Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0707.4568 · AIP conference proceedings

Emergent Quantum Mechanics and Emergent Symmetries

Gerard ’t Hooft, Arttu Rajantie, Carlo Contaldi, Paul Dominic Dauncey, Horace Stoica

Published Jan 1, 2007• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum mechanics is ‘emergent’ if a statistical treatment of large scale phenomena in a locally deterministic theory requires the use of quantum operators. These quantum operators may allow for symmetry transformations that are not present in the underlying deterministic system. Such theories allow for a natural explanation of the existence of gauge equivalence classes (gauge orbits), including the equivalence classes generated by general coordinate transformations. Thus, local gauge symmetries and general coordinate invariance could be emergent symmetries, and this might lead to new alleys towards understanding the flatness problem of the Universe.

DOI
10.1063/1.2823751

Related papers

Emergent quantum mechanics and emergent symmetries

Gerard ’t Hooft

Quantum mechanics is ‘emergent’ if a statistical treatment of large scale phenomena in a locally deterministic theory requires the use of quantum operators. These quantum operators may allow for symmetry transformations that are not present in the underlying deterministic system. Such theories allow for a natural explanation of the existence of gauge equivalence classes (gauge orbits), including the equivalence classes generated by general coordinate transformations. Thus, local gauge symmetries and general coordinate invariance could be emergent symmetries, and this might lead to new alleys towards understanding the flatness problem of the Universe. Presented at the 13th International Symposium on Particles, Strings and Cosmology, PASCOS, Imperial College, London, July 6, 2007

•Jan 1, 2007•57 citations

Gauge equivalence of representations of symmetry groups in quantum mechanics

Henk Hoogland

The equivalence of representations of symmetry groups operating upon wavefunctions in configuration space is studied with regard to the (intuitive) notion of physical equivalence. A refinement of the usual projective equivalence relation is introduced, called gauge equivalence, for which the allowed unitary equivalence transformations are gauge transformations. For a Euclidean as well as for a Newton-Hooke symmetry group the gauge equivalence classes of unitary multiplier representations are determined. These examples support the assertion that equivalence from a physical viewpoint corresponds better to this new gauge equivalence concept than to the usual notion of projective equivalence.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 1, 1978•10 citations

A mathematical theory for deterministic quantum mechanics

Gerard ’t Hooft

Classical, i.e. deterministic theories underlying quantum mechanics are considered, and it is shown how an apparent quantum mechanical Hamiltonian can be defined in such theories, being the operator that generates evolution in time. It includes various types of interactions. An explanation must be found for the fact that, in the real world, this Hamiltonian is bounded from below. The mechanism that can produce exactly such a constraint is identified in this paper. It is the fact that not all classical data are registered in the quantum description. Large sets of values of these data are assumed to be indistinguishable, forming equivalence classes. It is argued that this should be attributed to information loss, such as what one might suspect to happen during the formation and annihilation of virtual black holes. The nature of the equivalence classes follows from the positivity of the Hamiltonian. Our world is assumed to consist of a very large number of subsystems that may be regarded as approximately independent, or weakly interacting with one another. As long as two (or more) sectors of our world are treated as being independent, they all must be demanded to be restricted to positive energy states only. What follows from these considerations is a unique definition of energy in the quantum system in terms of the periodicity of the limit cycles of the deterministic model.

arXiv:quant-ph/0604008•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2007•100 citations

Gauge-Independent Theory of Symmetry. II.

H. A. Buchdahl, LJ Tassie

This paper develops a gauge-independent symmetry theory of non-relativistic quantum mechanical systems, in line with that previously considered in the context of classical mechanics. We first discuss at length the motivation for adopting the view that the invariance of a system K under a physical symmetry operation .<I' should be taken to mean invariance of the equation of motion of K under a certain gauge-independent unitary transformation U c( .<1'). The formal development of the theory is then carried through, and some detailed examples are presented. In particular, corresponding to every direction along which a system K happens to be translation invariant there exists a gauge-independent generator of translations which leaves K invariant but which is not, in general, a component of either the canonical or the kinetic momentum. The connexion between such invariant generators of translations and the so-called magnetic translation operators is referred to.

Australian Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1965•4 citations

On the emergence of quantum mechanics, diffeomorphism invariance and the weak equivalence principle from deterministic Cartan-Randers systems

Ricardo Gallego Torromé

Quantum systems are viewed as emergent systems from the fundamental degrees of freedom. The laws and rules of quantum mechanics are understood as an effective description, valid for the emergent systems and specially useful to handle probabilistic predictions of observables. After introducing the geometric theory of Hamilton-Randers spaces and reformulating it using Hilbert space theory, a Hilbert space structure is constructed from the Hilbert space formulation of the underlying Hamilton-Randers model and associated with the space of wave functions of quantum mechanical systems. We can prove the emergence of the Born rule from ergodic considerations. A geometric mechanism for a natural spontaneous collapse of the quantum states based on the concentration of measure phenomena as it appears in metric geometry is discussed.We show the existence of stable vacua states for the quantized matter Hamiltonian. Another consequence of the concentration of measure is the emergence of a weak equivalence principle for one of the dynamics of the fundamental degrees of freedom. We suggest that the reduction of the quantum state is driven by a gravitational type interaction. Such interaction appears only in the dynamical domain when localization of quantum observables happens, it must be a classical interaction. We discuss the double slit experiment in the context of the framework proposed, the interference phenomena associated with a quantum system in an external gravitational potential, a mechanism explaining non-quantum locality and also provide an argument in favour of an emergent interpretation of every macroscopic time parameter. Entanglement is partially described in the context of Hamilton-Randers theory and how naturally Bell's inequalities should be violated.

•Feb 20, 2014•2 citations

Note on the existence theorem in ‘emergent quantum mechanics and emergent symmetries’

Hans-Thomas Elze

Recently 't Hooft demonstrated that ‘ For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization’ . An extension is presented here which covers quantum systems that are characterized by a complete set of mutually commuting Hermitian operators ( beables ). We introduce the symmetry of beables: any complete set of beables is as good as any other one which is obtained through a real general linear group transformation. The quantum numbers of a specific set are related to symmetry breaking initial and boundary conditions in a deterministic model. The Hamiltonian, in particular, can be taken as the emergent beable which provides the best resolution of the evolution of the model universe.

arXiv:0710.2765•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jul 15, 2008•21 citations
Quantum mechanics is ‘emergent’ if a statistical treatment of large scale phenomena in a locally deterministic theory requires the use of quantum operators. These quantum operators may allow for symmetry transformations that are not present in the underlying deterministic system. Such theories allow for a natural explanation of the existence of gauge equivalence classes (gauge orbits), including the equivalence classes generated by general coordinate transformations. Thus, local gauge symmetries and general coordinate invariance could be emergent symmetries, and this might lead to new alleys towards understanding the flatness problem of the Universe.
Quantum mechanics is ‘emergent’ if a statistical treatment of large scale phenomena in a locally deterministic theory requires the use of quantum operators. These quantum operators may allow for symmetry transformations that are not present in the underlying deterministic system. Such theories allow for a natural explanation of the existence of gauge equivalence classes (gauge orbits), including the equivalence classes generated by general coordinate transformations. Thus, local gauge symmetries and general coordinate invariance could be emergent symmetries, and this might lead to new alleys towards understanding the flatness problem of the Universe. Presented at the 13th International Symposium on Particles, Strings and Cosmology, PASCOS, Imperial College, London, July 6, 2007
The equivalence of representations of symmetry groups operating upon wavefunctions in configuration space is studied with regard to the (intuitive) notion of physical equivalence. A refinement of the usual projective equivalence relation is introduced, called gauge equivalence, for which the allowed unitary equivalence transformations are gauge transformations. For a Euclidean as well as for a Newton-Hooke symmetry group the gauge equivalence classes of unitary multiplier representations are determined. These examples support the assertion that equivalence from a physical viewpoint corresponds better to this new gauge equivalence concept than to the usual notion of projective equivalence.
Classical, i.e. deterministic theories underlying quantum mechanics are considered, and it is shown how an apparent quantum mechanical Hamiltonian can be defined in such theories, being the operator that generates evolution in time. It includes various types of interactions. An explanation must be found for the fact that, in the real world, this Hamiltonian is bounded from below. The mechanism that can produce exactly such a constraint is identified in this paper. It is the fact that not all classical data are registered in the quantum description. Large sets of values of these data are assumed to be indistinguishable, forming equivalence classes. It is argued that this should be attributed to information loss, such as what one might suspect to happen during the formation and annihilation of virtual black holes. The nature of the equivalence classes follows from the positivity of the Hamiltonian. Our world is assumed to consist of a very large number of subsystems that may be regarded as approximately independent, or weakly interacting with one another. As long as two (or more) sectors of our world are treated as being independent, they all must be demanded to be restricted to positive energy states only. What follows from these considerations is a unique definition of energy in the quantum system in terms of the periodicity of the limit cycles of the deterministic model.
This paper develops a gauge-independent symmetry theory of non-relativistic quantum mechanical systems, in line with that previously considered in the context of classical mechanics. We first discuss at length the motivation for adopting the view that the invariance of a system K under a physical symmetry operation .<I' should be taken to mean invariance of the equation of motion of K under a certain gauge-independent unitary transformation U c( .<1'). The formal development of the theory is then carried through, and some detailed examples are presented. In particular, corresponding to every direction along which a system K happens to be translation invariant there exists a gauge-independent generator of translations which leaves K invariant but which is not, in general, a component of either the canonical or the kinetic momentum. The connexion between such invariant generators of translations and the so-called magnetic translation operators is referred to.
Quantum systems are viewed as emergent systems from the fundamental degrees of freedom. The laws and rules of quantum mechanics are understood as an effective description, valid for the emergent systems and specially useful to handle probabilistic predictions of observables. After introducing the geometric theory of Hamilton-Randers spaces and reformulating it using Hilbert space theory, a Hilbert space structure is constructed from the Hilbert space formulation of the underlying Hamilton-Randers model and associated with the space of wave functions of quantum mechanical systems. We can prove the emergence of the Born rule from ergodic considerations. A geometric mechanism for a natural spontaneous collapse of the quantum states based on the concentration of measure phenomena as it appears in metric geometry is discussed.We show the existence of stable vacua states for the quantized matter Hamiltonian. Another consequence of the concentration of measure is the emergence of a weak equivalence principle for one of the dynamics of the fundamental degrees of freedom. We suggest that the reduction of the quantum state is driven by a gravitational type interaction. Such interaction appears only in the dynamical domain when localization of quantum observables happens, it must be a classical interaction. We discuss the double slit experiment in the context of the framework proposed, the interference phenomena associated with a quantum system in an external gravitational potential, a mechanism explaining non-quantum locality and also provide an argument in favour of an emergent interpretation of every macroscopic time parameter. Entanglement is partially described in the context of Hamilton-Randers theory and how naturally Bell's inequalities should be violated.
Recently 't Hooft demonstrated that ‘ For any quantum system there exists at least one deterministic model that reproduces all its dynamics after prequantization’ . An extension is presented here which covers quantum systems that are characterized by a complete set of mutually commuting Hermitian operators ( beables ). We introduce the symmetry of beables: any complete set of beables is as good as any other one which is obtained through a real general linear group transformation. The quantum numbers of a specific set are related to symmetry breaking initial and boundary conditions in a deterministic model. The Hamiltonian, in particular, can be taken as the emergent beable which provides the best resolution of the evolution of the model universe.