimir force, which, however, will constrain the closest distance between the mirrors in its implementation.

•Oct 1, 2017•7 citations

Quantum superposition of massive objects and collapse models

Oriol Romero‐Isart

We analyze the requirements to test some of the most paradigmatic collapse models with a protocol that prepares quantum superpositions of massive objects. This consists of coherently expanding the wave function of a ground-state-cooled mechanical resonator, performing a squared position measurement that acts as a double slit, and observing interference after further evolution. The analysis is performed in a general framework and takes into account only unavoidable sources of decoherence: blackbody radiation and scattering of environmental particles. We also discuss the limitations imposed by the experimental implementation of this protocol using cavity quantum optomechanics with levitating dielectric nanospheres.

arXiv:1110.4495•Physical Review A•Nov 28, 2011•276 citations
Micro-optomechanical systems are central to a number of recent proposals for realizing quantum mechanical effects in relatively massive systems. Here, we focus on a particular class of experiments which aim to demonstrate massive quantum superpositions, although the obtained results should be generalizable to similar experiments. We analyze in detail the effects of finite temperature on the interpretation of the experiment, and obtain a lower bound on the degree of non-classicality of the cantilever. Although it is possible to measure the quantum decoherence time when starting from finite temperature, an unambiguous demonstration of a quantum superposition requires the mechanical resonator to be in or near the ground state. This can be achieved by optical cooling of the fundamental mode, which also provides a method to measure the mean phonon number in that mode. We also calculate the rate of environmentally induced decoherence and estimate the timescale for gravitational collapse mechanisms as proposed by Penrose and Diosi. In view of recent experimental advances, practical considerations for the realization of the described experiment are discussed.
In this thesis, I studied two different approaches which are promising for creating macroscopic quantum superpositions. The first approach, which is the main focus of this thesis, is based on optomechanical systems. The basic challenge to realize quantum effects in optomechanical systems, is considered to be the weak optomechanical coupling rate compared to the decoherence rates of the system caused by the cavity and mechanical damping. To enhance the optomechanical coupling it has been suggested to pump the cavity with coherent laser light \cite{Vitali07}. By this method the strong coupling regime in which the optomechanical coupling rate exceeds all decoherence rates has been demonstrated very recently \cite{Verhagen12,Groblacher09}. It is also known that the optomechanical systems may exhibit nonlinear behaviours such as bistability. After introducing the basic ideas of optomechanical systems in chapter 1, in chapter 2 we studied the connection between optomechanical entanglement and bistability. In chapter 3, we studied the drawback of using a laser to enhance the interaction. We studied the effect of the laser phase noise, as an additional decoherence channel, on the optomechanical entanglement. We have shown that the system is very sensitive to this new source of decoherence and the sensitivity is maximum in the bistable threshold. We discussed that our results are independent of how we model the laser phase noise. In chapter 4, we studied single photon optomechanics. In this regime, we proposed a new scheme to enhance the optomechanical coupling based on post selection. Our scheme is potentially promising to create a superposition of the massive oscillator in different motional states. We also discussed the potential application of our scheme to test some decoherence models. The second approach that we consider in this thesis is based on amplifying single photons with high gain to create micro-macro superpositions . In chapter 5, we discussed the De Martini scheme. We then present our scheme for creating optical micro-macro superposition and discussed its experimental realization under realistic conditions when losses are taken into account.
Optomechanics is currently believed to provide a promising route towards the achievement of genuine quantum effects at the large, massive-system scale. By using a recently proposed figure of merit that is well suited to address continuous-variable systems, in this paper we analyze the requirements needed for the state of a mechanical mode (embodied by an end-cavity cantilever or a membrane placed within an optical cavity) to be qualified as macroscopic. We show that according to the phase-space-based criterion that we have chosen for our quantitative analysis, the state achieved through strong single-photon radiation-pressure coupling to a quantized field of light and conditioned by measurements operated on the latter might be interpreted as macroscopically quantum. In general, though, genuine macroscopic quantum superpositions appear to be possible only under quite demanding experimental conditions.
In this dissertation, I theoretically investigate the open system dynamics of cavity optomechanical systems in the quantum limit, where a mechanical resonator couples to a cavity mode via radiation pressure force. Recent developments in nano-fabrication and cooling techniques make it possible to optically control and manipulate the motion of micro- and nano-mechanical resonator. Several experiments have demonstrated the possibility of preparing macroscopic mechanical resonators into their quantum ground state, which makes optomechanical systems an ideal candidate for studying the quantum behavior of macroscopic objects. One important direction in quantum optomechanics is the study of the decoherence of optomechanical system due to the interaction with their external environments. This dissertation explores the decoherence effects by considering the influence of the radiation pressure coupling on the interaction between optomechanical system and its environments. Because the effects of the nonlinear interaction vary with the optomechanical coupling strength, three different interaction regimes are fully studied here: the weak coupling, the intermediate coupling and the strong coupling.
In many experiments isolated atoms and ions have been inserted into high-finesse optical resonators for the study of fundamental quantum optics and quantum information. Here, we introduce another application of such a system, as the realization of cavity optomechanics where the collective motion of an atomic ensemble serves the role of a moveable optical element in an optical resonator. Compared with other optomechanical systems, such as those incorporating nanofabricated cantilevers or the large cavity mirrors of gravitational observatories, our cold-atom realization offers direct access to the quantum regime. We describe experimental investigations of optomechanical effects, such as the bistability of collective atomic motion and the first quantification of measurement backaction for a macroscopic object, and discuss future directions for this nascent field.
The probing of the quantum nature of a macroscopic object is an open problem. Approaches in preparing quantum superposition towards a larger scale, which has been progressively accessible in a variety of experimental implementations, may detect new physics or extend the boundary of quantum theory. Development on a nano-mechanical system in the framework of quantum optics and information theory has opened new research directions. It paves ways to manipulate the wavefunction of a massive particle over a large spatial range and probe its quantum behavior to an unprecedented precision. In this thesis, quantum superposition on a mechanical system is studied theoretically in the light of possible implementations under current techniques in order to test superposition principle and the quantum nature of gravity in the mesoscopic region. The work includes two lines of study. In the first line, the motion of the center of mass (c.m.) of the mechanical system is coupled to its internal spin system magnetically, and a Ramsey scheme is developed based on coherent spin control. The wavepacket of the test object, under a spin-dependent force, may then be delocalized to a macroscopic scale. A gravity induced dynamical phase (accrued solely on the spin state, and measured through a Ramsey scheme) is used to reveal the above spatially delocalized superposition of the spin-nano-object composite system that arises during the scheme. A remarkable immunity to the motional noise in the c.m. (initially in a thermal state with moderate cooling) and also a dynamical decoupling nature of the scheme itself is revealed. A careful examination of the perturbation effect due to setup imperfection and environment-induced decoherence is performed, which shows that the Ramsey fringes have a high tolerance on those unwanted faults under realistic experimental conditions. The scheme also facilitates a gravimetry protocol that potentially could be developed for a novel on-chip gravimeter with a precision of 10−6g/Hz10^{-6}g/\sqrt{\text{Hz}}10−6g/Hz​. In the second line, an opto-mechanical experiment is proposed to entangle the motion of two mechanical oscillators through their mutual gravitational interaction. The feasibility of such an experiment is critically examined within the framework of cavity optomechanics. It is shown that within the decoherence time of mechanical noise and potentially gravitational induced state collapse, entanglement between mirrors could be obtained when the initial state of the cavity field is prepared in some particular states. Strategies that give enhancement to entanglement generation rate are studied in light of quantum estimation theory. It is shown that for a cavity initially in a coherent state, the resulting entanglement generation rate would be enhanced linearly with the amplitude of the coherent state. Lastly, it shows that in the proposed setup Casimir effect would significantly affect the gravity-induced entanglement. A proper shield can eliminate the detrimental effect of Casimir force, which, however, will constrain the closest distance between the mirrors in its implementation.
We analyze the requirements to test some of the most paradigmatic collapse models with a protocol that prepares quantum superpositions of massive objects. This consists of coherently expanding the wave function of a ground-state-cooled mechanical resonator, performing a squared position measurement that acts as a double slit, and observing interference after further evolution. The analysis is performed in a general framework and takes into account only unavoidable sources of decoherence: blackbody radiation and scattering of environmental particles. We also discuss the limitations imposed by the experimental implementation of this protocol using cavity quantum optomechanics with levitating dielectric nanospheres.