Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0709.2530 · Physical Review A

Three-boson problem at low energy and implications for dilute Bose-Einstein condensates

Shina Tan

Published Jul 25, 2008• 93 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is shown that the effective interaction strength of three bosons at small collision energies can be extracted from their wave function at zero energy. Asymptotic expansions of this wave function at large interparticle distances are derived, from which is defined a quantity $D$ named three-body scattering hypervolume, which is an analog of the two-body scattering length. Given any finite-range interactions, one can thus predict the effective three-body force from a numerical solution of the Schr\"odinger equation. In this way, the constant $D$ for hard-sphere bosons is computed, leading to the first complete result for the ground-state energy per particle of a dilute Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) of hard spheres to order ${\ensuremath{\rho}}^{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is the number density. Effects of $D$ are also demonstrated in the three-body energy in a finite box of size $L$, which is expanded to the order ${L}^{\ensuremath{-}7}$, and in the three-body scattering amplitude in vacuum. The three-body scattering amplitude calculated in this paper disagrees with an earlier calculation in the literature, because of the omission of the two-body effective range in that earlier work. Another key prediction is the condensate fractions of dilute BECs, which also disagree with an earlier work in the literature based on the effective field theory (EFT), as a result of short-range physics. An EFT prediction of the BEC ground-state energy, however, is corroborated.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.78.013636

Related papers

The scattering of a few particles with short-range interactions at low energies

Shangguo Zhu

The low-energy scattering of three bosons or distinguishable particles with short-range interactions is characterized by a fundamental parameter, the three-body scattering hypervolume, which is responsible for the nonuniversal effects in dilute Bose-Einstein condensates. We derive an analytical formula of the three-body scattering hypervolumes for weak interactions. When the interaction supports two-body bound states, the three-body scattering hypervolume gains a negative imaginary part, which is directly related to the rate constant for three-body recombinations. We develop a numerical method to calculate the three-body scattering hypervolumes for some model potentials with variable strengths. For real atoms with van der Waals potential, the three-body scattering hypervolumes are much harder to compute, because the three-body wave function is highly oscillatory at smaller inter-atomic distances. However, they may be extractable from precision data such as the collective-mode frequencies of trapped Bose-Einstein condensates. In many numerical simulations, the system being simulated is put into a large but finite volume, such as a large periodic box of size $L$. To extract the low-energy scattering properties of two particles in infinite space from such simulations, L\\"uscher's formula must be used. In the second part of this thesis, we generalize L\\"uscher's formula to $d$ spatial dimensions. We obtain its $s$-wave and $p$-wave approximations and the systematic expansions of the energies of the low-lying states. At a $s$-wave resonance in $d\\ge4$ dimensions, we identify two low-lying states close to the threshold with nearly opposite energies, $E\\sim \\pm 1/L^{d/2}$ when $d\\ge 5$, or $E \\sim \\pm 1/L^2 \\sqrt{\\ln L}$ when $d= 4$. These calculations provide important insights to the physics of three particles at a three-body resonance in finite volumes in two or three dimensions. Three-body resonances are important phenomena not yet completely explored in the experiments on cold atoms.

•Nov 8, 2018•0 citations

Three-body scattering area of identical bosons in two dimensions

Junjie Liang, Hongye Yu, Shina Tan

We study the wave function $φ^{(3)}$ of three identical bosons scattering at zero energy, zero total momentum, and zero orbital angular momentum in two dimensions, interacting via short-range potentials with a finite two-body scattering length $a$. We derive asymptotic expansions of $φ^{(3)}$ in two regimes: the 111-expansion, where all three pairwise distances are large, and the 21-expansion, where one particle is far from the other two. In the 111-expansion, the leading term grows as $\ln^3(B/a)$ at large hyperradius $B=\sqrt{(s_1^2+s_2^2+s_3^2)/2}$. At order $B^{-2}\ln^{-3}(B/a)$, we identify a three-body parameter $D$ with dimension of length squared, which we term the three-body scattering area. This quantity should be contrasted with the three-body scattering area previously studied for infinite or vanishing two-body scattering length. If the two-body interaction is attractive and supports bound states, $D$ acquires a negative imaginary part, and we derive its relation to the probability amplitudes for the production of two-body bound states in three-body collisions. Under weak modifications of the interaction potentials, we derive the corresponding shift of $D$ in terms of $φ^{(3)}$ and the changes of the two-body and three-body potentials. We also study the effects of $D$ and $φ^{(3)}$ on three-body and many-body physics, including the three-body ground-state energy in a large periodic volume, the many-body energy and the three-body correlation function of the dilute two-dimensional Bose gas, and the three-body recombination rates of two-dimensional ultracold atomic Bose gases.

cond-mat.quant-gasCross-listedarXiv:2601.20509•Jan 29, 2026•0 citations

Three-body scattering hypervolume of particles with unequal masses

Zipeng Wang, Shina Tan

We analyze the collision of three particles with arbitrary mass ratio at zero collision energy, assuming arbitrary short-range potentials, and generalize the three-body scattering hypervolume $D$ first defined for identical bosons in 2008. We solve the three-body Schr\"odinger equation asymptotically when the three particles are far apart or one pair and a third particle are far apart, deriving two asymptotic expansions of the wave function, and the parameter $D$ appears at the order $1/{B}^{4}$, where $B$ is the overall size of the triangle formed by the particles. We then analyze the ground state energy of three such particles with vanishing or negligible two-body scattering lengths in a large periodic volume of side length $L$, where the three-body parameter contributes a term of the order $D/{L}^{6}$. From this result we derive some properties of a two-component Bose gas with negligible two-body scattering lengths: its energy density at zero temperature, the corresponding generalized Gross-Pitaevskii equation, the conditions for the stability of the two-component mixture against collapse or phase separation, and the decay rates of particle densities due to three-body recombination.

arXiv:2103.13869•Physical Review A•Jun 21, 2021•8 citations

Three-boson scattering hypervolume for a nonzero orbital angular momentum

Pui In Ip, Shina Tan

We analyze the zero energy collision of three identical bosons in the same internal state with total orbital angular momentum $L=2$, assuming short range interactions. By solving the Schrödinger equation asymptotically, we derive two expansions of the wave function when three bosons are far apart or a pair of bosons and the third boson are far apart. The scattering hypervolume $D$ is defined for this collision. Unlike the scattering hypervolume defined by one of us in 2008, whose dimension is length to the fourth power, the dimension of $D$ studied in the present paper is length to the eighth power. We then derive the expression of $D$ when the interaction potentials are weak, using the Born's expansion. We also calculate the energy shift of such three bosons with three different momenta $\hbar \mathbf{k_{1}}$, $\hbar\mathbf{k_{2}}$ and $\hbar\mathbf{k_{3}}$ in a large periodic box. The obtained energy shift depends on $D^{(0)}/Ω^{2}$ and $D/Ω^{2}$, where $D^{(0)}$ is the three-body scattering hypervolume defined for the three-body $L=0$ collision and $Ω$ is the volume of the periodic box. We also calculate the contribution of $D$ to the three-body T-matrix element for low-energy collisions. We then calculate the shift of the energy and the three-body recombination rate due to $D^{(0)}$ and $D$ in the dilute homogeneous Bose gas. The contribution to the three-body recombination rate constant from $D$ is proportional to $T^2$ if the temperature $T$ is much larger than the quantum degeneracy temperature but still much lower than the temperature scale at which the thermal de Broglie wave length becomes comparable to the physical range of interaction.

arXiv:2507.20787•Physical Review A•Jan 9, 2026•0 citations

Three-body scattering area for particles with infinite or zero scattering length in two dimensions

Junjie Liang, Shina Tan

We derive the asymptotic expansions of the wave function of three particles having equal mass with finite-range interactions and infinite or zero two-dimensional scattering length colliding at zero energy and zero orbital angular momentum, from which a three-body parameter $D$ is defined. The dimension of $D$ is length squared, and we call $D$ three-body scattering area. We find that the ground-state energy per particle of a zero-temperature dilute Bose gas with these interactions is approximately $\frac{{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}D}{6m}{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is the number density of the bosons and $m$ is the mass of each boson. Such a zero-temperature Bose gas is stable at $D>0$ in the thermodynamic limit, and metastable at $D<0$ in the isotropic harmonic trap if the number of bosons is less than ${N}_{\mathrm{cr}}\ensuremath{\approx}3.6413\sqrt{\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{m\ensuremath{\omega}|D|}\phantom{{}^{1}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\omega}$ is the angular frequency of the harmonic trap. If the two-body interaction supports bound states, $D$ typically acquires a negative imaginary part, and we find the relation between this imaginary part and the amplitudes of the pair-boson production processes. We derive a formula for the three-body recombination rate constant of the many-boson system in terms of the imaginary part of $D$.

arXiv:2402.02202•Physical Review A•Jun 24, 2024•2 citations

Stability and condensation of dilute Bose gases

François Louis Antoine Visconti

This thesis is devoted to the rigorous study of dilute Bose gases with two-body and three-body interactions at zero temperature in two and three dimensions. Bose gases are many-body quantum systems composed of bosons, which notably do not obey the Pauli exclusion principle. As a consequence, at extremely low temperatures, a macroscopic fraction of the particles can occupy the same one-body quantum state. This phenomenon, known as Bose–Einstein condensation, was predicted in the 1920s by Bose and Einstein for noninteracting Bose gases, and first realised experimentally by the groups of Cornell and Wieman, and Ketterle, earning them the Nobel Prize for Physics in 2001. However, proving the occurrence of Bose–Einstein condensation in general interacting bosonic systems remains a major open problem and constitutes a central theme in this thesis. Another important property of bosonic matter is that it is generally more unstable than fermionic matter. In particular, for systems interacting via the Coulomb force, the Pauli exclusion principle is essential for explaining the stability of the second kind, which states that the energy and volume scale linearly with the number of particles. Nonetheless, bosonic systems with attractive but less singular interactions can also be stable, and the rigorous proof of this fact forms a second focus of this thesis. In three dimensions, we consider predominantly repulsive interactions. Firstly, we prove a leading order upper bound on the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with hard-core three-body interactions, which matches an existing lower bound. In addition, we obtain a simpler proof for integrable potentials. Secondly, we derive the leading order of the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with combined two-body and three-body interactions. More specifically, we show that, at the leading order, the ground state energy is entirely characterised by the scattering length of the two-body potential and the scattering hypervolume of the three-body potential. Thirdly, we study the time evolution of Bose–Einstein condensates with three-body interactions in the so-called Gross–Pitaevskii regime. We show that Bose–Einstein condensation is preserved under many-body evolution and that the condensate wavefunction evolves according to the quintic Gross–Pitaevskii equation. In particular, we show that the effective coupling constant is universal in the sense that it depends only on the scattering hypervolume of the interaction potential. As a by-product of our proof, we derive a stability of the second kind result for Bose gases with attractive two-body interactions and repulsive three-body interactions. In two dimensions, we consider trapped Bose gases with mean-field-type interactions, including the purely attractive case. We prove the stability of the second kind of the system and the convergence of the ground state energy per particle to that of a non-linear Schrödinger energy functional. As a consequence of the stability of the second kind, we also obtain Bose–Einstein condensation for the many-body ground states.

•Aug 4, 2026•0 citations
It is shown that the effective interaction strength of three bosons at small collision energies can be extracted from their wave function at zero energy. Asymptotic expansions of this wave function at large interparticle distances are derived, from which is defined a quantity DDD named three-body scattering hypervolume, which is an analog of the two-body scattering length. Given any finite-range interactions, one can thus predict the effective three-body force from a numerical solution of the Schr"odinger equation. In this way, the constant DDD for hard-sphere bosons is computed, leading to the first complete result for the ground-state energy per particle of a dilute Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) of hard spheres to order \ensuremathρ2{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{2}\ensuremathρ2, where \ensuremathρ\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremathρ is the number density. Effects of DDD are also demonstrated in the three-body energy in a finite box of size LLL, which is expanded to the order L\ensuremath−7{L}^{\ensuremath{-}7}L\ensuremath−7, and in the three-body scattering amplitude in vacuum. The three-body scattering amplitude calculated in this paper disagrees with an earlier calculation in the literature, because of the omission of the two-body effective range in that earlier work. Another key prediction is the condensate fractions of dilute BECs, which also disagree with an earlier work in the literature based on the effective field theory (EFT), as a result of short-range physics. An EFT prediction of the BEC ground-state energy, however, is corroborated.
The low-energy scattering of three bosons or distinguishable particles with short-range interactions is characterized by a fundamental parameter, the three-body scattering hypervolume, which is responsible for the nonuniversal effects in dilute Bose-Einstein condensates. We derive an analytical formula of the three-body scattering hypervolumes for weak interactions. When the interaction supports two-body bound states, the three-body scattering hypervolume gains a negative imaginary part, which is directly related to the rate constant for three-body recombinations. We develop a numerical method to calculate the three-body scattering hypervolumes for some model potentials with variable strengths. For real atoms with van der Waals potential, the three-body scattering hypervolumes are much harder to compute, because the three-body wave function is highly oscillatory at smaller inter-atomic distances. However, they may be extractable from precision data such as the collective-mode frequencies of trapped Bose-Einstein condensates. In many numerical simulations, the system being simulated is put into a large but finite volume, such as a large periodic box of size LLL. To extract the low-energy scattering properties of two particles in infinite space from such simulations, L\\"uscher's formula must be used. In the second part of this thesis, we generalize L\\"uscher's formula to ddd spatial dimensions. We obtain its sss-wave and ppp-wave approximations and the systematic expansions of the energies of the low-lying states. At a sss-wave resonance in dge4d\\ge4dge4 dimensions, we identify two low-lying states close to the threshold with nearly opposite energies, Esimpm1/Ld/2E\\sim \\pm 1/L^{d/2}Esimpm1/Ld/2 when dge5d\\ge 5dge5, or Esimpm1/L2sqrtlnLE \\sim \\pm 1/L^2 \\sqrt{\\ln L}Esimpm1/L2sqrtlnL when d=4d= 4d=4. These calculations provide important insights to the physics of three particles at a three-body resonance in finite volumes in two or three dimensions. Three-body resonances are important phenomena not yet completely explored in the experiments on cold atoms.
We study the wave function φ(3)φ^{(3)}φ(3) of three identical bosons scattering at zero energy, zero total momentum, and zero orbital angular momentum in two dimensions, interacting via short-range potentials with a finite two-body scattering length aaa. We derive asymptotic expansions of φ(3)φ^{(3)}φ(3) in two regimes: the 111-expansion, where all three pairwise distances are large, and the 21-expansion, where one particle is far from the other two. In the 111-expansion, the leading term grows as ln⁡3(B/a)\ln^3(B/a)ln3(B/a) at large hyperradius B=(s12+s22+s32)/2B=\sqrt{(s_1^2+s_2^2+s_3^2)/2}B=(s12​+s22​+s32​)/2​. At order B−2ln⁡−3(B/a)B^{-2}\ln^{-3}(B/a)B−2ln−3(B/a), we identify a three-body parameter DDD with dimension of length squared, which we term the three-body scattering area. This quantity should be contrasted with the three-body scattering area previously studied for infinite or vanishing two-body scattering length. If the two-body interaction is attractive and supports bound states, DDD acquires a negative imaginary part, and we derive its relation to the probability amplitudes for the production of two-body bound states in three-body collisions. Under weak modifications of the interaction potentials, we derive the corresponding shift of DDD in terms of φ(3)φ^{(3)}φ(3) and the changes of the two-body and three-body potentials. We also study the effects of DDD and φ(3)φ^{(3)}φ(3) on three-body and many-body physics, including the three-body ground-state energy in a large periodic volume, the many-body energy and the three-body correlation function of the dilute two-dimensional Bose gas, and the three-body recombination rates of two-dimensional ultracold atomic Bose gases.
We analyze the collision of three particles with arbitrary mass ratio at zero collision energy, assuming arbitrary short-range potentials, and generalize the three-body scattering hypervolume DDD first defined for identical bosons in 2008. We solve the three-body Schr\"odinger equation asymptotically when the three particles are far apart or one pair and a third particle are far apart, deriving two asymptotic expansions of the wave function, and the parameter DDD appears at the order 1/B41/{B}^{4}1/B4, where BBB is the overall size of the triangle formed by the particles. We then analyze the ground state energy of three such particles with vanishing or negligible two-body scattering lengths in a large periodic volume of side length LLL, where the three-body parameter contributes a term of the order D/L6D/{L}^{6}D/L6. From this result we derive some properties of a two-component Bose gas with negligible two-body scattering lengths: its energy density at zero temperature, the corresponding generalized Gross-Pitaevskii equation, the conditions for the stability of the two-component mixture against collapse or phase separation, and the decay rates of particle densities due to three-body recombination.
We analyze the zero energy collision of three identical bosons in the same internal state with total orbital angular momentum L=2L=2L=2, assuming short range interactions. By solving the Schrödinger equation asymptotically, we derive two expansions of the wave function when three bosons are far apart or a pair of bosons and the third boson are far apart. The scattering hypervolume DDD is defined for this collision. Unlike the scattering hypervolume defined by one of us in 2008, whose dimension is length to the fourth power, the dimension of DDD studied in the present paper is length to the eighth power. We then derive the expression of DDD when the interaction potentials are weak, using the Born's expansion. We also calculate the energy shift of such three bosons with three different momenta ℏk1\hbar \mathbf{k_{1}}ℏk1​, ℏk2\hbar\mathbf{k_{2}}ℏk2​ and ℏk3\hbar\mathbf{k_{3}}ℏk3​ in a large periodic box. The obtained energy shift depends on D(0)/Ω2D^{(0)}/Ω^{2}D(0)/Ω2 and D/Ω2D/Ω^{2}D/Ω2, where D(0)D^{(0)}D(0) is the three-body scattering hypervolume defined for the three-body L=0L=0L=0 collision and ΩΩΩ is the volume of the periodic box. We also calculate the contribution of DDD to the three-body T-matrix element for low-energy collisions. We then calculate the shift of the energy and the three-body recombination rate due to D(0)D^{(0)}D(0) and DDD in the dilute homogeneous Bose gas. The contribution to the three-body recombination rate constant from DDD is proportional to T2T^2T2 if the temperature TTT is much larger than the quantum degeneracy temperature but still much lower than the temperature scale at which the thermal de Broglie wave length becomes comparable to the physical range of interaction.
We derive the asymptotic expansions of the wave function of three particles having equal mass with finite-range interactions and infinite or zero two-dimensional scattering length colliding at zero energy and zero orbital angular momentum, from which a three-body parameter DDD is defined. The dimension of DDD is length squared, and we call DDD three-body scattering area. We find that the ground-state energy per particle of a zero-temperature dilute Bose gas with these interactions is approximately $\frac{{\ensuremath{\hbar}}^{2}D}{6m}{\ensuremath{\rho}}^{2}$, where $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is the number density of the bosons and mmm is the mass of each boson. Such a zero-temperature Bose gas is stable at D>0D>0D>0 in the thermodynamic limit, and metastable at D<0D<0D<0 in the isotropic harmonic trap if the number of bosons is less than ${N}_{\mathrm{cr}}\ensuremath{\approx}3.6413\sqrt{\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{m\ensuremath{\omega}|D|}\phantom{{}^{1}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\omega}$ is the angular frequency of the harmonic trap. If the two-body interaction supports bound states, DDD typically acquires a negative imaginary part, and we find the relation between this imaginary part and the amplitudes of the pair-boson production processes. We derive a formula for the three-body recombination rate constant of the many-boson system in terms of the imaginary part of DDD.
This thesis is devoted to the rigorous study of dilute Bose gases with two-body and three-body interactions at zero temperature in two and three dimensions. Bose gases are many-body quantum systems composed of bosons, which notably do not obey the Pauli exclusion principle. As a consequence, at extremely low temperatures, a macroscopic fraction of the particles can occupy the same one-body quantum state. This phenomenon, known as Bose–Einstein condensation, was predicted in the 1920s by Bose and Einstein for noninteracting Bose gases, and first realised experimentally by the groups of Cornell and Wieman, and Ketterle, earning them the Nobel Prize for Physics in 2001. However, proving the occurrence of Bose–Einstein condensation in general interacting bosonic systems remains a major open problem and constitutes a central theme in this thesis. Another important property of bosonic matter is that it is generally more unstable than fermionic matter. In particular, for systems interacting via the Coulomb force, the Pauli exclusion principle is essential for explaining the stability of the second kind, which states that the energy and volume scale linearly with the number of particles. Nonetheless, bosonic systems with attractive but less singular interactions can also be stable, and the rigorous proof of this fact forms a second focus of this thesis. In three dimensions, we consider predominantly repulsive interactions. Firstly, we prove a leading order upper bound on the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with hard-core three-body interactions, which matches an existing lower bound. In addition, we obtain a simpler proof for integrable potentials. Secondly, we derive the leading order of the thermodynamic ground state energy of Bose gases with combined two-body and three-body interactions. More specifically, we show that, at the leading order, the ground state energy is entirely characterised by the scattering length of the two-body potential and the scattering hypervolume of the three-body potential. Thirdly, we study the time evolution of Bose–Einstein condensates with three-body interactions in the so-called Gross–Pitaevskii regime. We show that Bose–Einstein condensation is preserved under many-body evolution and that the condensate wavefunction evolves according to the quintic Gross–Pitaevskii equation. In particular, we show that the effective coupling constant is universal in the sense that it depends only on the scattering hypervolume of the interaction potential. As a by-product of our proof, we derive a stability of the second kind result for Bose gases with attractive two-body interactions and repulsive three-body interactions. In two dimensions, we consider trapped Bose gases with mean-field-type interactions, including the purely attractive case. We prove the stability of the second kind of the system and the convergence of the ground state energy per particle to that of a non-linear Schrödinger energy functional. As a consequence of the stability of the second kind, we also obtain Bose–Einstein condensation for the many-body ground states.