Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0805.0029 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

How to simulate a universal quantum computer using negative probabilities

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

Published Jun 15, 2009• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The concept of negative probabilities can be used to decompose the interaction of two qubits mediated by a quantum controlled-NOT into three operations that require only classical interactions (that is, local operations and classical communication) between the qubits. For a single gate, the probabilities of the three operations are 1, 1 and −1. This decomposition can be applied in a probabilistic simulation of quantum computation by randomly choosing one of the three operations for each gate and assigning a negative statistical weight to the outcomes of sequences with an odd number of negative probability operations. The maximal exponential speed-up of a quantum computer can then be evaluated in terms of the increase in the number of sequences needed to simulate a single operation of the quantum circuit.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/42/27/275304

Related papers

Simulation of quantum algorithms using classical probabilistic bits and circuits

Deniz D. Yavuz, Anirudh Yadav

We discuss a new approach to simulate quantum algorithms using classical probabilistic bits and circuits. Each qubit (a two-level quantum system) is initially mapped to a vector in an eight dimensional probability space (equivalently, to a classical random variable with eight probabilistic outcomes). The key idea in this mapping is to store both the amplitude and phase information of the complex coefficients that describe the qubit state in the probabilities. Due to the identical tensor product structure of combining multiple quantum systems as well as multiple probability spaces, $n$ qubits are then mapped to a tensor product of $n$ 8-dimensional probabilistic vectors (i.e., the Hilbert space of dimension $2^n$ is mapped to a probability space of dimension $8^n$). After this initial mapping, we show how to implement the analogs of single-qubit and two-qubit gates in the probability space using correlation-inducing operations on these classical random variables. The key defining feature of both the mapping to the probability space and the transformations in this space (i.e., operations on the random variables) is that they are not linear, but instead affine. Using this architecture, the evolution of the $2^n$ complex coefficients of the quantum system can be tracked in the joint fully-correlated probabilities of the polynomial number of random variables. We then give specific procedures for implementing (1) the Deutsch-Jozsa algorithm, and (2) the Quantum Fourier Transform in the probability space. Identical to the Quantum case, simulating the Quantum Fourier Transform in the probability space requires $O(n)$ probabilistic bits and $O(n^2)$ (i.e., quadratic in the number of quantum bits) operations.

arXiv:2307.14452•Jul 26, 2023•1 citation

What Limits the Simulation of Quantum Computers?

Yiqing Zhou, E. Miles Stoudenmire, Xavier Waintal

An ultimate goal of quantum computing is to perform calculations beyond the reach of any classical computer.It is therefore imperative that useful quantum computers be very difficult to simulate classically, otherwise classical computers could be used for the applications envisioned for the quantum ones.Perfect quantum computers are unarguably exponentially difficult to simulate: the classical resources required grow exponentially with the number of qubits N or the depth D of the circuit.This difficulty has triggered recent experiments on deep, random circuits that aim to demonstrate that quantum devices may already perform tasks beyond the reach of classical computing.These real quantum computing devices, however, suffer from many sources of decoherence and imprecision which limit the degree of entanglement that can actually be reached to a fraction of its theoretical maximum.They are characterized by an exponentially decaying fidelity F ∼ ð1 -ϵÞ ND with an error rate ϵ per operation as small as ≈1% for current devices with several dozen qubits or even smaller for smaller devices.In this work, we provide new insight on the computing capabilities of real quantum computers by demonstrating that they can be simulated at a tiny fraction of the cost that would be needed for a perfect quantum computer.Our algorithms compress the representations of quantum wave functions using matrix product states, which are able to capture states with low to moderate entanglement very accurately.This compression introduces a finite error rate ϵ so that the algorithms closely mimic the behavior of real quantum computing devices.The computing time of our algorithm increases only linearly with N and D in sharp contrast with exact simulation algorithms.We illustrate our algorithms with simulations of random circuits for qubits connected in both one-and twodimensional lattices.We find that ϵ can be decreased at a polynomial cost in computing power down to a minimum error ϵ ∞ .Getting below ϵ ∞ requires computing resources that increase exponentially with ϵ ∞ =ϵ.For a two-dimensional array of N ¼ 54 qubits and a circuit with control-Z gates, error rates better than state-of-the-art devices can be obtained on a laptop in a few hours.For more complex gates such as a SWAP gate followed by a controlled rotation, the error rate increases by a factor 3 for similar computing time.Our results suggest that, despite the high fidelity reached by quantum devices, only a tiny fraction ð∼10 -8 Þ of the system Hilbert space is actually being exploited.

arXiv:2002.07730•Physical Review X•Nov 23, 2020•301 citations

Modelling of Grover’s quantum search algorithms: implementations of Simple quantum simulators on classical computers

Sergey Victorovich Ulyanov, Andrey G. Reshetnikov, Olga Tyatyushkina

Models of Grover’s search algorithm is reviewed to build the foundation for the other algorithms. Thereafter, some preliminary modifications of the original algorithms by others are stated, that increases the applicability of the search procedure. A general quantum computation on an isolated system can be represented by a unitary matrix. In order to execute such a computation on a quantum computer, it is common to decompose the unitary into a quantum circuit, i.e., a sequence of quantum gates that can be physically implemented on a given architecture. There are different universal gate sets for quantum computation. Here we choose the universal gate set consisting of CNOT and single-qubit gates. We measure the cost of a circuit by the number of CNOT gates as they are usually more difficult to implement than single qubit gates and since the number of single-qubit gates is bounded by about twice the number of CNOT’s.

System Analysis in Science and Education•Sep 30, 2020•4 citations

Quantum Computing Simulation Optimizations and Operational Errors on Various 2-qubit Multiplier Circuits

Hsu, Eric

Since simulating quantum computers requires exponentially more classical resources, efficient algorithms are extremely helpful. We analyze algorithms that create single qubit and specific controlled qubit matrix representations of gates. Additionally, we use the simulator to investigate errors based on different probability distributions and to investigate the robustness of different 2-qubit multiplier circuits in the presence of operational errors.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208113•Aug 15, 2002•1 citation

Quantum computation

This chapter introduces the basic principles of quantum computation. We shall adhere to the quantum circuit model of computation, with which it is easy to work and which is close to physical implementations. We shall not discuss the more abstract quantum Turing machine model, which, however, has been shown to be equivalent to the circuit model. The elementary unit of quantum information and the basic building block of quantum computation is the qubit, a two-level quantum system that can be prepared, manipulated and measured in a controlled way. A quantum computer can be seen as a collection of n qubits and therefore its wave function resides in a 2 n -dimensional complex Hilbert space. As far as coupling to the environment may be neglected, its evolution in time is unitary and governed by the Schrödinger equation. A quantum computation is composed of three basic steps: preparation of the input state, implementation of the desired unitary transformation acting on this state and measurement of the output state. The output of the measurement process is inherently probabilistic and the probabilities of the different possible outputs are set by the basic postulates of quantum mechanics. Therefore, in a quantum algorithm we must, in general, repeat several times the algorithm to obtain the correct solution of our problem with probability as close to one as desired. In this sense, quantum algorithms are analogous to classical probabilistic algorithms. However, the superposition principle and quantum entanglement open up new possibilities for computation. Quantum computers are potentially more powerful than classical (deterministic or probabilistic) computers due to quantum interference and entanglement. We show that, analogously to classical computation, there exists a small set of gates that are universal, that is, any unitary transformation can be decomposed into a sequence of these gates. We then discuss the implementation of the basic Boolean functions and arithmetic operations on a quantum computer.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 2018•0 citations

Adiabatic quantum simulators

Jacob Biamonte, V. Bergholm, James Daniel Whitfield +2 more

In his famous 1981 talk, Feynman proposed that unlike classical computers, which would presumably experience an exponential slowdown when simulating quantum phenomena, a universal quantum simulator would not. An ideal quantum simulator would be controllable, and built using existing technology. In some cases, moving away from gate-model-based implementations of quantum computing may offer a more feasible solution for particular experimental implementations. Here we consider an adiabatic quantum simulator which simulates the ground state properties of sparse Hamiltonians consisting of one- and two-local interaction terms, using sparse Hamiltonians with at most three-local interactions. Properties of such Hamiltonians can be well approximated with Hamiltonians containing only two-local terms. The register holding the simulated ground state is brought adiabatically into interaction with a probe qubit, followed by a single diabatic gate operation on the probe which then undergoes free evolution until measured. This allows one to recover e.g. the ground state energy of the Hamiltonian being simulated. Given a ground state, this scheme can be used to verify the QMA-complete problem LOCAL HAMILTONIAN, and is therefore likely more powerful than classical computing.

arXiv:1002.0368•AIP Advances•May 27, 2011•56 citations
The concept of negative probabilities can be used to decompose the interaction of two qubits mediated by a quantum controlled-NOT into three operations that require only classical interactions (that is, local operations and classical communication) between the qubits. For a single gate, the probabilities of the three operations are 1, 1 and −1. This decomposition can be applied in a probabilistic simulation of quantum computation by randomly choosing one of the three operations for each gate and assigning a negative statistical weight to the outcomes of sequences with an odd number of negative probability operations. The maximal exponential speed-up of a quantum computer can then be evaluated in terms of the increase in the number of sequences needed to simulate a single operation of the quantum circuit.
We discuss a new approach to simulate quantum algorithms using classical probabilistic bits and circuits. Each qubit (a two-level quantum system) is initially mapped to a vector in an eight dimensional probability space (equivalently, to a classical random variable with eight probabilistic outcomes). The key idea in this mapping is to store both the amplitude and phase information of the complex coefficients that describe the qubit state in the probabilities. Due to the identical tensor product structure of combining multiple quantum systems as well as multiple probability spaces, nnn qubits are then mapped to a tensor product of nnn 8-dimensional probabilistic vectors (i.e., the Hilbert space of dimension 2n2^n2n is mapped to a probability space of dimension 8n8^n8n). After this initial mapping, we show how to implement the analogs of single-qubit and two-qubit gates in the probability space using correlation-inducing operations on these classical random variables. The key defining feature of both the mapping to the probability space and the transformations in this space (i.e., operations on the random variables) is that they are not linear, but instead affine. Using this architecture, the evolution of the 2n2^n2n complex coefficients of the quantum system can be tracked in the joint fully-correlated probabilities of the polynomial number of random variables. We then give specific procedures for implementing (1) the Deutsch-Jozsa algorithm, and (2) the Quantum Fourier Transform in the probability space. Identical to the Quantum case, simulating the Quantum Fourier Transform in the probability space requires O(n)O(n)O(n) probabilistic bits and O(n2)O(n^2)O(n2) (i.e., quadratic in the number of quantum bits) operations.
An ultimate goal of quantum computing is to perform calculations beyond the reach of any classical computer.It is therefore imperative that useful quantum computers be very difficult to simulate classically, otherwise classical computers could be used for the applications envisioned for the quantum ones.Perfect quantum computers are unarguably exponentially difficult to simulate: the classical resources required grow exponentially with the number of qubits N or the depth D of the circuit.This difficulty has triggered recent experiments on deep, random circuits that aim to demonstrate that quantum devices may already perform tasks beyond the reach of classical computing.These real quantum computing devices, however, suffer from many sources of decoherence and imprecision which limit the degree of entanglement that can actually be reached to a fraction of its theoretical maximum.They are characterized by an exponentially decaying fidelity F ∼ ð1 -ϵÞ ND with an error rate ϵ per operation as small as ≈1% for current devices with several dozen qubits or even smaller for smaller devices.In this work, we provide new insight on the computing capabilities of real quantum computers by demonstrating that they can be simulated at a tiny fraction of the cost that would be needed for a perfect quantum computer.Our algorithms compress the representations of quantum wave functions using matrix product states, which are able to capture states with low to moderate entanglement very accurately.This compression introduces a finite error rate ϵ so that the algorithms closely mimic the behavior of real quantum computing devices.The computing time of our algorithm increases only linearly with N and D in sharp contrast with exact simulation algorithms.We illustrate our algorithms with simulations of random circuits for qubits connected in both one-and twodimensional lattices.We find that ϵ can be decreased at a polynomial cost in computing power down to a minimum error ϵ ∞ .Getting below ϵ ∞ requires computing resources that increase exponentially with ϵ ∞ =ϵ.For a two-dimensional array of N ¼ 54 qubits and a circuit with control-Z gates, error rates better than state-of-the-art devices can be obtained on a laptop in a few hours.For more complex gates such as a SWAP gate followed by a controlled rotation, the error rate increases by a factor 3 for similar computing time.Our results suggest that, despite the high fidelity reached by quantum devices, only a tiny fraction ð∼10 -8 Þ of the system Hilbert space is actually being exploited.
Models of Grover’s search algorithm is reviewed to build the foundation for the other algorithms. Thereafter, some preliminary modifications of the original algorithms by others are stated, that increases the applicability of the search procedure. A general quantum computation on an isolated system can be represented by a unitary matrix. In order to execute such a computation on a quantum computer, it is common to decompose the unitary into a quantum circuit, i.e., a sequence of quantum gates that can be physically implemented on a given architecture. There are different universal gate sets for quantum computation. Here we choose the universal gate set consisting of CNOT and single-qubit gates. We measure the cost of a circuit by the number of CNOT gates as they are usually more difficult to implement than single qubit gates and since the number of single-qubit gates is bounded by about twice the number of CNOT’s.
This chapter introduces the basic principles of quantum computation. We shall adhere to the quantum circuit model of computation, with which it is easy to work and which is close to physical implementations. We shall not discuss the more abstract quantum Turing machine model, which, however, has been shown to be equivalent to the circuit model. The elementary unit of quantum information and the basic building block of quantum computation is the qubit, a two-level quantum system that can be prepared, manipulated and measured in a controlled way. A quantum computer can be seen as a collection of n qubits and therefore its wave function resides in a 2 n -dimensional complex Hilbert space. As far as coupling to the environment may be neglected, its evolution in time is unitary and governed by the Schrödinger equation. A quantum computation is composed of three basic steps: preparation of the input state, implementation of the desired unitary transformation acting on this state and measurement of the output state. The output of the measurement process is inherently probabilistic and the probabilities of the different possible outputs are set by the basic postulates of quantum mechanics. Therefore, in a quantum algorithm we must, in general, repeat several times the algorithm to obtain the correct solution of our problem with probability as close to one as desired. In this sense, quantum algorithms are analogous to classical probabilistic algorithms. However, the superposition principle and quantum entanglement open up new possibilities for computation. Quantum computers are potentially more powerful than classical (deterministic or probabilistic) computers due to quantum interference and entanglement. We show that, analogously to classical computation, there exists a small set of gates that are universal, that is, any unitary transformation can be decomposed into a sequence of these gates. We then discuss the implementation of the basic Boolean functions and arithmetic operations on a quantum computer.
In his famous 1981 talk, Feynman proposed that unlike classical computers, which would presumably experience an exponential slowdown when simulating quantum phenomena, a universal quantum simulator would not. An ideal quantum simulator would be controllable, and built using existing technology. In some cases, moving away from gate-model-based implementations of quantum computing may offer a more feasible solution for particular experimental implementations. Here we consider an adiabatic quantum simulator which simulates the ground state properties of sparse Hamiltonians consisting of one- and two-local interaction terms, using sparse Hamiltonians with at most three-local interactions. Properties of such Hamiltonians can be well approximated with Hamiltonians containing only two-local terms. The register holding the simulated ground state is brought adiabatically into interaction with a probe qubit, followed by a single diabatic gate operation on the probe which then undergoes free evolution until measured. This allows one to recover e.g. the ground state energy of the Hamiltonian being simulated. Given a ground state, this scheme can be used to verify the QMA-complete problem LOCAL HAMILTONIAN, and is therefore likely more powerful than classical computing.