Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0708.0584 · Physical Review Letters

Experimental Falsification of Leggett’s Nonlocal Variable Model

Cyril Branciard, Alexander Ling, Nicolas Gisin, Christian Kurtsiefer, Antı́a Lamas-Linares, Valerio Scarani

Published Nov 21, 2007• 107 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Bell's theorem guarantees that no model based on local variables can reproduce quantum correlations. Also, some models based on nonlocal variables, if subject to apparently "reasonable" constraints, may fail to reproduce quantum physics. In this Letter, we introduce a family of inequalities, which use a finite number of measurement settings, and which therefore allow testing Leggett's nonlocal model versus quantum physics. Our experimental data falsify Leggett's model and are in agreement with quantum predictions.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.99.210407

Related papers

Crypto-nonlocality in arbitrarily dimensional systems

Jianqi Sheng, Dongkai Zhang, Lixiang Chen

According to Bell's theorem, any model based on local variables cannot reproduce certain quantum correlations. A critical question is whether one could devise an alternative framework, based on nonlocal variables, to reproduce quantum correlations while adhering to fundamental principles. Leggett proposed a nonlocal model, termed crypto-nonlocality, rooted in considerations of the reality of photon polarization, but this property restricted it to being bi-dimensional. In this Letter, we extend the crypto-nonlocal model to higher dimensions and develop a framework for constructing experimentally testable Leggett-type inequalities for arbitrary dimensions. Our investigation into models that yield specific predictions exceeding those of quantum mechanics is intriguing from an information-theoretic perspective and is expected to deepen our understanding of quantum correlations.

arXiv:2501.03123•Jan 6, 2025•0 citations

Experimental test of Leggett's inequalities with solid-state spins

Xianzhi Huang, Xiaolong Ouyang, Wenqian Lian +9 more

Bell's theorem states that no local hidden-variable model is compatible with quantum mechanics. Surprisingly, even if we release the locality constraint, certain nonlocal hidden-variable models, such as the one proposed by Leggett, may still be at variance with the predictions of quantum physics. Here, we report an experimental test of Leggett's nonlocal model with solid-state spins in a diamond nitrogen-vacancy center. We entangle an electron spin with a surrounding weakly coupled $^{13}\mathrm{C}$ nuclear spin and observe that the entangled states violate Leggett-type inequalities by more than four and seven standard deviations for six and eight measurement settings, respectively. Our experimental results are in full agreement with quantum predictions and violate Leggett's nonlocal hidden-variable inequality with a high level of confidence.

arXiv:1912.08214•Physical Review A•Jul 9, 2020•3 citations

Tests of alternative quantum theories with neutrons

Stephan Sponar, Jürgen Klepp, Claus Schmitzer +4 more

According to Bell’s theorem, every theory based on local realism is at variance with certain predictions of quantum mechanics. A theory that maintains realism but abandons reliance on locality, which has been proposed by Leggett, is incompatible with experimentally observable quantum correlations. In our experiment correlation measurements of spin-energy entangled single-neutrons violate a Leggett-type inequality by more than 7.6 standard deviations. The experimental data falsify the contextual realistic model and are fully in favor of quantum mechanics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Collapse of Bell’s Theorem

Guangye Chen

Bell’s theorem founded on Bell’s inequalities asserts that no local realistic theories can reproduce all quantum mechanical predictions for spin correlation of particle pairs. It is pointed out that the assumption of setting-independent probability makes Bell’s inequalities not impose constraint on all local realistic models and thus constitutes a theoretical loophole of Bell’s theorem. A counterexample is presented by showing that a local realistic model with appropriate probability density reproduces all quantum mechanical predictions. It becomes clear that experiments violate Bell’s inequalities because the real correlation functions are not constrained by these inequalities. It is also exposed that, rigorous logical reasoning of counter factual deduction does not permit to exclude any premises of Bell’s inequalities by a certain amount of experimental violations of these inequalities.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2019•4 citations

Leggett-type model with relaxed measurement independence

F. De Zela

We present a Leggett-type model that reproduces quantum correlations for the Bell states. It cannot be falsified through known tests based on Bell-type, Leggett-type, or so-called chained Bell inequalities. The model entails partial suppression of measurement independence (free will) to a fraction of $1/4$, as quantified by a recently proposed measure that varies between 0 and 1. This is a consequence of assuming a possible nonlocal relationship between an entangler and one of two measuring stations, thereby differing from the usual nonlocal, Leggett-type models. Furthermore, the model admits arbitrary time ordering for events occurring at two spacelike separated measuring stations. The predicted correlations reproduce the quantum-mechanical ones. Thus, the model is not falsified by so-called before-before tests.

Physical Review A•Jan 28, 2013•1 citation

Hidden Variable Models for Quantum Theory Cannot Have Any Local Part

Roger Colbeck, Renato Renner

It was shown by Bell that no local hidden variable model is compatible with quantum mechanics. If, instead, one permits the hidden variables to be entirely nonlocal, then any quantum mechanical predictions can be recovered. In this Letter, we consider general hidden variable models which can have both local and nonlocal parts. We show the existence of (experimentally verifiable) quantum correlations that are incompatible with any hidden variable model having a nontrivial local part, such as the model proposed by Leggett.

arXiv:0801.2218•Physical Review Letters•Aug 1, 2008•107 citations
Bell's theorem guarantees that no model based on local variables can reproduce quantum correlations. Also, some models based on nonlocal variables, if subject to apparently "reasonable" constraints, may fail to reproduce quantum physics. In this Letter, we introduce a family of inequalities, which use a finite number of measurement settings, and which therefore allow testing Leggett's nonlocal model versus quantum physics. Our experimental data falsify Leggett's model and are in agreement with quantum predictions.
According to Bell's theorem, any model based on local variables cannot reproduce certain quantum correlations. A critical question is whether one could devise an alternative framework, based on nonlocal variables, to reproduce quantum correlations while adhering to fundamental principles. Leggett proposed a nonlocal model, termed crypto-nonlocality, rooted in considerations of the reality of photon polarization, but this property restricted it to being bi-dimensional. In this Letter, we extend the crypto-nonlocal model to higher dimensions and develop a framework for constructing experimentally testable Leggett-type inequalities for arbitrary dimensions. Our investigation into models that yield specific predictions exceeding those of quantum mechanics is intriguing from an information-theoretic perspective and is expected to deepen our understanding of quantum correlations.
Bell's theorem states that no local hidden-variable model is compatible with quantum mechanics. Surprisingly, even if we release the locality constraint, certain nonlocal hidden-variable models, such as the one proposed by Leggett, may still be at variance with the predictions of quantum physics. Here, we report an experimental test of Leggett's nonlocal model with solid-state spins in a diamond nitrogen-vacancy center. We entangle an electron spin with a surrounding weakly coupled 13C^{13}\mathrm{C}13C nuclear spin and observe that the entangled states violate Leggett-type inequalities by more than four and seven standard deviations for six and eight measurement settings, respectively. Our experimental results are in full agreement with quantum predictions and violate Leggett's nonlocal hidden-variable inequality with a high level of confidence.
According to Bell’s theorem, every theory based on local realism is at variance with certain predictions of quantum mechanics. A theory that maintains realism but abandons reliance on locality, which has been proposed by Leggett, is incompatible with experimentally observable quantum correlations. In our experiment correlation measurements of spin-energy entangled single-neutrons violate a Leggett-type inequality by more than 7.6 standard deviations. The experimental data falsify the contextual realistic model and are fully in favor of quantum mechanics.
Bell’s theorem founded on Bell’s inequalities asserts that no local realistic theories can reproduce all quantum mechanical predictions for spin correlation of particle pairs. It is pointed out that the assumption of setting-independent probability makes Bell’s inequalities not impose constraint on all local realistic models and thus constitutes a theoretical loophole of Bell’s theorem. A counterexample is presented by showing that a local realistic model with appropriate probability density reproduces all quantum mechanical predictions. It becomes clear that experiments violate Bell’s inequalities because the real correlation functions are not constrained by these inequalities. It is also exposed that, rigorous logical reasoning of counter factual deduction does not permit to exclude any premises of Bell’s inequalities by a certain amount of experimental violations of these inequalities.
We present a Leggett-type model that reproduces quantum correlations for the Bell states. It cannot be falsified through known tests based on Bell-type, Leggett-type, or so-called chained Bell inequalities. The model entails partial suppression of measurement independence (free will) to a fraction of 1/41/41/4, as quantified by a recently proposed measure that varies between 0 and 1. This is a consequence of assuming a possible nonlocal relationship between an entangler and one of two measuring stations, thereby differing from the usual nonlocal, Leggett-type models. Furthermore, the model admits arbitrary time ordering for events occurring at two spacelike separated measuring stations. The predicted correlations reproduce the quantum-mechanical ones. Thus, the model is not falsified by so-called before-before tests.
It was shown by Bell that no local hidden variable model is compatible with quantum mechanics. If, instead, one permits the hidden variables to be entirely nonlocal, then any quantum mechanical predictions can be recovered. In this Letter, we consider general hidden variable models which can have both local and nonlocal parts. We show the existence of (experimentally verifiable) quantum correlations that are incompatible with any hidden variable model having a nontrivial local part, such as the model proposed by Leggett.