Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0709.3352 · Physical Review A

Relation between fundamental estimation limit and stability in linear quantum systems with imperfect measurement

Naoki Yamamoto, Shinji Hara

Published Sep 19, 2007• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

From the noncommutative nature of quantum mechanics, estimation of canonical observables $\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{q}$ and $\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}$ is essentially restricted in its performance by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, $⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{q}}^{2}⟩⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}}^{2}⟩\ensuremath{\geqslant}{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}∕4$. This fundamental lower bound may become bigger when taking the structure and quality of a specific measurement apparatus into account. In this paper, we consider a particle subjected to a linear dynamics that is continuously monitored with efficiency $\ensuremath{\eta}∊(0,1]$. It is then clarified that the above Heisenberg uncertainty relation is replaced by $⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{q}}^{2}⟩⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}}^{2}⟩\ensuremath{\geqslant}{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}∕4\ensuremath{\eta}$ if the monitored system is unstable, while there exists a stable quantum system for which the Heisenberg limit is reached.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.76.034102

Related papers

Uncertainty relation revisited from quantum estimation theory

Yu Watanabe, Takahiro Sagawa, Masahito Ueda

We use quantum estimation theory to formulate bounds of errors in quantum measurement for arbitrary quantum states and observables in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space. We prove that the measurement errors of two noncommuting observables satisfy Heisenberg-type uncertainty relation, find the achievable bound, and propose a strategy to achieve it.

arXiv:1010.3571•Physical Review A•Oct 28, 2011•88 citations

Measurement uncertainty relations: characterising optimal error bounds for qubits

Tom Bullock, Paul Busch

Abstract In standard formulations of the uncertainty principle, two fundamental features are typically cast as impossibility statements: two noncommuting observables cannot in general both be sharply defined (for the same state), nor can they be measured jointly. The pioneers of quantum mechanics were acutely aware and puzzled by this fact, and it motivated Heisenberg to seek a mitigation, which he formulated in his seminal paper of 1927. He provided intuitive arguments to show that the values of, say, the position and momentum of a particle can at least be unsharply defined, and they can be measured together provided some approximation errors are allowed. Only now, nine decades later, a working theory of approximate joint measurements is taking shape, leading to rigorous and experimentally testable formulations of associated error tradeoff relations. Here we briefly review this new development, explaining the concepts and steps taken in the construction of optimal joint approximations of pairs of incompatible observables. As a case study, we deduce measurement uncertainty relations for qubit observables using two distinct error measures. We provide an operational interpretation of the error bounds and discuss some of the first experimental tests of such relations.

arXiv:1512.00104•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 23, 2018•18 citations

Measurement uncertainty: the problem of characterising optimal error bounds

Tom Bullock, Paul Busch

In standard formulations of the uncertainty principle, two fundamental features are typically cast as impossibility statements: two noncommuting observables cannot in general both be sharply defined (for the same state), nor can they be measured jointly. The pioneers of quantum mechanics were acutely aware and puzzled by this fact, and it motivated Heisenberg to seek a mitigation, which he formulated in his seminal paper of 1927. He provided intuitive arguments to show that the values of, say, the position and momentum of a particle can at least be unsharply defined, and they can be measured together provided some approximation errors are allowed. Only now, nine decades later, a working theory of approximate joint measurements is taking shape, leading to rigorous and experimentally testable formulations of associated error tradeoff relations. Here we briefly review this new development, explaining the concepts and steps taken in the construction of optimal joint approximations of pairs of incompatible observables. As a case study, we deduce measurement uncertainty relations for qubit observables using two distinct error measures. We provide an operational interpretation of the error bounds and discuss some of the first experimental tests of such relations.

•Dec 1, 2015•1 citation

Uncertainty Relations for Coarse–Grained Measurements: An Overview

Fabricio Toscano, Daniel S. Tasca, Łukasz Rudnicki +1 more

Uncertainty relations involving incompatible observables are one of the cornerstones of quantum mechanics. Aside from their fundamental significance, they play an important role in practical applications, such as detection of quantum correlations and security requirements in quantum cryptography. In continuous variable systems, the spectra of the relevant observables form a continuum and this necessitates the coarse graining of measurements. However, these coarse-grained observables do not necessarily obey the same uncertainty relations as the original ones, a fact that can lead to false results when considering applications. That is, one cannot naively replace the original observables in the uncertainty relation for the coarse-grained observables and expect consistent results. As such, several uncertainty relations that are specifically designed for coarse-grained observables have been developed. In recognition of the 90th anniversary of the seminal Heisenberg uncertainty relation, celebrated last year, and all the subsequent work since then, here we give a review of the state of the art of coarse-grained uncertainty relations in continuous variable quantum systems, as well as their applications to fundamental quantum physics and quantum information tasks. Our review is meant to be balanced in its content, since both theoretical considerations and experimental perspectives are put on an equal footing.

arXiv:1805.00782•Entropy•Jun 10, 2018•23 citations

Conditionally valid uncertainty relations

Kazuo Fujikawa

It is shown that the well-defined unbiased measurement or disturbance of a dynamical variable is not maintained for the precise measurement of the conjugate variable, independently of uncertainty relations. The conditionally valid uncertainty relations on the basis of those additional assumptions, which include most of the familiar Heisenberg-type relations, thus become singular for the precise measurement. We clarify some contradicting conclusions in the literature concerning those conditionally valid uncertainty relations: The failure of a naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation and the modified Arthurs-Kelly relation in the recent spin measurement is attributed to this singular behavior. The naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation is formally preserved in quantum estimation theory, which is shown to be based on the strict unbiased measurement and disturbance, but it leads to unbounded disturbance for bounded operators such as spin variables. In contrast, the Heisenberg-type error-error uncertainty relation and the Arthurs-Kelly relation, as conditionally valid uncertainty relations, are consistently maintained.

arXiv:1305.6375•Physical Review A•Jul 26, 2013•6 citations

Tradeoff relations in open quantum dynamics via Robertson, Maccone–Pati, and Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty relations

Tomohiro Nishiyama, Yoshihiko Hasegawa

Abstract The Heisenberg uncertainty relation, together with Robertson’s generalisation, serves as a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics, showing that noncommutative pairs of observables cannot be measured precisely. In this study, we explore the Robertson-type uncertainty relations to demonstrate their effectiveness in establishing a series of thermodynamic uncertainty relations and quantum speed limits in open quantum dynamics. The derivation utilises a scaled continuous matrix product state representation that maps the time evolution of the quantum continuous measurement to the time evolution of the system and field. Specifically, we consider the Maccone–Pati uncertainty relation, a refinement of the Robertson uncertainty relation, to derive thermodynamic uncertainty relations and quantum speed limits. These newly derived relations, which use a state orthogonal to the initial state, yield bounds that are tighter than previously known bounds. Moreover, we consider the Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty, which extends the Robertson uncertainty relation. Our findings not only reinforce the significance of the Robertson-type uncertainty relations, but also expand its applicability in identifying uncertainty relations in open quantum dynamics.

arXiv:2402.09680•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 11, 2024•4 citations
From the noncommutative nature of quantum mechanics, estimation of canonical observables q\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{q}q\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​ and p\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}p\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​ is essentially restricted in its performance by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, ⟨\ensuremathΔq\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi2⟩⟨\ensuremathΔp\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi2⟩\ensuremath⩾\ensuremathℏ2∕4⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{q}}^{2}⟩⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}}^{2}⟩\ensuremath{\geqslant}{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}∕4⟨\ensuremathΔq\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​2⟩⟨\ensuremathΔp\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​2⟩\ensuremath⩾\ensuremathℏ2∕4. This fundamental lower bound may become bigger when taking the structure and quality of a specific measurement apparatus into account. In this paper, we consider a particle subjected to a linear dynamics that is continuously monitored with efficiency \ensuremathη∊(0,1]\ensuremath{\eta}∊(0,1]\ensuremathη∊(0,1]. It is then clarified that the above Heisenberg uncertainty relation is replaced by ⟨\ensuremathΔq\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi2⟩⟨\ensuremathΔp\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi2⟩\ensuremath⩾\ensuremathℏ2∕4\ensuremathη⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{q}}^{2}⟩⟨\ensuremath{\Delta}{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{p}}^{2}⟩\ensuremath{\geqslant}{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}∕4\ensuremath{\eta}⟨\ensuremathΔq\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​2⟩⟨\ensuremathΔp\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​2⟩\ensuremath⩾\ensuremathℏ2∕4\ensuremathη if the monitored system is unstable, while there exists a stable quantum system for which the Heisenberg limit is reached.
Abstract In standard formulations of the uncertainty principle, two fundamental features are typically cast as impossibility statements: two noncommuting observables cannot in general both be sharply defined (for the same state), nor can they be measured jointly. The pioneers of quantum mechanics were acutely aware and puzzled by this fact, and it motivated Heisenberg to seek a mitigation, which he formulated in his seminal paper of 1927. He provided intuitive arguments to show that the values of, say, the position and momentum of a particle can at least be unsharply defined, and they can be measured together provided some approximation errors are allowed. Only now, nine decades later, a working theory of approximate joint measurements is taking shape, leading to rigorous and experimentally testable formulations of associated error tradeoff relations. Here we briefly review this new development, explaining the concepts and steps taken in the construction of optimal joint approximations of pairs of incompatible observables. As a case study, we deduce measurement uncertainty relations for qubit observables using two distinct error measures. We provide an operational interpretation of the error bounds and discuss some of the first experimental tests of such relations.
In standard formulations of the uncertainty principle, two fundamental features are typically cast as impossibility statements: two noncommuting observables cannot in general both be sharply defined (for the same state), nor can they be measured jointly. The pioneers of quantum mechanics were acutely aware and puzzled by this fact, and it motivated Heisenberg to seek a mitigation, which he formulated in his seminal paper of 1927. He provided intuitive arguments to show that the values of, say, the position and momentum of a particle can at least be unsharply defined, and they can be measured together provided some approximation errors are allowed. Only now, nine decades later, a working theory of approximate joint measurements is taking shape, leading to rigorous and experimentally testable formulations of associated error tradeoff relations. Here we briefly review this new development, explaining the concepts and steps taken in the construction of optimal joint approximations of pairs of incompatible observables. As a case study, we deduce measurement uncertainty relations for qubit observables using two distinct error measures. We provide an operational interpretation of the error bounds and discuss some of the first experimental tests of such relations.
Uncertainty relations involving incompatible observables are one of the cornerstones of quantum mechanics. Aside from their fundamental significance, they play an important role in practical applications, such as detection of quantum correlations and security requirements in quantum cryptography. In continuous variable systems, the spectra of the relevant observables form a continuum and this necessitates the coarse graining of measurements. However, these coarse-grained observables do not necessarily obey the same uncertainty relations as the original ones, a fact that can lead to false results when considering applications. That is, one cannot naively replace the original observables in the uncertainty relation for the coarse-grained observables and expect consistent results. As such, several uncertainty relations that are specifically designed for coarse-grained observables have been developed. In recognition of the 90th anniversary of the seminal Heisenberg uncertainty relation, celebrated last year, and all the subsequent work since then, here we give a review of the state of the art of coarse-grained uncertainty relations in continuous variable quantum systems, as well as their applications to fundamental quantum physics and quantum information tasks. Our review is meant to be balanced in its content, since both theoretical considerations and experimental perspectives are put on an equal footing.
It is shown that the well-defined unbiased measurement or disturbance of a dynamical variable is not maintained for the precise measurement of the conjugate variable, independently of uncertainty relations. The conditionally valid uncertainty relations on the basis of those additional assumptions, which include most of the familiar Heisenberg-type relations, thus become singular for the precise measurement. We clarify some contradicting conclusions in the literature concerning those conditionally valid uncertainty relations: The failure of a naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation and the modified Arthurs-Kelly relation in the recent spin measurement is attributed to this singular behavior. The naive Heisenberg-type error-disturbance relation is formally preserved in quantum estimation theory, which is shown to be based on the strict unbiased measurement and disturbance, but it leads to unbounded disturbance for bounded operators such as spin variables. In contrast, the Heisenberg-type error-error uncertainty relation and the Arthurs-Kelly relation, as conditionally valid uncertainty relations, are consistently maintained.
Abstract The Heisenberg uncertainty relation, together with Robertson’s generalisation, serves as a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics, showing that noncommutative pairs of observables cannot be measured precisely. In this study, we explore the Robertson-type uncertainty relations to demonstrate their effectiveness in establishing a series of thermodynamic uncertainty relations and quantum speed limits in open quantum dynamics. The derivation utilises a scaled continuous matrix product state representation that maps the time evolution of the quantum continuous measurement to the time evolution of the system and field. Specifically, we consider the Maccone–Pati uncertainty relation, a refinement of the Robertson uncertainty relation, to derive thermodynamic uncertainty relations and quantum speed limits. These newly derived relations, which use a state orthogonal to the initial state, yield bounds that are tighter than previously known bounds. Moreover, we consider the Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty, which extends the Robertson uncertainty relation. Our findings not only reinforce the significance of the Robertson-type uncertainty relations, but also expand its applicability in identifying uncertainty relations in open quantum dynamics.